Teenage girls, body image and Instagram's ‘perfect storm'

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: ljubaphoto/Getty

Emily started using Instagram when she was in her mid-teens and found it helpful at first. She used the photo-sharing app to follow fitness influencers, but what began as a constructive relationship with the platform spiralled into a crisis centred on body image. At 19 she was diagnosed with an eating disorder.

“I felt like my body wasn’t good enough, because even though I did go to the gym a lot, my body still never looked like the bodies of these influencers,” says Emily, now a 20-year-old a student who is in recovery.

Emily, who preferred not to use her real name, uses Instagram sparingly now. She is one of many Instagram users whose suffering came to prominence this week with revelations that the platform’s owner, Facebook, seemed to know it was damaging teenage girls’ mental health.

According to internal research leaked to the Wall Street Journal (WSJ), the app has made body image issues worse for one in three girls and in one Facebook study of teenagers in the UK and the US, more than 40% of Instagram users who said they felt “unattractive” said the feeling began while using the app.

Instagram has more than 1 billion users worldwide and an estimated 30 million in the UK, with Kim Kardashian, Selena Gomez and Ariana Grande among the accounts with hundreds of millions of followers between them. In the UK, the Love Island couple Liam Reardon and Millie Court have already raced to a combined following of nearly 3 million since winning the 2021 title.

© Photograph: ljubaphoto/Getty More than 40% of Instagram users say feelings of being unattractive began while using the app, according to leaked Facebook research.

Two in five girls (40%) aged 11 to 16 in the UK say they have seen images online that have made them feel insecure or less confident about themselves. This increases to half (50%) in girls aged 17 to 21, according to research by Girlguiding in its annual girls’ attitudes survey.

Sonia Livingstone, professor of social psychology at the department of media and communications, LSE, describes adolescence for teenage girls as an “arc” that tends to begin with the staple experiences of interest in pets, painting or playing with younger siblings, through to the more confident young woman ready to face the world. But it is the experience in the middle of that parabola that represents a particular challenge, and where Instagram can be most troubling.

“It is at that point where they are assailed with many answers to their dilemmas and a prominent answer at the moment is that it might be what they look like, that it matters what they bought,” says Livingstone, who next week is due to give evidence to MPs and peers scrutinising the draft UK online safety bill, which imposes a duty of care on social media companies to protect users from harmful content.

Facebook’s in-depth research into the photo-sharing app stated that Instagram had a deeper effect on teenage girls because it focused more on the body and lifestyle, compared with TikTok’s emphasis on performance videos such as dancing, and Snapchat’s jokey face features. “Social comparison is worse on Instagram,” said the Facebook study. The leaked research pointed to the app’s Explore page, where an algorithm tailors the photos and videos that a user sees, potentially creating a spiral of harmful content.

Related: MP calls for Facebook to be punished if it holds back evidence of harm to users

“Aspects of Instagram exacerbate each other to create a perfect storm,” said the research.

Livingstone says a key feature of the online safety bill will be its provisions on regulating the algorithms that constantly tailor and tweak what you view according to your perceived needs and tastes – and can push teenage girls into that vortex of esteem-damaging content. “There is a lot to be done about algorithms and AI [artificial intelligence].”

Beeban Kidron, the crossbench peer who sits on the joint committee into the online safety bill and was behind the recent introduction of a children’s privacy code, says Ofcom, the UK communications watchdog, will have a vital role in scrutinising algorithms.

“The value in algorithmic oversight for regulators, is that the decisions that tech companies make will become transparent, including decisions like FB took to allow Instagram to target teenage girls with images and features that ended in anxiety, depression and suicidal thoughts. Algorithmic oversight is the key to society wrestling back some control.”

A spokesperson for the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport says the bill will address those concerns. “As part of their duty of care, companies will need to mitigate the risks of their algorithms promoting illegal or harmful content, particularly to children. Ofcom will have a range of powers to ensure they do this, including the ability to request information and enter companies’ premises to access data and equipment.”

For others, there is a wider issue of educating the young how to navigate a world dominated by social media. Deana Puccio, co-founder of the Rap project, which visits schools across the UK and abroad to discuss issues such as consent, online and offline safety and building confidence in body image and self-esteem, says the bill should be accompanied by a wider education drive.

“We, parents, educators, politicians need to equip our young people with the tools, the analytical skills to make healthy choices for themselves. Because they will get access to whatever they want to. They are better at navigating the online world than we are.”

Puccio adds that teenagers should be encouraged to make their social media posts reflect a more realistic vision of the world. “We need to start building up people’s confidence to post real-life ups and downs.”

The head of Instagram risked fanning criticism of the app on Thursday with comments that compared social media’s impact on society to that of cars. “We know that more people die than would otherwise because of car accidents, but by and large, cars create way more value in the world than they destroy. And I think social media is similar,” said Adam Mosseri.

Facebook referred the Guardian to a blogpost by Karina Newton, the head of public policy at Instagram, who said the internal research showed “our commitment to understanding complex and difficult issues young people may struggle with, and informs all the work we do to help those experiencing these issues”.

The Instagram revelations came as part of a WSJ investigation into Facebook, in which the newspaper revealed that Facebook gives high-profile users special treatment, that changes to its news feed algorithm in 2018 made the platform’s users angrier and more divisive, and that employees had warned Facebook was being used by drug cartels and human traffickers in developing countries.

Responding to the algorithm and drug cartel allegations, Facebook said divisions had existed in society long before its platform appeared and that it had a “comprehensive strategy” for keeping people safe in countries where there was a risk of conflict and violence.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

‘What he brings at No.6 is something you can't create overnight': Kohli backs Hardik, says he's fit to bowl 'at least 2'

© Provided by Hindustan Times India’s captain Virat Kohli, right, talks with teammate Hardik Pandya during the Cricket Twenty20 World Cup (AP) India captain Virat Kohli sounded confident about Hardik ... Read more »

DA's Steenhuisen asks voters to resist ‘emotional appeals' at November polls

© Provided by Eyewitness News JOHANNESBURG – Democratic Alliance (DA) leader John Steenhuisen has painted a picture of the party as the only rational choice for the 1 November local ... Read more »

At least 2 hedge funds dumped their SPAC stakes after a merger with Trump's new media company was announced, reports say

© Chris Delmas/AFP via Getty Images Former President Donald Trump’s new social media site. Chris Delmas/AFP via Getty Images Investors in the SPAC that merged with Trump Media reportedly sold ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing star opens up on ‘overwhelming' experience ‘It's a struggle'

The new series of Strictly Come Dancing 2021 is well underway as the celebrities take to the dance floor in a bid to impress the judges. Over the years, the ... Read more »

Watch: Bohs' Georgie Kelly buzzing for ‘big day out' in Extra.ie FAI Cup final

© Provided by Extra.ie Bohemians’ match-winner Georgie Kelly was delighted to secure a ‘big day out’ for the club’s supporters by sealing their place in the Extra.ie FAI Cup final. ... Read more »

Patel backs a change in law for victims of domestic abuse

© PA Images priti patel The limit on common assault cases is currently six months, which means a prosecution has to be brought to court within that time frame from ... Read more »

The popular kids toys likely to be in short supply in Ireland ahead of Christmas

Irish shoppers are being warned to get their Christmas shopping finished early this year as supply issues are likely to leave some disappointed. According to reports, delays have affected most ... Read more »

Rust crew members expressed ‘safety concerns' before Alec Baldwin's prop gun killed Halyna Hitchins

© Getty Images / Instagram @halynahitchins Alec-Baldwin-Halyna-Hitchins.jpg Camera crew members walked off the set of Rust due to “safety concerns” a day before Alec Baldwin’s prop gun killed cinematographer Halyna ... Read more »

Better meals ahead with the newest butter in town, Maven Pure Butter

Have you ever found yourself going through the same recipes week on week? Finding it tiring to cook the same meal over and over again? Or maybe scrolled way too ... Read more »

Tryst With Destiny trailer out: Drishyam Films' internationally acclaimed anthology to release on THIS date - Watch

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Drishyam Films has launched the trailer of Tryst With Destiny, the internationally acclaimed anthology which is all set to release on 5th November ... Read more »

Rani Mukerji to play Fashion Queen of Fursatgunj

© Glamsham/Instagram/Twitter Rani Mukerji to play Fashion Queen of Fursatgunj Bollywood star Rani Mukerji is known for her stellar performances that have been etched into the hearts of audiences. She ... Read more »

PHOTOS: Vijay Deverakonda sports pastel pink mirror kurta with a Gucci watch worth a whopping price

© Provided by Pinkvilla Vijay Devarakonda who is emerging as the dream boy of young women in South India is among the most wanted actors in Telugu. After the success ... Read more »

Jacqueline's YOLO Foundation pledges support to young girls for better future

© IANS Jacqueline Fernandez Mumbai, Oct 23 (IANS) Jacqueline Fernandez is known for her talent as a dancer, an actress and an entertainer. However, her humanitarian side is something that ... Read more »

Singapore conditionally lifts travel restrictions from India starting Oct 27

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Singapore will from October 27 again allow certain categories of visitors from India subject to certain conditions. “Currently, travellers with travel ... Read more »

Queen Letizia dazzles in the dreamiest black ballgown

© Provided by Hello! letizia-lbd Looking every inch the modern-day Cinderella, Queen Letizia donned the dreamiest black ballgown on Friday night as she attended the Princesa de Asturias Awards 2021 ... Read more »

SAGE scientist calls for masks and WFH NOW

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A Government scientific adviser said he is ‘very fearful’ there will be another ‘lockdown Christmas’. Professor Peter Openshaw, a member of the New and ... Read more »

Clashes continue as thousands of Islamists march to Pakistan capital

Thousands of supporters of a banned radical Islamist party have left the eastern Pakistan city of Lahore, clashing for a second straight day with police who lobbed tear gas into ... Read more »

Perfect for a shelfie! The Etsy shop selling statement concrete plant pots & incense holders

Etsy UK shop Yeux Studios sell beautiful, sculptural concrete plant pots and incense holders, and despite it being less than a year old, it’s becoming a firm favourite on the ... Read more »

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and Jurgen Klopp's similar records do not tell the full story

Despite the unrelenting pressure weighing down on his shoulders, there is a crumb of comfort for Ole Gunnar Solskjaer. Manchester United will end the weekend seven points behind Liverpool if ... Read more »

Laura Kuenssberg replacement at BBC should be ‘pro-Brexit', says senior Tory MP

The BBC should hire a political editor who is “pro-Brexit” to replace Laura Kuenssberg if she leaves her role, a senior Conservative MP has said. © BBC BBC political editor ... Read more »

British woman denied entry to Spain after passport stamp issue- ‘frustrating'

Passport stamps show the entry and exit date of British nationals and enable border guards to keep track of tourists. However, some guards are reportedly unsure about the new rules ... Read more »

Up to 150 people with Covid could be in ICU by end of November – Taoiseach

Up to 150 people could be in intensive care with Covid by the end of November, the Taoiseach has warned. © Brian Lawless Micheal Martin said it was difficult to ... Read more »

Five Myanmar nationals without valid documents apprehended in Assam's Cachar district

Five Myanmar nationals without valid documents apprehended in Assam’s Cachar district. Five Myanmar nationals who entered India without valid documents were apprehended by police in Assam’s Cachar district along the ... Read more »

COVID-19 Delta variant mutant AY.4.2 may be more transmissible: UK health agency

© Provided by Zee News London: The UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) confirmed that the Delta variant sub-lineage (Delta AY.4.2) was designated a Variant Under Investigation (VUI) on October 20, ... Read more »

J-K: Home Minister Amit Shah meets family members of slain Inspector Parvaiz Ahmad

© Provided by Zee News Srinagar: In his first visit to the Valley since the abrogation of Article 370, Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Saturday met the family of ... Read more »

IOCL Recruitment 2021: Apply for 1968 posts at iocl.com – Check eligibility, last date, selection process

© Provided by DNA Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOCL) is inviting applications for 1968 Apprentice posts under the Apprentices Act, 1961 in Refineries Division. Interested candidates can apply through the ... Read more »

Odisha: Opp intensifies demand for Minister Dibya Shankar Mishra's arrest

© Provided by The Statesman Odisha: Opp intensifies demand for Minister Dibya Shankar Mishra’s arrest The Opposition BJP, Congress and Left parties stepped up their demand for the resignation of ... Read more »

Death of workers in stone quarries on the rise: INTUC

© Provided by The Statesman Death of workers in stone quarries on the rise: INTUC Workers are dying daily in stone quarries across India in accidents and occupational diseases. Health ... Read more »

Capt slams personal attack after Punjab govt orders probe over ISI link of his female friend

© Provided by The Statesman Capt slams personal attack after Punjab govt orders probe over ISI link of his female friend With Punjab home minister Sukhjinder Singh Randhawa ordering a ... Read more »

A Special Diwali for AAP: Delhi CM Kejriwal to Visit Ayodhya on October 26

© Provided by News18 A Special Diwali for AAP: Delhi CM Kejriwal to Visit Ayodhya on October 26 In a big Hindutva push, Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal will visit Ayodhya in ... Read more »

Electric Zambonis, rainwater for ice at new climate-friendly Seattle arena

Seattle’s new Climate Pledge Arena is hardly subtle with its message.  © Provided by NBC News Walk through the south entrance and visitors will see a one-story digital waterfall pouring ... Read more »

Jim Clyburn Says Democrats Are Close to 'Sweet Spot' on Build Back Better Cost

Representative Jim Clyburn has said that Democrats are “close to finding the sweet spot” on the cost of the Build Back Better Act amid ongoing debate within the party. © ... Read more »

Frontpoint home security review: An ace DIY system grounded by expensive subscription fees

Update, Oct 23: Since our initial review, Frontpoint added a feature called Frontpoint ID Protect to its monthly subscription. This new feature, in partnership with Allstate, will allow you to ... Read more »

Hidupkan projek HSR, jangan bayar Singapura RM320 juta, kata Guan Eng

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Lim Guan Eng berkata, PH tidak mempersoalkan keperluan untuk projek HSR, tetapi mahu menyemak semula harga terlalu tinggi dan struktur kos dipersetujui kerajaan BN ... Read more »

Ray Parks repaying Nagoya coach, teammates' trust with solid play

© Provided by SPIN.ph BOBBY Ray Parks is grateful to the Nagoya Diamond Dolphins for giving him the confidence which led to his standout showing in the past three games. ... Read more »

Carlos Yulo unable to defend title in World Championships, settles for 5th in floor exercise

Photo: FIG/Twitter It was another heartbreaker for the Philippines’ Carlos Yulo. The young Filipino gymnast was unable to defend his world title after he fell short in floor exercise finals ... Read more »

Sargeant's future "looking difficult" before Williams F1 Academy signing

© Williams Logan Sargeant, Williams Driver Academy The 20-year-old American finished third in last year’s FIA Formula 3 championship, driving for Prema Racing, but was unable to move up to ... Read more »

A Guide to Tehrangeles, Los Angeles's Pocket of Iranian Culture

© Getty The crackling pops of saffron-colored rice frying at the bottom of an old pot was the sound of dinner in my household growing up. The intense aroma of ... Read more »

Grocery Prices Are About to Spike 10% for the Rest of 2021, Insider Predicts

Grocery shoppers have noticed their supermarket receipts have gotten shorter, but the total cost has gone up. Retailers across the country have reported item shortages, worker shortages, and shipping delays, ... Read more »

Goldman Cites Tesla, Facebook as Digital Revolution Favorites

Goldman Sachs has put together a list of favored companies that it sees benefiting from “the broadening of the digital revolution” and “increased focus and spending on decarbonization.” © TheStreet ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic