That creeping game changer

Asia's Tech News Daily

That creeping game changer
© Provided by BusinessWorld

For those of us old enough to remember, the sharp increases in oil prices led to the oil crises in 1973 and 1979. Output slumped in the US, Europe, and Japan by sizeable amounts in 1973 while the global economy dropped by about 3% in 1979. In developing countries like the Philippines, we experienced queuing up for rationed fuel in gas stations.

OPEC nations made hundreds of billions of petrodollars, with collateral benefits to Russia and Norway. In the absence of sufficient investment outlets in the oil-exporting nations, these petrodollars were recycled to both the US and Europe.

While a scourge to many countries, the oil crisis was a compelling incentive to explore various energy sources other than fossil fuel. OPEC supremacy in oil politics unmasked the vulnerability of Western economies to external events outside their control. Climate change prompted investments in research focused on wind and solar power technologies while advocacies to reduce oil consumption and greenhouse gas emissions proliferated in both advanced economies and emerging markets. Renewable energy became the buzzword.

We need to jog our memory to realize how oil prices have climbed to dizzying heights. In 1973-74 when OPEC declared an oil embargo against pro-Israel countries, oil prices rose from $3 to $12 per barrel, or 300%. In 1979-80, a drop in oil production due to the Iranian Revolution saw oil prices escalating to over $39 per barrel.

Unfortunately, we are again seeing the same oil dynamics today.

Brent and Dubai oil prices have been rising fast. From $42.15 and $42.30 per barrel averages, respectively, in 2020, they climbed to $67.25 and $69.01 per barrel averages for nearly 10 months this year. These gains were huge, nearly 60% for Brent and 63% for Dubai.

As of Oct. 25, Brent and Dubai have risen to $82.87 and $85.36 per barrel, respectively.

Some long-term factors appear at work. Supply and delivery hub inventories are down because of extraordinary recoveries in demand from major economies. Typhoon Ida in the US also reportedly shut down at least nine refineries. OPEC has sustained its production cutback for some time now. To adjust to the emerging situation, there has been steady decumulation of oil reserves in many countries.

The long-term prospects are not very promising. Investment in new rigs and wells, natural gas hubs, and even coal mines has been minimal resulting in a global energy shortage.

Therefore, we see that the significant increase in oil prices is driving up local fuel prices and, by extension, many food and non-food commodities in the consumer basket.

It was Energy Secretary Al Cusi who spoke on the possibility of suspending the excise tax on fuel products. He expects that this could reduce pump prices by some P8 to P10 per liter. Cusi was correct in saying that an executive order is not enough to implement his proposal. A congressional action is required. While the Bayanihan Law contained a mechanism for suspending the excise tax when oil prices hit certain thresholds, the period of implementation has elapsed. Only the years 2018-2020 were covered. The TRAIN (Tax Reform for Acceleration and Inclusion) Law slaps duties on both gasoline and diesel with no provision for automatic adjustment.

Some presidential aspirants, before and after Cusi spoke, have also sounded the alarm against the continued implementation of this tax measure because the transport sector is affected and consumers would have to suffer, too. High prices affect everyone, but the poor have the least capacity to absorb them. It is very tempting to go populist.

What is being asked may not exactly be a zero-sum game, but the risks are just too great to be ignored.

The Department of Finance’s argument against this proposal is more than compelling. If Congress should legislate the suspension of the oil tax, the National Government (NG) stands to lose some P131 billion in 2022, or around 3% of the proposed P5-trillion budget for 2022.

This potential loss derives from the P24.7 billion from the Bureau of Customs (BoC) baseline excise collection and P106.7 billion incremental excise revenue collection.

Suspending the excise tax would require a budget realignment to ensure that the portion for pandemic management and economic recovery are kept intact. But the practical problem is that everything has been earmarked by this time to finance, for instance, infrastructure especially during this election time, intelligence fund, the pension of uniformed personnel, anti-insurgency measures and other similar objects of public spending. In short, an enlightened budget realignment may not be possible even if the amount involved is only 3% of the overall budget. No one department would budge.

The outcome is inexorably a larger fiscal deficit, and the only solution is for Finance Secretary Sonny Dominguez to further increase the nation’s borrowing, and in the process further bloat the debt to GDP ratio. Next year’s fiscal deficit to GDP ratio is projected at an already high 7.5% while NG’s debt to GDP ratio has already exceeded 60% as early as June of this year.

We might be understating the consequences of bad public finance but one can expect tremendous impact on investor confidence in the Philippines, cost of both sovereign and corporate credit, and ultimately on the cost of doing business in the Philippines. We worked hard to convince the world that our territory is truly investment grade, invite investors to put up production outfits here and employ more of our people, and, in the process, enlarge the economic base of our democracy. The tragic results of the pandemic on our people’s lives and livelihood should be enough.

We support the position that we should keep the excise tax on fuel products. While higher oil prices and inflation could indeed weigh on our economic recovery, it is our success in neutralizing the pandemic that should inspire greater confidence among consumers to spend and investors to start manufacturing and hiring people. Keeping the budget for pandemic mitigation is non-negotiable and should be kept away from fraud and conspiracy.

Equally important, suspending the excise tax on fuel, while benefiting the poor, would also benefit those who could very well afford high fuel pump prices. What would happen to energy conservation and minimizing gas emissions? This move can be regressive.

To achieve targeted and direct support to transport groups and ensure minimal adjustment to transport costs, our finance officials could consider providing some direct subsidy, to the extent allowed by law and the budget process. Already, we heard the Development Budget Coordination Committee approved, and this was announced the other day, some P1 billion in subsidy that would be extended by the NG to some 178,000 registered public utility drivers to help them cope with this series of oil price escalations. This is a good approach to ensure that the subsidy is given “directly to the driver.” This is the essence of transparent fiscal policy.

As we recover from the pandemic, and as health protocols would allow, the transport group’s petition for an increase in the authorized capacity of public utility vehicles may also merit serious study. The Department of Transportation recently cited some scientific studies in some countries and a report by the British Medical Journal that “public transport capacity has no significant correlation with the number of COVID-19 cases.”

To many, scrapping the excise tax on fuel could be a game changer in addressing inflation and helping the poor. This is what is salient about the proposal, but this salience effect could also distort our perspective on the more important, though less obvious, bad consequences of this regressive proposal on our desire to recover from the pandemic and economic recession.

Diwa C. Guinigundo is the former deputy governor for the Monetary and Economics Sector, the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP). He served the BSP for 41 years. In 2001-2003, he was alternate executive director at the International Monetary Fund in Washington, DC. He is the senior pastor of the Fullness of Christ International Ministries in Mandaluyong.


Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Turkey's Erdogan replaces finance minister amid economic turmoil

© Provided by Al Jazeera The lira has lost more than 40 percent of its value against the US dollar this year [File: Ozan Kose/AFP] Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan ... Read more »

Fact Check: This was not Keshav Prasad Maurya rebuked by Yogi Adityanath on stage

A video of Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath has gone viral where he’s seen asking a person to move away during a public event. Several social media users have ... Read more »

UPSC CISF Recruitment 2021: Apply for various posts at, here's direct link, other details

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) has issued a notification for the recruitment of candidates for over 19 posts of Assistant Commandants (AC). ... Read more »

Another smartphone from a popular Chinese manufacturer burst into flames, this time it's the Poco X3

© Twitter/ @Mahesh08716488 Another smartphone from a popular Chinese manufacturer burst into flames, this time it’s the Poco X3 A user’s Poco M3 caught fire and exploded last week. The ... Read more »

Govt taking cautious, balanced approach to normalising int'l flight ops: Jyotiraditya Scindia

The international travel and tourism sector in India will have to wait longer for a post-covid revival as the Union government is adopting a cautious approach to restarting international commercial ... Read more »

'Before Babur's Era, Everyone was a Hindu in India': At News18 Chaupal, Assam CM's Take on CAA

© Provided by News18 ‘Before Babur’s Era, Everyone was a Hindu in India’: At News18 Chaupal, Assam CM’s Take on CAA Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma on Thursday said ... Read more »

Restrictions to be imposed in malls, theatres in Bengaluru? Here's what BBMP said

© Provided by DNA The Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP), amid the new COVID-19 variant Omicron scare, has revealed that, as of now, there is no plan before the civic ... Read more »

Ambrane Launches Apple AirPods 3-Like Dots Tune Earbuds, Priced at Rs 2,199

© Provided by News18 Ambrane Launches Apple AirPods 3-Like Dots Tune Earbuds, Priced at Rs 2,199 Ambrane India has refreshed its audio portfolio with the new TWS earbuds dubbed Ambrane ... Read more »

IND vs NZ 2nd Test, Mumbai weather forecast: Will unseasonal rain stop play at Wankhede Stadium?

© Provided by DNA It is the return of Test cricket to the Wankhede Stadium after a gap of nearly five years and the venue will be now hosting the ... Read more »

I'm a Celebrity: Ant and Dec poke fun at Boris Johnson and Conservative Party in latest episode

© Provided by The Independent I’m a Celebrity viewers were left in hysterics as Ant McPartlin and Declan Donnelly mocked Boris Johnson in the latest episode. At the beginning of ... Read more »

Freddie Prinze Jr. won't star alongside wife Sarah Michelle Gellar again

Freddie Prinze Jr. will never star in another movie with his wife Sarah Michelle Gellar. © Bang Showbiz Freddie Prinze Jr won’t star alongside his wife Sarah Michelle Gellar in ... Read more »

Care workers: ‘It's an honour to do this job, but we feel burnt out and undervalued'

‘I loved the job – but I had to leave because of the stress’ Kiri Williams, 38, from Caerphilly, south Wales, left her job in a care agency after suffering ... Read more »

Russia orders some U.S. diplomatic staff to leave as embassy spat expands

FILE PHOTO: Vehicles drive past the embassy of the U.S. in Moscow MOSCOW (Reuters) –Russia said on Wednesday it was ordering U.S. Embassy staff who have been in Moscow for ... Read more »

At least 42,000 social care staff have left sector since April

There are fears of a ‘deepening crisis’ in the sector (Peter Byrne/PA) (PA Archive) More than 40,000 social care staff have left the sector over the last six months, analysis ... Read more »

Alarming number of people still think HIV can be transmitted through kissing, study finds

In 2021, almost a third of people still think that HIV can be transmitted through kissing, according to new research released for World AIDS Day. The research was conducted by ... Read more »

Man Utd transfer news LIVE: Rangnick to sit in stands for Arsenal game, SHOCK Mancini link, Ronaldo FUMES at Ballon d'Or

RALF RANGNICK has been confirmed as the new Manchester United manager until the end of the season. The former Lokomotiv Moscow sporting director is also interested in RB Leipzig's £33m ... Read more »

Sajid Javid Insists Downing Street Followed Rules After Claims They Partied Last Christmas

The health secretary did not deny that the parties took place, but he said he was “not aware” of any and he did not attend them. (Photo: Anadolu Agency via ... Read more »

People should ‘Covid certify' before mixing at Christmas, says Jason Leitch

People are being urged to take lateral flow tests before mixing at Christmas (Dominic Lipinski/PA) (PA Archive) People should informally “Covid certify” themselves before attending events and family gatherings this ... Read more »

Tara Singh Returns: Sunny Deol and Ameesha Patel start filming 'Gadar 2'

© IANS Gadar 2. Mumbai, Dec 2 (IANS) Sunny Deol and Ameesha Patel from ‘Gadar: Ek Prem Katha’ have reunited for the film’s sequel, 20 years after the blockebuster. The ... Read more »

Kumkum Bhagya, 2 December 2021, Written Update: Ranbir refuses to get married

© Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, Prachi arrives at the Kohli residence and searches for Ranbir. Prachi asks the home staff about Ranbir. The servant informs her that Ranbir ... Read more »

Is Salman Khan invited to Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal's wedding? Arpita Khan makes the BIG reveal

© Provided by From the past few days, one thing that has been in the headlines the most is Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal‘s wedding. We have read multiple ... Read more »

Tadap Premiere Was A Star-studded Affair: B-town Biggies Salman Khan, Kajol, Arjun Rampal In Attendance

Ahaan Shetty and Tara Sutaria starrer Tadap had a star-studded premiere last evening. Attended by the who’s who of the film fraternity, it is the first major film event post-Covid. ... Read more »

Adarsh Gourav grateful to Priyanka, Anupam Kher, Irrfan for paving the way to Hollywood

© IANS Adarsh Gourav. Mumbai, Dec 2 (IANS) Indian breakout star Adarsh Gourav, who has made a mark on the international scene, feels grateful that earlier Indian talents paved the ... Read more »

India tour of South Africa likely to be pushed back by one week amid Omicron scare

India’s tour of South Africa is likely to be postponed back by one week due to the threat of the COVID-19 Omicron variant as per a report in ANI. India ... Read more »

Kriti Sanon Apologises to Man Who Accused Actor of 'Ruining' His Life: 'Why Did You Do This?'

© Provided by News18 Mimi proved to be a milestone in the 7-year-long career graph of Kriti Sanon. The actress was hailed for her phenomenal acting by both critics and ... Read more »

Anupamaa: In Fresh Twist, Anuj's Ex-Girlfriend To Enter The Show, But There's a Catch

© Provided by News18 Hit Star Plus show Anupamaa will soon witness a major twist with the entry of Anuj’s ex-girlfriend. She will advise Anupama on how to impress Anuj ... Read more »

Ajaz Patel set for emotional return to city of birth: From Mumbai Indians net bowler to playing a Test at Wankhede

Ajaz Patel New Zealand spinner Ajaz Patel is set for a nostalgic homecoming. The Mumbai-born cricketer left the Indian city when he was 8 years old and he will be ... Read more »

BWF World Tour Finals: Srikanth, Ashwini Ponnappa-Sikki Reddy pair lose; Satwik-Chirag pull out due to injury

BWF World Tour Finals: Srikanth, Ashwini Ponnappa-Sikki Reddy pair lose; Satwik-Chirag pull out due to injury Indian shuttler Kidambi Srikanth suffered a straight-game defeat in his second Group B match ... Read more »

Unvaccinated workers to be sacked under Anglo American plans

The mining giant Anglo American is planning to dismiss staff who refuse to be vaccinated against Covid, including those in the UK, The Telegraph can reveal. © Provided by The ... Read more »

TikTok's Glasses Concealer Hack Is Ridiculous But It Banishes Dark Circles

Welcome to Beauty In A Tik, where each week we put TikTok’s viral beauty hacks and innovative trends to the test. I’ve tried my fair share of ridiculous TikTok beauty ... Read more »

100 Amazon Fashion Gifts For Everyone On Your Christmas List

Sure, shopping for Christmas presents is fun. It’s exciting playing Santa, trying to second-guess what your loved ones want and how they’ll react on Christmas Day. But it can also ... Read more »

Covid jab factory gets £400m expansion boost

A North East factory that has been making coronavirus vaccines is set for a £400m expansion. © Scott Heppell /PA Fujifilm Diosynth Biotechnologies plant Billingham Teesside Novavax vaccine – Scott ... Read more »

Mets' Starling Marte always wanted to play with Robinson Cano

Sure, there were 78 million reasons for Starling Marte to choose the Mets. There also was a long-held hope to join together with another star from the Dominican Republic. “I ... Read more »

Rakesh Jhunjhunwala-backed Star Health IPO subscribed 37%, QIB portion booked 32%

© Kshitij Anand Rakesh Jhunjhunwala-backed Star Health IPO subscribed 37%, QIB portion booked 32% The public issue of Star Health and Allied Insurance Company continued to see muted response from ... Read more »

The Hill's 12:30 Report: Trump's pre-debate COVID-19 test sparks criticism

Former President Trump To view past editions of The Hill's 12:30 Report, click here: To receive The Hill's 12:30 Report in your inbox, please sign up here: –> ... Read more »

Radhe Shyam Nagumomu Thaarale song: Prabhas & Pooja Hegde give retro vibes as they enjoy the ride of love

© Provided by Pinkvilla The much-awaited love anthem from Prabhas’ pan Indian film Radhe Shyam is out in all South languages. Titled Nagumomu Thaarale in Telugu, the song follows the ... Read more »

Trump had positive COVID test before event with Gold Star families: book

Shortly after he contracted COVID in fall 2020, then-President Donald Trump suggested he may have gotten the virus from a White House event with Gold Star families with whom he ... Read more »

Introvert, extrovert or other? Welcome to the age of the ambivert

Photograph: Betsie Van der Meer/Getty Images We are not just tick boxes on a personality test. In these tediously unprecedented times we need a more nuanced understanding of ourselves and ... Read more »

Donald Trump 'tested positive for Covid ahead of debate with Joe Biden,' says former top aide

Mr Trump had tested positiive for Covid-19 in the days leading up to the first election debate with rival Joe Biden according to a new book – CRISTOBAL HERRERA-ULASHKEVICH/EPA-EFE /Shutterstock ... Read more »

Snow falls in LONDON and across UK in -6C plunge – with more on the way

SNOW has fallen in LONDON and across the UK in a -6C temperature plunge as more icy flurries are on the way. The dramatic cold snap has brought snowfall to ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic