The death in custody of Frank Coleman highlights Australia's national shame

See all newsletters, GetUp’s

Frank ‘Gud’ Coleman when he was younger. Source: Aboriginal Legal Service.Source:Supplied


We don’t know much yet about how Frank “Gud” Coleman died.

We know that Gud, a 43-year-old Ngemba man, was found dead in his Long Bay Correctional Complex cell last week.

We know that his family only heard of his death through a family friend – hours before authorities contacted them with the news.

We know that his family is awaiting the results of an autopsy, as well as investigations by police and corrective services. Based on the experiences of other families, they could be waiting for years. They may never get answers at all.

See all newsletters, GetUp’s

Frank (right) with his deceased son Ricardo. This is one of the last photos they had taken together and was Frank’s prized possession. Source: Aboriginal Legal Service.Source:Supplied

Gud’s daughter Lakota Coleman told the ABC that the way they found out about her dad’s death was unacceptable.

“To hear through word of mouth, that’s just completely unacceptable and it further adds to the distress, because I don’t think any family member should have to be ringing around to find out if someone’s passed away,” she said.

Later that same week, an as-yet unidentified Aboriginal man on remand from Port Lincoln Prison died at the Royal Adelaide Hospital on Thursday.

Gud was the ninth First Nations person to die in custody in four months. The man in Adelaide was the 10th.

I am filled with grief and rage.

The Party Games newsletter Get your political briefing from’s political editor Samantha Maiden.

The Party Games newsletter Success! Check your inbox for details. See all newsletters

Grief for Gud. For his family. For those that loved him. For the life he should have lived.

And rage at the justice system that took him away. At the politicians who could have stopped this. At the indifference that caused his death, and the indifference it will be met with.

Gud is not a statistic. Tane Chatfield is not a statistic. David Dungay Jr is not a statistic. Tanya Day is not a statistic. Nathan Reynolds is not a statistic. Anzac Sullivan is not a statistic.

Every single one of the 479 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who have died in custody since 1991 was somebody. They had lives they should have lived. Families they should have grown old with. Decades ahead of them, filled with possibilities and potential, ripped away.

See all newsletters, GetUp’s

Frank ‘Gud’ Coleman when he was younger. Source: Aboriginal Legal Service.Source:Supplied

Instead, their families and loved ones have been left with holes in their lives that can never be filled. Losing a loved one in any circumstance, at any age, is a profoundly traumatic thing. But to have someone taken away so unfairly, and so needlessly, is more than tragic. It is an abomination.

When the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody handed down its recommendations in July 1991, I was only a few years old. For 30 years – nearly my entire life – the justice system has kept killing Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.

And for that entire time, apparently, governments have had more important things to do. They’ve had everything they need to make the justice system safer. All the hard work was done for them. And they haven’t been bothered to take the last, simple step of making those recommendations law.

Some of those recommendations are infuriatingly basic. Simple principles of international law – like only arresting people as a last resort, or not treating 10-year-old children as adults with criminal responsibility for their actions – have been ignored or further undermined by “tough-on-crime” policies and rhetoric.

Offences that are used to disproportionately target Indigenous people, like offensive language and public drunkenness, remain on the books. And as the world begins to move away from the prison-industrial complex – the practice of using incarceration as a way to deal with people labelled as undesirable, while helping private industry to turn a profit – state and territory governments across the country are opening new jails.

See all newsletters, GetUp’s

Long Bay Correctional Complex in Sydney where Gud died. Picture: Joel Carrett/AAPSource:AAP

The fruits of that three decades of inaction are obvious. First Nations people are the most incarcerated people in the world. Since 1991, the rate of Indigenous people in custody has more than doubled. First Nations people make up almost twice the percentage of the total prison population now than they did 30 years ago.

When Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people win Wimbledon or State of Origin, politicians can’t slap us on the back fast enough. But when a First Nations person dies in jail, or in lockup, or in police custody, they’re nowhere. For 30 years, they’ve been nowhere.

When we try to get answers about these deaths through the justice system – the ‘right’ way – we’re met with silence. When we ask politicians to do their jobs and protect us, we get empty promises.

And when we stand up against the system that’s killing us – like the young men who spelled out ‘BLM’ with sheets on the roof of the Parklea private prison last week – we’re beaten and tear-gassed. Demonised by the media. And abused in the comments sections.

What’s it going to take? How many more coroner’s reports and inquiries and commissions and Senate hearings are in our future, piling up like all the ones that came before? How many more rallies and vigils and minutes of silence?

Will 500 deaths be enough? A thousand?

How many more times will First Nations people have to pour out our grief, perform our sorrow and lay out the case for our own humanity, before Australia can be moved to change a system that kills us?

The day of Gud’s death was another day of shame for Australia. Unutterable shame. And those days are becoming too many to count.

Larissa Baldwin is a Widjabul woman from the Bundjalung Nations and GetUp’s First Nations Justice Campaign Director.

News Related


Indigenous leaders call for halt on Boral's sand mine excavation near massacre site

© Provided by ABC Business The Illawarra Local Aboriginal Land Council is seeking an urgent intervention from the federal government to stop work on Boral’s expanded Dunmore sand mind. (ABC Illawarra: Justin ... Read more »

Spirit of Tasmania overnight sailings cancelled following COVID-19 fears

© Provided by ABC Health Public Health says there is no risk to the 60 passengers booked on last night’s sailing from Devonport. (Facebook: Spirit of Tasmania) Spirit of Tasmania sailings ... Read more »

Victoria records 847 new local COVID-19 cases and one further death

© Provided by ABC Health Victoria has recorded 847 new locally acquired cases of COVID-19 and one further death, amid warnings to stay home this grand final day. The new ... Read more »

Wayne Bennett says Brisbane Broncos attempted to undermine South Sydney coaching career

Wayne Bennett has taken a major swipe at his former employers, the Brisbane Broncos, just minutes after he guided South Sydney to next week’s NRL grand final. After South Sydney romped ... Read more »

Victoria recorded 847 new Covid-19 cases

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Victoria has recorded 847 new Covid-19 cases and one death with the next set of restrictions to be eased a week later than ... Read more »

New testing centres open after more than 30 COVID-19 exposure sites listed in south-west Victoria

© Provided by ABC Health Two new testing centres have opened in south-west Victoria after more than 30 COVID-19 exposure sites were identified in the region. Two of the exposure ... Read more »

Vics record 847 virus cases, one death

Victoria has recorded 847 new locally acquired COVID-19 cases and another death from the virus. © James Ross/AAP PHOTOS Victoria has recorded 847 new virus cases and another death. The ... Read more »

Hear her roar: Danielle Hardwick is kicking goals after the end of her marriage to Richmond coach Damien

© Provided by ABC NEWS Danielle Hardwick is celebrating her new life in art. (ABC News: Matilda Marozzi) Danielle Hardwick is still grieving the break-up of her marriage to Richmond coach Damien ... Read more »

Three fatal shark attacks in three years won't stop Esperance residents moving forward

© Provided by ABC NEWS Karen Milligan returns to the water one year after her husband’s death.  (ABC News: Emily Smith) Karen Milligan could have easily turned her back on ... Read more »

Melbourne Demons, Western Bulldogs fans nervous as Perth stadium awaits first AFL grand final

© Provided by ABC NEWS Devout Demons fan Joan Lawson is ready for a win tonight. (ABC News: Rebecca Trigger) As Perth wakes to its first AFL grand final in ... Read more »

Piecing together 'tectonic jigsaw' shows ancient earthquakes shaped the mighty Murray River

© Provided by ABC NEWS The Barmah Millewa Forest in southern NSW was created by the series of earthquakes on the Cadell Fault. (Supplied: MDBA) The modern course of the ... Read more »

Morrison meets with Quad leaders as Australia gets serious about tempering China's strength

It is entirely conceivable to assume news of Australia’s shock foray into nuclear-powered submarines was deliberately timed to drop as Prime Minister Scott Morrison hit the world stage. Flying to the ... Read more »

‘No timeframe, let alone a date': France has no immediate plans to speak to Canberra

© Reuters French President Emmanuel Macron has been angered by Australia’s decision to axe a major submarine contract. France has no immediate plans to restore diplomatic relations with Australia, as ... Read more »

Victorian COVID-19 exposure sites list includes venues in Warrnambool, Camperdown, Brunswick, Hampton Park

More exposure sites have been identified in regional Victoria as COVID-19 continues its spread into all parts of the state. Shops, restaurants, public transport and an antique market have been ... Read more »

In Melbourne, AFL fans can't go to the grand final, but are still celebrating the game

Ted Dorhmann lives deep in the Western Bulldog’s heartland, but his heart beats red and blue. “I was born into it, I’m the fourth generation in a Demons family,” he explains. ... Read more »

Deep in the Daintree, this couple joins tree changers switching to off-grid living

© Provided by ABC Business Janelle and Mark Moore live an off-grid lifestyle north of the Daintree River in Queensland. (Supplied) Janelle and Mark Moore spent five years sailing around ... Read more »

Andrews and Berejiklian weigh defamation risks of allowing Facebook comments

The offices of Daniel Andrews and Gladys Berejiklian are considering how to manage defamation risks on their social media pages, as Tasmanian Premier Peter Gutwein said he would turn off ... Read more »

Annastacia Palaszczuk's comments about COVID-19 travel overseas perplexes Queensland's Indian community

© Provided by ABC Health Pooja Manchanda, who has a two-year-old son with husband Sahil Garg, has no other family support in Australia. (Supplied) Pooja Manchanda hasn’t been home to ... Read more »

High cost of veterinary care at major chains causing pets to be unnecessarily euthanised, senior vets say

© Provided by ABC Business Dan Blackwell travelled interstate with his dog Angel after being quoted up to $8,000 for surgery for his pet. (Supplied) Senior veterinarians say it is ... Read more »

Fraudulent ivermectin studies open up new battleground between science and misinformation

Dr Carlos Chaccour ran into difficulty when he and his colleagues began recruiting patients in Peru for their study to determine the effect of a daily dose of the anti-parasitic ... Read more »

‘Are you going to India?': Queensland isn't in any hurry to open borders

A steel shade structure went up on Friday over the Gold Coast highway at Tugun, where police and soldiers are manning the border checkpoint between New South Wales and Queensland. ... Read more »

Vaccine passports in Australia: who will impose them and how will they work?

As states and territories set out their plans to ease Covid-19 health restrictions, one leader has made clear that it’s now every jurisdiction for itself when it comes to the ... Read more »

NSW on track to hit 90 per cent first dose COVID-19 vaccination milestone

NSW is on track to have 90 per cent of its population aged 16 and over vaccinated with a first dose of a COVID-19 shot by next month. Chief Health ... Read more »

'Effective unemployment' is as high as a year ago, but households not getting same support

© Provided by ABC Business Government income support is not the same in these lockdowns, but some households are still saving a lot (ABC News: John Gunn) Australia’s effective unemployment rate ... Read more »

Is there likely to be a religious exemption for the COVID-19 vaccine?

Since the recent round of stay-at-home orders were introduced in Sydney and Melbourne, religious messages and motifs have been popping up at loosely defined “anti lockdown” protests across Australia.   As ... Read more »

Family, fans in thoughts at AFL decider

When he runs out before a capacity AFL grand final crowd in Perth, Melbourne skipper Max Gawn will spare a thought for fans in lockdown back home. © Richard Wainwright/AAP ... Read more »

Joyce calls for caution on net zero target

Barnaby Joyce has warned the Nationals will not back a 2050 net zero greenhouse gas emissions target without power reliability guarantees. © Lukas Coch/AAP PHOTOS Barnaby Joyce won’t back a ... Read more »

Hasler calls for review after Keppie knock

Coach Des Hasler has called for closer examination of game stoppages after Manly’s Sean Keppie was allowed to wobble on the field for almost a minute after a head knock ... Read more »

Johnson bid to mend Franco-British relations met with cool response

Boris Johnson has told Emmanuel Macron he wants to “re-establish cooperation” in the wake of the Aukus defence pact row, during a frosty-sounding call between the leaders of Britain and ... Read more »

Treasurer signing up to 'Marxist, green, woke agenda'

Queensland Liberal Senator Gerard Rennick says Treasurer Josh Frydenberg is signing up to a “Marxist, green, woke agenda” amid the treasurer revealing he backs a net zero commitment ahead of ... Read more »

All eyes turn to the MCG… um, wait … Optus Stadium as footy fever strikes

One sleep to go before the AFL Grand Final, and Optus Stadium in Perth is a nice, neutral ground for the footy match that stops a nation. Judging by WA ... Read more »

Victoria's Pfizer doses locked in for October

Vaccine manufacturer Pfizer has assured Australia it will receive 9 million doses of its COVID-19 vaccine next month, providing certainty after state and territory governments were warned of a potential ... Read more »

Man bashed wife to death with concrete bollard

A Brisbane man who bashed his wife to death with a concrete bollard after a fight over infidelity has been found guilty of manslaughter. Sandra Peniamina, a mother of four, ... Read more »

Failure to regulate flood plain harvesting ‘a real embarrassment', Bret Walker tells NSW inquiry

Australia’s failure to regulate flood plain harvesting was “a real embarrassment”, but the practice was unlikely to be illegal, the former chair of South Australia’s royal commission into the Murray-Darling ... Read more »

Australian not-for-profit rescues orphans from Afghanistan

An Australian not-for-profit has rescued 17 at-risk people from Afghanistan, including 10 orphans. First international flight leaves Kabul since Taliban takeover The children were being cared for in orphanages run ... Read more »

Man dies after serious crash in South Australia

One man is dead and another is in hospital after a crash on South Australia‘s South Eastern Freeway this afternoon. Major crash investigators are working to determine the circumstances surrounding ... Read more »

Supercars back on track in NSW in October

The interrupted Supercars championship will get back on track next month with four back-to-back weekends of racing at Sydney Motorsport Park as NSW emerges from coronavirus lockdown. © PR HANDOUT ... Read more »

As Frydenberg peddles net-zero, it's still all about… coal

Rarely has the gap between political reality and fantasy peddled by a government and press gallery been wider. © Provided by Crikey Today we have yet another round of the ... Read more »

Mixed reactions to SA Parliament's changes to Independent Commissioner Against Corruption

© Provided by ABC NEWS Former South Australian independent commissioner against corruption Bruce Lander. (File: ABC News) South Australia’s former independent commissioner against corruption (ICAC) Bruce Lander has joined those ... Read more »

Queensland woman charged with importing 14kg of meth from Mexico

A Queensland woman is facing life in prison after being charged with importing 14kg of methamphetamine from Mexico. Border Force officers allegedly found the drugs hidden inside boxes labelled as ... Read more »