The 5 Most Important Revelations From the 'Facebook Papers'

Asia's Tech News Daily

A more complete portrait of how Facebook was vividly aware of its harmful effects came to light Monday, both at Frances Haugen’s testimony in front of the British Parliament and via a series of reports based on internal documents she leaked, deemed “The Facebook Papers.” During the 2.5 hour question-and-answer, Haugen repeatedly said that Facebook puts “growth over safety,” particularly in developing areas of the world where the company does not have language or cultural expertise to regulate content without fostering division among users.

The 5 Most Important Revelations From the 'Facebook Papers'
© Tolga Akmen—AFP/Getty Images Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen (center) leaves the Houses of Parliament in central London on October 25, 2021 after giving evidence to members of the UK parliament on the Joint Committee on the draft Online Safety Bill.

Here are the most explosive revelations from her Oct. 25 testimony and the internal documents.

Facebook fails to moderate harmful content in developing countries

The documents, confirmed by multiple news outlets, reveal that problems with hate speech and disinformation are dramatically worse in the developing world, where content moderation is often weaker. In India, Facebook reportedly did not have enough resources or expertise in the country’s 22 officially recognized languages, leaving the company unable to grapple with a rise in anti-Muslim posts and fake accounts tied to the country’s ruling party and opposition figures. According to one document, 87% of Facebook’s global budget for time spent on classifying misinformation goes towards the United States, while 13% is set aside for the rest of the world — despite the fact that North American users make up just 10% of its daily users.

When a pair of Facebook researchers created a dummy account in 2019 to test how users in Kerala, India, experienced the social media site, they found a staggering amount of hate speech, misinformation and calls for violence on the platform. “I’ve seen more images of dead people in the past three weeks than I’ve seen in my entire life total,” the researcher wrote. With 340 million Facebook users, India is the company’s largest market.

The studies by Facebook employees reveal that the company moves into countries without fully understanding its potential impact on local communities, particularly with regard to culture and politics, and then fails to provide adequate resources to mitigate those effects.

During her testimony Monday, Haugen said that Facebook has a “strategy” of only slowing down harmful content when “the crisis has begun,” deploying its “glass break measures” instead of making the platform “safer as it happens.” She referred to the ongoing ethnic violence in Ethiopia and Myanmar as the “opening chapters of a novel that is going to be horrific to read.”

Facebook AI fails to accurately detect dangerous content in non-English languages

Facebook’s algorithm mistakenly banned a hashtag referencing the Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem’s Old City because it thought it represented the militant group Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade, an armed offshoot of the secular Fatah party, documents show. The company later apologized, but the accidental removal of content serves as a shining example for how the social media giant’s algorithms can stifle political speech due to language barriers and a lack of resources outside of North America.

“Facebook says things like, ‘we support 50 languages,’ when in reality, most of those languages get a tiny fraction of the safety systems that English gets,” Haugen told British lawmakers. “UK English is sufficiently different that I would be unsurprised if the safety systems that they developed primarily for American English were actually [under-enforced] in the UK.”

The company has long relied on artificial-intelligence systems, in combination with human review, as a way of removing dangerous content from its platforms. But languages spoken outside of North America and Europe have made Facebook’s automated content moderation much more difficult.

A document showed that in 2020, the company did not have screening algorithms to find misinformation in Burmese, the language of Myanmar, or hate speech in the Ethiopian languages of Oromo or Amharic.

Facebook labeled election misinformation as “harmful, non-violating” content

Internal documents confirmed by multiple news outlets show that Facebook employees repeatedly raised red flags about misinformation and inflammatory content on the platform during the 2020 presidential election, but company leaders did little to address the issues. Posts alleging election fraud were labeled by the company as “harmful” but “non-violating” content — a problematic category that also includes conspiracy theories and vaccine hesitancy.

The false narratives about election fraud fell into that group of content, which under Facebook policies does not violate any rules. It’s a gray area that allows users to spread claims about a stolen election without crossing any lines that would warrant content moderation.

Although Facebook banned the Stop the Steal group on Nov. 5 for falsely casting doubt on the legitimacy of the election and calling for violence, the group had already amassed more than 360,000 members — and new Facebook groups filled with misinformation began popping up daily. Trump loyalists and right-wing conspiracists seemingly outwitted the social network.

