Sunak's budget responds to changing economy - but has he fumbled the climate crisis?

Asia's Tech News Daily

The budget strikes at a deeper question about the Tory party: do they stand for fiscal prudence, or for investing loads of money in some of the country’s more economically disadvantaged areas?


This was quite a complex budget – more so than usual.

On top of the usual barrage of figures at these fiscal events, there were two other things complicating matters: that this is also a Spending Review, where the government determines how much its departments will be able to budget in coming years, and that many of these decisions were not taken today, but last month.

But when you strip away the complexity and dig into the numbers themselves, what emerges is actually quite a simple story.

With that in mind, here are five things you need to know about today’s big fiscal event.

The situation has changed

The first is that the economy of October 2021 looks very different to the economy of March 2021, the last time the Office for Budget Responsibility updated its numbers.

Gross Domestic Product, otherwise known as national income – the most comprehensive measure of how well we’re doing – is higher than predicted back in March, and looks likely to return to pre-COVID levels sooner than expected.

More national income means more money in our collective pockets which also means more tax revenues going from our pockets into the Treasury’s.

At the same time inflation, which last March looked somewhat tame, is very much back, heading up to 4% by next year, at least according to the OBR’s projections. In fact, the OBR added in a footnote that it suspects this is an undershoot and the consumer price index will actually peak closer to 5%.

This is a big deal, not just for our standards of living but also for the chancellor: it both means he has to pay slightly more in debt interest but, by the same token, it also nets him more tax revenues (things cost more which means more VAT receipts).

Rishi’s big payday

Anyway, this brings us to the second thing you need to know: the impact of all these economic revisions has a big – a very big – impact on the public finances.

Take a single year, 2022/23, as our example. In that year alone, the OBR reckons the improved, but also more inflationary, economy will result in a whopping £51.8bn more in tax receipts.

That is enormous. Now, some of that windfall is eaten up by higher spending on welfare and debt interest, to the tune of £12.4bn.

But even when you subtract that amount, we’re still talking about a monumental windfall. That year alone the chancellor can expect roughly £39bn more coming into the Exchequer than was anticipated back in March.

In fact, when you add up the combined windfall from these forecast changes between this fiscal year and 2026/27, the final one in the forecast horizon, you get a whopping total of £225bn.

Or, if you’re looking solely at the period between next fiscal year and the next election, about £100bn. It’s a lot of money.

Pocket the profit

That brings us to the third thing you need to know about this budget.

The chancellor has chosen to pocket more than half of this windfall, using it to reduce his borrowing. This is actually highly significant.

He could, had he chosen to do so, have spent nearly all of the windfall. Doing so would have threatened his newly announced fiscal rules, but not, frankly, by all that much.

And anyway, let’s not forget that these rules are his own creation. There is no definitive fiscal tablet of stone saying this is or isn’t the “correct” way to run the public finances.

In short: he has taken a choice, to save that money rather than spending it. Which raises a few questions.

Is this a sign of his fiscal prudence? Will it undermine the nature of the economic recovery, since some of that money might plausibly have contributed to economic growth? Is he just saving it in advance of, say, the next general election?

Certainly, this budget gives him plenty of room – even within his new fiscal rules – to splurge in 2023 or 2024 on either more spending or tax cuts. The pre-election bribe is, one might speculate, in the can.

It is quite hard, at this stage, to say where the chancellor comes out in these questions.

If you listened to his speech you will probably have been somewhat bewildered. In one sentence this man talked proudly about the billions of pounds he was spending on public infrastructure; in the next he warned that with the size of the state now at its biggest in decades, this spending was unsustainable.

It comes back to a deeper unanswered question about the Tory party: do they stand for fiscal prudence or for investing loads of money in some of the country’s more economically disadvantaged areas?

For the time being, the chancellor’s answer seems to be: “yes, to both”. How easily he walks this tightrope in the coming years remains to be seen.

Numbers on the scoreboards

The fourth thing you need to know about this budget is that the vast, vast majority of policy decisions happened long before budget day itself.

Here’s one way of looking at it. Typically when one looks at a budget document the most important table of all is somewhere towards the end, called the “scorecard”. This table tots up the fiscal impact (money in or out) of every policy in the document. It’s a big deal in Whitehall.

So what did we learn from this scorecard?

Well, again let’s take 2022/23 as our main year to focus on.

In this fiscal year the government will spend an extra £47bn; but of that, roughly £39bn was decided months ago: the September announcement to spend more on health and social care and the announcement of the spending envelope for the Spending Review.

Its policies will bring in an extra £24bn but of that a whopping £23bn again occurred back in September, when the prime minister and chancellor announced an increase in National Insurance (well, the “health and social care levy”) and changed the pensions triple lock into a double lock (saving about £5bn a year).

This is not to dismiss the policies announced today: the universal credit taper rate cut will be very important for many families and will blunt some of the pain from the removal of the COVID period uplift.

Business rates relief will make a difference for many businesses.

But these policies will cost roughly £2bn a year each – not exactly enormously generous by the standards of recent budgets (then again, recent budgets have been pretty enormous).

An environmentally damaging budget?

The final thing you need to know about the budget is that if you had been hoping for a big environmentally friendly piece of fiscal policy ahead of next week’s COP26 climate summit then, well, you’ll be disappointed.

In fact it’s worse than that: all else equal this budget might plausibly increase carbon emissions rather than diminishing them.

This is something of a surprise; after all, the whole point of this particular COP summit is that having made bold promises on climate change, governments around the world now need to show some evidence that they’re actually serious about getting to net zero.

So what did the chancellor do?

Well, instead of raising taxes on emissions, he effectively cut them. Britain has a few of what you might call green taxes, of which the biggest is fuel duty and the second biggest is air passenger duty.

In this budget Rishi Sunak froze fuel duty and cut APD.

One can understand why: petrol prices are close to record highs and flight numbers remain very low compared with the pre-pandemic era.

These tax measures will help households – especially the poorest and those outside London, who tend to suffer the biggest impact from higher fuel prices.

With inflation on the rise, is this really the right time to penalise motorists whose finances are already squeezed?

But, well, this is the dilemma of net zero. It is ultimately about trade-offs between cheap but dirty fossil fuel energy and expensive but clean renewable energy.

Much as he may be enthusiastic about clean tech, much as he is investing more via the Spending Review on these technologies, the clearest indication of a chancellor’s preferences is his tax policy.

And the chancellor has signalled in this budget a preference for fossil fuels over clean energy.

Now, the above is hardly an exhaustive list. This was, as I say, a complex budget. And with complex budgets often it takes some days to understand their true significance, or to tease out the problematic bits under the surface.

But perhaps it’s a start.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

States debt-to-GDP ratio worryingly higher than FY23 target, says RBI report

Representative Image: Shutterstock The combined debt-to-GDP ratio of states is expected to remain at 31 per cent by end-March 2022 which is worryingly higher than the target of 20 per ... Read more »

The world's most powerful central banker gives the Bank of England cover to raise rates

Sky's Ian King says that if the Bank of England was reluctant to be the first major economy to raise interest rates, Fed chair Jay Powell has handed UK policymakers an open goal. Read more »

Passengers from ‘at-risk' countries should expect to stay in airports for 3-4 hours after arrival

Representative image. A day after the Indian government came out with guidelines to regulate the entry of international passengers from countries that have detected the Omicron variant of the coronavirus, ... Read more »

Honda Cars India reports 31% dip in total sales at 6,904 units in November

Honda Cars India Ltd (HCIL) on Wednesday reported a 31 per cent decline in total sales at 6,904 units in November 2021. The company had sold a total of 10,021 ... Read more »

Vaccine champions Spain, Portugal focus on the reluctant few

The Associated PressPeople queue for Pfizer COVID-19 vaccinations in the Wizink Center in Madrid, Spain, Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021. Health authorities in the Spanish capital have confirmed a second case ... Read more »

Holiday fair in Jaarbeurs Utrecht is canceled

Photo: ANP The Vakantiebeurs, which was to take place from 12 to 16 January in the Jaarbeurs in Utrecht, is canceled due to the corona pandemic. Many exhibitors from all ... Read more »

Supply chain chaos to persist through to next summer, Siemens chairman says

Jim Hagemann Snabe is chairman of the supervisory board at Siemens and chairman of the board at Danish conglomerate A.P. Moller – Maersk.Ralph Orlowski | Bloomberg | Getty Images Supply chain chaos ... Read more »

Travel stocks lead FTSE 100 higher in latest Omicron-driven market swing

British Airways owner International Airlines Group and travel giant Tui as well as aero engine maker Rolls-Royce were among those making strong gains. Read more »

Wealthy Asians likely to bequeath US$2.54 trillion to their heirs by 2030, report says

About 70,000 affluent Asians are likely to transfer an estimated total wealth of US$2.54 trillion by 2030, the third-largest amount after North America with US$10.6 trillion and Europe with US$3.58 ... Read more »

HLE Glascoat Consolidated September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 124.02 crore, up 2.07% Y-o-Y

Reported Consolidated quarterly numbers for HLE Glascoat are: Net Sales at Rs 124.02 crore in September 2021 up 2.07% from Rs. 121.51 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

V2 Retail Standalone September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 149.53 crore, up 75.93% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for V2 Retail are: Net Sales at Rs 149.53 crore in September 2021 up 75.93% from Rs. 85.00 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Loss at ... Read more »

Energy company Essent finds new top woman at PostNL

Photo: ANP Energy company Essent has a new top woman as of 1 February. Resi Becker will then succeed interim chairman of the board Suzan Schakenraad. Becker comes over from ... Read more »

Toys R Us is opening a flagship store at American Dream later this month, marking its return to malls

A 20,000-square-foot Toys R Us location will open in mid-December at the American Dream megamall in New Jersey.Source: WHP Global Toys R Us is taking another shot at opening up ... Read more »

Why China is warning of yuan speculation when the currency looks so stable

In a meeting hosted by the People’s Bank of China, Chinese financial regulators’ warning against so-called speculation in the foreign exchange market has attracted much attention. Yet the Chinese currency ... Read more »

Exxon Mobil ups spending on emission reduction plan to $15B

The Associated PressFILE – The logo for ExxonMobil appears above a trading post on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, April 23, 2018. ExxonMobil says it is boosting ... Read more »

STI up 1.9% as S'pore market snaps six-day losing streak

The local banks thrived with DBS emerging as the STI’s top gainer. SINGAPORE (THE BUSINESS TIMES) – Local shares snapped a dispiriting six-day losing streak with gusto on Wednesday on ... Read more »

Spotify's 2021 Wrapped gives users a peek into their listening habits this year

As 2022 draws to a close, Spotify is launching its annual Wrapped hub on the app that will tell users what songs, artistes, genres, and podcasts they listened to during ... Read more »

Gazprom notes daily records of gas withdrawal from European UGSF in November

Meanwhile, Gazprom continues to inject its gas into five European UGS facilities Read more »

Spandana Sphoorty founder-board battle intensifies as Reddy questions long list of consultants, collection efficiency figures

Padmaja Reddy will be among the key shareholders of the proposed NBFC initially and may later take up a senior management role. (Illustration: Suneesh Kalarickal) Padmaja Reddy, founder and former ... Read more »

Gajanan Sec Standalone September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 0.14 crore, up 169.38% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for Gajanan Securities Services are: Net Sales at Rs 0.14 crore in September 2021 up 169.38% from Rs. 0.05 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit ... Read more »

Third tranche of Bharat Bond ETF to be launched on December 3; here're the details

Representative image The third tranche of Bharat Bond Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) will be launched on December 3, with the NFO (new fund offer) continuing till December 9. With a base ... Read more »

V2 Retail Consolidated September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 149.53 crore, up 75.93% Y-o-Y

Reported Consolidated quarterly numbers for V2 Retail are: Net Sales at Rs 149.53 crore in September 2021 up 75.93% from Rs. 85.00 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Loss at ... Read more »

Government accelerates Tata Steel's harmful emissions

State Secretary Steven van Weyenberg (Infrastructure and Water Management) will announce these measures on Wednesday, now that he has sat down with the province of North Holland and the IJmond ... Read more »

European Commission: we can fight with China's ‘silk road'

Photo: ANP The European Commission thinks it will be able to compete with developing countries with new billions in investments. China has been able to gain a foothold in countries ... Read more »

$34m break fee payable to Keppel would be 'indirectly borne' by Cuscaden if it succeeds in SPH bid

This means the break fee won’t come out of the pockets of SPH shareholders if the Cuscaden offer succeeds, said the consortium. SINGAPORE – Cuscaden Peak said on Wednesday (Dec ... Read more »

Tata Steel permits tightened: air must be cleaner faster

Tata Steel’s permits for the emission of harmful substances are being tightened up and extra checks will be carried out on those emissions. In this way, the central government and ... Read more »

Raymond approves Rs 800 crore IPO of subsidiary JK Files & Engineering

Branded fabric and fashion retailer Raymond is planning to list its material subsidiary JK Files & Engineering as it approved an initial public offering of its subsidiary on December 1. The ... Read more »

All new cars in Hong Kong could be electric by 2030

EVs accounted for 30% of newly registered cars in October, up from 12% last year and 6% in 2019. (South China Morning Post photo) HONG KONG: All new cars in ... Read more »

S'pore Prison Service launched new vehicle for infectious inmates 3 weeks before Covid-19 hit

SINGAPORE – In December 2019, Singapore Prison Service (SPS) Rehabilitation Officer Zulkifli Zakaria and his team began trialling a minibus that could transport sick inmates who need to be isolated. ... Read more »

Tel Aviv is the most expensive city in the world this year

Not Paris, New York or Singapore, but Tel Aviv will be the most expensive city in the world in 2021. According to research by the British magazine The Economist. Main ... Read more »

Bookings cancelled and plans changed as 'chilling talk of Plan B' hits hospitality sector

Restaurants and bars desperately need to have a good festive period after a "lost" Christmas last year - but now there are fears that mixed messaging and nervousness among customers could have a catastrophic impact. Read more »

China extends battle lines to manage capital outflows as Beijing doubles down on ‘economic security'

Police, prosecutors, as well as customs and financial regulators in China have joined forces to tackle all possible channels of capital outflow as Beijing scrambles to ensure the world’s second ... Read more »

Bank of Thailand says doesn't support digital assets as payments

FILE PHOTO: A representation of the virtual cryptocurrency Bitcoin is seen in this picture illustration taken Oct 19, 2021. (Reuters) The central bank on Wednesday warned companies about accepting digital ... Read more »

Musk mocks Apple's $19 cloth as Tesla sells out of new ‘cyberwhistle'

Tesla CEO Elon Musk unveiled the “cyberwhistle” — an apparent jab at the company’s various whistleblowers who have alleged sexual harassment. Britta Pedersen-Pool/Getty Images Tesla CEO Elon Musk took a ... Read more »

Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: Salesforce, Allbirds, DoorDash and more

Check out the companies making headlines in premarket trading. Salesforce — Shares of the software giant dropped more than 6% in premarket trading despite a better-than-expected third-quarter earnings report. The company's ... Read more »

As lawmakers mull curbs on social media, Facebook whistleblower Haugen weighing in

Haugen, a former Facebook product manager, is testifying at a House hearing Wednesday on the legislative proposals. Read more »

Armed security guards are allowed on Dutch ships

Merchant ships flying the Dutch flag will be allowed to take on board private security officers who carry weapons from 1 January. On Tuesday, the Senate approved a repair law ... Read more »

Tata Power Solar gets letter of award for Rs 945 crore project

Representative image Tata Power Solar has received letter of award (LoA) for a solar and battery storage project worth Rs 945 crore from Solar Energy Corporation of India Ltd (SECI). ... Read more »

Leading Chinese EV trio Xpeng, NIO and Li Auto post record month, triple-digit rise in November deliveries

China’s three leading electric vehicle (EV) start-ups posted a record number of deliveries for November, amid a surge in demand for premium EVs. Guangzhou-based Xpeng Motors delivered 15,613 vehicles last ... Read more »

Supreme Court to hear arguments in major abortion case challenging Roe v. Wade

Pro-choice demonstrators are seen outside of the US Supreme Court in Washington, DC on November 1, 2021.Mandel Ngan | AFP | Getty Images The Supreme Court is about to hear ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic