The 2009 financial crisis taught us hard lessons. Have Democrats learned them?

Asia's Tech News Daily

The 2009 financial crisis taught us hard lessons. Have Democrats learned them?
© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Tannen Maury/EPA

A first-term Democratic president with a majority in Congress and an uncompromising Republican opposition. A country disillusioned by a previous administration’s corruption and mismanagement. A working class traumatized by an economic downturn. An establishment calling not for aggressiveness and boldness, but for half measures and compromise.

Related: Democrats’ tax plan to pay for Biden agenda would affect 700 of America’s super-rich

If this sounds familiar, it is not only because it describes this current moment, but because it is the experience we lived through 12 years ago – a political meltdown that destroyed many Americans’ remaining faith in their government, and ultimately birthed Donald Trump’s presidency.

That meltdown crushed faith in hope and change, and led to Maga and mayhem. And if Democrats continue making the same choices again, we should expect the same results – or worse.

2009 was not 2021, but history tends to rhyme. Back then, the contagion wasn’t a virus, it was a financial panic brought on by the collapse of what had been the American economy’s most stable pillar: the mortgage. But the homes were built atop a precarious foundation. After a spate of bank deregulation, Wall Street giants had transformed themselves into the newest peddlers of the old swampland-in-Florida schemes, enticing borrowers and pension funds to bet life savings on unsustainable housing prices and debt.

The 2009 financial crisis taught us hard lessons. Have Democrats learned them?
© Photograph: Tannen Maury/EPA George and Laura Bush talking with the newly inaugurated Barack Obama and first lady Michelle Obama in January 2009.

When enough homeowners couldn’t make their payments and home prices cratered, millions faced foreclosure, retirement systems faced huge losses on mortgage-related investments, 401k plans faced stock market declines, and banks faced the prospect of insolvency.

Amid this financial pandemic, though, there was a glimmer of something better – Barack Obama, who had campaigned on an inspiring promise to “bring a new era of responsibility and accountability to Wall Street and to Washington”.

That FDR-esque rhetoric resulted in a 2008 election landslide, a huge Democratic congressional majority, and high hopes that a new administration would fight the Great Recession with the same kind of robust New Deal that Franklin Roosevelt deployed to successfully combat the Great Depression.

But that didn’t happen.

When America votes for hope and change but is force-fed more of the same, the backlash can be swift

Obama had helped the Bush administration forge the Troubled Asset Relief Program (Tarp), whose name seemed to promise assistance for homeowners, but which instead provided most of its benefits to a handful of financial institutions. When he took office, Obama could have changed how Tarp money was being spent, but he and his administration kept funneling the cash to Wall Street. The relative pittance that trickled out to aid borrowers mostly stretched out foreclosures to “foam the runway” for financial institutions, as Obama’s treasury secretary Tim Geithner reportedly said.

Soon after, the Wall Street-bankrolled Obama administration scaled back its economic stimulus plan, backed off its promise to reform bankruptcy laws, refused to prosecute bankers, abandoned legislation to limit the size of too-big-to-fail banks, and allowed bailout money to subsidize lavish executive bonuses.

Some lonely voices in Washington tried to sound an alarm. Tarp Inspector General Neil Barofsky warned that the opaque bailout was being misused. Congressman Brad Miller, a Democrat from North Carolina, tried to hold Obama to his promise to let judges write down mortgagors’ loans. And Senators Carl Levin and Ted Kaufman, a longtime aide to Joe Biden, pressed their party to prosecute and break up the banks.

They were largely ignored – and Obama later justified the brush-offs by insisting that doing anything more would have “required a violence to the social order, a wrenching of political and economic norms”.

But defending the banks and failing to deliver material gains to a nation ravaged by corporate malfeasance gave conservatives a political bailout, allowing them to further shred the social fabric once stitched together by a belief in shared sacrifice.

Boosted by Glenn Beck’s blubbering broadsides and Rick Santelli’s CNBC dog-whistle rant against mortgage “losers”, Republicans were able to divide the country and portray themselves as populists – and shellack Democrats in 2010’s Tea Party election.

A few years later, Democratic leaders confidently predicted that they would be able to overcome working-class rage with support from wealthier suburbanites. After all, the top 10% of income earners saw their fortunes rise by 27% during Obama’s presidency.

But every other stratum saw incomes decline, and countless neighborhoods were eviscerated by more than 6m foreclosures, dooming families to losing battles with bank bureaucracy, government red tape, and a judicial foreclosure machine.

There was Detroit’s Sandra Hines, who tearfully told a congressional committee about being thrown out of her home in the dead of winter after she fell behind on her mortgage payments.

There was Florida oncology nurse Lisa Epstein, who, just after giving birth to an infant daughter, faced foreclosure and then endured a Kafkaesque struggle to expose fraudulent mortgage practices – which resulted in a slap-on-the-wrist settlement that netted her just $600.

These experiences, repeated ad nauseam as Wall Street executives swelled their stock portfolios, convinced many to view the past promises of “hope and change” as a ruse. The subsequent outrage helped Republicans complete their takeover with Trump, a billionaire charlatan ginning up racial animosity and depicting himself as singularly able to “make America great again.”

The throughline from the financial crisis to Democrats’ failure to deliver help to the rise of Trump is evident in a study from the Center for American Progress. The Democratic thinktank found that “larger proportions of underwater homeowners were prominent features” of more than a third of the 206 counties won by Obama in 2012 that flipped to Trump in 2016.

“The legacy of the financial crisis is Donald J Trump,” concluded Trump consigliere Steve Bannon.

For today’s Democrats, the takeaway is not merely that Trump is a pathological liar, a racist and an anti-democratic menace who exacerbated the problems he diagnosed. The lesson is more elemental: when America votes for hope and change and is instead force-fed more of the same, the backlash can be swift – and can benefit conservative opportunists who will make things worse.

A dozen years later, with Democrats assuming power amid another national crisis, there were initial signs that this lesson had been learned: the Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer said at the outset of the Biden presidency that Democrats must pass bills that are “big and bold and strong”, and he added that “we will not repeat that mistake” of watering down legislation. The child tax credit in the initial Covid relief package was a solid victory – it significantly reduced child poverty, and a recent poll shows less anti-Biden animus among Trump voters who received it.

A new crop of rightwing media hucksters are converting discontent into support for authoritarianism

However, much of the direct aid in that legislation has been stalled, cut off or scheduled for expiration – even as nearly one in five households lost all of their savings during the pandemic. Worse, Biden and Democrats have been considering big cuts to their already scaled-back package of housing, anti-poverty and climate initiatives. They’ve also pondered defanging provisions to reduce drug prices, and considered adding means-testing and work requirements that could make direct aid more difficult to access.

Taken together, it feels like 2009 all over again.

Billionaires are doing better than ever, while more and more Americans are getting economically pulverized – and simmering with rage. Just a year out from the midterm election, the latest polls show Biden’s approval rating plummeting, with particular erosion among Democratic constituencies who were promised change, but seem to be feeling like they’re only getting more of the same.

Once again, progressive voices sounding the alarm are getting drowned out by conservative Democrats, their corporate donors, and pundits demanding surrender. Meanwhile, Trump and his Republican mini-mes are barnstorming the country preening as populists, all while a new crop of rightwing media hucksters are converting popular discontent into increasing support for rightwing authoritarianism.

But let’s remember: the past does not have to be prelude. If the Democrats are willing to learn from recent history, they still have time to make different choices.

In Congress, Democratic lawmakers can realize there is no “middle-ground” compromise with Republicans or corporate greed. They can end the filibuster and ignore the business lobbyists and the donors trying to halt their legislative program, which may be the last chance to help workers and ward off a climate cataclysm.

In the White House, Biden can break from Obama’s fetishization of bipartisanship. He can instead try to be a modern-day Lyndon Johnson, arm-twisting his recalcitrant party members into embracing real hope and change.

Though none of this would guarantee success, it would at least give the party a fighting chance to enact its agenda and materially improve people’s lives.

That simple objective is often obscured in the social media-driven miasma of politics. But history suggests that going big and delivering tangible help to a nation in need is probably the only way to restore some faith in government, ward off an authoritarian takeover and end the meltdown of disillusionment that threatens to incinerate our democracy.

  • Investigative reporter David Sirota and Oscar-winning documentarian Alex Gibney are the executive producers of the new podcast series Meltdown, which explores the aftermath of the financial crisis

  • This essay is being published in conjunction with the launch of Meltdown. Find the podcast episodes here

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Why Chicago P.D.'s Big Twist For Upton And Halstead Isn't Too Soon

© Provided by CinemaBlend chicago pd season 8 upstead halstead and upton MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD for the winter finale of Chicago P.D. Season 9, called “A Way Out.” Chicago P.D. ... Read more »

Storm Barra news – news: UK hit by 80mph gales as pensioner found dead in flooded river

© PA Wire A fallen tree blocks the A702 near Coulter in South Lanarkshire as Storm Barra hits the UK (Jane Barlow/PA) – PA Wire LIVE – Updated at 07:36 ... Read more »

Colombian police who caught Escobar to help Gardai battle drug gangs

© Provided by Gardaí are going to work alongside the Colombian police force who took down Pablo Escobar to help them tackle organised crime gangs, such as the Kinahan ... Read more »

Sudha Bharadwaj Held Under UAPA Released After Over 3 Years in Jail

© Provided by News18 Sudha Bharadwaj Held Under UAPA Released After Over 3 Years in Jail Sudha Bharadwaj, lawyer and activist, one of the acussed in Elgar Parishad-Maoist links case ... Read more »

Air quality improves to 'moderate' in Gurugram after 41 days

Gurugram air quality improves to ‘moderate’ category after 41 days In a big relief for Gurugram residents, the air quality index (AQI) showed a considerable improvement and entered the ‘moderate’ ... Read more »

India's first high-speed Bullet Train to hit track by 2026, says Railway Minister - Know key facts

© Provided by DNA India’s first high-speed Bullet Train is all set to hit the railway tracks by 2026, Union Railways Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw made the big announcement. The Mumbai-Ahmedabad High-speed Rail ... Read more »

PM pays tributes to stalwarts of Constituent Assembly

© Provided by The Statesman PM pays tributes to stalwarts of Constituent Assembly Prime Minister Narendra Modi has paid tributes to eminent stalwarts of the Constituent Assembly to mark 75 ... Read more »

‘Not seniority, it's govt decision': Ex-Army chief Shankar Roy Chowdhury on CDS selection | Exclusive

The selection of the Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) is a matter not of seniority of a military officer, said former Indian Army chief General (retd) Shankar Roy Chowdhury while ... Read more »

'This is India's Golden Opportunity': Harbhajan Singh Explains How India Can Script History in South Africa

© Provided by News18 ‘This is India’s Golden Opportunity’: Harbhajan Singh Explains How India Can Script History in South Africa Veteran spinner Harbhajan Singh has reckoned that Team India’s upcoming tour ... Read more »

Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal Wedding: A Look at Other Bollywood Families with Actress Bahus

© Provided by News18 The wedding festivities for Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal are underway at the Six Senses Resort, Fort Barwara in Sawai Madhopur, Rajasthan. Vicky comes from a ... Read more »

Back to ground zero for Salman Khan

© Provided by Mid-Day In late May, the Tiger 3 team had to pull down the elaborate set at SRPF Grounds in Goregaon, Mumbai, after it was partially damaged by ... Read more »

Tsareena is now live in Pokémon UNITE

© Provided by Dot Esports Pokémon UNITE is back live after a long maintenance period and there is a new entry to the game’s roster ready to play. Tsareena is ... Read more »

It's Official: Pantone Unveils "Very Peri" as 2022's Color of the Year

© Provided by At the end of every year, we await the announcement of Pantone, the global authority for color communication and inspiration, for the new color of the ... Read more »

Bonia now offers exquisite tableware crafted from fine bone China

© Provided by PrestigeOnline Bonia is now expanding the lifestyle brand to include intricately-designed tableware crafted from fine bone china. An international luxury fashion retailer based in Malaysia, Bonia is ... Read more »

If you are unable to dial emergency numbers from Android phones, you can blame Microsoft Teams for it

Some users in the United States were in for a rude shock when they were unable to dial emergency numbers from their Android phones. Several users took to Reddit to ... Read more »

Torrance Police: California department under state investigation for racist texts and excessive force

Following allegations of excessive force, racist text messages and other misconduct, the Torrance Police Department in California faces an independent review from the state’s department of justice, Attorney General Rob ... Read more »

Singaporean singer Qiu Fengze drops dance hit Moon Landing with Taiwanese band W0LF(S)

Moon Landing, a single from Taiwanese band W0LF(S)’s upcoming first album, features Singaporean singer-songwriter Qiu Fengze, also known as Kenny Khoo, attempt dancing in a music video for the first ... Read more »

Unfassbar: SO äußert sich Michael Wendler zum Tod von Mirco Nontschew

© IMAGO / Kathrin Schubert Mirco Nontschew (†) Nach dem Tod von Mirco Nontschew hat sich nun auch Sänger Michael Wendler zu Wort gemeldet. Nach dem Tod von Mirco Nontschew ... Read more »

Lewis Hamilton's F1 title showdown with Max Verstappen in Abu Dhabi to be shown for FREE on Channel 4

LEWIS HAMILTON'S titanic battle with Max Verstappen for the F1 title will be shown live on Channel 4. Sky F1 have reached an agreement with the channel to provide free-to-air ... Read more »

Rolls-Royce expects 2021 cash outflow to be better than forecast

(Reuters) – Rolls-Royce expects free cash outflow in fiscal year 2021 to be better than its previous guidance of 2 billion pounds ($2.64 billion) thanks to cost cuts and the ... Read more »

DS Smith profit surges as FMCG demand, online shopping fuel cardboard demand

(Reuters) -Cardboard maker DS Smith posted an 80% surge in first-half profit and declared a higher interim dividend on Thursday, helped by strong demand from fast-moving consumer goods makers and ... Read more »

Jacqueline Fernandez appears before ED for 2nd day in Rs 200 crore extortion case

Jacqueline Fernandez appears before ED for 2nd day in Rs 200 crore extortion case Actor Jacqueline Fernandez has appeared before the Enforcement Directorate (ED) for the second consecutive day in ... Read more »

Deutsche Bank Told by DOJ It May Have Breached Criminal Deal

(Bloomberg) — The Justice Department has told Deutsche Bank AG that it may have violated a criminal settlement by failing to inform prosecutors about an internal complaint tied to the ... Read more »

Italy's antitrust fines Amazon 1.13 billion euros for alleged abuse of market dominance

FILE PHOTO: The logo of Amazon is seen at the company logistics centre in Boves MILAN (Reuters) -Italy's antitrust said on Thursday it had fined e-commerce giant Amazon 1.13 billion ... Read more »

‘There is just a lake with crocodiles!': hope and homkesickness for Kiribati nurses in the outback

A Pacific labour scheme has been transformative for Kiribati families but the loss of nurses has hit the country’s hospitals hard Every night, sitting in her room in the remote ... Read more »

Here's how the Middle East is set to become a powerhouse of innovation

© Motivate Publishing illustration of global futuristic abstract background,digital global and binary code connecting with line,Global communication network connection concept Driven by national visions and ICT goals, the public and ... Read more »

Niger set to be first African nation to eliminate river blindness

© Provided by The National Mocé lives in the town of Tienfala, in south-west Mali. He lost his eyesight more than 30 years ago to river blindness. Photo: End Fund ... Read more »

UAE's Etihad signs codeshare agreement with Italy's ITA Airways

© Motivate Publishing Etihad Airways The UAE’s national airline, Etihad Airways, has signed a codeshare agreement with ITA Airways, the national carrier of Italy. The new commercial partnership is designed ... Read more »

Microsoft India partners with WhiteHat Jr to offer coding concepts for students

© Provided by Business Today Microsoft India partners with WhiteHat Jr to offer coding concepts for students Microsoft India and edtech start-up WhiteHat Jr on Thursday announced a collaboration to ... Read more »

Elon Musk's SpaceX Sending An X-Ray Telescope To Space: NASA IXPE Mission Explained

© Provided by News18 Elon Musk’s SpaceX Sending An X-Ray Telescope To Space: NASA IXPE Mission Explained NASA and SpaceX are sending an X-ray telescope in space. The NASA Imaging ... Read more »

New UAE weekend: Dubai Financial Market revises trading hours

© Provided by Khaleej Times Reuters file Dubai Financial Market (DFM) has announced its new trading hours that will come into effect from January 3, 2022, with a five hours ... Read more »

Here's how you can manage your business like an F1 race car

© Motivate Publishing Vijay Jaswal, Software AG This season’s Formula 1 competition is most definitely one of the most compelling in recent years. One of F1’s greats: Alain Prost recently ... Read more »

Video: Saudi Crown Prince arrives in Qatar on first official visit

© Provided by Khaleej Times SPA Prince Mohammed bin Salman bin Abdulaziz, Saudi Crown Prince, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Defence of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, arrived in ... Read more »

Tri-service inquiry ordered into helicopter crash: Rajnath

© Provided by The Statesman Tri-service inquiry ordered into helicopter crash: Rajnath A tri-service inquiry has been ordered into yesterday’s crash of an Indian Air Force (IAF) helicopter near Coonoor ... Read more »

Peta Todd reveals heartbreak as husband Mark Cavendish beaten in front of kids by armed gang in ‘nightmare' burglary

PETA Todd has revealed her heartbreak after her husband Mark Cavendish was brutally beaten in front of his children by an armed gang who broke into his home. She has ... Read more »

David Foster Praises Wife Katharine McPhee as a 'Triple Threat' After 'Masked Singer' Unmasking (Exclusive)

© Fox Sweet as sugar! David Foster and Katharine McPhee were unmasked at the conclusion of The Masked Singer‘s Group B finals on Wednesday, but that didn’t keep the pair ... Read more »

Now play Halo Infinite with Xbox Game Pass, available on both Xbox and PC

The sequel to the legendary game series Halo is out now on all Microsoft gaming platforms. Called Halo Infinite, the new edition to the series with over 20 years of ... Read more »

UN's Peacekeeping~II

© Provided by The Statesman UN’s Peacekeeping~II The Sudanese Comprehensive Peace Agreement, signed in 2005, ended the second Sudanese civil war. It paved the way for the referendum that ultimately ... Read more »

Jennifer Aniston reveals why doing the 'Friends' reunion was 'jarring' and more difficult than she expected it to be: 'Time travel is hard'

Jennifer Aniston told The Hollywood Reporter that the “Friends” reunion was harder than expected. She said that returning to set made her remember what she felt the last time she ... Read more »

Covid-19: BioNTech, Pfizer say 3 vaccine doses neutralise Omicron variant

© Provided by Khaleej Times Reuters BioNTech and Pfizer said on Wednesday a three-shot course of their Covid-19 vaccine was shown to generate a neutralising effect against the new Omicron ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic