The case for big-time college sports helping academics remains weak

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Maria Lysaker/USA Today Sports

Riding the short distance from downtown to the University of Houston campus, light rail passengers arrive at Athletics District station in the shadow of a towering 40,000-capacity football stadium that opened in 2014 at a cost of about $125m.

An adjacent $20m, 100,000 sq ft indoor football practice centre opened in 2017. The smart facilities give the impression that you’ve stepped into a big-time institution, and the university’s football team will soon have the cachet to match its bricks and mortar.

University leaders were jubilant earlier this month when it was announced that the Cougars will join the Big 12 conference, along with three others, as the prestigious league restocks after two of the biggest college football powers, Oklahoma and Texas, decided to leave for the Southeastern Conference.

“I love big. I love everything big,” the Houston president, Renu Khator, told reporters.

Houston is widely viewed as a poor relation to Texas’ better-known public universities, the University of Texas at Austin and Texas A&M, and is often dismissed as a “commuter school” – of its 47,090 students last year, 80% came from the Houston area. So football and basketball are central to its profile-boosting efforts, or so the theory goes.

Indeed, the university’s new television commercial debuted on ESPN and is based around a football chant. No one would dispute that a thrilling season – like the Cougars’ run to the Final Four of March Madness this year – brings more media attention than, say, a new library. And some studies have found that successful teams can help increase student applications, at least in the short term.

© Photograph: Maria Lysaker/USA Today Sports The Houston Cougars are backed my a multimillion dollar business.

But athletic prominence comes at a price. President since 2008, Khator has overseen an outlay of hundreds of millions of dollars into athletics: a bet that spending heavily on football and basketball, alongside improved academic offerings, adds value to the institution. A university spokesman declined to comment for this article.

Revenues have risen but Houston’s athletics expenses soared from $39.5m in 2014 to $73.7m in 2019 – less than half the amount that the top 10 schools spend but still a hefty amount. A handful of athletics departments, such as Texas (which has newly renovated one end of its football stadium at a cost of $175m) are profitable. Many others, such as Houston, subsidise sports programmes through funds from the university’s wider budget, mandatory student fees of hundreds or even thousands of dollars each year, and donations.

The spending sprees invite philosophical and practical questions. Are high-level sports teams an investment or an indulgence? Do the trappings of professionalism divorce athletics from universities’ core educational mission, or are sports like football and basketball so embedded in American college culture that they are fundamental to the identity of the institution? And, in the absence of tight regulations, should more be done to ensure income is spent prudently and expenses kept in check, especially at a time when rising tuition costs add to the burden of student debt and many academic departments face budget squeezes?

There is a $10m exit fee to leave the American Athletic Conference – a relative bargain compared with reported penalties of up to $80m facing the Longhorns and Sooners should they leave the Big 12 before 2025. But Houston’s jump to a bigger division means a likely five- or six-fold increase in annual media rights revenue from the current $7m.

As in the professional ranks, pressure to win demands ever-higher spending, abetted by skyrocketing media rights deals and the enthusiasm of rich donors. But in a realm where players are unpaid “student-athletes”, the money is not going on stars’ salaries. Instead the arms race manifests in extravagant facilities, recruiting costs and coaches’ wages. Texas has a $7m locker room. Oregon has a $12m video board and sound system.

The $3m-per-year agreement signed in 2020 by Kelvin Sampson, the Houston men’s basketball head coach, included a range of performance-related bonuses (for academic as well as sporting results), two courtesy cars and up to 40 hours of private plane use per year for recruiting purposes.

Houston’s football head coach, Dana Holgorsen, signed a contract in 2019 that pays him in excess of $20m over five years – more than double his predecessor’s deal and a far more generous package than his peers outside the elite Power Five conferences. Sampson and Holgorsen, who has won 10 games and lost 14 at Houston, are each reportedly in line for a $1m bonus now that Houston is joining the Big 12. Holgorsen is also set for a raise.

“When the College Football Playoff was created, when the conferences began their [broadcast] networks, billions of dollars of new revenues flowed into college sports and those revenues disproportionately were spent on coaches’ salaries, increasing athletics personnel, and facilities,” says Amy Privette Perko, chief executive of the Knight Commission on Intercollegiate Athletics, which advocates for reform in college sports.

“While there were increases in athlete benefits, [they were] clearly not to the degree that money was spent in those other areas and we know there’s still a tremendous unmet need which relates to medical expenses and additional educational benefits for athletes.”

The Commission has released a report that recommends changes to the distribution and spending of the more than $3.5bn given out annually by the NCAA, College Football Playoff and Division I conferences. “At the highest levels there’s just a continuous drive for more revenue but there’s no educational nexus that connects where those additional revenues are going to be spent,” she says.

NCAA figures tell a predictable story of expenses outpacing revenues. Only 25 athletics departments among the 351 Division I institutions generated a surplus in 2018-19. Of the nearly $19bn spent on athletics in 2019 among more than 1,100 NCAA schools, $3.6bn went on financial aid for student-athletes and $3.7 bn was paid to coaches. Altogether, athletics departments generated 56% of their own revenue, with the other 44% subsidised by other sources, such as “institutional support” and student fees.

Rutgers University switched conferences and began play in the Big Ten in 2014: a chance for the Scarlet Knights to face giants such as Michigan and Ohio State and a move touted at the time as heralding a financial windfall for the school. But their balance sheet is as red as their uniforms. The athletics department is $265m in debt, The Record discovered, including internal loans worth $84m to cover annual losses, as coaches’ salaries and operating expenses ballooned.

Another college with a heavily-subsidised athletics department, the University of Cincinnati, is ascending to the Big 12. Last year it eliminated its men’s soccer team, which lost about $700,000 in 2019, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported, while giving its head football coach a privately-funded contract extension raising his annual pay by $1m, to $3.4m.

Dave Ridpath, associate professor of sports management at Ohio University, believes there is a “trickle-down effect of where schools feel that they have to have some type of a premier football program or be in the company of premier football and that somehow makes the university.” He is a past president of the Drake Group, an advocacy network with a stated mission to “defend academic integrity in higher education from the corrosive aspects of commercialised college sports.”

As a large university with a solid sports tradition in a major city, Houston has greater potential than many ambitious smaller institutions. “I think it’s OK to try to be the best you can at the level you can be at, but if you’re trying to reach an impossible dream you can spend yourself into oblivion and you see a lot of schools doing that that really have no chance of breaking into that exclusive club. Even if you’re invited into that club it’s not a panacea,” Ridpath says.

With the future of college sports at a crossroads given the pressures on the amateurism model and the strident demands for governance reform, now might be the moment to refocus the relationship between sports and education – or, perhaps, sever it. “I’m OK if it goes completely professional,” Ridpath says. “Let’s just be honest. Don’t put that cost on the back of tuition-paying students.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

1 deputy killed, 2 injured in shooting at Houston bar

A constable deputy was killed and two others were injured in a shooting early Saturday while they were working an extra job at a bar in Houston, according to police. ... Read more »

Nuñez sentenced to 21 years for his role in beating death of teen

Oct. 16—State District Judge Matthew Wilson sentenced Jordan Nuñez to 21 years in prison Friday for failing to intervene while his father beat and tortured 13-year-old Jeremiah Valencia to death ... Read more »

Why Are All the Grandparents Freaking Out About Christmas Presents and Supply Chains All of a Sudden?

© Licensed from Adobe If your Boomer-generation parents or grandparents have recently started panicking about the availability of Christmas presents and sharing urgent concerns about “supply chains,” then you’re not ... Read more »

Man ‘impersonated a police officer to kidnap girl of 14 in Sussex'

Photograph: Nigel Bowles/Alamy A man has been charged with sexual offences after allegedly kidnapping a teenage girl while impersonating a police officer. David Peter Young, 32, a chef from Ifield, ... Read more »

Jussie Smollett case will go to trial

A judge denied a request to dismiss Empire actor Jussie Smollett's criminal case after he allegedly lied to police officers over being a victim of a hate crime in January ... Read more »

Jaguars vs. Dolphins odds, picks, how to watch, live stream: 2021 NFL in London predictions from top model

The Jacksonville Jaguars (0-5) will head to England for the eighth time to take on the Miami Dolphins (1-4) on Sunday. The Jaguars have lost 20 consecutive games dating back ... Read more »

Lamar Jackson reacts to surprise Louisville number retirement: 'Y'all just made my day'

Lamar Jackson will be the last player to wear No. 8 at Louisville. The university surprised Jackson with that announcement, and captured his reaction to the news. Jackson went back ... Read more »

Clay Martin's intervention during live play isn't uncommon, but definitely looked unusual

© Provided by NBC Sports During Thursday night’s game between the Buccaneers and the Eagles, Fox cameras caught referee Clay Martin keeping Philadelphia defensive end Derek Barnett and Tampa Bay ... Read more »

Missouri governor is calling for criminal charges against a journalist who found social security numbers exposed on a public website

© Provided by INSIDER Missouri Gov. Mike Parson Jeff Roberson/AP The governor of Missouri is calling for criminal charges against a reporter who found social security numbers exposed online. The ... Read more »

Piers Morgan pays tribute to Sir David Amess as MP seen grinning at daughter's wedding just weeks before stabbing murder

PIERS Morgan has shared a photograph of a murdered MP attending his daughter's wedding just a month before his death. Sir David Amess is seen beaming alongside wife Julia and ... Read more »

Here's What To Do if Taking Vitamins Doesn't Agree With Your Stomach, According to a G.I. Doc

© Photo: Getty Images/ Grace Cary upset stomach from vitamins In a perfect world, everyone would get all the nutrients they need from food and there would be no need ... Read more »

Blair ‘very confident' federal vaccine passport coming by U.S. border reopening on Nov. 8

Public Safety Minister Bill Blair says he’s ‘very confident’ that Canadians will have a national vaccine passport in place by the time the U.S. border reopens for non-essential travel on ... Read more »

Indigenous Peoples Day marked with celebrations, protests

FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. (AP) — Indigenous people across the United States marked Monday with celebrations of their heritage, education campaigns and a push for the Biden administration to make good on ... Read more »

A NASA engineer on Mars and life in the universe: ‘It would be very lonely if it were only us'

I operate Perseverance, NASA’s rover on the surface of Mars—we have a team of about 60 people. We work on local Mars time, or LMST. A Martian day, or sol, ... Read more »

T20 World Cup: MS Dhoni's eye for intricate details will increase our confidence, says Virat Kohli

© Provided by Zee News Dubai: His mere presence aside, Indian team mentor Mahendra Singh Dhoni’s “eye for intricate details” and “practical advice” will help in enhancing the confidence of ... Read more »

Duterte: Gov't expediting Marawi rehab

© Screengrab from RTVM video President Duterte in Marawi for the fourth anniversary of the city’s liberation from Maute rebels (October 16, 2021) President Rodrigo Duterte on Saturday vowed to ... Read more »

COLUMN: MS Dhoni Might Not be The Best IPL Captain By The Numbers, But Numbers Do Lie

© Provided by News18 COLUMN: MS Dhoni Might Not be The Best IPL Captain By The Numbers, But Numbers Do Lie Great players are often judged by their numbers. The ... Read more »

Maring leaves 22 dead; 17 other reported fatalities being validated –NDRRMC

Maring leaves P980-million damage to agriculture —DA The death toll from Severe Tropical Storm Maring climbed to 22, with 17 more reported fatalities still being validated, the National Disaster Risk ... Read more »

IPL 2021 Delhi Capitals Review: Peaking at the Wrong Time DC Endure Another 'Almost There' Season

© Provided by News18 IPL 2021 Delhi Capitals Review: Peaking at the Wrong Time DC Endure Another ‘Almost There’ Season It was a strange IPL season for Delhi Capitals; at ... Read more »

How unlucky has Alonso really been in F1 2021?

© Jerry Andre / Motorsport Images Fernando Alonso, Alpine A521, in the gravel But how unlucky has he really been in 2021? At Istanbul Park Alonso excelled in qualifying and ... Read more »

India vs Nepal SAFF Championship 2021 Final Live Score and Updates: Igor Stimac Eyes First Title, Blue Tigers Aim for 8th Trophy

© Provided by News18 India vs Nepal, SAFF Championship 2021 Live: Despite a jittery start to its 2021 South Asian Football Federation (SAFF) Championship campaign, India find themselves in the ... Read more »

Power-hitting? Sure, but Pollard expects 'complete games of cricket' from West Indies

© AFP/Getty Images “We have a lot of powerful guys in the line-up, but if the situation warrants, we also have guys who can manoeuvre strike, run between the wickets” ... Read more »

Older adults shouldn't take aspirin daily to prevent 1st heart attack, stroke: U.S. panel

© Lee Brown/The Canadian Press Healthy seniors shouldn’t take Aspirin to prevent heart attacks, a U.S. panel says. People over 60 shouldn’t take daily aspirin to prevent a first stroke ... Read more »

A 22-year-old Texas man involved in a plot to use Grindr to kidnap and rob gay men has been sentenced to 23 years in prison

© Thomas Trutschel/Getty Images Grindr app. Thomas Trutschel/Getty Images A Texas man involved in a Grindr plot to kidnap and rob Grindr users has been sentenced. Daniel Jenkins is the ... Read more »

The devastating Hurricane Hazel ravaged Haiti, North Carolina, and the GTA

This Day In Weather History is a daily podcast by Chris Mei from The Weather Network, featuring stories about people, communities and events and how weather impacted them. — Hurricane ... Read more »

Twitter debuts new ad features, revamped algorithm ahead of ecommerce push

By Sheila Dang © Reuters/Dado Ruvic FILE PHOTO: A 3D-printed logo for Twitter is seen in this picture illustration made in Zenica (Reuters) – Twitter Inc on Tuesday rolled out ... Read more »

Tuberculosis outbreak “under control” in Black Lake and Fond Du Lac First Nations

A tuberculosis (TB) outbreak in Black Lake and Fond Du Lac First Nations has been declared to be under control by the Athabasca Health Authority. The outbreak, when first declared ... Read more »

How a group of 'ornery,' 'nerdy' divers pulled off the miraculous Thai cave rescue

The divers who saved 12 boys and their soccer coach from a flooded Thailand cave in 2018 were obviously brave. Immense courage would be required from anyone willing to swim ... Read more »

Locked and Loaded: Supreme Court is ready for a showdown on the Second Amendment

In the movie “True Grit,” federal marshal Rooster Cogburn is asked if the gun that he brandished at a crime scene was loaded. Cogburn, played by John Wayne, dryly responds: ... Read more »

Global tax accord could earn Canada up to $4.5 billion per year, says Freeland

© Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press Minister of Finance and Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland holds a press conference in Ottawa on Wednesday, Oct. 6, 2021. Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland says ... Read more »

A young Chrystia Freeland impressed Soviet Russia's KGB

Welcome to a sneak peek of the Maclean’s Politics Insider newsletter. Sign up to get it delivered straight to your inbox in the morning. © Used with permission of / ... Read more »

FDA Panel Recommends a Booster Shot for All Johnson & Johnson Vaccine Recipients

An external panel of experts recommended that the Food and Drug Administration authorize booster shots for everyone who received Johnson & Johnson’s COVID-19 vaccine on Friday, to be given at ... Read more »

10 Stylish Jean Cuts That Aren't Skinny Jeans

© Pexels Woman sitting in mom jeans Although for a number of years it looked like skinny jeans were here to stay, Gen Z has declared that stick-thin denim is ... Read more »

Toronto hospitals, Quebec company behind world's first delivery of lungs by drone

TORONTO — Dr. Shaf Keshavjee was full of nerves as he scanned Toronto’s darkened skyline, craning his neck to spot a drone whizzing toward the downtown rooftop he was standing ... Read more »

All the Celebrities Who Got Married in 2021

© Getty Images Christina Ricci in a forest green collard dress Despite a global pandemic and unpredictable lockdowns, these celebs pushed through and said ‘I do.’ A post shared by ... Read more »

Judge strikes down Maj.-Gen. Fortin's request for reinstatement to vaccine campaign

OTTAWA — A Federal Court judge has struck down Maj.-Gen. Dany Fortin’s request for reinstatement as the head of Canada’s COVID-19 vaccine distribution campaign after he was abruptly removed from ... Read more »

Medical examiner describes deaths of mother, toddler at Calgary murder trial

CALGARY — A Calgary mother who was found buried along with her young daughter in a shallow grave two years ago was beaten and shot in the head, a forensic ... Read more »

Saudi Arabia's PIF launches offshore platform tourism project

© Reuters/HANDOUT Saudi launch Public Investment Fund Strategy 2021-2025 CAIRO (Reuters) – Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund, the Public Investment Fund, announced on Saturday the launch of “THE RIG”, which ... Read more »

Senior CAF officer steps aside months into sexual misconduct investigation against him

© Adrienne South/Global News Canadian Armed Forces will be conducting a training exercise beginning Saturday at the old Guelph Correctional Centre A senior military officer in the Canadian Armed Forces ... Read more »

Man accused of murdering Calgary mom, toddler in 2019 enters guilty plea to one count

British citizen Robert Leeming has pleaded guilty to the second-degree murder of Calgary mom Jasmine Lovett in 2019. © File/Global News Accused murderer Robert Leeming pictured in Calgary in 2019. ... Read more »