‘The Fix Was In': DOJ Takes on Chicken Insiders in Price-Fixing Trial

Asia's Tech News Daily

(Bloomberg) — “The fix was in.” That’s what the Justice Department charged against major players in the U.S. chicken industry as a hotly anticipated criminal antitrust trial got underway in Denver this week.

Most Read from Bloomberg

    At the heart of the matter is whether the 10 defendants, which include two former chief executive officers, conspired together to keep prices elevated in the $95 billion U.S. market. In his opening remarks, DOJ lawyer Michael Koenig said the insiders, who worked for five competing chicken companies including top producer Tyson Foods Inc., came together to create “massive, historic price increases” and stonewalled efforts by customers including KFC Corp., Chick-fil-A Inc. to negotiate lower.

    The result was profits so massive it prompted former Pilgrim’s Pride Corp. top executive Jayson Penn to tell his boss, Pilgrim’s then-CEO William Lovette, that “2014 was chicken nirvana,” Koenig said.

    “The 10 defendants in this courtroom worked together to make sure they were not competing,” communicating by phone, text and email to coordinate pricing and guarantee high profits to their companies, he said. “The fix was in and the defendants didn’t budge.”

    The defendants fired back.

    “Chicken nirvana has nothing to do with fixing prices,” said Lovette’s lawyer, John Fagg, the first of 10 defense lawyers to deliver opening statements on Tuesday and Wednesday.

    ‘No Agreement’

    “There was no conspiracy,” he said. “There was no agreement among these men to fix prices or to rig bids.”

    The trial comes as consumers are facing the fastest pace of food inflation in years, thanks partly to big increases in protein prices.

    While the evidence covers alleged efforts to fix prices and rig bids from 2012 to early 2019, the findings could set the stage for further moves against the industry, which has caught the ire of the Biden administration. Officials have said meatpackers engaged in “pandemic profiteering,” squeezing consumers and farmers. Meat companies have also been thrust into the spotlight after a wave of Covid-19 outbreaks at packing plants early in the pandemic.

    The trial is the first after a years-long investigation into the pricing of chickens sold to restaurants, grocery stores and consumers. The industry executives and employees are charged with a criminal antitrust conspiracy and face prison sentences and million-dollar fines if convicted.

    All the defendants have pleaded not guilty. They claim price rises were a result of supply and demand, not an illegal agreement. And defendants communicated as part of their independent efforts to collect pricing information from many sources, said Michael Tubach, a lawyer for Penn.

    Chicken Math

    Penn, who became Pilgrim’s CEO after Lovette retired in 2019, succeeded by using “chicken math” — advanced analytical data tools designed to maximize profit, Tubach said. Prices rose after the 2014 negotiations because demand for small chickens, used by fast-food franchises, went up while supply was decreasing.

    “It was market forces that drove up those prices,” Tubach told jurors. He claimed the government cherry-picked statements from more than 16 million documents but it has no witnesses who can tell jurors they have personal knowledge of any illegal agreement.

    Read more: Big Chicken Executives Face Prison in Denver Price-Fixing Trial

    Dennis Canty, a lawyer for one of the defendants, warned jurors they’re likely to learn “way more than you ever wanted to know” about the chicken industry in the trial, which may last until Dec. 21.

    Pilgrim’s Employee Testimony

    Trial watchers are likely to closely monitor the upcoming testimony of Robbie Bryant, a Pilgrim’s employee who is currently on leave. He’s expected to take the stand against his former colleagues as a prosecution witness. Bryant is testifying with immunity as a result of the company’s plea deal.

    In addition to Penn and Lovette, prosecutors charged Roger Austin, a former vice president of Pilgrim’s; Mikell Fries, president of Claxton Poultry Farms Inc.; Scott Brady, a Claxton vice president; Timothy Mulrenin, a Perdue Farms Inc. executive who previously worked at Tyson; William Kantola, a Koch Foods Inc. sales executive; Jimmie Lee Little, a former Pilgrim’s Pride sales director; Gary Brian Roberts, a Case Farms Inc. employee who had previously worked at Tyson; and Rickie Blake, a former director and manager at George’s Inc.

    Each of the men is charged with conspiracy to restrain trade, which carries a maximum of 10 years in prison. Little is also charged with obstruction of justice, which has a 20-year maximum.

    ‘Sell it or Smell it’

    Greeley, Colorado-based Pilgrim’s Pride, a unit of Brazilian food giant JBS SA, pleaded guilty to price-fixing conspiracy in February and was sentenced to pay $108 million in fines. As part of the plea, Pilgrim’s agreed to cooperate with the government investigation. In a statement Monday, the company said it is “focused on maintaining our commitment to fair and honest competition in compliance with U.S. antitrust laws.”

    A lawyer for Austin refuted the government’s claim that the companies colluded in furnishing chickens to competitors who had promised to sell birds they didn’t yet own. Companies cover one another’s chicken short sales not as part of any illegal cooperation but out of a need to move a perishable commodity, Michael Feldberg, a lawyer for Austin said, citing what he said is an industry maxim: “Sell it or smell it.”

    Lawyers for Claxton’s Fries and Brady told jurors the Georgia company is a very small player with less than 1% of the U.S. market, putting it at the mercy of its bigger fast-food customers.

    “Claxton doesn’t control the market,” Fries’s lawyer, Rick Kornfeld, told the jury. “The market controls Claxton.”

    The case is U.S. v. Penn, 20-cr-00152, U.S. District Court, District of Colorado (Denver).

    (Corrects lawyer’s first name in sixth paragraph)

    Most Read from Bloomberg Businessweek

      ©2021 Bloomberg L.P.

      Internet Explorer Channel Network
      Asia's Tech News Daily
      News Related


      Arjun Kapoor's heart goes ‘Bijlee Bijlee' for ladylove Malaika Arora, shares glimpse of Maldivian beach date

      © Provided by Pinkvilla Arjun Kapoor and Malaika Arora make one of the most popular couples in the tinsel town of Bollywood. Both the celebs are quite active on their ... Read more »

      Priyanka Chopra shares a glimpse of The Matrix: Resurrections' new promo featuring her dialogue; WATCH

      The Matrix: Resurrections is one of the most-anticipated films of the year and ahead of its release on December 22, the film’s final trailer is set to release soon. Priyanka ... Read more »

      Smollett trial to resume with defense possibly calling him

      On Location: December 3, 2021 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.The Associated Press CHICAGO — After two brothers spent hours telling a jury how Jussie Smollett paid them ... Read more »

      Trending TV News Today: Ankita Lokhande-Vicky Jain ALMOST get married during pre-wedding festivities; Sayantani Ghosh's wedding pictures go viral and more

      © Provided by BollywoodLife.com Let’s walk you through the TV Newsmakers of 6 December 2021. Sayantani’s wedding pics Naagin actress Sayantani Ghosh got married to her long time beau Anugrah ... Read more »

      New York City mayor says he is imposing a COVID-19 vaccine mandate on private sector employers

      NEW YORK — New York City mayor says he is imposing a COVID-19 vaccine mandate on private sector employers. Read more »

      Mayor: Vaccine mandates to be required for all NYC employers

      The Associated PressIn this image taken from video, New York Mayor Bill de Blasio speaks during a virtual press conference, Thursday, Dec. 2, 2021, in New York. Multiple cases of ... Read more »

      Revealed: Royal Mint dropped National Trust coin after charity judged ‘troubled and political'

      Commemorative coin idea was dropped following rows over volunteers at the Trust being asked to wear gay pride badges and the word “Easter” being removed from its annual egg hunt ... Read more »

      Billionaire investor Chris Sacca says day traders are begging him for bailouts — and reveals he bought the dip

      Chris Sacca.YouTube/Kevin Rose Chris Sacca warned retail traders not to bet on meme stocks and crypto with borrowed funds. The billionaire investor is now fielding bailout requests after the recent ... Read more »

      Durham college head apologises for calling students 'pathetic' for staging walkout over Rod Liddle speech

      Professor Tim Luckhurst A Durham college head has apologised for calling students “pathetic” as the university launches an investigation into the events. Professor Tim Luckhurst, principal of South College, said ... Read more »

      Maryland man busted allegedly selling 600 fake vaccine cards for $75 each

      Amar Shabazz is facing up to 20 years each for mail fraud and obstruction of justice if convicted in the vaccine card case. Maryland Department of Public Safety and Correctional ... Read more »

      15-year-old student arrested after a threat against Miami High, school district says

      Police have arrested a 15-year-old student accused of making a social media threat against Miami Senior High School, a threat that was then altered by others to affect other schools, ... Read more »

      Queen Elizabeth is in mourning after Duchess of Grafton dies aged 101

      Queen Elizabeth is in mourning following the death of one of her most trusted aides. © Bang Showbiz Fresh heartache for Queen Elizabeth as close friend dies Ann Fortune FitzRoy, ... Read more »

      Putin and Modi discuss trade, humanitarian situation in Afghanistan

      © Reuters/ADNAN ABIDI Russia’s President Putin meets with India’s PM Modi, in New Delhi By Alasdair Pal and Neha Arora NEW DELHI (Reuters) – Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi met ... Read more »

      Terengganu FC kekal khidmat Nafuzi

      © Provided by Sinar Harian TERENGGANU FC (TFC) mengambil keputusan mengekalkan khidmat pengendali skuad Penyu, Nafuzi Zain bagi mengharungi saingan Liga Malaysia (Liga-M) pada musim depan. Menurut laman sesawang TFC, ... Read more »

      Ghum Hai Kiskey Pyaar Meiin, 6 December 2021, Written Update: Virat becomes emotional as he misses Sadanand

      © Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, Virat informs his team that they are camping in open grounds. So that Sadanand sends his men to find out the reason and ... Read more »

      Pampasan terlalu rendah, mana nak cari rumah di KL, keluh penduduk Kampung Baru

      © Provided by Free Malaysia Today Penduduk Kampung Baru mendakwa pampasan diberikan tidak mengikut nilaian semasa dan menyukarkan mereka mencari rumah ganti yang sesuai. KUALA LUMPUR: Penduduk sekitar Kampung Sungai ... Read more »

      Wembley murders officers branded ‘disgrace' over WhatsApp images

      Two police officers who took pictures of murdered sisters Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman have been accused of a “catastrophic betrayal”. Pc Deniz Jaffer and Pc Jamie Lewis were assigned ... Read more »

      ISL 2021-22 LIVE Score and Updates, Jamshedpur FC vs ATK Mohun Bagan: ATKMB Look to Bounce Back from Loss

      © Provided by News18 ISL 2021-22 LIVE Score and Updates, Jamshedpur FC vs ATK Mohun Bagan: ATK Mohun Bagan will take on Jamshedpur FC on Monday at the GMC Athletic ... Read more »

      Samsung Galaxy F12, Realme Narzo 50A, POCO C31 and more: Check smartphone deals on Flipkart's 'Big Bachat Dhamal' sale

      © Provided by CNBCTV18 Flipkart is offering a number of super-saver deals on its ‘Big Bachat Dhamal’ sale, which ends today. A number of smartphones by Realme, Samsung and MotoG ... Read more »

      'I Was Trying to be on The Money Every Ball': Ajaz Patel to Ravichandran Ashwin on 10-fer

      © Provided by News18 ‘I Was Trying to be on The Money Every Ball’: Ajaz Patel to Ravichandran Ashwin on 10-fer New Zealand spinner Ajaz Patel opened up on creating ... Read more »

      These viral sleep hacks could solve your shut-eye

      Beautiful young woman with sleeping mask holding alarm clock. She is tired and lazy in morning. Over the last few months, a whole host videos outlining various methods to fall ... Read more »

      South Africa's Biovac to start making Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine in early 2022 - exec

      The logo of South African vaccine manufacturing and storage company Biovac is seen outside the company’s offices in Cape Town KIGALI (Reuters) – South Africa's Biovac Institute will start making ... Read more »

      Trump-linked stocks get a boost after social media venture raises $1 billion

      FILE PHOTO: Former President Donald Trump speaks in Sarasota (Reuters) – Shares of a clutch of companies linked to former U.S President Donald Trump rose in premarket trading on Monday, ... Read more »

      Alec Baldwin deletes personal Twitter account following emotional interview on tragic Rust shooting

      © Provided by Pinkvilla Alec Baldwin has now deleted one of his two verified accounts on Twitter days after his emotional interview about the tragic shooting on the sets of ... Read more »

      Bristol private school will drop name of slave trader Edward Colston

      © Ben Birchall Protesters throw the statue of Edward Colston into Bristol harbour (PA) A school set up more than 300 years ago will drop the name of slave trader ... Read more »

      Three in four girls have been sent sexual images via social media apps, report says

      © PA Archive Code to protect children’s data and privacy online come into full effect Three in four young girls have been sent sexual images via smartphone apps, according to ... Read more »

      Myanmar's Suu Kyi gets 4 years in further blow to democracy

      BANGKOK (AP) — Aung San Suu Kyi, the civilian leader of Myanmar who was ousted in a de facto coup this year, was convicted of incitement and another charge Monday ... Read more »

      «Erhebliche Anzahl»: Neuer Lavastrom zerstört weitere Häuser auf La Palma

      Ein neuer Lavastrom hat auf der zu Spanien gehörenden Vulkaninsel La Palma weitere Häuser zerstört. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Neuer Lavastrom zerstört weitere Häuser auf La Palma Es handele sich ... Read more »

      Zehn Rückkehrer aus Südafrika: Erste Omikron-Fälle in Russland nachgewiesen

      In Russland haben die Behörden die ersten beiden Fälle der neuartigen Omikron-Variante des Coronavirus nachgewiesen. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Erste Omikron-Fälle in Russland nachgewiesen Insgesamt seien zehn Rückkehrer aus Südafrika ... Read more »

      Newcastle identify £40m rated defender as their ‘primary target'

      © PA Images Newcastle-linked-Sven-Botman Newcastle United have identified Lille’s £40m rated defender Sven Botman as one of their “primary targets” during the January window transfer window, according to reports. The ... Read more »

      Jack in the Box to acquire Del Taco for over $450 million

      © Reuters/Rick Wilking The sign outside the Jack in the Box in Westminster (Reuters) – U.S. hamburger restaurant chain Jack in the Box Inc said on Monday it would buy ... Read more »

      T-Mobile Customer Service Is Getting as Bad as All the Others

      (Bloomberg) — T-Mobile US Inc.’s merger with Sprint Corp. was supposed to create a supercharged wireless competitor pushing innovations, lowering prices and staying true to its core principle — standing ... Read more »

      Dubai unveils programme to help creative talents set up businesses quickly

      © Provided by The National Four types of licences are being offered as part of the Creatives Journey initiative. Photo: D3 Dubai unveiled a new programme on Monday that will ... Read more »

      British companies set for ESG hiring spree in 2022

      © Andy Rain London. The rising demand for environment, social and governance workers comes at a time when Britain is facing a labour shortage. EPA A record number of British ... Read more »

      Arun Matheswaran's Tamil crime thriller 'Rocky' to release on Dec 23

      © IANS Rocky story Chennai, Dec 6 (IANS) Director Arun Matheswaran’s ‘Rocky’, featuring actor Vasanth Ravi and Bharthirajaa in the lead, will hit screens on December 23, its makers announced ... Read more »

      Ankita Lokhande and Vicky Jain look ecstatic during their pre wedding rituals; Photos

      © Provided by Pinkvilla Ankita Lokhande is presently on cloud nine as the actress will be soon marrying the love of her life, Vicky Jain. Ankita had recently shared a ... Read more »

      'Lehra Do' unfurls the sheer joy of epic '83' World Cup campaign

      © IANS Lehra Do Mumbai, Dec 6 (IANS) The first song from the highly-anticipated Ranveer Singh-starrer ’83’ titled ‘Lehra Do’ has been released. The patriotic track starts off with the ... Read more »

      Harry Maguire, Raphael Varane, Edinson Cavani - Manchester United injury latest and return dates

      Ralf Rangnick got off to a winning start at the weekend against Crystal Palace but now his attention turns to the Champions League when Young Boys visit Old Trafford. The ... Read more »

      Conman posed as descendent of Shivaji Maharaj to lure women

      © Provided by Hindustan Times To lure women, the conman would tell them that he is a descendent of Shivaji Maharaj. (HT File) Vijay Kumar Yadav Mumbai Pune resident Yuvraj ... Read more »

      Bigg Boss 15 EXCLUSIVE: Tejasswi Prakash's brother Pratik on her relationship with Karan Kundrra: ‘I like him'

      © Provided by Pinkvilla Tejasswi Prakash is considered to be one of the strongest contestants inside Salman Khan’s Bigg Boss 15 house, and in an exclusive conversation with Pinkvilla recently ... Read more »
      On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic