Tech Giants Used ‘Loopholes' to Duck Merger Reviews, FTC Says

© Bloomberg FTC Chief Says He’s Willing To Break Up Big Tech Companies

(Bloomberg) — Hundreds of deals by U.S. technology giants flew under the radar of merger watchdogs, fueling the companies’ unchecked growth in the digital economy, according to a Federal Trade Commission study.

The data on acquisitions by Apple Inc., Amazon.com Inc., Alphabet Inc.’s Google, and Microsoft Corp. show that antitrust enforcers must be more aggressive in making sure companies aren’t taking advantage of “loopholes” to avoid reporting deals to regulators, FTC Chair Lina Khan said Wednesday.

“This study highlights the systemic nature of their acquisition strategy,” Khan said about the tech companies during an FTC public meeting. “Digital markets in particular reveal how smaller transactions invite vigilance.”

Subscribe to our Telegram News Service
Download our mobile app

The findings could bolster arguments that competition cops need to step up scrutiny of acquisitions by tech platforms to curb their power. In July, President Joe Biden vowed tougher merger enforcement of tech companies, saying the industry’s biggest players have used deals to shut down emerging threats to their businesses.

“Too often, federal agencies have not blocked, conditioned, or, in some cases, meaningfully examined these acquisitions,” the administration said. 

The data comes from a study the FTC announced last year to examine deals between 2010 and 2019 by the five tech giants to better understand whether acquisitions occurring outside the view of antitrust enforcers could be undermining competition. 

The FTC issued orders to the five companies requiring them to provide information about past acquisitions that weren’t reported to antitrust agencies. The companies identified 819 such transactions, including acquisitions of voting control of companies, partial investments, patent acquisitions, and what the FTC called “hiring events” in which a group of employees were hired from another company.

Although the FTC didn’t identify specific transactions by companies, one example is Facebook’s acquisition last year of image library Giphy for about $400 million. Bloomberg News reported last month that before the takeover, Giphy paid a dividend to investors. While perfectly legal, the payment lowered the value of Giphy’s assets so that antitrust officials didn’t have to be notified of the deal under the reporting thresholds at the time.

Read More:
Facebook’s Stealth M&A Puts Focus on Deals Under Antitrust RadarRecord M&A Boom Risks Running Afoul of Biden’s Antitrust CopsBig Tech Goes on Shopping Spree, Brushing Off Antitrust Scrutiny

Antitrust enforcers look at only a fraction of deals that occur every year. Slightly more than 2,000 deals were filed to the government between October 2018 and September 2019, the most recent period reported by the FTC and the Justice Department, which share antitrust duties. The government reviews account for about 10% of almost 22,000 deals announced in that period involving a U.S. company, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.

The U.S. system for screening mergers was created by the 1976 law known as the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act. The law requires companies to notify antitrust officials about deals that meet annually adjusted thresholds. Transactions valued at $92 million or less don’t have to be reported, while those over $368 million do. For deals between $92 million and $368 million, filing requirements are based on assets and sales of the buyer and seller.

Those levels are far below the multibillion-dollar deals that typically garner the most attention. The thinking behind the cut-offs is that small deals don’t raise antitrust concerns and looking at every transaction would be a waste of resources.

Reviewing more deals, however, could strain resources at the Justice Department and the FTC. The FTC has said it’s struggling to handle this year’s record merger levels and has warned that it may extend merger reviews that can’t be completed during an initial 30-day period.

Khan said the study shows that tech companies are devoting resources to acquiring startups, patent portfolios and engineering talent outside the purview of antitrust enforcers. She said the FTC may be “unjustifiably” allowing companies to make acquisitions without any scrutiny.

“While broader reforms to HSR may be overdue, the antitrust agencies must also guard against unduly permissive interpretations that handicap us,” Khan said, referring to the current law.

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2021 Bloomberg L.P.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

UN suspends aid flight to Ethiopia's Tigray after airstrikes

The United Nations (UN) has suspended flights to Tigray's regional capital after an aid flight had to abort landing in Mekelle. The humanitarian situation in the region is dire with ... Read more »

After a smooth path to the top, is Sunak now in for a bumpy ride?

Photograph: Oli Scarff/AFP/Getty Images So smoothly and swiftly has Rishi Sunak risen through the Tory ranks that by the time he reached Westminster, the only blot on his political copybook ... Read more »

1 killed, 1 arrested in northside shooting

Oct. 24—A Kokomo man is now under arrest after police say he fatally shot another man early Saturday morning on the city's north side. According to a Kokomo Police Department ... Read more »

Ugandan president says deadly blast a 'terrorist act'

© Badru KATUMBA A “serious blast” hit a grilled pork joint in Komamboga, a northern Kampala suburb popular with roadside diners Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni said Sunday an explosion in ... Read more »

Why can't I lose weight? - the 7 conditions that make weight loss feel impossible

Dieting is emotionally and physically draining and most people find it hard, which is why 95 percent of diets fail. The best way to lose weight is to ensure you’re ... Read more »

Man Utd offer update on Ole's future to ‘circling' agents

© PA Images Solskjaer gestures Manchester United have delivered a clear message to ‘circling’ agents amid mounting pressure on Ole Gunnar Solskjaer: the Norwegian will not be sacked. That’s according ... Read more »

Fiery Liverpool can keep hell-bent Manchester United in the furnace

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Cape Town – DISCLAIMER: I don’t hate Manchester United (Red Devils), I have nothing but respect for the club. Another disclaimer: I love Liverpool, ... Read more »

Horner expects "grandstand start" to US GP with Verstappen/Hamilton front row

© Steve Etherington / Motorsport Images Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing, 2nd position, and Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes, 1st position, congratulate each other in Parc Ferme Red Bull’s Verstappen narrowly beat ... Read more »

We will deal with corruption decisively, Ramaphosa tells traditional leaders

© Provided by Eyewitness News JOHANNESBURG – ANC President Cyril Ramaphosa has assured traditional leaders and pastors in the Vhembe district in Limpopo that the party would deal with corruption ... Read more »

IND vs PAK, T20 World Cup 2021: Virat Kohli Spends Time in Nets With Mentor MS Dhoni Ahead of Facing Pakistan | VIDEO

© Provided by News18 IND vs PAK, T20 World Cup 2021: Virat Kohli Spends Time in Nets With Mentor MS Dhoni Ahead of Facing Pakistan | VIDEO Ahead of the ... Read more »

India look set to make it 13-0 against Pakistan, and that's not a jingoistic assessment

© Provided by Firstpost India look set to make it 13-0 against Pakistan, and that’s not a jingoistic assessment Well, the day has arrived! As it has happened in the ... Read more »

Dabur's new ad on Karwa Chauth featuring same-sex couple sparks controversy on social media- Watch

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: As the festival of Karwa Chauth is almost here, Dabur’s has rolled out its new ad on Fem Creme Gold Bleach. This ad ... Read more »

BB 15: Akasa's Parents Call Her And Pratik's Friendship As Genuine

© Provided by Lehren BB 15 Akasa’s Parents Bigg Boss 15 has been in the news since day one. From fights to romance and friendship, the show is fully high ... Read more »

Rajinikanth to be conferred with Dadasaheb Phalke Award tomorrow

© Provided by The Statesman Rajinikanth to be conferred with Dadasaheb Phalke Award tomorrow Megastar Rajinikanth will be conferred with the 51st Dadasaheb Phalke Award tomorrow. He will receive the ... Read more »

'India haven't even won yet but celebrations have begun': Wasim Akram issues warning, says he'll dance if Pakistan win

Legendary fast bowler Wasim Akram has issued a warning to India and its fans, reminding them not to get carried away with premature celebrations related to the prospect of India ... Read more »

Gal Gadot hints her kids may appear again in 'Wonder Woman 3'

© Provided by WION Gal Gadot has revealed a little something you can look forward to in ‘Wonder Woman 3′. Gadot is all set to reprise her role as everyone’s ... Read more »

Boxing Day Test could have upto 80,000 fans at the MCG

© Getty Images Signs are looking promising for the Boxing Day Test at the MCG © Getty Images There are hopes that a crowd of 80,000 could be allowed into ... Read more »

Flooat creates "fluctuating landscape" inside publishing office near Tokyo

Design studio Flooat has used elevated work areas, structural columns and chunky plinths to simulate natural topography inside the offices of book publisher Kadokawa in Japan. © Provided by Dezeen Interiors ... Read more »

‘She's knackered': Queen exhausted after whirlwind of engagements

Sources close the Queen have admitted she is “knackered” after a busy summer of engagements “got too much”. © REUTERS FILE PHOTO: Britain’s Queen Elizabeth and members of the Royal ... Read more »

British Columbia: Fire blazes cargo ship containers

A fire broke out on Saturday on containers on a cargo ship carrying mining chemicals off British Columbia, and the Canadian Coast Guard said it is working with the U.S. ... Read more »

Cinemagic arrives in the Philippines with the newly launched Xiaomi 11T Series and Xiaomi 11 Lite 5G NE

Global technology leader, Xiaomi, today announced the Philippine launch of new smartphones under the Xiaomi 11T family of devices – Xiaomi 11T and Xiaomi 11T Pro – all designed to ... Read more »

Albert Martinez, Faith Da Silva have chemistry together as the veteran actor claims

Albert Martinez said that he and Faith Da Silva have chemistry together as they star in the upcoming Kapuso teleserye Las Hermanas. © Provided by LionhearTV To recall, Martinez, 60, ... Read more »

Rishi Sunak warning: Plan to crash UK economy ‘onto the rocks'- higher taxes 'not answer'

The former Brexit Secretary claimed “every indication” of Mr Sunak’s budget “will take us onto the rocks – not away from them”. Despite Mr Sunak reportedly being a fan of ... Read more »

Tony Visconti says David Bowie's Toy is a 'ghost album'

Tony Visconti has described David Bowie’s ‘Toy’ as a “ghost album”. © Bang Showbiz David Bowie The previously unheard collection – which was recorded in 2001 and will finally get ... Read more »

Markets on red alert over interest rate rise after UK inflation 'above 5 percent' warning

Bank of England chief economist Huw Pill said the UK’s central bank will have to make a “live” decision on interest rates at a coming meeting in November. However, Mr ... Read more »

Home Office refuses to reveal details of Afghans' resettlement

Photograph: Leon Neal/Getty Images The Home Office will not say how many of the airlifted Afghans qualify to be rehoused in the UK and has refused to reveal how many ... Read more »

‘I was born in war': an Afghan family's joy at resettlement in UK

Photograph: Graeme Robertson/The Guardian An intricately handwoven rug is one of the few things British embassy worker <a href="/tag/shukoor-sangar”>Shukoor Sangar and his family were able to bring with them when ... Read more »

'It hurts me' - Michael Obafemi opens up on difficulties since Southampton move as Swansea City star's unseen role revealed

Swansea City star Michael Obafemi says the Jack Army support gives him the chills as he opened up on his difficult start to life in south Wales. The young striker ... Read more »

Inside the luxury 7-bedroom £2.2m mansion with Tatton Park right on its doorstep

A Cheshire mansion that opens up onto a luxury championship golf course could be yours – if you have a couple of million going spare. The seven-bedroom property is situated ... Read more »

Prop gun that killed Halyna Hutchins ‘used by crew for fun' in ‘off-set target practice while loaded with real bullets'

THE gun that killed Halyna Hutchins was used for off-set target practice fun by the film's crew using real bullets, it was reported. Halyna, 42, was shot by Alec Baldwin ... Read more »

‘I hug them': meet the farmer raising 2,000lb pumpkins

It starts with a tiny seed. Leonardo Urena opened his palm to show a small plastic bag containing a single special specimen. Smooth and white, it wasn’t yet remarkable, but ... Read more »

Gekappte Lieferketten: Bundespräsident Parmelin befürchtet mehr Kurzarbeit

Dem Wirtschaftsminister machen die unterbrochenen Lieferketten Sorgen. Der harte Abstimmungskampf ums Covid-Gesetz aber nicht. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Bundespräsident Parmelin befürchtet mehr Kurzarbeit Herr Bundespräsident, bei Ihrer Partei ist der ... Read more »

NDRRMC to hold online nationwide earthquake drill on November 11

NDRRMC to hold online nationwide earthquake drill on November 11 The National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council, (NDRRMC) through the Office of Civil Defense (OCD), will hold the Fourth ... Read more »

'It could save us' Boris Johnson handed COP26 lifeline to avoid Sturgeon humiliation

The Prime Minister has already proven his commitment to tackling the climate crisis with domestic policies aimed at slashing planet-warming greenhouse gases across every aspect of public life. The Government ... Read more »

Government eyes legal requirement for NHS staff to be vaccinated

© Provided by City AM The government is looking at legally enforcing a Covid vaccine mandate for all NHS staff. Health secretary Sajid Javid wants to push through legislation requiring ... Read more »

Civilian Killed in J&K's Shopian, Cops Say Was Caught in Crossfire Between CRPF & Militants

© Provided by News18 Civilian Killed in J&K’s Shopian, Cops Say Was Caught in Crossfire Between CRPF & Militants A person was killed on Sunday after a brief firing near ... Read more »

Mum reveals huge difference in size 14 jeans despite buying from same shop

© TikTok / @justablusmom Mum reveals huge difference in Size 14 jeans she bought from same shop in viral TikTok Between finding the right cut, the right length, and the ... Read more »

All India Bar Examination on October 31: Major relaxation for students

A major relaxation has been provided to candidates who are appearing for the All India Bar Examination (AIBE) on October 31.  This will be the 16th edition of the AIBE. ... Read more »

Cong running away from public issues by not convening Assembly's pending monsoon session: AAP

© Provided by The Statesman Cong running away from public issues by not convening Assembly’s pending monsoon session: AAP Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) Punjab on Saturday accused the ruling Congress ... Read more »

UK warns of substantial differences with EU over Northern Ireland trade

© Provided by City AM The UK has said that post-Brexit talks with the EU over Northern Ireland trade rules are constructive, but substantial differences remain. Goods sent between Britain ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic