The Farmani Naaz fatwa: How the mullahs got it wrong on bhajan-singing Muslim artiste

The Farmani Naaz fatwa: How the mullahs got it wrong on bhajan-singing Muslim artiste

Farmani Naaz. YouTube

If you’re a Muslim, you’re never far away from mullahs telling you how to lead your life — what or what not to eat, how to dress, who or who not to marry. The urge to control your life by invoking often dubious religious doctrines or unauthenticated Hadith extends even to how to remember your dead.

Fatwas fly around like confetti with semi-literate maulvis vying with each other to jump on any passing bandwagon and — with a little help from news hungry media — have their moment in the headlines. And it has mostly worked.

It was this playbook that was at work when two notoriously loud-mouthed mullahs from Deoband (described by the media with some exaggeration as “Ulema”) announced a fatwa against a little-known female Muslim singer, Farmani Naaz, for singing bhajans — declaring her conduct “un-Islamic”, and telling her to seek “Allah’s forgiveness”.

“Our religion does not allow us to sing bhajans of other religions. This is against the shariat as well as the basic tenets of Islam,” said Maulana Ishaq Gora.

Another ulema, Mufti Asad Qasmi, suggested she needed to do penance. “You can’t just sing any kind of song if you follow Islam. Despite being a Muslim, Naaz is singing bhajans. She should ask for forgiveness from God.”

Sure enough, they got their moment in the media headlines, but then nemesis that inevitably follows hubris caught up with them. If they thought their gratuitous intervention would prompt the community to turn against Naaz, they were in for a shock. Far from turning against her, it turned against them. Their Fatwas got a short shrift even from the usual suspects, the assorted Right-wing Muslim groups, normally quick to seize any opportunity to divide communities in the name of religion.



I had never heard of Naaz until I read about the so-called fatwas and Googled her. I discovered that thanks to the fatwas, her following on YouTube had gone through the roof. In the unlikely event that there are still people who haven’t heard about her, Naaz is a Muzaffarnagar-based popular Muslim female singer famous for singing bhajans in Sanskrit. Her rendition of the bhajan “Har Har Shambhu” has attracted an estimated 100,000 so far. It proved so popular that apparently it was also played by kanwarias on their recent march to Haridwar.

The extraordinary bit is the support she received from Muslims — evident from the following random selection of comments “Har Har Shambhu” bhajan video elicited from Muslim viewers / listeners on YouTube:

Uzain Saeed Qadri: Love ur voice farmani naz and team.

Aliyah Rehman: Breaking barriers…piercing hearts…hats off. Wonderful flawless rendition of Sanskrit slokas.

Rumi Roy: Artists are beyond religion.

Manzoor Ahmad Ansari: Great songs sister.

Mahtab Alam: Heart-touching..Ahsan

Zahir: Please continue to sing these kinds of bhakti songs… Good to see this kind of inter-religious respect and regard…Ignore the fundamentalists… they are unfortunately everywhere.

Happily, I didn’t come across a single criticism of Naaz. On the other hand, some mocked the mullahs. “Arre, fatwa jaari ho gaya hai!! (Beware, fatwa has come!!),” wrote one. The comment was accompanied by a funny emoji.

Their isolation was complete. A far cry from when even the silliest of fatwas by any old attention-seeking mullah tended to unleash furies against their target. So, was it a one-off? Or is it the start of a push back against mullahcracy!  Whatever the answer, it represents a significant shift in the Muslim mood. One swallow doesn’t, of course, make a summer but sociological trends have a way of catching up. And the clerical establishment should take a serious note of the popular Muslim backlash against the Naaz fatwa.

In future, they will need to be more careful in choosing their target. This time, they clearly picked the wrong number — forgetting that Indian Muslims have a long tradition of singing Hindu Bhakti songs. Once, it was common for Muslim artistes to compose and sing bhajans and Bhakti geets. In the 1952 film Baiju Bawra, the famous bhajan “Man tarpat Hari darshan” was written by Shakeel Badayuni, composed by Naushad, and sung by Mohammed Rafi who, it is reckoned, sang more bhajans than any other playback singer of his time.

Almost all Muslim lyricists of the time — Sahir Ludhianvi, Kaifi Azmi, Majrooh Sultanpuri, Shakil Badayuni — wrote bhajans for films. And nobody ever accused them of “un-Islamic” activity.

Indeed, the so-called “Ganga-Jamni” tradition of Muslims singing Hindu devotional songs still survives. Take Ramzan Khan, a practising Muslim bhajan singer from Rajasthan (popularly known as Munna Master) who was conferred Padma Shri, for his contribution to arts. And that was only two years ago.

His father was a Sanskrit scholar. And so is his son, Feroz Khan, who was an assistant professor at Banaras Hindu University’s Sanskrit Vidya Dharma Vijnan, but was forced to resign after protests from Hindu groups that a Muslim was not fit to teach Hindu scriptures. He was transferred to the university’s Faculty of Arts to teach Sanskrit.

The dilemma for liberal Muslims and Hindus, as illustrated by the anti-Naaz fatwa and Feroz Khan’s difficulties, is that they are simply not allowed to reach out to people of other faiths by self-appointed gatekeepers of respective communities.

The only way of creating inter-community awareness is exposing ourselves to other faiths and cultures through music, arts and places of worship. To interpret it as indoctrination or brainwashing is a wilful act of bigotry. Exposure to new cultural experiences is the most effective way of enriching diversity and breaching the communal divide.

I was brought up on the idea of “unity in diversity” in which Muslim artistes were not “fatwa-ed” for assuming Hindu names; or Hindu musicians and singers pilloried for having Muslim ustads. There’s a famous image of Pandit Ravi Shankar touching the feet of Ustad Allaudin Khan signifying the transcendental nature of music. Today, both Ravi Shankar and Allaudin Khan might have been targeted by gatekeepers of their respective communities.

Growing up in Delhi in the 1950s, I remember visiting Birla Mandir and making a beeline to Gurdwara Sisganj in Chandni Chowk for the delicious Kara Prasad generously distributed by Sikh worshippers to all passers-by. It was heaven. I wonder if a Muslim child would be allowed to do it today. Clearly, times have changed.

The author is an independent commentator. Views expressed are personal.

News Related


Ice Road Truckers' Camera Crew Constantly Risks Their Lives In Order To Get The Shot

History Channel/YouTube One of the things that make “Ice Road Truckers” such a compelling reality show is the dangerous nature of its subject matter. The series depicts truckers getting into deadly ... Read more »

A TikTok creator came up with the fake 'porcelain challenge' to parody viral fearmongering. He says his account is now banned.

A TikTok creator said he persuaded his followers to spread awareness about the fake “porcelain challenge” to comment on the “moral panic” that misrepresents individual viral videos as widespread social ... Read more »

Black Panther director Ryan Coogler was ready to 'walk away from the business' after the 2020 death of Chadwick Boseman

Black Panther director Ryan Coogler was ready to ‘walk away from the business’ entirely after the tragic death of his star and friend Chadwick Boseman, at age 43, in 2020. ... Read more »

Everything we don’t know about Elon Musk’s latest about-face on Twitter

Elon Musk wants to buy Twitter for $54.20 a share: A headline from April, yes, but also breaking news, with the on-again, off-again Silicon Valley saga looping back around on ... Read more »

Listen to Michael Kay and John Sterling call Aaron Judge’s 62nd homer

Aaron Judge has hit his 62nd home run, and Yankees fans will relish the calls for posterity. Judge’s homer passed Roger Maris’ 61 from 1961 for the American League record, ... Read more »

Damian Bendall admits killing girls, 11, brother, 13, and mum but denies rape of child

A MAN today admitted killing his partner, her two children and a pal at a sleepover but denied murder and rape. Damian Bendall, 32, allegedly slaughtered 11-year-old Lacey, her brother ... Read more »

We swapped our £900-a-month houseshare for life in a converted van to save money – we had enough of paying rent & bills

A COUPLE decided to ditch their home and move into a converted van to help the cost of living squeeze – and expect to save over £8,000 a year. Ollie ... Read more »

NHL players reflect on another wild summer of goalie musical chairs

Andrei Vasilevskiy doesn’t pay attention to off-season NHL news. The signings, the trades, the big moves just aren’t on the Tampa Bay Lightning goaltender’s radar. That means every so often, ... Read more »

Shocking video shows man casually jumping across rooftop of NYC high-rise

A well-dressed daredevil was seen mysteriously jumping between awnings of a Financial District high-rise before climbing into a window on Tuesday. In a viral video shared by Emmy Award-winning film ... Read more »

More sports upgrades planned for Mission Recreation Park in Kelowna, B.C.

The busiest section of sports fields in Kelowna, B.C., will, in time, become even busier. On Monday, Kelowna city council was updated on Mission Recreation Park and its ongoing master ... Read more »

I knocked £845 a year off my electricity bill thanks to some savvy tips – money’s getting tighter so you need to act now

A MUM-OF-TWO has revealed some of her top money-saving tips which saw her electric bill fall by a huge £845 a year. Stacey Victoria, 35, a stay-at-home mum from Huddersfield, ... Read more »

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews last night's TV: Who thought we'd see merciless Paxman so horribly dejected?

Paxman: Putting Up With Parkinson’s Make Me Prime Minister God in Heaven, life plays cruel tricks. Imagine the reaction 20 years ago of Jeremy Paxman, scourge of all politicians and ... Read more »

‘Devastating’: N.W.T. health minister vows to address decade-high suicide rate

The Northwest Territories health minister says recent statistics indicating an increase in suicides in the territory are “devastating.” N.W.T. chief coroner Garth Eggenberger released the numbers on suicides in 2021 ... Read more »

Brad Pitt 'choked' one of his children and 'slapped another in the face' during spat on private jet where he also 'grabbed ex-wife Angelina Jolie by the head', new countersuit by the actress claims

Angelina Jolie on Tuesday countersued her ex-husband Brad Pitt after he took legal action in a row over the sale of the French winery they both ownedThe couple separated in September 2016 and Jolie sold her stake in the winery, Chateau Miraval, in September 2021 Pitt argues that they had an unwritten agreement that they would continue to jointly own the estate, and has sued her for selling itIn her court documents, filed at Los Angeles Supreme Court, Jolie detailed the September 2016 row that led to their divorce and accused Pitt of violenceShe states in the filing that she never wanted to make the circumstances public, but her hand has been forcedJolie, 47, accuses Pitt, 58, of having 'choked' one of their six children; poured beer over her; grabbed her by the hair, and slammed her into the wallPitt has always denied violence against any of the children but admitted he had problems with alcohol  Read more »

Aaron Judge’s parents, Patty and Wayne, celebrate as Yankees star hits 62nd home run

Aaron Judge made history on Tuesday night with two of his biggest fans nearby. As the Yankees superstar broke Roger Maris’ regular-season home run record with home run No. 62, ... Read more »

Terrified neighbours hear screams as ‘amazing’ schoolboy, 14, stabbed to death with teen arrested for murder

NEIGHBOURS have told of their horror after hearing screams when an “amazing” schoolboy, 14, was stabbed to death, leading to the arrest of a teen. A girl, 13, has also ... Read more »

Yankees’ Aaron Judge hits 62nd home run to break Maris' AL record

Aaron Judge New York Yankees’ Aaron Judge hits a solo home run, his 62nd of the season, during the first inning in the second baseball game of a doubleheader against ... Read more »

Suspect detained in kidnapping of 4 family members in California; victims remain missing

A California man suspected of kidnapping four members of a family — including an 8-month-old girl — was detained Tuesday. But the family remained missing. Jesus Manuel Salgado, 48, used ... Read more »

Home builder refuses to comment on alleged shoddy work, misleading documents

Two West Kelowna, B.C., families have come forward over the past couple weeks, with allegations including shoddy work and misleading documents after purchasing newly-built homes. According to the families, the ... Read more »

Love Changes Everything: Michael Ball Will Revisit ‘Aspects Of Love’ In A Reimagined Version Of Andrew Lloyd Webber Musical

Michael Ball Joanne Davidson EXCLUSIVE: Three decades ago Michael Ball (Les Miserables) had teeny-bopper groupies waiting for him at the stage door — in London and on Broadway — thanks ... Read more »

Why Aaron Judge should be MLB’s rightful home run champ now

The verdict is in, and not just from the Judge’s Chambers out at Yankee Stadium, either: Aaron Judge, who hit his historic 62nd home run Tuesday night, is now the ... Read more »

Jury Awards $4.5M to Bystander Injured in Chicago Police Pursuit

Link video: A Cook County jury has awarded $4.5 million to a woman who suffered horrific injuries as a result of a Chicago police chase that her attorneys say ... Read more »

Real Men Wear Pink: KPRC 2 teams up with the American Cancer Society to support the fight to end breast cancer

Breast cancer. It’s a disease that impacts women and men. It’s an illness that changes the lives of both those battling and those who love and support them. In October ... Read more »

I was forced to dig up my garden in a desperate attempt to protect my home from rain – I’m terrified it will collapse

A FURIOUS dad-of-two dug a massive crater in his front garden after his basement “turned into a swimming pool” and claims the council refuse to help. Lewyn Clegg fears his ... Read more »

How Mobile Suit Gundam: The Witch From Mercury Makes Anime History

Sunrise “Mobile Suit Gundam” has had the kind of shelf life that most anime properties can only dream of. First premiering all the way back in 1979, the franchise is ... Read more »

I’m a property expert – here are seven easy ways you can transform a tiny space on a budget

IF you live in a tiny flat or apartment, chances are you're experiencing one main problem – not having enough space. Well, the good news is…size doesn't matter! Property expert ... Read more »

Five ways you can lower your cooking costs with an air fryer as energy prices spiral

AIR fryers are the must- have money-saving gadget of the year. Energy price hikes have helped to catapult them to popularity as they are much cheaper to run than an ... Read more »

Aaron Judge’s most memorable home run moments in 2022

Aaron Judge has made history. The slugging outfielder now owns the record for most home runs by a Yankee, surpassing Roger Maris’ American League record of 61 with his 62nd ... Read more »

We won £3.2million in postcode lottery – now all our neighbours are booking holidays in the sun… it’s like a fairy tale

MORE than a hundred neighbours were celebrating over the weekend after cashing in massive wins on the People's Postcode Lottery. The lucky locals all hit the jackpot thanks to living ... Read more »

This Mysterious 90-Foot Slab Brought More Questions Than Answers To Curse Of Oak Island Investigators

History Channel/YouTube Everyone loves a good treasure hunt, and it’s one of the reasons that “The Curse of Oak Island” has proven so popular. In today’s hyper-connected, endlessly Google-able world, ... Read more »

EPHRAIM HARDCASTLE: Emily Maitlis received reassuring words over Prince Andrew chat

Does Emily Maitlis suspect King Charles wasn’t surprised when his brother Andrew’s royal career was ended by her Newsnight interview with him? Whispers Emily: ‘A good friend of Charles said, ... Read more »

Machine Gun Kelly is lowered onto the stage by a prop helicopter as he kicks off his UK tour in Birmingham

Machine Gun Kelly made a dramatic entrance as he kicked off his Mainstream Sellout tour at the Utilia Arena in Birmingham on Tuesday. The singer, 32, entered the 15,000 seat ... Read more »

Top Costumes of 2022 For Pets, Kids and Adults Revealed by

The costume website based the list off of sales data and current trends Read more »

Harry & Meg ‘at odds’ with Netflix staff over ‘demands for edits’ to docuseries – and it could be ‘shelved indefinitely’

PRINCE Harry and Meghan Markle desperately want to edit their Netflix show after the Queen's death, it has been reported. The Duke and Duchess of Sussex are feeling panicked and ... Read more »

Winnipeg Blue Bombers re-acquire Alden Darby in trade

Winnipeg Blue Bombers’ Alden Darby (22) celebrates his sack on Saskatchewan Roughriders quarterback Isaac Harker (16) during the second half of CFL action in Winnipeg Saturday, September 11, 2021.THE CANADIAN ... Read more »

Liz Truss to ram through Rwanda bill to stop Euro-judges blocking deportations & Home Sec will visit France for talks

LIZ Truss will try to ram through a ultra short Rwanda bill to stop Euro-judges blocking deportations of small boat migrants. The new legislation will also stop them exploiting modern ... Read more »

We bought disgusting home piled high with rubbish for £140k… after our transformation it’s unrecognisable

A FAMILY have completed a stunning renovation of a home just four months after they bought it in a state of ruin. John Badkin completely overhauled the Sheffield property with the ... Read more »

Quality street fans outraged over new eco-friendly wrappers that ‘look like knock-offs’ after classic packaging axed

CHOCOLATE fans have slammed Quality Street's new eco-friendly wrappers – saying the recyclable packing makes them look “like knock-offs”. The famous shiny foil has been a Christmas staple for 86 ... Read more »

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson Makes Waves in First Supreme Court Arguments

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, in just her second day on the bench, spoke about the enactment of the Constitution's 14th Amendment Read more »

Wounded Liz Truss will try to salvage Tory party conference with blistering attack on enemies of business

WOUNDED Liz Truss will try to salvage her disastrous Tory conference with an attack on the enemies of enterprise today. The new Prime Minister is set to go on the ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network