Taxpayer takes CRA to court after it dings him for RRSP overcontribution tax due to a bank error

taxpayer takes cra to court after it dings him for rrsp overcontribution tax due to a bank error

When accepting a Home Buyers’ Plan payment for the one spouses’s RRSP, the bank erred and placed the payment in the spousal RRSP account, which resulted in an overcontribution situation for the other party.

As first-time homebuyers prepare for the launch of the tax-free first home savings account (FHSA) later this year, let’s not forget it may be used in conjunction with the existing Home Buyers’ Plan (HBP) to assist with the purchase of a first home.

Indeed, for many first-time homebuyers , especially those who plan to buy their first home within the next few years, having the ability to tap into existing registered retirement savings plans (RRSPs) via the HBP may be the only way to come up with a sufficient down payment.

But the HBP comes with its own set of rules that could potentially land you in trouble with the taxman if not followed, which is what happened in a recent case. Before delving into the details, let’s review some HBP basics.

The HBP allows a first-time homebuyer to withdraw up to $35,000 from an RRSP to purchase or build a first home without having to pay tax on the withdrawal. Amounts withdrawn under the HBP must be repaid to an RRSP over a period not exceeding 15 years, starting the second year following the year of the withdrawal. Amounts not repaid in a particular year, as required, must be included in income.

In the recent tax case, a taxpayer and his spouse purchased their first home together in 2006, each of them making withdrawals from their respective RRSPs as part of the HBP. In 2012, the taxpayer’s spouse had an outstanding HBP balance of $13,142. In 2013, she went into her local bank branch to make a payment into her RRSP to pay off this HBP balance.

Unfortunately, it seems her bank mistakenly placed this payment into her spousal RRSP account for which the taxpayer (the husband) was the contributor, rather than into her personal RRSP account. She then claimed this $13,142 contribution as an HBP repayment on her 2013 tax return.

The taxpayer also made an RRSP contribution of $13,111 in repayment of his own HBP balance, and claimed that repayment on his return. But because of the alleged bank error, the Canada Revenue Agency took the position that the taxpayer was also the contributor of the $13,142 HBP payment made by his spouse, which resulted in the taxpayer being in an overcontribution situation in 2013.

Fast forward to 2018, when the taxpayer mistakenly contributed an additional $19,000 to his RRSP following a pension buyout. It was this overcontribution that led the CRA to assess a penalty tax, which is equal to one per cent per month for each month the overcontribution (in excess of an allowable $2,000) remains in the RRSP.

The taxpayer testified it was only during a December 2020 phone call with a CRA representative that he learned of the CRA’s position that he had both made an accidental overcontribution in 2018 relating to his pension buyback, and that he still had a $13,142 excess contribution from 2013.

Following this call, the taxpayer realized this situation resulted from what he considered to be a bank error when it processed his spouse’s HBP repayment.

taxpayer takes cra to court after it dings him for rrsp overcontribution tax due to a bank error

A person looks at the Canada Revenue Agency website.

In July 2021, the taxpayer requested the CRA waive this tax. Under the Income Tax Act, the CRA has the discretion to cancel or waive the overcontribution tax when the excess contributions were made because of a reasonable error and the taxpayer took, or was taking, reasonable steps to remove the excess.

The CRA denied the taxpayer’s first request because he did not provide an amended RRSP receipt or a letter from his bank acknowledging the alleged error, and “it was the (taxpayer’s) responsibility to make sure that all contributions were made according to the rules and regulations.”

But the taxpayer was unable to get an amended receipt or bank letter because more than seven years had passed since the time of the HBP repayment, and he was told his bank no longer had records of the transaction.

In May 2022, the taxpayer submitted a second request to waive the tax. In response, the CRA acknowledged the taxpayer’s RRSP excess contributions were not intentional, but, nonetheless, “third-party errors do not normally justify the cancellation of a tax.”

In addition, the CRA claimed the taxpayer was informed of his excess RRSP contributions on his 2017 and 2018 Notices of Assessment (NOAs), and his bank would still have had the required records from 2013 had the taxpayer acted upon this information at that time.

As a result, the CRA again denied the taxpayer’s request for relief, concluding “there were no circumstances beyond the (taxpayer’s) control, such as a natural or human-made disaster, that would permit the cancellation of the penalty,” and it expressed “regret” that its decision “cannot be more favourable.”

The taxpayer appealed the CRA’s second decision to the Federal Court, which heard the case in Toronto on March 6. He argued there was no information in the 2017 and 2018 NOAs that could have alerted him to the CRA’s position that he had made an RRSP overcontribution of $13,142 back in 2013 relating to the HBP repayment.

The judge agreed, saying it was “unclear to me how the (CRA) could have concluded that, simply by alerting the (taxpayer) to the fact that he was in an overcontribution situation, the 2017 and 2018 NOAs were sufficient to put him on notice that CRA considered him to have made (an) overcontribution in 2013 such that he could pursue that subject with (his bank). I consider this reasoning to be lacking in logic and transparency.”

The taxpayer had hoped for a court order immediately cancelling the overcontribution tax, but the judge referred the matter back to the CRA to be reconsidered by a different decision-maker. The judge also rejected the taxpayer’s damages claim of $1 for “causing mental illness and stress during the time of the COVID-19 pandemic,” but did award him his out-of-pocket court disbursement costs.

Jamie Golombek, CPA, CA, CFP, CLU, TEP, is the managing director, Tax & Estate Planning with CIBC Private Wealth in Toronto. [email protected] .


If you liked this story, sign up for more in the FP Investor newsletter.


News Related


Penguins’ Evgeni Malkin Named a Top Draft Pick of All-Time

The NHL is getting ready to host their 60th entry draft and they decided to celebrate by ranking the top 60 draft picks of all-time; a list there are sure ... Read more »

The NBA Finals are set: It's the Heat and the Nuggets for the Larry O'Brien Trophy

The NBA Finals are set: It’s the Heat and the Nuggets for the Larry O’Brien Trophy Cancel that flight plan, Denver. Turns out, the NBA Finals are starting in the ... Read more »

Drury, Angels spoil Hendriks' return with 6-4 victory over White Sox

Drury, Angels spoil Hendriks’ return with 6-4 victory over White Sox CHICAGO (AP) — Brandon Drury and Matt Thaiss homered during a fast start for the Los Angeles Angels, who ... Read more »

Tim Tszyu injury: Carlos Ocampo fight to go ahead despite emergency surgery following dog bite

Tim Tszyu injury: Carlos Ocampo fight to go ahead despite emergency surgery following dog bite Tim Tszyu’s upcoming fight against Carlos Ocampo won’t be scrapped after the Aussie required emergency ... Read more »

Windsor city council endorses plan for civic esplanade project

Windsor council chambers are shown in a file photo. Plans for a sweeping redesign of the corridor from Windsor city hall to the Detroit River took a big step forward Monday ... Read more »

China launches mission with first civilian to space station

Long March-2F rocket, carrying the Shenzhou-16 Manned Space Flight Mission, lifts off from the Jiuquan Satellite Launch Centre in China’s northwestern Gansu province, on May 30 2023, heading to the ... Read more »

Capitals’ rough and rowdy prospect Ryan Hofer loves to get in your face

A view of the Washington Capitals logo worn by a member of the team. Ryan Hofer plays a rough and tough throwback style of hockey. He calls it “a little ... Read more »

Biden says he and Erdogan talked about F-16s, Sweden's NATO bid

FILE PHOTO: A Turkish Air Force F16 jet lands at a new airport under construction in Istanbul By Steve Holland and Humeyra Pamuk WASHINGTON (Reuters) -U.S. President Joe Biden said ... Read more »

Blazers defenceman Masters out of hospital, will miss remainder of Memorial Cup

Blazers defenceman Masters out of hospital, will miss remainder of Memorial Cup KAMLOOPS, B.C. — Kamloops Blazers head coach and general manager Shaun Clouston says defenceman Kyle Masters has been ... Read more »

Ten Hag says Maguire has ‘decision to make’ over Manchester United future

Photograph: Paul Ellis/AFP/Getty Images Erik ten Hag has indicated that Harry Maguire can depart Manchester United, with the manager saying it is a “decision he has to make”. United’s captain ... Read more »

Capitals Wrap: Coaching Search Heating Up, Trade Talk, Hershey's Run & Tom Wilson Tries Beekeeping

The Washington Capitals are in the midst of an extended offseason, one where they’re making their way down a lengthy to-do list while their AHL-affiliate Hershey Bears are inching closer ... Read more »

Ukraine air defences battle fresh wave of Russian attacks

Aftermath of a Russian drone attack in Kyiv By Pavel Polityuk and Max Hunder KYIV (Reuters) – Russia launched another wave of attacks on Kyiv in the early hours of ... Read more »

Why I’m Bullish on Canadian Bank Stocks Right Now

stock market Canadian bank stocks took a massive hit to the chin again last week, as the round of quarterly earnings results came flowing in. Though CIBC (TSX:CM) managed to ... Read more »

The Latest on the provincial election in Alberta

It’s election day in Alberta with Danielle Smith’s United Conservative Party fighting to win a second consecutive majority government, while Rachel Notley’s NDP is trying to regain the government it ... Read more »

Royce Lewis excels in Minnesota Twins win a year to the day he tore his ACL

A year ago to the day that he suffered a torn ACL, Royce Lewis was a key factor in the Minnesota Twins’ 7-5 win over the Houston Astros on Monday ... Read more »

Good as gold: Winnipeggers Glass, Hofer, on top of the hockey world

World hockey champions Joel Hofer (left) and Cody Glass display their medals at the Winnipeg airport on Monday, May 29, 2023. It’s a good thing Cody Glass packed his gold ... Read more »

YOU BE THE BOSS: The Annual Winnipeg Jets Survey

Jets goalie Connor Hellebuyck has .893 save percentage and 3.00 goals against average through two games of the playoffs. Welcome back, and sorry for the wait. It’s not that we ... Read more »

NATO soldiers injured in Kosovo clashes with Serb protesters

NATO Kosovo Force (KFOR) soldiers clash with local Kosovo Serb protesters in the town of Zvecan By Fatos Bytyci LEPOSAVIC, Kosovo (Reuters) – Around 25 NATO peacekeeping soldiers defending three ... Read more » CEO says US default would hit crypto initially

Illustration shows representations of cryptocurrencies By Andrew Mills DOHA (Reuters) – A U.S. government default would trigger an initial pull-back from crypto currencies followed by a “push upward” the CEO ... Read more »

The ‘Angel of Alkmaar’, landing haymakers for club, king and country

Photograph: DeFodi Images/Getty Images BUBBLES. LOTS OF BUBBLES In the wake of West Ham’s Tin Pot semi-final win over AZ last week, one man was honoured as a hero, the ... Read more »

Your pets produce just as much pollution as private jets, says luxury aviation company boss

A private jet interior. Marin Tomas/Getty Images Luxaviation’s CEO told a FT summit that one of his firm’s clients produced as much CO2 as three dogs per year. He was ... Read more »

YOU SAID IT: Our buffoon

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, French President Emmanuel Macron and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau take part in a working lunch session at the G7 Leaders’ Summit in Hiroshima, Japan, on ... Read more »

Dems Insisted They Wouldn’t Negotiate. Then Biden Started Negotiating.

Photo Illustration by Thomas Levinson/The Daily Beast/Getty/Reuters With just days to go until a catastrophic default on U.S. debt, Republicans are openly bragging that in exchange for accepting massive spending ... Read more »

Australia's Treasury Wine warns of demand hit from inflation

Bottles of Penfolds Grange on sale at a wine shop in Sydney By Navya Mittal and Echha Jain (Reuters) -Australia’s Treasury Wine Estates warned on Thursday that inflation was squeezing ... Read more »

A quarter of Canadians plan to buy investment property in next five years: Royal LePage survey

Royal LePage said a new study uncovered a strong desire among Canadians to purchase a home for investment purposes. Approximately 11 per cent of Canadians currently invest in residential real ... Read more »

Vietnam's VinFast recalls first batch of US-bound EVs over security risk

2022 Paris Auto Show HANOI (Reuters) -Vietnamese electric vehicle (EV) maker VinFast is recalling all of the first batch of vehicles it shipped to the United States following a security ... Read more »

Nicole Kidman Uses This Brightening Concealer for Flawless, Radiant Skin at 55

Nicole Kidman showed off her glowing, radiant skin on the 2023 Met Gala red carpet. The star’s makeup artist revealed that she used Chanel’s Le Correcteur de Chanel Longwear Concealer ... Read more »

As governments shirk their responsibilities, non-profits are more important than ever

In a neoliberal era, where profitability is prioritized over social duty, all orders of government in Canada are increasingly shirking responsibility for providing social services onto non-profits. You’ve likely walked ... Read more »

Biden set to nominate Air Force Gen. C.Q. Brown as the next chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff

President Joe Biden is set to announce on Thursday that he will nominate Air Force chief of staff Gen. Charles Q. Brown as the next chairman of the Joint Chiefs ... Read more »

British EV maker Arrival seeks second chance with US EV tax credits

Jules Carter, vice president of the L-Van program at electric van maker Arrival, walks next to a working prototype vehicle at the company’s factory in Bicester By Paul Lienert and ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự