The bigger problem revealed by a viral fight between NYC police and subway riders

Asia's Tech News Daily

The bigger problem revealed by a viral fight between NYC police and subway riders
© Provided by NBC News

On Tuesday, a man named Andrew Gilbert approached to New York police officers in a Manhattan subway station and asked why they weren’t wearing masks, in accordance with police department and city public transit policy. As bystanders filmed, the unmasked officers forced Gilbert off the platform through an emergency exit door. Video of the incident has been viewed close to three million times.

While the video is striking, the behavior it illustrates has been going on for well over a year now. Americans riding public transit, shopping in stores, and walking on the street have repeatedly asked why are so many officers not wearing a cloth covering medical officials have proven can reduce the likelihood of transmitting Covid-19? (The trend is so prevalent it has inspired Twitter accounts.)

It’s bad enough that mask mandates seemingly do not apply to the officers often tasked with enforcing them. But the altercation in New York City highlights a deeper problem: The way police seek to penalize or harass anyone who dares question the unofficial and ultra-legal privileges of being an officer.

Mask mandates are a canary in the coal mine. If there is no plausible way to get all officers to wear a small strip of fabric that does quantifiable good for the public, what does that say about the institution as a whole? Who really controls police?

We’re told that police are there to protect and serve the public. It’s written on the side of police cars and on badges across the country. And yet, when it comes to mask and vaccine mandates, both of which experts say limit the spread of a pandemic, these words ring particularly hollow. In cities like Los Angeles or states like Oregon, police and state troopers are willing to face fines or firing in order to avoid getting a vaccine.

In an act of cosmic irony, police really do not like being told what to do. For a profession that continues to claim that obedience provides a magic armor that will prevent motorists and pedestrians from being injured by police, some members of law enforcement feel emboldened to disregard orders, policies, and laws with aplomb.

Covid has punctuated this reality, but it is not a recent phenomenon. For as long as commissioners and mayors have been giving orders, police have resisted them if they have contradicted their understanding of the job or their vision of themselves.

In 1917, New York City Police Commissioner Arthur Woods publicly toyed with the idea of requiring police officers to wear wrist watches. Chaos ensued. What began with a trifling suggestion in an attempt to make paperwork more accurate ended in revolt.

Some officers joked to the press that if required to wear a wristwatch, they would wear them hidden above the elbow or strapped to the small of their back. Others chaffed at the idea that the commissioner, a political appointee and not a uniformed officer, would dare to try to impose reforms on the rank and file. One officer harkened back to the romanticized earlier days of policing, claiming that the manly patrolmen of the past would reject watches as being “dandy-ish” and a sign of weakness. “Why, every gang on the beat,” he said, “would be waiting for you to beat you up.” This small reform chafed against officer’s image of themselves as tough and unrestrained.

The officer concluded by telling journalists, “When they put that rule into effect I guess I’ll ask to retire.”

One century and two pandemics later, police are still resistant to top-down orders that interfere with their vision and image. The politics of police and their unions have also become more entrenched and strongly partisan. Watches don’t benefit the public good in the same way masks do, but still the rebellion continues. In Los Angeles, New York, Kansas City and a number of other cities, mayors, governors, and commissioners have pleaded with officers to follow mask mandates. But as we can see, these calls can be ignored.

And the idea that police reforms can be ignored is quantifiably dangerous. In July 2014, State Island resident Eric Garner was killed by a police officer using a chokehold the New York City Police Department banned in 1993. Around the country, bans of chokeholds going back decades have not impeded their continued use. Similar bans on shooting at moving vehicles have also been ignored, as was the case in the police killing Sean Bell in 2006.

Police officers, and their union leaders, appear able to resist changes to policing and policy, in part because of accumulated political power — and because of the ace up their sleeve. Police can always threaten that if pushed too far into change or reform, they can walk off the job — prompting fears that cities would descend into chaos. It’s why police are invested in perpetuating the notion that people are constantly in danger, and that they are the only institution that can provide relief. It’s also why, despite calls for serious police reform, police department budgets universally increased in 2021.

Cities have found themselves in a Catch-22: they have underfunded alternative institutions designed to address public well-being to the extent that police are often the only branch of government able to respond to calls for service. That gives them considerable leverage over the democratically elected people who run cities and it’s why so many elected officials seem powerless to enact any street-level change whatsoever.

It’s unclear if anything can contain the conduct of police on the street. If policy, laws, and pleas from superiors and elected officials have, historically and in the current moment, had little impact, what is the public to do? The hard lesson may be that policing as an institution is perhaps too politically entrenched, too resistant and too subject to inertia to be reformed.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Soccer-Arsenal not willing to entertain offers for Pepe, says Arteta

© Reuters/HANNAH MCKAY FA Cup – Third Round – Arsenal v Newcastle United (Reuters) – Arsenal are yet to see whether club-record signing Nicolas Pepe will live up to their ... Read more »

Heathrow and Gatwick: Where you can travel with kids - vaccine rules for 12-15 year olds

The Government are continuing to encourage 12-15 year olds to come forward for their first (and only) jab as we approach winter. It was back in September that Prime Minister ... Read more »

French fishermen block UK boats in post-Brexit protest

French fishermen block boats at St Malo (REUTERS) French fisherman who claim they have been ‘humiliated’ by Britain over post-Brexit operating licences on Friday begun blockading UK ships. Their boats ... Read more »

Crusaders star reveals the biggest threat to their 2022 title hopes

© (Photo by Fiona Goodall/Getty Images) Crusaders star reveals the biggest threat to their 2022 title hopes Crusaders star Bryn Hall has pinpointed his former team, the Blues, as the ... Read more »

Horoscope Today, November 27, Saturday: These 2 Zodiac Signs Should Thinking About Saving Money

© KS Swati | Pandit Jagannath Guruji Representational Picture. Horoscope Today, November 27, Saturday: A little sneak-peak on how your day will go does no harm. Sagittarius and Gemini should ... Read more »

Junior Men's Hockey World Cup: India eye win over Poland to get to quarterfinals

© Provided by The Times of India After India’s shocking defeat in the tournament opener, the hosts had come out all guns blazing and beaten Canada 13-1 in their Junior ... Read more »

Quiz: Five questions on Magnus Carlsen's challenger- Ian Nepomniachtchi, and his maverick life

© Provided by The Indian Express Q1. Nepo was asked about his plans to spend the money earned from Candidates and other prize tournaments. For the moment I don’t have ... Read more »

Havana Syndrome: FBI warns staff amid reports of symptoms among agents

Photograph: Joshua Roberts/Reuters The FBI has warned its employees about Havana Syndrome, a mysterious ailment that appears to have affected US diplomats and spies in several countries in recent years ... Read more »

CIA director is said to have warned Russia of 'consequences' if it's found to be behind the 'Havana Syndrome' illnesses hurting US personnel around the world

Russian President Vladimir Putin.Photo by Mikhail Svetlov/Getty Images US personnel have reported brain damage and other symptoms of the mysterious “Havana Syndrome.” CIA Director Bill Burns warned Russian intel services ... Read more »

UAE reaches Covid-19 vaccination milestone as 100% receive first jab

© DHA The UAE’s vaccine campaign has reached an important milestone as 100 per cent of people have received the first dose. The UAE has reached a major milestone in ... Read more »

10 Restaurants in Manila With Breathtaking Views

© Provided by PHOTO BY Discovery Primea, Facebook/La Cathedral Cafe ILLUSTRATION Warren Espejo © Provided by PHOTO BY Discovery Primea, Facebook/La Cathedral Cafe ILLUSTRATION Warren Espejo ( With ... Read more »

New COVID variant threat causes worldwide scramble

The Associated PressPeople line up to get on the Air France flight to Paris at OR Tambo International Airport in Johannesburg, South Africa, Friday Nov. 26, 2021. A slew of ... Read more »

G.V. Mavalankar — the man who Nehru dubbed the ‘father of Lok Sabha'

© Provided by The Print On his 133rd birth anniversary, ThePrint examines G.V. Mavalankar’s role as the first Speaker of the Lok Sabha. On 15 May 1952, the first session ... Read more »

Delhi-Mumbai Industrial Corridor: Four industrial smart cities being developed, says Commerce Ministry

© Provided by The Financial Express Four greenfield industrial smart cities or nodes are being developed in the states of Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, and Uttar Pradesh under DMIC. (representational ... Read more »

Pulp-it | Should you lose sleep over Omicron?

© Provided by Hindustan Times It’s safe to assume that full vaccination provides more protection than partial vaccination (REUTERS) The answers to three questions should guide our response to Omicron, ... Read more »

Over 20 injured as pick-up truck rams into pedestrians near Pune

More than 20 people were injured when a pick-up truck ploughed into a group of pilgrims in Vadgaon Maval area near Pune on Saturday morning. The pilgrims, known as warkaris ... Read more »

Time to open the shroud of Gandhiji, says assassination case researcher

© Provided by The Times of India After losing all legal battles over reopening of the Gandhi murder case, is Dr Pankaj Phadnis going to rely on bedside stories of ... Read more »

Prashant Kishor's Bengaluru visit meant to build base for TMC in Karnataka?

© Provided by DNA Political strategist Prashant Kishor who was in Bengaluru on Thursday is reportedly trying to build a base for the Trinamool Congress in the BJP-ruled state of ... Read more »

Punjab Police Constable recruitment 2021: Results of written exam out; check

© Provided by Firstpost Punjab Police Constable recruitment 2021: Results of written exam out; check The results for the written exam of the Punjab Police Constable 2021 have been ... Read more »

Blast die «Normalisierung» ab!

