‘Survival at any cost’: Myanmar generals move to cement power

Bangkok/ Yangon – Failing to subdue resistance across Myanmar, military government chief Min Aung Hlaing is resorting to increasingly desperate measures to cling to power, firing senior ministers and military officers, and purging business cronies.

The heads of the navy and air force are among those who have lost their positions, as Min Aung Hlaing has sought to consolidate his position amid continued armed resistance to his rule — including with ethnic armed groups along the borders — a rebellious population in the heartland, and economic crisis.

After plunging by nearly 20 percent in the year after the February 1, 2021 coup, the World Bank has forecast growth of 3 percent this year for Myanmar’s economy and warned of “substantial risks”.

“When it starts dismissing its own team and established business cronies it does suggest its position is highly fragile and its leadership rather insecure,” a Western diplomat in Yangon told Al Jazeera. “Its top priority is its survival at any cost and given its disastrous economic interventions it would appear Myanmar and its people are that cost.”

On July 25, the regime executed four activists in a move that triggered outrage around the world.

Laetitia van den Assum, former Dutch ambassador to Myanmar, says the executions demonstrated that the military government was rejecting any dialogue about the future of Myanmar unless on its own terms.

“Even though its attempted coup failed long ago, it mistakenly believes that executing four political prisoners will help it to establish control. Instead, it is strengthening the resolve of the broad-based resistance movement.”

‘survival at any cost’: myanmar generals move to cement power

General Maung Maung Kyaw (centre) was removed as head of the air force in January. Analysts say his departure was probably part of an attempt by armed forces chief Min Aung Hlaing to consolidate his power [File: Lynn Bo Bo/AFP]

Policy analyst Matthew Arnold sees Min Aung Hlaing sending the message that he is ready to resort to more violence.

“Regardless of structures, protocols, constitutions, Min Aung Hlaing is simply consolidating power with loyalists. There doesn’t need to be any coherence to the overall structure as long as it secures, in his own head, his position as senior general,” he said.

“The executions were both meant to scare the public but also for Min Aung Hlaing to demonstrate to his own people, especially hardliners in the wider security sector complex, his resolve and willingness to use such violence.”

Centralised power

The extreme violence, policy failures and chaos unleashed by the military have left not just protesters but also observers and more conservative businesspeople shocked and despondent. Apart from the strong anti-coup opposition, experts point to the structure within the regime that undermines sound decision-making and centralises too much power on a few generals even compared with previous periods of military rule.

Governance has been split between three entities: the State Administration Council, the regime’s top ruling body, senior military officials and the cabinet. While there is some overlap between the different groups, it is Min Aung Hlaing who is increasingly dominant, according to analysts.

The armed forces chief and coup leader has named new military officers since the coup, and only four SAC members still hold their military posts in the 19-member council.

“None of the younger officers who now hold senior posts in the Tatmadaw are members of the SAC,” noted analyst Htet Myet Min Tun in a January analysis, referring to the military by its name in Myanmar.

Since the coup, navy chief Admiral Tin Aung San, air force chief General Maung Maung Kyaw, judge advocate general Lt General Aung Lin Dwe and Commander of Joint Chief of Staff General Mya Tun Oo have been stripped of their military positions.

‘survival at any cost’: myanmar generals move to cement power

The military faces sustained resistance to its rule despite a brutal crackdown in which nearly 2,200 people have been killed and thousands arrested. After the regime executed four political prisoners in July, some took to the streets of Yangon [Lu Nge Khit/via Reuters]

Even though the stated reason is retirement or the end of their assignments, “the real story may be more complex,” Htet, who hails from Myanmar, wrote. “These moves can be seen as Min Aung Hlaing attempting to consolidate his Tatmadaw power base even more.”

To complicate matters, only six SAC members are also members of the cabinet, including Min Aung Hlaing and Soe Win, the only two who have positions in all three entities. The SAC “has gradually turned into a shell entity with power becoming more concentrated in the hands of Senior General Min Aung Hlaing,” Htet observed.

“The appointments of Union ministers replacing the deposed National League for Democracy-appointed ministers actually pre-dated the formation of the SAC. So, from the outset, it seemed that the military intended to keep the SAC separate from the cabinet,” said Moe Thuzar, a research fellow at Singapore-based think-tank ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute.

The August 2021 formation of a ‘caretaker government’ also seems to point to the intention of the SAC to differentiate its ‘governing’ role from the cabinet’s job of ‘implementation’, she added. The head of this “caretaker” government, the chair of SAC and commander-in-chief are all the same person, Min Aung Hlaing. Likewise, Soe Win is deputy PM, SAC vice chair and deputy commander-in-chief.

In May, the regime fired the electricity and energy minister, Aung Than Oo, and replaced him with Thaung Han, a former military officer. The ministry was also separated into two – one to cover electric power and the other focused on energy, a decision the military said would improve implementation.

Guillaume de Langre, a former adviser to the ministry, branded the reshuffle as “part of the recent ‘bunkerisation’ of the junta”.

“They have effectively replaced a ‘ministry man’ with a military man, reflecting the low confidence that the junta has in the bureaucracy, exacerbated since the civil disobedience movement. It is also the replacement of a Thein Sein [Former army chief who was president from 2011 to 2016] technocrat by a Min Aung Hlaing loyalist,” he told Al Jazeera.

Myanmar’s energy crisis is mostly the result of the country’s political and economic crisis, triggered by the generals themselves, he adds.

“A change of minister has little effect on the fact that power lines and power plants are now battle targets, bill collectors and repair crews are being killed, the ministry is incurring record losses, key foreign partners have left and they’re struggling to meet 60 percent of demand half of the year,” de Langre warned.

Aung Than Oo is just the latest senior official to be booted out.

Earlier dismissals include the Yangon region’s chief minister, Hla Soe, and economic minister Aung Than Oo (who has the same name as the fired electricity and energy minister but is unrelated), who were charged under the anti-corruption law. Yangon’s mayor, Bo Htay, was also detained and questioned, adding to speculation of a dispute between the old guard from previous military eras and the current ruling generals.

The former Yangon economic minister was detained for granting land to retired Joint Chief of Staff General Hla Htay Win’s family. According to a well-connected businessman in Yangon, his arrest is the result of a rivalry between Myanmar Economic Corporation Chairman Lt General Nyo Saw’s group, and cronies close to former General Hla Htay Win, who became a member of parliament for the pro-military party after retirement.

Tycoons targeted

The sackings have been accompanied by a crackdown on business grandees.

Chit Khine of the construction to resources conglomerate Eden Group as well as Khin Shwe of communications and construction company Zaykabar and his son Zay Thiha were arrested and detained earlier this year. Chit Khine was charged with corruption and accused of tax evasion for his coal mining business.

“They [the generals] aren’t happy that people who they thought were their friends are staying away from them. If rightly or wrongly they suspect them of supporting the opposition, they will use opportunities to nail them if there are corruption cases, particularly if that corruption case can also implicate NLD people,” said a source close to some of Myanmar’s tycoons who declined to be named for fear of reprisals.

“Chit Khine is a classic example of that, dobbed in by reliable crony Nay Win Tun with whom he has had years of crony-wrangling,” the source added, referring to the gemstone and real estate magnate.

Min Aung Hlaing probably targets those who could become a threat preemptively, as well as making an example of anyone who commits the slightest transgressions, according to Myanmar politics researcher Kim Jolliffe. “The general’s entire gambit from day one has been to demonstrate his willingness to go one step further than anyone else with threats and coercion. It is ‘rule by fear’.”

Historically, Myanmar’s military rulers have been notorious for purging any potential opponents or opposition within their own ranks.

‘survival at any cost’: myanmar generals move to cement power

Myanmar has a long history of military rule, but analysts say previous military leaders such as Than Shwe were more politically savvy than Min Aung Hlaing [File: Adrees Latif/Reuters]

Military strongman Than Shwe, who ran Myanmar for nearly two decades from 1992 to 2011, purged the military intelligence chief and his prime minister Khin Nyunt as well as several intelligence officers in 2004. Than Shwe himself rose to power after a ‘palace coup’ in 1992, removing his predecessor General Saw Maung, who also took over after toppling General Ne Win in September 1988.

The primary difference this time around is political savvy, said Khin Zaw Win, director of the Yangon-based Tampadipa Institute.

“All the Bamar (Myanmar’s ethnic majority group) generals share the caudillist mindset but the earlier cohort understood the political landscape much better,” he told Al Jazeera.

Min Aung Hlaing is a graduate of Mandalay’s Defence Service Academy, an officer training institute set up more than 60 years ago.

“The present problems stem not only from the military but particularly the Defence Service Academy [DSA]. Min Aung Hlaing is the first chief of staff from the DSA, and DSA graduates think of themselves as a breed apart. But this ‘apartness’ moulded a worldview that is removed from the Myanmar people,” Khin added.

“The 2021 coup and its bloody aftermath can be seen as a direct consequence of this disparity and divergence.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

The Conners Fans Finally Learned What Happened To This Iconic Roseanne Prop

Kathy Hutchins/Shutterstock This article contains spoilers for “The Conners” Season 5, Episode 2. Season 5 of “The Conners” has been all about change. While Jackie Harris (Laurie Metcalf) and Darlene ... Read more »

How to Help the Red Cross With Hurricane Ian Relief Efforts

NBCUniversal Media, LLC Hurricane Ian made landfall in Florida as one of the most powerful storms in decades, leaving residents without electricity, submerging streets and sweeping homes off their foundations. Many residents ... Read more »

Landlord Arrested After Allegedly Threatening Tenant in Video

A video of a Denton landlord reportedly threatening a tenant with a gun went viral earlier this month. Now, that landlord is under arrest. It happened in the 2000 block ... Read more »

Mike Lupica: Aaron Judge evokes memory of Babe Ruth as he finally catches Roger Maris with homer No. 61

So now all the home run magic that had begun over 100 years ago with Babe Ruth, that had once run through the magical home run summer of 1961 with ... Read more »

Auburn already told football coach Bryan Harsin he’s done: AJ McCarron

Bryan Harsin is dealing with yet another rumor of his demise. Appearing on the “Slow News Day” podcast with Kevin Clark, former Alabama quarterback AJ McCarron shared a juicy tidbit ... Read more »

Can You Trust Your Online Search Results? Users Out Big Cash, Falling for ‘Misrepresenting' Ads

They thought they were speaking with their airline, but it turned out to be a travel agency that charged them hundreds of dollars extra. And it all started with a simple web search. Read more »

10 Observations: Blackhawks Beat Red Wings for First Win of Preseason

10 observations: Hawks beat Wings for first win of preseason originally appeared on NBC Sports Chicago The Blackhawks knocked off the Detroit Red Wings 4-2 at Little Caesars Arena on ... Read more »

Vancouver mayoral candidates face off with just over 2 weeks until election day

For the third time in a week, Vancouver’s top mayoral candidates found themselves face to face as the fight heats up for the top job in city politics. The all-candidates ... Read more »

Video shows Hurricane Ian obliterate an entire section of Fort Myers

Stunning footage from Hurricane Ian’s assault on Florida showed the storm pummeling homes in Fort Myers Wednesday with raging winds and unrelenting sheets of rain. An apocalyptic clip posted to ... Read more »

300K barrels of diesel arriving to help power Puerto Rico after Fiona, Biden admin says

300K barrels of diesel arriving to help power Puerto Rico after Fiona, Biden admin says The Department of Homeland Security waived a 1920 law to allow a ship to dock. ... Read more »

Highland Park shooting victims file lawsuits against gun-maker over advertising practices

Highland Park shooting victims file lawsuits against gun-maker over advertising practices One victim's attorney told ABC News about 10 lawsuits will be filed. Victims of the July 4 shooting in ... Read more »

Actors In Jim Carrey Movies You May Not Know Are Dead

Kevin Winter/Getty Images Jim Carrey is one of the most well-known faces in the world of comedy. After breaking through into show business in 1990 as part of the sketch ... Read more »

Singapore's HeadsUp secures $8.5M seed fund led by 645 Ventures

HeadsUp, the Singapore-based conversion engine for product led sales, announced Wednesday that it has closed $8.5 million in seed funding from top software as a service (SaaS) venture capitals, as ... Read more »

Blue Jays fans just miss catching Aaron Judge’s 61st home run

Aaron Judge will be getting his No. 61 home run ball back.Judge tied Roger Maris’ Yankees and American league record on Wednesday, sending a go-ahead two-run homer in the seventh ... Read more »

Police uncertain if girl killed in shootout was abducted

Police uncertain if girl killed in shootout was abducted Authorities say the Southern California man who was accused of killing his estranged wife and abducting their 15-year-old daughter had been ... Read more »

Coolio, Legendary Rapper of ‘Gangsta's Paradise' Fame, Dies at 59

NBCUniversal Media, LLC Coolio, the rapper who was among hip-hop’s biggest names of the 1990s with hits including “Gangsta’s Paradise” and “Fantastic Voyage,” died Wednesday at age 59, his manager ... Read more »

Ken Paxton’s office knew he’d be subpoenaed before he fled his home to avoid being served, emails show

Lawyers for the state argue they didn’t know the attorney general would be served at home. Emails from opposing counsel show they tried repeatedly to serve him through his attorneys. Read more »

California’s outgoing chief justice is named new CEO of public policy think tank

When California Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye announced this summer that she would not be seeking another term on the bench, she said she didn’t plan on retiring completely. “My husband ... Read more »

Coolio, rapper best known for hit ‘Gangsta’s Paradise,’ dead at 59

Coolio, the rapper who was among hip-hop’s biggest names of the 1990s with hits including “Gangsta’s Paradise” and “Fantastic Voyage,” died Wednesday at age 59, his manager said. Coolio, whose ... Read more »

El BMW ‘M’ eléctrico está listo para las pistas mundiales

El mundo del automovilismo ha sido una parte intrínseca de la industria automotriz. Y desde 1923 hay una carrera en Francia que todos los fabricantes de automóviles importantes han intentado ... Read more »

‘Telling our own story’: Gondek talks city’s perception and attracting investment to Calgary

Mayor Jyoti Gondek told an audience of the city’s business community that Calgary needs to be “telling our own story,” to help change perceptions of investors elsewhere. Gondek gave a ... Read more »

Calgary police investigations into 2022 shootings reveal reasons, origins of gun crime

The day after the 106th shooting incident in the city, Calgary police told the Calgary Police Commission that gun crime continues to be addressed through investigations. “We know that we’re ... Read more »

How a B.C. business owner lost over $12,000 despite having bank check authenticity of bank draft

A B.C. business owner is warning others after he received a fraudulent bank draft and lost thousands of dollars in merchandise despite having the issuing bank check the draft’s authenticity. ... Read more »

The rapper Coolio has died at 59

Coolio, the rapper who was among hip-hop’s biggest names of the 1990s with hits including “Gangsta’s Paradise” and “Fantastic Voyage,” died Wednesday, Sept. 28, at age 59, his manager said. ... Read more »

The Devastating Death Of Coolio

Featureflash Photo Agency/Shutterstock As revealed by TMZ on September 28, 2022, famous rapper Coolio — real name Artis Leon Ivey Jr. — has died at the age of 59. According ... Read more »

2 Charged in Collin County Home Invasion

NBC Connecticut Two men are in custody Wednesday, accused of breaking into a Collin County home, tying the hands of the elderly woman who lived there and stealing her belongings, ... Read more »

Rapper Coolio, known for Grammy-winning song ‘Gangsta’s Paradise,’ dead at 59

Coolio, the Grammy-winning rapper best known for the 1995 single “Gangsta’s Paradise,” has died, his longtime manager confirmed Wednesday to The Times. He was 59. The musician was found unresponsive ... Read more »

Two of Hong Kong's Largest IPOs for 2022 Plunge in Trading Debut

Shares of Onewo dropped from its offer price of 49.35 Hong Kong dollars ($6.29) per share in early trade, while Leapmotor’s stock also fell compared to its offer price of ... Read more »

Couple Robbed at Gunpoint While Walking in Lincoln Park: Police

Couple targeted while walking down Fullerton Avenue Read more »

Man left with broken bones after trying to prevent NYC subway train assault

A straphanger who stepped in when he saw a person being assaulted on a Manhattan train had his jaw, cheek and nose broken, police said Wednesday. The 25-year-old man spotted ... Read more »

Aaron Judge’s mom, Patty, hugs Roger Maris’ son after Yankee star hits 61st home run

Aaron Judge’s biggest fan had a front-row seat to her son’s historic night. As Judge tied Roger Maris’ home run record at 61 on Wednesday night against the Blue Jays, ... Read more »

Listen to Michael Kay and John Sterling call Aaron Judge’s 61st home run

It is high, it is far, it has finally happened! Aaron Judge, who was stuck on 60 home runs for the past seven games, hit his 61st home run on ... Read more »

Coolio, rapper who won Grammy for hit 'Gangsta's Paradise,' dies at 59, manager says

Coolio, rapper who won Grammy for hit 'Gangsta's Paradise,' dies at 59, manager says Coolio, rapper who won Grammy for hit 'Gangsta's Paradise,' dies at 59, manager says LOS ANGELES ... Read more »

Arizona museum exhibit marks end to de Kooning painting saga

Arizona museum exhibit marks end to de Kooning painting saga After a Willem de Kooning painting worth millions was brazenly stolen in 1985 from an Arizona museum, the staff clung ... Read more »

Review: 'Smile' turns twisted grin into bland horror flick

Review: 'Smile' turns twisted grin into bland horror flick Parker Finn’s directorial debut, “Smile,” adapts his own 11-minute short into a jump scare-rich thriller about a hospital emergency ward therapist ... Read more »

Daniel And Louis' Tense Relationship On Interview With The Vampire Explained

Alfonso Bresciani/AMC Fans of Anne Rice’s horror series The Vampire Chronicles have already gotten some very good news about the new AMC show based on the first book. Not only ... Read more »

Yankees star Aaron Judge hits 61st home run, ties Roger Maris’ AL record

TORONTO —  Aaron Judge tied Roger Maris’ American League record of 61 home runs in a season, going deep for the New York Yankees against the Toronto Blue Jays on Wednesday ... Read more »

Knott’s Scary Farm to offer free ticket for adults chaperoning groups of minors

Knott’s Berry Farm, which banned unaccompanied minors following a series of fights involving teenagers over the summer, announced Wednesday that adults accompanying groups of minors to its Halloween after-hours event ... Read more »

Aaron Judge Hits 61st Home Run to Tie Roger Maris' Record

The record-tying shot landed in the Blue Jays' bullpen Read more »

Aaron Judge hits 61st home run of season, ties Roger Maris’ AL and Yankees single-season record

TORONTO — After seven games and eight days without a home run, Aaron Judge made history Wednesday. The Yankees slugger hammered his 61st home run of the season off Blue Jays’ ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network