Texas AG’s office sends mixed signals about whether it can fine nonprofits that pay for out-of-state abortions

Lawyers for abortion funds want Ken Paxton to testify in their lawsuit. He fled his home Monday while being served a subpoena that was later quashed by a judge.

Texas AG’s office sends mixed signals about whether it can fine nonprofits that pay for out-of-state abortions

A federal judge heard arguments Tuesday about Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s role in enforcing the state’s abortion laws — and whether Paxton should be called to the stand to explain things himself.

The lawsuit was brought by a group of nonprofits, called abortion funds, that help Texans pay for abortions in states where the procedure remains legal. The abortion funds argue that Paxton’s statements since the overturn of Roe v. Wade, coupled with the actions of conservative lawmakers, have made them so fearful of potential criminal and civil penalties that they have stopped their work.

They have asked U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman for a preliminary injunction that would stop Paxton from pursuing criminal charges or civil penalties against abortion funds. The state has countered that their fear of prosecution is “self-imposed,” as the attorney general cannot bring criminal charges and the law that allows him to bring civil penalties does not apply to abortion funds.

At the end of the seven-hour hearing Tuesday, Pitman noted that while attorneys for the state had repeatedly implied that the abortion funds had “nothing to worry about,” they had stopped short of saying so directly.

Pitman is expected to rule on the request for a preliminary injunction in the coming weeks but in the meantime is also considering a motion to require Paxton to testify himself. Before the hearing Tuesday, Pitman quashed a subpoena seeking the attorney general’s testimony, but lawyers for the plaintiffs have asked him to reconsider. Paxton fled his home Monday to avoid being served with the original subpoena.

The lawsuit also seeks clarity on whether a Texas-based abortion provider can perform abortions for Texans in other states where the procedure remains legal, or provide telehealth services from Texas to patients in other states.

On that question, the attorney for the state was even less definitive about whether the attorney general would try to enforce the civil penalties in the law, saying that situation was not amenable to a clear “up or down” answer but would have to be handled on a case-by-case basis.

Legal confusion

A year ago, when Texas banned most abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy, abortion funds stepped up to help Texans leave the state to continue to access abortions. Their hotlines were flooded with calls — people who needed to get to Oklahoma or Kansas or New Mexico to access abortions they could no longer get in Texas.

These small nonprofits rely mostly on donations and volunteers, who flooded in after the law went into effect. Several of them added staff and scaled up their operations to accommodate the increased need.

But their high-profile work came with backlash. State Rep. Briscoe Cain, R-Deer Park, sent them cease-and-desist letters, claiming that their work was in violation of pre-Roe abortion laws that had never been repealed, and started using #ProsecuteTexasAbortionFunds on Twitter. Anti-abortion activists also targeted two abortion funds for potential lawsuits.

The funds were undeterred, continuing to help thousands of Texans seek abortions in surrounding states.

But all of that changed when the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in late June, allowing states to set their own laws on abortion. Immediately, Paxton issued guidance that said prosecutors could “immediately pursue criminal prosecutions based on violations of Texas abortion prohibitions predating Roe that were never repealed by the Texas Legislature.”

“Under these pre-Roe statutes, abortion providers could be criminally liable for providing abortions starting today,” Paxton wrote.

But those pre-Roe statutes don’t criminalize just abortion providers — they also criminalize anyone who “furnishes the means” for an abortion, punishable by up to five years in prison.

Immediately, abortion funds in Texas stopped their operations, citing confusion over whether paying for abortions out of state constituted furnishing the means for an illegal abortion. As the leaders of several abortion funds testified to on Tuesday, they were particularly alarmed by Paxton’s statement that his office would “assist any local prosecutor who pursues criminal charges.”

Their fears were exacerbated, according to testimony, when a group of conservative lawmakers in the Texas House, including Cain, issued a letter to Sidley Austin, a prestigious law firm that had offered to pay for its Texas-based employees to travel out of state to get abortions. In the letter, the lawmakers threatened the law firm with criminal prosecution for their actions.

Based on these indications from Paxton and lawmakers, “we believed we would be prosecuted, to be frank,” Anna Rupani, the executive director of Fund Texas Choice said Tuesday.

This freeze on their work came with other consequences, according to Tuesday’s testimony. Several of the funds said they had lost donors or had to spend more time reassuring donors who were confused and worried. Some said they had lost staff or board members over fear of criminal prosecution.

Lawyers for the state, though, argued that this chilling effect was “self-imposed” and “unreasonable.” None of the people the abortion funds cited threats from — Cain, the other legislators or Paxton himself — have the ability to bring criminal charges against anyone.

Only district and county attorneys can bring criminal charges in Texas; the prosecutors named on this lawsuit have agreed not to press charges against abortion funds for paying for out-of-state abortions until the case is fully resolved.

Paxton, though, still has the ability to pursue civil cases and, in the case of Texas’ more recent abortion laws, is actually required to by state statute.

In 2021, the state Legislature passed a so-called “trigger ban” that went into effect 30 days after the U.S. Supreme Court certified its judgment overturning Roe v. Wade.

The trigger law comes with heightened criminal penalties — up to life in prison — and says that the attorney general “shall” seek civil penalties of at least $100,000 per abortion.

The trigger law criminalizes only the person who “performs, induces or attempts” an abortion. As the state pointed out in court Tuesday, there are no penalties for “furnishing the means” or “aiding and abetting” in an abortion, unlike in other Texas abortion laws.

But Paxton has alluded to wanting to find ways to use these civil penalties against people who pay for abortions out of state. In a TV interview with NewsNation, Paxton was asked about companies that are paying for employees to leave the state to get abortions.

“We’re going to be looking at whether the language covers at least the civil side, and that’s obviously what we can deal with,” Paxton said. “These penalties could even be for corporations, over $100,000 per violation. So we’re looking at that literally as we speak.”

Lawyers for the state disputed that concern Tuesday, saying that “for the most part,” the activities that abortion funds want to resume would not put them in danger of civil penalties from the attorney general’s office.

But in their filings in response to the lawsuit, the state wrote that they see penalizing people who help pay for abortions out of state as “a means to an end — the protection of human life, including the life of the unborn.”

“That interest continues whether the Texan mother seeks an abortion in Denver or Dallas, in Las Cruces or Lamesa,” the filing reads. “It does not matter if the travel and hotel are in Albuquerque or Austin—the procurement in Texas of the means of an abortion has intruded upon the State’s interest in the protection of human life.”

So no matter the statements of the lawyers in the courtroom, an attorney for the plaintiffs said their clients wouldn’t feel comfortable resuming services just yet.

“It was not clear to us based on statements made in court whether the behavior [funds would] like to resume would put them at threat from the attorney general,” attorney Elizabeth Myers said after the hearing. “We eagerly await a ruling from the court.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Carlos Queiroz was hired to fix American soccer. Now he could oust the United States from World Cup

DOHA, Qatar — The 69-year-old globetrotting polyglot who’ll try to topple the USMNT at the 2022 World Cup once spent an entire year trying to fix American soccer. Carlos Queiroz ... Read more »

Route 222 shut down north of Reading

WGAL breaking news. A stretch of Route 222 is shut down in Berks County this morning. Video above: The Susquehanna Valley’s busiest roads, intersections. Sign up for our Newsletters A ... Read more »

What temperature should my home be this winter?

The temperature your home should be can vary depending on your age and health. (Getty Images) While winter is well and truly here, the rising cost of energy and living ... Read more »

Montreal dental hygienists give back to the community with free oral hygiene clinic

For dental hygienist Tayyaba Fiaz and about 50 other volunteers, giving back means holding a free oral hygiene clinic at John Abbott College for people who have limited access to ... Read more »

Is a Beast from the East 2022 coming to UK? Met Office weather forecast, where will it snow, how bad was 2018

The UK is just days away from officially entering winter, with the Met Office warning temperatures in the run up to Christmas. While snowfall in winter tends to be a ... Read more »

ANALYSIS: Do we know what Jets are fully capable of?

View image in full screen The Winnipeg Jets have reached the quarter mark of the schedule, and while that should no longer be considered a “small sample size,” it still ... Read more »

Keir Starmer: what did Labour leader say about freedom of movement? MP’s comments on immigration and Brexit

Keir Starmer has said that free movement of people between the UK and the EU “won’t come back” if he becomes Prime Minister. The Labour Party leader added that it ... Read more »

Prep Rally: State championship bowl matchups are set

Hi, and welcome to another edition of Prep Rally. My name is Eric Sondheimer. The state football bowl games begin this weekend. There’s only two weeks left in the high ... Read more »

Michelle Yeoh laughs at 60: ‘Yes! Finally! I’m cool!’

Michelle Yeoh was having a flashback, not of the acid variety, but it was pretty intense all the same. She was seated in the middle of the Paramount Theatre in ... Read more »

Iran Calls for U.S. World Cup Teams' Suspension After It Changes Iranian Flag Icon to Support Protesters

The United States Soccer Federation, in its social media posts over the weekend, featured the flags of the countries competing in Group B, which includes a match between the U.S. ... Read more »

Residents of This State Have the Worst Average Credit Score—See How You Stack Up

No one wants to see their state on the list of worst anything, be it food, standardized test scores or road rage incidents. But being among the worst when it ... Read more »

World Cup 2022: Jurgen Klinsmann defends controversial Iran comments which drew fury from Carlos Queiroz

Jurgen Klinsmann and Carlos Queiroz are in the middle of a war of words (Photos: Getty) Jurgen Klinsmann has defended controversial comments he made about the performance of the Iranian ... Read more »

USMNT vs. Iran 2022 World Cup Preview, Storylines, Key Players, More

NBC Universal, Inc. It’s now all to play for on Tuesday. Following the United States men’s national team’s 0-0 draw with England and Iran’s 2-0 win over Wales on Friday, ... Read more »

City of Houston Under Boil Water Notice After Power Outage

Getty Images The main water system for Houston, Texas, has been given a boil water notice after water pressure dropped below minimum water pressure levels following a power outage at ... Read more »

Ghana Takes Early Lead With Two First-Half Goals Vs. South Korea

NBC Universal, Inc. Ghana is working to escape elimination from this year’s 2022 World Cup as they take on South Korea in a Group H clash on Monday in Qatar. ... Read more »

Tom Stoppard’s Jewish roots: Carey Perloff on Broadway’s acclaimed play of the season

“Leopoldstadt,” Tom Stoppard’s stunning new play on Broadway about a highly cultivated extended family in Vienna that was decimated in the Holocaust, isn’t autobiographical. But the work springs from the ... Read more »

'The greatest': Princess Beatrice breaks Twitter hiatus to celebrate Mike Tindall

Oops! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Oops! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Oops! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Mike Tindall (left) and Princess Beatrice. ... Read more »

911 calls surge as University of Idaho murders leave community on edge

University of Idaho students return to campus following the Thanksgiving break on Sunday. James Keivom Police in the college town home to the University of Idaho have been inundated with ... Read more »

Shop the Colorful Monday sale at Le Creuset for Cyber Monday deals 2022

New York Post Composite Happy Colorful Monday, shoppers! What’s that? We’re glad you asked. It is the adorable name that Le Creuset is using for their doorbuster Cyber Monday sale, ... Read more »

6 Mistakes Everyone Makes When Painting Concrete Floors

painting concrete floor Whether in your basement or garage, concrete as flooring can be a boring and dull material to look at. Covering it with vinyl or other flooring options ... Read more »

New Smyrna Beach to share recovery plan on storm damage, beach erosion from Hurricane Nicole

Storm damage victims in New Smyrna Beach can learn this week how the city plans to move forward from Hurricane Nicole. >>> STREAM CHANNEL 9 EYEWITNESS NEWS LIVE <<< Photos: ... Read more »

Don Lemon and Ex-Trump Staffer Clash Over Trump’s Dinner With White Supremacist: ‘Don’t Put Words in My Mouth’

CNN’s Don Lemon grilled a former Donald Trump administration staffer with a relentless series of questions on whether he condemns the ex-president for hosting anti-semites at Mar-a-Lago. Lemon spoke to ... Read more »

Will Smith knows you don’t want to see him after slap: ‘I completely understand’

Will Smith has acknowledged that his fans may not be “ready” to watch him on screen in the upcoming drama film “Emancipation.” The movie is the 54-year-old’s first project following ... Read more »

92-year-old woman killed after being hit by SUV in Lanaudière, Que.

A 92-year-old woman is dead after she was struck by an SUV on Sunday evening in Saint-Jean-de-Matha in Quebec’s Lanaudière region, police say. Quebec provincial police say emergency services were ... Read more »

Man arrested for fatal Bronx shooting that was part of suspected drug rip-off

A man with no criminal history has been arrested for a fatal Bronx shooting cops suspect was part of a drug rip-off, police said Monday. Manuel Palma was nabbed Wednesday ... Read more »

Niece of Iran’s supreme leader urges world to cut ties with Tehran over protest crackdown

BAGHDAD —  The niece of Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is calling on people to pressure their governments to cut ties with Tehran over its violent suppression of anti-government protests. ... Read more »

Morehouse College class will teach Black history in the metaverse

This spring, Ovell Hamilton, a professor at Morehouse College in Atlanta, will guide students through a first-of-its-kind course in which Black history is taught entirely through the metaverse, a virtual ... Read more »

Protests against Covid lockdowns sweep China, challenge Xi Jinping

HONG KONG — Chinese citizens increasingly fed up with President Xi Jinping’s “zero-Covid” restrictions protested in cities across the country over the weekend, in a widespread show of resistance to ... Read more »

World Cup Tourists Put Strain on Qatar's Camels

AP Photo/Ashley Landis Shaheen stretched out on the sand and closed his eyes, but there was little time to rest for the camel. World Cup fans coming in droves to ... Read more »

Ziyech turns it on to shock Belgium, Kovačić and Croatia return to form, Germany earn draw, Costa Rica eke out a win, too

Ziyech turns it on to shock Belgium, Kovačić and Croatia return to form, Germany earn draw, Costa Rica eke out a win, too The theme for day eight was set ... Read more »

Looks like Donald Trump may have handed the Senate race in Georgia to Democrats again

By endorsing Herschel Walker, Trump chose a candidate who was guaranteed to struggle in what should have been an easy race for the GOP. The Senate race in Georgia has ... Read more »

It takes a village to build the Torrance Rose Float

Nov. 28—On Jan. 2, Torrance’s dazzling Rose Parade float will glide effortlessly down Colorado Boulevard,. But getting the float to the finish line is anything but easy. It requires over ... Read more »

Olivia Culpo and Christian McCaffrey kiss on the sideline before 49ers-Saints game

Olivia Culpo has become a sideline staple at Levi’s Stadium after the Panthers traded her boyfriend Christian McCaffrey to 49ers last month. The model and actress shared a kiss with ... Read more »

Carnival passenger rescued after 15 hours at sea got in trouble for vaping

The passenger who was miraculously rescued in the Gulf of Mexico 15 hours after he fell off a Carnival cruise ship had gotten in trouble for vaping — and was ... Read more »

Dumb Boss Rejects Client's Payment Over 30 Stupid Cents, Loses His Business $300,000 Over This

If anyone should be leaving the company, it should be the boss! This thread was posted to Reddit’s r/antiwork subreddit by u/Competitive_Humor610, who opened up about a sales job they ... Read more »

Elon Musk Says Tesla Co-Founder Eberhard 'Was Wealthy And Could Have Risked His Money, But...'

Tesla Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) CEO Elon Musk responded to a Twitter post that played down his role in the automaker’s early years. What Happened: Musk’s reaction was in response to a ... Read more »

Dehumidifier deals have dried up but you can still buy these models

You won't have much luck finding a discounted dehumidifier on Cyber Monday but there are still some models available to buy Read more »

Line to Shutter US Crypto Exchange Next Year, Suspends Onboarding Today

The Japanese social media firm Line will shutter its American crypto exchange, adding that the decision was unrelated to FTX’s collapse. Read more »

Hawaii’s Mauna Loa starts to erupt, spewing ash and debris

HONOLULU —  Hawaii’s Mauna Loa, the world’s largest active volcano, has started to erupt, sending volcanic ash and debris falling nearby, authorities said Monday. The eruption began late Sunday night in ... Read more »

Shoprite employs heavy-duty electric truck that glows in the dark

The Shoprite Group, which owns popular grocery store Checkers, has become the first retailer in South Africa to employ a heavy-duty electric truck as part of its delivery vehicle fleet. ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network