Many employees voiced their concerns on internal message boards as they watched the violent mob attack the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6 — some writing that they wanted to quit working for the company because leaders failed to heed to their warnings.

While the documents provide insight into Facebook’s awareness of election misinformation, they do not reveal inside information behind the company’s decision-making process to label election misinformation as non-violating content.

Facebook was aware that maids were being sold on its platform

Internal documents show that Facebook admitted it was “under-enforcing on confirmed abusive activity” when it failed to take action after Filipina maids complained of being abused and sold on the platform, according to the Associated Press.

“In our investigation, domestic workers frequently complained to their recruitment agencies of being locked in their homes, starved, forced to extend their contracts indefinitely, unpaid, and repeatedly sold to other employers without their consent,” one Facebook document read, the AP reports. “In response, agencies commonly told them to be more agreeable.”

Apple threatened to remove Facebook and Instagram from its app store over the issue, but changed course after the social media giant removed 1,000 accounts linked to the sale of maids from its platform. Although Facebook has since cracked down on the sale of maids, human rights activists have noted that images of maids with their age and price can still be found on the platform.

Facebook internally debated removing the Like button

In 2019, Facebook examined how people would interact with content if it no longer had a Like feature on Instagram, suggesting that the company was aware that this feature could have a negative impact on well-being. According to documents, the Like button had sometimes caused the platform’s youngest users “stress and anxiety” if the posts didn’t get many likes from friends — but when hidden, users interacted less with posts and ads, and it failed to alleviate social anxiety as they thought it might.

When asked why Facebook hasn’t made Instagram safer for children, Haugen said during her testimony that the company knows “young users are the future of the platform and the earlier they get them the more likely they’ll get them hooked.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Australia is the drunkest country in the world, according to survey

The 2020 Global Drug Survey found Australians were more likely to get drunk over the course of the year than their counterparts from 21 other nations. AFP via Getty Images ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity viewers are all saying the same thing as Danny Miller reveals he watches David Ginola sleep

I'M A Celebrity viewers are all saying the same thing after Danny Miller revealed he watched David Ginola sleeping. The two have taken on the role of the Lords of ... Read more »

First lesbian sex robots may be coming soon as sexbots start being programmed gay

THE first lesbian sex robots may be coming soon as sexbots start being programmed as gay. American adult toy and robotics company RealDoll are attempting to enter the LGBTQ market ... Read more »

Man Utd 3-2 Arsenal LIVE RESULT: Cristiano Ronaldo nets winning penalty and 800th goal but goes off injured

CRISTIANO RONALDO has netted a brace to put United in front against Arsenal. But there will be some concerns after the Portugal captain was forced off injured late in the ... Read more »

Nord-Fron: Deer hunter who shot two llamas by mistake fined 15,000 kroner

A hunter who shot two llamas that he thought were deer will be fined NOK 15,000. In addition, his weapon has been confiscated. Police lawyer Einar Gauslaa Bergem at the ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb fans all saying the same thing about Naughty Boy and Frankie Bridge's singing after disgusting trial

I'M A Celebrity viewers were all saying the same thing tonight as Naughty Boy and Frankie Bridge murdered a string of pop hits while doing a sickening singing trial. Both ... Read more »

Meghan Markle wins privacy battle… but judges point out her ‘unfortunate lapse of memory' and fight might not be over

THE Duchess of Sussex won a privacy battle yesterday — but judges pointed out her “unfortunate lapse of memory”. She was also warned the court fight may not be over. ... Read more »

How Bad Bunny and Olivia Rodrigo kicked Ed Sheeran and even Adele into touch to conquer Spotify and rake in MILLIONS

THE biggest pop star in the world is . . . a Puerto Rican rapper you have probably never heard of. Music streaming service Spotify has released its list of the world’s most listened-to ... Read more »

Get Your First Look At Alan Ritchson In Amazon's Jack Reacher Series

Amazon Studios/YouTube Amazon is giving viewers a glimpse into its upcoming Jack Reacher series (which we seem to be getting instead of a cinematic “Jack Reacher 3”) — and more ... Read more »

Did The New Hawkeye Trailer Tease Yelena's Return?

Marvel Studios/Disney+/YouTube Only a week and a day after its series premiere, “Hawkeye” is already halfway through its six-episode first season. The first three episodes have introduced Marvel fans to ... Read more »

The Real Reason Benedict Cumberbatch Refused To Shower For The Power Of The Dog

Kirsty Griffin/Courtesy of Netflix Actors can go to great lengths to deliver a memorable performance, and that includes strange on-set behavior. Sometimes that means staying in character the entire time ... Read more »

‘Fearless Girl' artist says State Street holding statue hostage

The permit for “Fearless Girl” to stand on Broad Street expired Nov. 29 and has yet to be renewed. AFP via Getty Images The “Fearless Girl” statue that’s mired in ... Read more »

Meghan Markle news latest – Piers Morgan SLAMS ‘two-faced' Duchess as she releases statement following court win

Piers Morgan has SLAMMED Meghan Markle for being 'two-faced' after she won her court battle against a newspaper publisher today. The TV show host branded the Duchess of Sussex “Princess ... Read more »

Kids found with 21 weapons at Brooklyn high school day after gun bust

A day after a student was found with a gun at the Urban Assembly School of Law and Justice, a newly installed metal detector uncovered 21 weapons on students including ... Read more »

Antonio Brown suspended for misrepresenting COVID vaccination status

Antonio Brown and his Buccaneers teammate, safety Mike Edwards, have been suspended for the next three games without pay over misrepresenting their vaccination status under NFL-NFLPA COVID-19 protocols, the league ... Read more »

Jeffrey Epstein's former housekeeper claims Ghislaine Maxwell was ‘lady of the house'

Juan Alessi, Jeffrey Epstein’s house manager, testified during Ghislaine Maxwell’s trial on on Dec. 2, 2021. AFP via Getty Images Jeffrey Epstein’s longtime housekeeper on Thursday testified that Ghislaine Maxwell ... Read more »

Bomb squad race to A&E after patient arrives with WW2 artillery shell stuck up his bottom

THE bomb squad raced to a crowded A&E after a patient arrived with an artillery shell stuck up his behind, The Sun can reveal. Army bomb disposal experts scrambled to ... Read more »

‘Up In The Blue Seats' Podcast Episode 66: Rangers Keep Fighting to Top of East feat. Bill Pidto

NHLI via Getty Images I-GOR, I-GOR, I-GOR. The Rangers netminder heard his name being chanted throughout Madison Square Garden Wednesday night, leading the Blueshirts to a 4-1 victory over the ... Read more »

New Barbie doll inspired by ‘Top Gun: Maverick' released

Mattel released a Barbie doll inspired by the upcoming Tom Cruise film “Top Gun: Maverick.” Barbie dolls can be fighter pilots, too. A new special-edition doll is being released by ... Read more »

Woman shares viral hack for hanging Christmas tree lights

Tamara Weatherbee shared a hack for hanging Christmas tree lights. Courtesy of @tamara_weatherbee Unless you’re among those who’ve already had their Christmas tree up since late October, you’re yet to ... Read more »

EXPLAINER: Must employers follow Biden's vaccine mandates?

The Associated PressFILE – New York City municipal workers protest against the coming COVID-19 vaccine mandate for city workers, Thursday, Oct. 28, 2021, outside the Gracie Mansion Conservancy in New ... Read more »

Sports betting ads: Industry weighs how much is too much?

The Associated PressA clerk counts money at the sports book at Freehold Raceway on Oct. 24, 2020, in Freehold, N.J. With advertisements for sports betting blanketing the airwaves, some in ... Read more »

Kroger, Okta rise; Dollar General, Apple fall

NEW YORK — Stocks that traded heavily or had substantial price changes Thursday: Synopsys Inc., up $14.92 to $349.67. The maker of software used to test and develop chips gave ... Read more »

UPenn transgender swimmer sparks outrage by shattering women's records

Transgender swimmer Lia Thomas is breaking records at UPenn. Lia Thomas, a 22-year old transgender swimmer at the University of Pennsylvania, has been shattering women’s records at the school. Before ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing 2021 news – Shirley Ballas gives health update as she opens up on personal battle with self-esteem

SHIRLEY Ballas have given an important update on her health – as she opened up about her “life long” battle with her self-esteem. The professional dancer and choreographer, 61, has ... Read more »

I pooed myself on my date's floor – he kicked it thinking it was mud… but what happened next was even worse

A WOMAN revealed that she pooed on her date’s floor by accident and he kicked it out of the way thinking it was mud – but it got so much ... Read more »

Turner & Hooch Fans Just Got Terrible News

DFree/Shutterstock Serving as a legacy sequel to the 1989 cop comedy starring Tom Hanks, the Disney+ series “Turner & Hooch” stars Josh Peck (“Drake & Josh”) as U.S. Marshal Scott ... Read more »

My boyfriend gave me flowers for Valentine's Day and then asked me to pay for them – but it gets worse

A WOMAN has recalled an awful Valentine’s Day she experienced thanks to her dismissive boyfriend at the time.  The woman claimed her boyfriend made no attempt to make Valentine’s Day ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity 2021 – David Ginola pokes fun at Naughty Boy before he takes on trial with Frankie Bridge

I'M A Celebrity's Frankie Bridge is forced to drink a glass containing deer testicles in a stomach-churning Bushtucker Trial tonight. The Saturdays singer gags as she chugs the gruesome drink ... Read more »

Brit teen backpacker savaged by giant crocodile has leg saved by hero surgeons

SURGEONS have saved the leg of a Brit teen gap year backpacker savaged by a giant crocodile. Amelie Osborn-Smith, 18, was left fighting for life after the 10ft beast dragged ... Read more »

Weather snow forecast UK: Britain gripped by freezing -9C Arctic blast as 15cm blizzard expected to hit THIS WEEKEND

EXTREME weather is set to hit the UK, with freezing temperatures and flurries of snow expected – as Met Office warnings for dangerous ice remain in place this morning. Temperatures ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing's Rose Ayling-Ellis turns down £1MILLION to be the face of Specsaver in protest against government

DEAF Strictly star Rose Ayling-Ellis has turned down lucrative deals to endorse hearing aids. The EastEnders actress refuses to promote any non-NHS devices. Rose and Strictly partner Giovanni Pernice are ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb's Frankie Bridge is queen of the high street… here's how to steal her looks WITHOUT breaking the bank

A RED gilet with combat trousers, her I’m A Celeb uniform, is not Frankie Bridge’s best look. The ex-Saturdays singer, 32, is known for her superb style and has a ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell trial LIVE – Latest updates from Jeffrey Epstein ‘madam' trial as sick obituary meme spreads online

THE sex trafficking trial of Jeffrey's Epstein's alleged “madam” Ghislaine Maxwell started on Monday, and a meme about a fake obituary for Maxwell spread on Twitter. A fake meme story ... Read more »

Record number of corona patients hospitalized in Bergen

A total of 25 people with COVID-19 are hospitalized in Bergen, the highest number of corona patients in the city so far.  On Wednesday, an infection record was set in ... Read more »

Biden to attend Kennedy Center Honors, resuming tradition

The Associated PressPresident Joe Biden gestures to reporters as he returns to the White House in Washington, Thursday, Dec. 2, 2021. Biden had visited to the National Institutes of Health. ... Read more »

US appeals court to rehear Tennessee abortion ban argument

The Associated PressA woman in an doctors uniform holds a poster that reads “Abortion is Healthcare” as abortion rights advocates and anti-abortion protesters demonstrate in front of the U.S. Supreme ... Read more »

EXPLAINER: What are the rules for travelers entering the US?

The Associated PressFILE – Travelers wait in line for screening near a sign for a COVID-19 testing site at the Los Angeles International Airport in Los Angeles on Nov. 24, ... Read more »

Cause of death revealed for mummified, eyeless cult leader found wrapped in lights

A cult leader whose mummified body was found without eyes and enshrined with Christmas lights in Colorado died due to a history of alcohol abuse, anorexia and colloidal silver dosing, ... Read more »

SEC mandates Chinese companies disclose ownership or risk delisting

The new rules by the SEC, led by Chairman Gary Gensler, implement a law passed by Congress in December 2020 that aims to ensure foreign companies listed in the United ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic