Surprised by census results, many in Puerto Rico reconsider views on race

Asia's Tech News Daily

“Puerto Ricans themselves are understanding their whiteness comes with an asterisk,” an expert said. “They know they’re not white by U.S. standards, but they’re not Black by Puerto Rico standards.”

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico — The number of people in Puerto Rico who identified as “white” in the most recent census plummeted almost 80 percent, sparking a conversation about identity on an island breaking away from a past where race was not tracked and seldom debated in public.

The drastic drop surprised many, and theories abound as the U.S. territory’s 3.3 million people begin to reckon with racial identity.

“Puerto Ricans themselves are understanding their whiteness comes with an asterisk,” said Yarimar Bonilla, a political anthropologist and director of the Center for Puerto Rican Studies at Hunter College in New York. “They know they’re not white by U.S. standards, but they’re not Black by Puerto Rico standards.”

Nearly 50 percent of those represented in the 2020 census — 1.6 million of 3.29 million — identified with “two races or more,” a jump from 3 percent — or some 122,200 of 3.72 million — who chose that option in the 2010 census. Most of them selected “white and some other race.”

Meanwhile, more than 838,000 people identified as “some other race alone,” a nearly 190 percent jump compared with some 289,900 people a decade ago, although Bonilla said Census Bureau officials have yet to release what races they chose. Experts believe people likely wrote “Puerto Rican,” “Hispanic” or “Latino,” even though federal policy defines those categories as ethnicity, not race.

Among those who changed their response to race was 45-year-old Tamara Texidor, who selected “other” in 2010 and this time opted to identify herself as “Afrodescendent.” She said she made the decision after talking to her brother, who was a census worker and told her how people he encountered when he went house to house often had trouble with the question about race.

Lawmakers seek answers from Luma Energy over worsening Puerto Rico power crisis

Oct. 14, 202103:10

Texidor began reflecting about her ancestry and wanted to honor it since she descended from slaves on her father’s side.

“I’m not going to select ‘other,’” she recalled thinking when filling out the census. “I feel I am something.”

Experts are still debating what sparked the significant changes in the 2020 census. Some believe several factors are at play, including tweaks in wording and a change in how the Census Bureau processes and codes responses.

Bonilla also thinks a growing awareness of racial identity in Puerto Rico played a part, saying that “extra intense racialization” in the past decade might have contributed. She and other anthropologists argue that change stemmed from anger over what many consider a botched federal response to a U.S. territory struggling to recover from Hurricane Maria and a crippling economic crisis.

“They’ve finally understood that they’re treated like second-class citizens,” Bárbara Abadía-Rexach, a sociocultural anthropologist, said of Puerto Ricans.

Another critical change in the 2020 census was that only a little over 228,700 identified solely as Black or African American, a nearly 50 percent drop compared with more than 461,000 who did so a decade ago. The decline occurred even as grass-roots organizations in Puerto Rico launched campaigns to urge people to embrace their African heritage and raised awareness about racial disparities, although they said they were encouraged by the increase in the “two or more races” category.

Puerto Rico raises minimum wage for the first time in 12 years

Sept. 23, 202103:14

Bonilla noted Puerto Rico currently has no reliable data to determine whether such disparities have occurred during the pandemic, noting that there is no racial data on coronavirus testing, hospitalizations or fatalities.

The island’s government also does not collect racial data on populations, including those who are homeless or incarcerated, Abadía-Rexach added.

“The denial of the existence of racism renders invisible, criminalizes and dehumanizes many Black people in Puerto Rico,” she said.

The lack of such data could be rooted in Puerto Rico’s history. From 1960 to 2000, the island conducted its own census and never asked about race.

“We were supposed to be all mixed and all equal, and race was supposed to be an American thing,” Bonilla said.

Some argued at the time that Puerto Rico should be tracking racial data while others viewed it as a divisive move that would impose or harden racial differences, a view largely embraced in France, which does not collect official data on race or ethnicity.

For Isar Godreau, an anthropologist and professor at the University of Puerto Rico, that type of data is crucial.

“Skin color is an important marker that makes people vulnerable to more or less racial discrimination,” she said.

How Puerto Rico is still recovering four years after Hurricane Maria

Sept. 20, 202104:09

The data helps people fight for racial justice and determines the allocation of resources, Godreau said.

The major shift in the 2020 census — especially how only 560,592 people identified as white versus more than 2.8 million in 2010 — comes amid a growing interest in racial identity in Puerto Rico, where even recent surveys about race prompted responses ranging from “members of the human race” to “normal” to “I get along with everyone.” Informally, people on the island use a wide range of words to describe someone’s skin color, including “coffee with milk.”

That interest is fueled largely by a younger generation: They have signed up for classes of bomba and plena — centuries-old, percussion-powered musical traditions — as well as workshops on how to make or wear headwraps.

More hair salons are specializing in curly hair, eschewing the blow-dried results that long dominated professional settings in the island. Some legislators have submitted a bill that cites the results of the 2020 census and that if approved would make it illegal to discriminate against someone based on their hair style. Several U.S. states already have similar laws.

As debate continues on what sparked so many changes in the 2020 census, Bonilla said an important question is what the 2030 census results will look like. “Will we see an intensification of this pattern, or will 2020 have been kind of a blip moment?”

Follow NBC Latino on FacebookTwitter and Instagram.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Teaching union calls for enhanced Covid measures

© BBC Unions want some restrictions reintroduced in schools to tackle the spread of Covid A teachers’ union has called on the government to “urgently” reintroduce Covid measures in Jersey ... Read more »

'Gaydar' or 'wishdar'? The danger in obsessing over Shawn Mendes' sexuality

Mendes’ breakup with Camila Cabello has the rumor mill turning about his sexuality once again. But could this public speculation have an unexpected cost? Read more »

Man City tipped to pursue Karim Benzema in the summer

Manchester City are believed to be eyeing a summer approach for veteran Real Madrid striker Karim Benzema as part of their hunt for a ‘number nine’. © Provided by 90min ... Read more »

How a writer found himself in a missing person story

While working on a book about missing persons, Francisco Garcia received a message that turned his life upside down. Here he reflects on love, loss and the enduring promise of ... Read more »

Xavi makes bizarre comment about Villarreal's pitch

Barcelona coach Xavi made a bizarre comment about Villarreal’s pitch at the Madrigal ahead of Saturday evening’s clash in La Liga, suggesting his players must adapt because of its size. ... Read more »

Thiago Silva close to agreeing Chelsea contract extension

Evergreen Chelsea centre-back Thiago Silva is close to agreeing a contract extension with the club – a reward for his continued age-defying form. © Provided by 90min Chelsea are working ... Read more »

Storyboard18 | Wait, how did we get here? Musings of an adman

(Representative image) Brand-building is not about aping what’s working for another brand. Back in 2015, when I joined the advertising space – there was a phrase that was doing the ... Read more »

The market's Black Friday freakout about the new variant shows how a reactionary Wall Street rules American life and politics

© Stan Honda/AFP/Getty Images Stan Honda/AFP/Getty Images Stocks plummeted on Friday as investors braced for the Omicron variant fueling a new round of lockdowns. In one day, the market challenged ... Read more »

Journalist drops two-word Spurs transfer message involving ‘amazing' striker likened to Suarez

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Copa Libertadores – Group D – River Plate v Santa Fe Taking to Twitter in reply to a Tottenham supporter, Sportitalia TV’s transfer ‘insider’ Gianluigi ... Read more »

Mass shooting leaves 3 dead, 4 injured in Nashville apartment

The incident comes after Black Friday saw shootings in malls in Tennessee and North Carolina. Read more »

Music therapy for better sleep and stress relief … in a Canto-pop song? Jocelyn Chan explains her use of tuning forks in Sound of Silence and the theory behind it

Do tuning forks have any place in a pop song? Yes, says Hong Kong singer-songwriter Jocelyn Chan Ming-hei – her song Sound of Silence, which recently topped city public broadcaster ... Read more »

TVs don't belong above the fireplace

© Provided by CNET Putting your TV over a fireplace is a big no-no. John Fedele/Getty Images © Provided by CNET Brett Pearce/CNET Mounting a TV above a fireplace seems ... Read more »

204-MPH Mercedes-AMG CLS 63 With 732 HP Is For Wagon Enthusiasts

© 204-MPH Mercedes-AMG CLS 63 With 732 HP Is For Wagon Enthusiasts Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and ... Read more »

Latest Mansory Venatus Lamborghini Urus Build Can Hurt Your Eyes

Yellow Mansory Venatus – Lamborghini Urus Yellow Mansory Venatus – Lamborghini Urus Yellow Mansory Venatus – Lamborghini Urus Yellow Mansory Venatus – Lamborghini Urus Yellow Mansory Venatus – Lamborghini Urus ... Read more »

Das plant die schwangere Sarah Engels

© imago images/Future Image Sarah Engels wird bald Mutter einer Tochter. Sarah Engels wird in Kürze wieder Mutter. Zusammen mit Ehemann Julian hat sie schon das Weihnachtsfest zu viert geplant. ... Read more »

Muere el compositor Stephen Sondheim a los 91 años, considerado una de las mayores leyendas de Broadway

© Proporcionado por Mundo Hispánico Muere el compositor Stephen Sondheim a los 91 años, considerado una de las mayores leyendas de Broadway Muere el compositor Stephen Sondheim a los 91 ... Read more »

West Brom boss frustrated at goal drought but indicates some positives

© PA Images West Bromwich Albion manager Valerien Ismael during the Sky Bet Championship match at The Hawthorns West Brom boss Valerien Ismael has admitted his side need to end ... Read more »

Homophobic gang attack gay couple with hammer in terrifying street robbery: ‘I'm lost for words'

A gay couple say they were “violently attacked” while walking down the street in Radcliffe, Bury, on Tuesday. Ryan Winnard, 21, was walking with his boyfriend Max Green, 18, on ... Read more »

Nem találtak megfelelőt; megírták – hiánypótló könyvvel segítik a kamaszokat az önismeret útján

A felnőtteknek szóló önfejlesztő könyveknek se szeri, se száma, viszont a tinédzserek nem kapnak a hétköznapokban is hasznosítható segítséget. Egy nemzetközileg elismert coach – a civil életben ötgyermekes családanya – ... Read more »

Conspiracy theorists are pushing toxic bleach and other harmful treatments they claim can 'de-vaccinate' people

A protest in London against plans to encourage vaccination on November 20, 2021.Wiktor Szymanowicz/Barcroft Media via Getty Images In Facebook groups and Telegram channels, “de-vaccination” misinformation is spreading. De-vaccination is ... Read more »

One seriously injured in shooting at mall in Washington state

Authorities said Tacoma Mall was shut down following the gunfire. Read more »

The CEO of cosmetics retailer Lush says he's 'happy to lose' $13 million by deleting Facebook, TikTok, Snapchat accounts over teen mental-health harms

Lush is making waves for shutting down its Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat accounts in the wake of the Facebook whistleblower revelations.Sergei Fadeichev/Getty Images UK cosmetics company Lush shut down ... Read more »

Gogglebox cast react to Boris Johnson's 'toe curling' Peppa Pig CBI speech

The cast of Gogglebox were left open mouthed and horrified as they watched Prime Minister Boris Johnson deliver his now infamous speech to the Confederation of British Industry on Tuesday ... Read more »

Person with knife fatally shot at entrance to California Marine Corps base

The incident is under investigation by the Naval Criminal Investigative Service. Read more »

El auge del e-commerce podría convertirse en el escenario de pesadilla para FedEx

© Unsplash. FedEx se tambalea en sus entregas debido al auge del e-commerce. Casi dos años después de la pandemia, FedEx parece estar en un nivel alto. Al final del ... Read more »

Steph Curry-Michael Jordan question shut down by Steve Kerr hilariously

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.Update your settings here to see it. Kerr hilariously shuts down Steph-MJ question from fan originally appeared on NBC Sports Bayarea ... Read more »

Stephen Sondheim, legendary composer and lyricist behind ‘Sweeney Todd' and other Broadway hits, dies at 91

Sondheim was considered American theater’s greatest composer and lyricist of the last half century or more. Read more »

Three wounded in shooting at mall in Durham, N.C.

Black Friday shoppers were escorted out of the mall as authorities responded to reports of shots fired. Read more »

Hati-hati Main Add Yours Challenge di Instagram, Bisa Curi Data Pribadi

© Arga sumantri Add Yours Challenge di Instagram berpotensi memunculkan tindakan pencurian data pribadi. Yogyakarta: Fitur stiker Add Yours di Instagram saat ini tengah menjadi tren di kalangan penggunanya. Melalui ... Read more »

Twitter reaction to my Deep State piece shows Dems are docile to Big Government

Getty Images Twitter is the gold standard for cutting-edge political commentary, at least according to Twitter aficionados. Roughly 20 percent of American adults use Twitter, though the large majority of ... Read more »

The Best Black Friday Deals of 2021 Have Begun! Save Big on Gadgets, Clothing, TVs & Appliances

© Courtesy of SPY Table of Contents Best Black Friday Deals On Our Radar Amazon Black Friday Deals Gap Black Friday Deals Walmart Black Friday Deals Walmart Black Friday Tech ... Read more »

Searching Mothers of Sonora find 16 clandestine graves near Sonoran capital of Hermosillo

The Searching Mothers of Sonora found more than 20 bodies in clandestine graves in a town east of Hermosillo, Mexico, this week. The group announced the finding Wednesday on Twitter. ... Read more »

West Brom boss frustrates at goal drought but indicates positives

© PA Images West Bromwich Albion manager Valerien Ismael during the Sky Bet Championship match at The Hawthorns West Brom boss Valerien Ismael has admitted his side need to end ... Read more »

Wajah Anak Kedua Raffi Ahmad dan Nagita Slavina Disebut Mirip Rafathar

© istimewa Raffi Ahmad Posting Foto Gendong Anak Kedua. Rieta Amilia mengungkap jika wajah anak kedua Raffi Ahmad dan Nagita Slavina mirip Rafathar. TRIBUNNEWS.COM – Kehadiran anak kedua Raffi Ahmad ... Read more »

All the Best Black Friday Deals Under $50 to Shop Today: Tech, Home Goods, Kitchen Appliances and More

© Courtesy of amazon The best part about Black Friday? Feeling like you’ve scored an amazing deal on the perfect treat for yourself, gift for a family member, or high-ticket ... Read more »

Morpheus Absolutely Looks Cooler Than Ever In Last Matrix Resurrections Image

© Provided by CinemaBlend Yahya Abdul Mateen II as Morpheus in The Matrix Resurrections Matrix Resurrections is one of the most anticipated movies of the year, and its fantastic trailer ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic