The Expropriation Bill and the 18th Constitutional Amendment process: The cart is still behind the horse

The statement that ‘before the Expropriation Bill can be passed, the Constitution needs to be amended’, as expressed in a recent Daily Maverick Opinionista, is not correct. The processes running concurrently are typically confusing and are frequently confused. However, it is important to look at them separately.

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved  

Professors Elmien du Plessis (North West University), ZsaZsa Boggenpoel (Stellenbosch University), Willemien du Plessis (NWU), Juanita Pienaar (SU), Danie Brand (University of the Free State) and Jackie Dugard (Wits University) are professors of law. Johan Lorenzen is with Richard Spoor Attorneys.

Pam Saxby wrote on the Constitution 18th Amendment Bill in Daily Maverick of 13 September 2021, asking if Parliament is putting the cart before the horse by trying to finalise the Expropriation Bill before finalising the Constitutional Amendment Process. We would like to engage with some of the questions raised in the opinion piece.

The main point that we would like to engage with is the statement that “before the Expropriation Bill can be passed, the Constitution needs to be amended”.

This is not correct.

The processes running concurrently are confusing and get confused often. Still, it is important to look at them separately as well.

Expropriation Bill

The history of this bill is relatively long and started long before the 18th Constitutional Amendment process. The first attempt at a new Expropriation Bill, aligned with the Constitution, was in 2008. That bill was shelved for fears of unconstitutionality, as it seemed to have excluded the courts’ role in the expropriation process.

The current bill is a changed version of the 2013 Bill, which became the 2015 bill after extensive deliberations. This bill was introduced in Parliament and adopted by the National Assembly (NA) and the National Council of Provinces (NCOP). It was then sent to the President for enactment, but due to a hurried process in the NCOP, it was vulnerable to legal challenges on procedural grounds.

This process was then halted because of the debate around expropriation without compensation. Notwithstanding, in December 2018, a Draft Expropriation Bill was gazetted for public comment, but the prospect of passing was slim because it was the end of the 5th Parliament. The 6th Parliament, therefore, had to revive the bill.

This draft bill was vital as it provided a clear signal in legal language of what the government had in mind for expropriation. It was also clear that whatever the outcome of the constitutional amendment process, expropriation legislation as a “law of general application” in line with the Constitution was still required. This further refinement of the bill always ran alongside the possible amendment to section 25.

The 2018 bill added mainly clause 12(3), which sets out the instances (but not restricted to the instances) where compensation may be nil. This makes it explicit that nil compensation can be paid in certain circumstances (such as abandoned land, land owned by state-owned corporations, etc. The bill can be found here). The constitutional compensation standard of “just and equitable” is still intact, and the discretion is still there to decide when it will be just and equitable to pay nil.

Mention is also made that the bill cannot be implemented without regulations. It is not clear why this is the case. The process is set out in the bill that gives certain people the authority to expropriate and sets out the requirements and consequences of a valid expropriation. This can be done without promulgating regulations.

18th Amendment Bill to the Constitution

Our Bill of Rights is written in “plain language”, consciously steering away from legalese and overly detailed formulations. This is to ensure that the Constitution is flexible and adaptable to endure. So, although Constitutions are generally not cast in stone, they are meant to endure for at least some time.

Constitutions are also “final” documents, in the sense that amending them (and especially the Bill of Rights) are long and complex processes. The current amendment to section 25 is no different and provides evidence of this. While we only will have finality on the process after the local government elections, all indications are that there will not be the required two-thirds majority to adopt the bill to amend the Constitution.

What we do have is the final proposed wording. For convenience, the proposed changes are cited below, with underlining of the additions.

25(2)(b): subject to compensation, the amount of which and the time and manner of payment of which have either been agreed to by those affected or decided or approved by a court: Provided that where land and any improvements thereon are expropriated for purposes of land reform as contemplated in subsection (8), the amount of compensation may be nil.’’;

(b): by the substitution in subsection (3) for the words preceding paragraph (a) of the following words:

25(3) The amount of the compensation as contemplated in subsection (2)(b), and the time and manner of any payment, must be just and equitable, reflecting an equitable balance between the public interest and the interests of those affected, having regard to all relevant circumstances, including—’’;

(3A)  For the furtherance of land reform, national legislation must, subject to subsections (2) and (3), set out circumstances where the amount of compensation is nil.’’;

(4A) The land is the common heritage of all citizens that the state must safeguard for future generations.

Section 25(5) The state must take reasonable legislative and other measures, within its available resources, to foster conditions which enable state custodianship of certain land in order for citizens to gain access to land on an equitable basis.’’

What is important to note here is that the compensation standard remains “just and equitable”, and it clarifies that land expropriated for land reform purposes “may be nil”. This is then in line with the mandate of the Ad Hoc Committee to Initiate and Introduce Legislation amending Section 25 of the Constitution’s mandate “to make explicit what is implicit” in the Constitution.

We agree that what is implicit is that the consequence of a valid expropriation is that an amount of compensation that is just and equitable under the circumstances is payable. However, in some cases, the circumstances may indicate that the just and equitable amount of compensation is R0 (or nil), just as, in other cases, it may be market value, below market value, or even above market value. This position — in other words, that compensation is always due for expropriation but may under appropriate circumstances be nil — is, in our view, the point of departure for the current interpretation of section 25 as well as the current 18th Amendment Bill. The Bill just states what is legally possible, in terms of section 25 as it currently stands, without any amendment.

As a point of departure, this position is notably different from “expropriation without compensation”, which in principle means that there is no obligation at all to compensate when property is expropriated. With “expropriation without compensation”, the expropriatee can in other words not question the payment of no compensation because there is no per se duty to compensate. In our view, this is not implicit in section 25 and would require a constitutional amendment. There is no mention of “expropriation without compensation”, in this sense, in either the 18th Amendment Bill or Expropriation Bill.

Legislation makes ‘explicit’, not a constitutional amendment

But it is not the job of a constitutional amendment to “make explicit” — that is the work of legislation. And questions can be asked if such an amendment indeed amends the law or merely clarifies it. Again, in our opinion, the Constitution is the framework, with legislation setting out the detail, giving flesh to the principles in the Constitution.

The only possible problem comes in with the addition of section 3A, that no longer leaves a discretion on whether compensation may be nil or not in a particular circumstance, but determines that legislation must set out where compensation “is” nil.  We commented (the submission can be found here) on this section stating that “just and equitable” is a contextual question, and “is” in the suggested formulation removes the discretion to determine in a particular case whether nil compensation is indeed “just and equitable”. Instead, the sentence should read, “the amount of compensation may be nil”.

This suggestion was not accepted by the committee, with the chair, honourable Motshekga, commenting that “[t]he Committee needed to bear in mind that members of the public were not all lawyers; they did not deal with such matters daily like the Committee Members. It was important that the Committee respected the public’s contribution, but where the Committee thought the contribution was based on a lack of understanding due to not being experts in the law”.

Can we please have a new Expropriation Act?

What will become of the Expropriation Bill if the Constitution 18th Amendment Bill isn’t passed? We argue that it can still go through the adoption process that Ms Saxby documents in her piece: to the National Assembly and the NCOP. Minister Patricia de Lille, in her presentation, also stated that the two are not “mutually exclusive”. This was also confirmed by the Office of the Chief State Law Adviser and by Parliament’s legal services.

That being said, we have the same concern about the false expectations that were often created in public utterances that the passing of either bill will expedite land reform. And this is where the real danger lies. Promulgating the legislation alone will not do it. There is a host of other processes that must be in place, of which the enactment of a proper Redistribution or Land Reform Act that authorises the expropriation of land for redistribution purposes should be high on the list.

But as for the Expropriation Bill: new expropriation legislation is long overdue, and the Expropriation Bill is a good piece of legislation (even if it is not perfect, see our submission here). The bill, once enacted, will give clarity to officials on how to do expropriation. That will remove the last excuse for the state not to use its expropriation powers where and if needed to acquire land for a public purpose or in the public interest.

We don’t need a constitutional amendment for that. We need the capacity. And we need the political will. DM

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


IPL 2021: MS Dhoni's Chennai Super Kings knock off Kolkata Knight Riders to lift fourth IPL title

© Provided by The Times of India Were those tears that we saw in MS Dhoni’s eyes? Probably. An adoring Chennai Super Kings fan brigade cheered him on from all ... Read more »

Trump's Picks Lag Cheney, GOP Incumbents in Fundraising

(Bloomberg) — Three House Republicans targeted by former President Donald Trump raised more money in the third quarter than his hand-picked candidates to defeat them, according to Federal Election Commission ... Read more »

AJ Raval denies being the third party in Ajlur Abrenica-Kylie Padilla breakup

© Provided by Mariing pinabulaanan ni AJ Raval na siya ang third party sa hiwalayan nina Aljur Abrenica at Kylie Padilla. Sa Facebook ngayong gabi ng Biyernes, October 15, ... Read more »

Rashford tersenarai kunjungan ke Leicester City

© Provided by Sinar Harian TONGGAK Manchester United, Marcus Rashford tersenarai dalam skuad The Red Devils menjelang kunjungan ke Stadium King Power menentang Leicester City dalam perlawanan Liga Perdana Inggeris ... Read more »

Barang runcit seludup bernilai RM14,148 dirampas

© Provided by Sinar Harian RANTAU PANJANG – Batalion 7 Pasukan Gerakan Am (PGA) Kuantan merampas pelbagai barangan runcit seludup bernilai RM14,148 selepas menahan sebuah lori di Lebuhraya Rantau Panjang-Pasir ... Read more »

Katrina Kaif, Sidharth Malhotra, Kiara Advani Attend Sardar Udham Screening, See Pics

© Provided by News18 On Friday evening, the team of Sardar Udham organised a special screening for the film fraternity in Mumbai. Lead actor Vicky Kaushal was seen greeting the ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15: Did Shamita Shetty go wrong when she bought scissors amidst an already intense physical fight in the house? Vote Now

© Provided by Bigg Boss OTT’s second runner-up Shamita Shetty was the highest-paid contestant in the show. Now, in Bigg Boss season 15 she is reportedly getting paid 5 ... Read more »

ICYMI: Singer Lucky Ali's daughter Sara Inara Ali's stunning photos go viral, fans wanna know if she sings too?

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Popular singer Lucky Ali’s daughter Sara Inara Ali was introduced on Instagram by actress Nafisa Ali Sodhi, who is a close family friend. ... Read more »

Aryan Khan Case: Here's Why Questions Are Being Raised About NCB's Two 'Panch' Witnesses

© Provided by News18 Aryan Khan Case: Here’s Why Questions Are Being Raised About NCB’s Two ‘Panch’ Witnesses In the traditional sense, panchas are five individuals who act as independent ... Read more »

Birthday Special: The Triumph of an Imperfect Romance Between Hema Malini and Dharmendra

© Provided by News18 One of the most epic romances the country saw was that of Hema Malini and Dharmendra’s. They worked in many films together, and their on-screen chemistry ... Read more »

Another defendant in University Hill riot takes plea deal

Oct. 15—Another defendant in the University Hill riot resolved his case with a misdemeanor plea deal. Boland Dodge, 21, pleaded guilty Friday to engaging in a riot, a Class 2 ... Read more »

Boulder man sentenced to six years in prison for assault

Oct. 15—A Boulder man who pleaded guilty to beating and choking a woman last year was sentenced to six years in prison Friday. John Conrad Richter, 21, pleaded guilty in ... Read more »

Longmont man fails to appear for sentencing in Boulder child sex assault case

Oct. 15—A warrant was issued for a Longmont man who failed to appear for sentencing in a child sex assault case. Jason Alan Elvey, 44, pleaded guilty in August to ... Read more »

Spain gets ‘tough' on Brits: Expats residency applications rejected for ‘nonsense'

Diego is a founding partner of Fairway Lawyers on the Costa del Sol and offers legal advice to British clients. He has worked with many British clients applying for Spanish ... Read more »

'You believe you're worthless' Woman hit by ageism recalls struggle to get job in her 50s

Jane Evans and Ally Owen are tackling an epidemic of joblessness for women over 50, and it’s led to countless women who have struggled to find work gain more confidence, ... Read more »

Aston Villa notebook: Newcastle coverage 'flabbergasts' Dean Smith as Villa Park expansion on hold

Villa boss Dean Smith was in a chirpy old mood this morning as he chatted to reporters via Zoom once more, while admitting how he had plenty of jobs that ... Read more »

Kahleah Copper demolishes Mercury, leads Sky to one win from first WNBA championship

Kahleah Copper could not be stopped and has the No. 6 Chicago Sky one win away from their first WNBA championship on a clunky night for the No. 5 Phoenix ... Read more »

NHL 22 Superstar Origins promo: How to complete all Event Objectives and master sets

© Provided by GamePur NHL 22 is now live, and so is the first Hockey Ultimate Team (HUT) promo. Superstar Origins is meant to overview the career arc for one ... Read more »

Squid Game: The rise of Korean drama addiction

If watching Squid Game means the prospect of playing red light, green light now fills you with nerve-shredding terror rather than fond childhood memories, you aren’t alone. The Korean thriller, ... Read more »

Largest ever heroin haul nabbed in Vic

An estimated $140 million worth of heroin hidden inside a shipping container sent to Melbourne from Malaysia has been intercepted by Australian authorities. © PR HANDOUT IMAGE PHOTO Australian authorities have ... Read more »

$8.34m Outback Museum of Australia to be built in Charleville

© Provided by ABC Business A mock design for the Outback Museum of Australia. A competition will decide the final design. (Supplied: Griffith University) A museum dedicated to showcasing the best ... Read more »

Retired farmer who shared his fears with wild creatures in his garden during cancer treatment has turned his chats into a book

A retired farmer who weathered chemotherapy as the pandemic struck confided his worries in the wild creatures gathered in and around his garden pond – turning his conversations into a ... Read more »

Contactless payment limit to jump to £100 in October

Contactless payments were first capped at £10 in 2007. (Jonathan Brady/PA) (PA Archive) The limit on contactless payments is set to rise for the second time in less than two ... Read more »

What is the new limit on contactless payments and how secure is it?

Contactless payments accounted for one in four UK transactions in 2020 (PA) British consumers will be able to make contactless payments of up to £100 in shops, cafes and bars ... Read more »

How to get a haunted house in BitLife

Choosing the location for you to live is essential and a fun option in BitLife. However, to complete many of the challenges in the game, you need to work towards obtaining a ... Read more »

CoD: Mobile season 9: Modern Warfare's Havoc Sawmill is coming to the game

Call of Duty: Mobile’s season nine is almost here and Activision has started revealing upcoming features in it. © Provided by Dot Esports The first of these is a new ... Read more »

IPL 2021 final: Spider-cam comes to Shubman Gill's rescue, denies Ravindra Jadeja from a wicket - Watch video

© Provided by Hindustan Times Spider-cam comes to Gill’s rescue, denies Jadeja from a wicket (HT Collage) A bizarre turn of events came to Shubman Gill’s rescue in the Indian ... Read more »

'We will be their biggest game' - Scotland coach Shane Burger's warning to first-round opponents

© Getty Images Shane Burger: “We can only focus on the Scotland way, and back each and every individual to bring out the best performance on the day” © Getty ... Read more »

Saurashtra Ranji Trophy winner Avi Barot dies aged 29

© MPCA Avi Barot had played for Gujarat and Haryana before settling down with Saurashtra © MPCA Avi Barot, the Saurashtra batter, occasional wicketkeeper and part-time offbreak bowler, died on ... Read more »

'A real boost to retirement savings' - the 'generous' alternative to pensions explained

Wealth Manager Christine Ross spoke exclusively to about other options apart from pensions that one may look into when retirement planning. Dealing with clients for many years, she has ... Read more »

Gabriel Garcia Marquez' clothes to go on sale in Mexico

© – Hundreds of articles of clothing and accessories owned by Nobel Prize-winning Colombian writer Gabriel Garcia Marquez go on sale in Mexico from October 20 Lovers of literature and ... Read more »

Philippines receives over 1M Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine doses

© NTF Against COVID-19 A total of 1,068,210 doses of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine arrive at the Ninoy Aquino International Airport Terminal 3 on Friday, October 15, 2021. The vaccines ... Read more »

Why Britney Spears says she is celebrating Christmas early this year

Britney Spears says she is celebrating Christmas early this year because “why not?” © Associated Press Britney Spears could regain control over her affairs in the next few months. Pic: ... Read more »

Moments of magic that capture mood of nation: Send us your pictures for our 2022 calendar

It is my pleasure to invite you, the reader, to be part of the 2022 Irish Independent Calendar. Every year, our calendar showcases the cream of the crop of pictures ... Read more »

Queensland records no new locally acquired cases of COVID-19 as Bunnings vaccination clinics open

Queensland has recorded no new locally acquired cases of COVID-19, as the state turns to a novel way to increase vaccination rates. Treasurer Cameron Dick held this morning’s press conference ... Read more »

Prince Philip Cut Sons Charles And Andrew Out Of His Will, Harry And Meghan's Nasty Fight, And More Royal Gossip

There’s been a surge of juicy gossip about the British royal family this past week, and we can’t wait to dig right in. Our favorite royal renegades, Prince Harry and ... Read more »

Russia is rolling out a facial recognition payment system for Moscow metro riders, sparking privacy concerns

© Provided by Business Insider Moscow metro’s new Face Pay could make life easier for some travelers, but also make it easier for Moscow to track down political opponents of ... Read more »

Biden supports DOJ prosecuting those defying subpoenas from committee

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo President Biden says he thinks those who refuse to comply with subpoenas from the January 6 select committee should be prosecuted by the ... Read more »

Security under spotlight after British MP stabbed to death

The fatal stabbing of British lawmaker David Amess was a terrorist incident, police said Saturday, as MPs pressed for tougher security in the wake of the second killing of a ... Read more »

Suspect in cold case homicides linked to 1988 slaying of 13-year-old girl

Oct. 15—In the early morning hours of Sept. 9, 1988, 13-year-old Stella Gonzales was walking home with a friend near Central and the river when she was shot in the ... Read more »