Der Bundesrat hat in der Bevölkerung naiv-optimistische Erwartungen geschürt. Nach der Abstimmung sollte er ein Zeitalter neuer Ehrlichkeit einläuten. © Foto: Peter Schneider (Keystone) Bundesrat Alain Berset spricht an einer ... Read more »

Dow plummets, travel changes coming over new omicron variant

The United States is putting in new travel restrictions for concerns over the new omicron variant, which has not been detected in Colorado as of now. Read more »

Omicron Covid variant: Greg Hunt backflips as Australia shuts border to southern Africa

Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP Australians attempting to return home from southern Africa will be allowed into the country, but ordered into mandatory hotel quarantine Get our free news app; get our ... Read more »

John Abraham reveals a massive scar on his chest on Kaun Banega Crorepati 13, says he ‘only' has 18 bikes

© Provided by The Indian Express Friday’s episode of Kaun Banega Crorepati 13 hosted the cast of new action thriller film Satyameva Jayate 2, John Abraham and Divya Khosla Kumar ... Read more »

India vs New Zealand Live Cricket Score, 1st Test, Day 3: Ashwin Strikes to Dislodge Young on 89 as NZ's Opening Partnership Ends on 151

© Provided by News18 India vs New Zealand Live Cricket Score, 1st Test, Day 3: Ashwin Strikes to Dislodge Young on 89 as NZ’s Opening Partnership Ends on 151 India ... Read more »

Bollywood Rewind | Mr and Mrs 55: When feminism was equated with being a vamp

© Provided by The Indian Express In this weekly column, we revisit gems from the golden years of Hindi cinema. This week, we revisit the 1955 release Mr and Mrs ... Read more »

Janhvi Kapoor dedicates a note to her ‘first film with Papa': ‘You give your heart and soul to every film'

© Provided by The Indian Express Janhvi Kapoor on Friday took to her social media platforms to announce that she has wrapped her upcoming film Mili, a film bankrolled by ... Read more »

Abhishek Bachchan said yes to Bob Biswas before reading the script, believes it is ‘better' than Kahaani

© Provided by The Indian Express Sujoy Ghosh’s 2012 film Kahaani had us picking up our jaws off the floor with its sinister plot twists but the character that left ... Read more »

Covid live: world scrambles to combat Omicron variant; New York declares ‘disaster emergency'

LIVE – Updated at 04:52 © Photograph: Jérôme Delay/AP People lineup to get tested for Covid in Johannesburg, South Africa. ECDC follows WHO in threat assessment of new variant; countries ... Read more »

New Covid variant: BioNTech says it could tweak Pfizer jab in 100 days if needed

© Provided by Khaleej Times Reuters file German biotechnology company BioNTech says it could produce and ship an updated version of the Pfizer vaccine within 100 days if the new ... Read more »

Duque: DOH backs travel ban on Hong Kong over new virus variant

Health Sec. Francisco Duque III at Nov. 15, 2021 briefing The Department of Health has recommended a ban on travelers from Hong Kong after the detection in the territory of ... Read more »

Black Friday Holiday Decor Deals From Home Depot, Macy's, Wayfair and More

© Cavan Images/Getty Images Each product has been independently selected by our editorial team. We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to ... Read more »

Peloton bikes are up to $350 off in a rare Black Friday sale — but you'll have to act fast

Prices are accurate at the time of publication. When you buy through our links, Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more. © Peloton Peloton The annual Black Friday sale ... Read more »

At least 19 killed in bus crash in central Mexico

At least 19 people were killed and 20 more injured on Friday when a passenger bus traveling on a highway in central Mexico crashed into a house, authorities said. © ... Read more »

Solomon Islands protests: 3 burned bodies found in Chinatown in Honiara following days of unrest

Three charred bodies have been found in a burned out building in the Chinatown district of the Solomon Islands’ capital, Honiara — the first reported fatalities after three days of ... Read more »

Brexit means you chose to give up migrant returns, France tells Boris Johnson

Pope Francis receives French President Emmanuel Macron in a private audience at the Vatican City on Friday French politicians have claimed that Brexit undercut the UK’s ability to tackle Channel ... Read more »

France's Macron tells UK to 'get serious' on Channel migrant crisis

1 / 3France’s Macron tells UK to ‘get serious’ on Channel migrant crisisTribute to the 27 migrants who died as they attempted to cross the English Channel By Sudip Kar-Gupta ... Read more »

Rain Updates: Waterlogging in Chennai After Continuous Showers, Schools Shut; Downpour Expected in Puducherry for Next 3 Days

© Provided by News18 Rain Updates: Waterlogging in Chennai After Continuous Showers, Schools Shut; Downpour Expected in Puducherry for Next 3 Days Areas in Tamil Nadu, Puducherry and Karaikal may ... Read more »

Karnataka UGCET first seat allotment result to release today, here's how to check

Karnataka Examinations Authority, KEA will release Karnataka UGCET first seat allotment result on November 27, 2021. Candidates who have registered themselves for the admission round can check the result through ... Read more »

In the Habs' Room: It 'breaks your back,' Ben Chiarot says of costly mistakes

BUFFALO — It wasn’t difficult for Dominique Ducharme to pinpoint what went wrong for the Canadiens in their 4-1 loss to the Buffalo Sabres on Friday. © Provided by The ... Read more »

India reports 8,318 new COVID-19 cases, 465 deaths in last 24 hours

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: India witnessed a decline in daily COVID-19 cases as 8,318 new infections were reported in the last 24 hours, as per the Ministry ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic