Successful UPSC candidates have no right to be allocated cadre of their choice: Supreme Court

Asia's Tech News Daily

Successful UPSC candidates have no right to be allocated cadre of their choice: Supreme Court
© Provided by Hindustan Times Justice Gupta noted that “scramble for the home cadre” starts once the candidates get selected to All-India Service. (Mint/Pradeep Gaur)

Setting aside the orders passed by the Kerala high court, the Supreme Court on Friday said that successful civil services candidates have no right to be allocated a cadre or place of appointment of their choice as they opt to serve anywhere in the country with “eyes wide open”. A bench comprising Justices Hemant Gupta and V Ramasubramanian held that if candidates from Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), or Other Backward Class (OBC) get selected in the general category without recourse to the benefit of reservation, they cannot use it for getting cadre or place of appointment of choice.

Justice Gupta, who authored the 36-page judgement for the bench, noted that “scramble for the home cadre” starts once the candidates get selected to All-India Service. Referring to the Indian Administrative Service (Recruitment) Rules, the bench said that the procedure for allocation of cadre is a “mechanical process” and the State has no discretion at its “whims and fancies.”

“It was held that a selected candidate has a right to be considered for appointment to the IAS but he has no such right to be allocated to a cadre of his choice or his home state. As stated above, allotment of cadre is an incidence of service,” the court said.

“The applicant as a candidate for the All-India Service with eyes wide open has opted to serve anywhere in the country. Once an applicant gets selected to service, the scramble for the home cadre starts…,” Justice Gupta noted.

The observation came after the Central government challenged a verdict of the Kerala high court which had asked it to grant home cadre Kerala to A Shainamol, a Muslim woman IAS officer who was posted in Himachal Pradesh. Shainamol secured 20th rank in the UPSC civil services examination 2006 under the general category despite belonging to the reserved Muslim OBC category.

She was allocated Himachal Pradesh cadre but the IAS officer moved the Ernakulam Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal against the allocation. The tribunal directed the Centre to accommodate her against “the outsider OBC vacancy in the Maharashtra cadre by virtue of her merit over the candidate already identified and allotted the Maharashtra cadre.”

After both the Centre and the IAS officer challenged the verdict in Kerala high court, it allowed Shainamol’s plea seeking the declaration that she was eligible to be allotted home state cadre.

“The entire basis of the claim of the applicant is that there was no consultation with the State of Kerala. The said argument is however untenable. The applicant was allocated to the State of Himachal Pradesh and there was consent duly given by the State of Himachal Pradesh for her allocation to that State. In fact, no consultation was required to be carried out in respect of the applicant with Kerala State,” the apex court held.

Sign on to read the HT ePaper

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


'Stupid to turn down' - Manager gives Leeds fresh hope in bid to sign Golden Boot hopeful

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Ben Brereton Diaz Blackburn Leeds United have been boosted in their efforts to sign Ben Brereton Diaz, with Blackburn Rovers manager Tony Mowbray admitting that ... Read more »

A queer-friendly pastor who dressed in drag on HBO's 'We're Here' claims he was forced out of his church

© Jakes Giles Netter/ HBO Pastor Craig Duke on “We’re Here” Jakes Giles Netter/ HBO An Indiana pastor says he was pushed out of his church after appearing in drag ... Read more »

Kapuso, Kapamilya: Big Winners in Asian Academy Creative Awards

On December 2 and 3, Kapuso’s 24 Oras and Kapamilya’s comedian-host Vice Ganda won the Asian Academy Creative Awards. © Provided by LionhearTV For Asian Academy Creative Awards Grand Awards ... Read more »

A French judicial official says a suspect in the killing of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi has been arrested in France

PARIS — A French judicial official says a suspect in the killing of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi has been arrested in France. Read more »

The Real Reason Dwayne Johnson Waited 10 Years To Play Black Adam

Kathy Hutchins/Shutterstock After being in development for over a decade (via SlashFilm), 2022 will finally be the year that audiences get to see Dwayne Johnson suit up as the titular star ... Read more »

Adam McKay And Jennifer Lawrence Are Teaming Up For This Real-Life Drama

Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty In November of 2021, Netflix released a new trailer for “Don’t Look Up,” a satirical disaster comedy with Adam McKay as its director. McKay’s prior filmography includes directing ... Read more »

Cookbook celebrates Latin America's vast and vital cuisine

Food – The Latin American Cookbook (ASSOCIATED PRESS) Putting together an entire nation's distinctive dishes is a daunting process for anyone. Then imagine doing it for 22 countries and you ... Read more »

Exclusive-Amazon offered France deal to have bill protecting bookshops pulled

Amazon logo at the company logistics center in Bretigny-sur-Orge By Elizabeth Pineau PARIS (Reuters) – Amazon proposed raising book delivery charges in France to around 2 euros from almost nothing ... Read more »

African Union calls for end to Omicron travel curbs on some African nations

© Reuters/TIKSA NEGERI The African Union logo is seen outside the AU headquarters building in Addis Ababa NAIROBI (Reuters) – The African Union on Tuesday called for an urgent end ... Read more »

DB Cooper hijacked a plane, stole a pile of cash, and vanished. Fifty years on, a ‘hero' flight attendant speaks out

Tina Mucklow (left) was one of three flight attendants on the flight hijacked by a man known as DB Cooper (pictured right in an FBI sketch) in 1971 (Yasmine Kateb) ... Read more »

Twitter tests overhaul of process to flag harmful tweets

FILE PHOTO: A Twitter logo is seen outside the company headquarters in San Francisco By Sheila Dang (Reuters) – Twitter Inc will begin overhauling how users report harmful tweets in ... Read more »

Omicron could be more transmissible than Delta, PM tells ministers

The Omicron variant of coronavirus appears to be “more transmissible” than the Delta strain, Boris Johnson told ministers, as the UK reported its highest weekly number of new Covid-19 cases ... Read more »

Putin and Biden hold two hours of talks amid Ukraine tensions

© Provided by Al Jazeera Russian President Vladimir Putin holds talks with US President Joe Biden via a video link in Sochi, Russia, on December 7, 2021 [Sputnik/Sergey Guneev/Pool via ... Read more »

More rapes reported in Denmark after the introduction of the consent law

The number of rape reports in Denmark has risen markedly since a new consent law came into force in January, according to figures from the police that the newspaper Politiken ... Read more »

Norway announces new corona measures: One meter of distance and alcohol-serving restrictions reintroduced

The requirement to keep a distance of one meter from others, which was phased out on Saturday, September 25, is being reintroduced. Seventy-four days after the then Minister of Health ... Read more »

Lausanne-Diaw verzeiht FCB-Fan die Rassismus-Attacke

Diashow ein Nach der rassistischen Beleidigung vom Sonntag: Lausanne-Sports Mory Diaw verzeiht dem FCB-Fan für seine Entgleisung und bedankt sich auf Instagram für den Support. Mit dieser Botschaft wendet er ... Read more »

«Nepo» mit fatalem Fehler beim 27. Zug – Carlsen profitiert und steht vor WM-Titel

© keystone Teaserbild © keystone Im Gegensatz zu seinem russischen Herausforderer begeht Magnus Carlsen kaum Fehler. Schach-Weltmeister Magnus Carlsen steht nach einem weiteren Sieg kurz vor der Verteidigung seines Titels. ... Read more »

Carlsen gewinnt wieder - Schach-WM fast entschieden

© KEYSTONE/EPA/ALI HAIDER Schach-Weltmeister Magnus Carlsen steht nach einem weiteren Sieg kurz vor der Verteidigung seines Titels. Der 31-jährige Norweger gewann in Dubai auch die neunte Partie gegen seinen russischen ... Read more »

Kaum Corona-Fälle, aber...: Kosovo führt Impfpflicht für Einreise ein

Der Kosovo führt ab der kommenden Woche neue Corona-Regeln für die Einreise ein. Ab dem neuen Jahr dürfen dann nur noch Geimpfte mit mindestens einem Piks in den Balkan-Staat einreisen. ... Read more »

Bed rails recalled after two deaths in US

The Drive DeVilbiss Healthcare Home Bed Assist Handle is among those products recalled. CPSC Nearly half a million adult portable bed rails sold nationwide have been recalled after being linked ... Read more »

Senate confirms Rosenworcel to new term on U.S. FCC

FILE PHOTO: FCC commissioners testify before U.S. Congress in Washington By David Shepardson WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Senate voted 68-31 on Tuesday to confirm Federal Communications Commission chair Jessica ... Read more »

'Hate won': top Indian comedian quits after receiving death threats from nationalists

Munawar Faruqui has quit his profession after receiving threats One of India’s top Muslim comedians has quit after serving a jail term for “indecent” jokes about Hindu gods and being ... Read more »

Firebomb thrown property in latest arson attack in Scottish town

Police have launched an investigation into the latest incident in Strathaven, South Lanarkshire (Peter Byrne/PA) (PA Wire) Another property has fallen victim to an arsonist in South Lanarkshire after a ... Read more »

Jon Rahm is back at No. 1 in Golfweek/Sagarin rankings after Jordan Spieth's tough week in the Bahamas

© Provided by Golfweek Ryder Cup 2021 It was a struggle for Jordan Spieth down in Albany, the Bahamas, this past weekend at the Hero World Challenge. He came in ... Read more »

BBL: Cox and Lammonby add to English influx with Hurricanes deals

© PA Images/Getty Jordan Cox was the player of the final in the most recent T20 Blast season © PA Images/Getty Jordan Cox and Tom Lammonby have become the latest ... Read more »

Ex-Libor trader Tom Hayes's attempt to appeal conviction provisionally blocked

© Reuters/TOBY MELVILLE Tom Hayes poses for a picture, in Arundel By Kirstin Ridley LONDON (Reuters) -Tom Hayes, the British trader who became the face of the global Libor interest ... Read more »

Biden to speak with European leaders after virtual summit with Putin – live

© Photograph: Patrick Semansky/AP Joe Biden and Vladimir Putin in Geneva, Switzerland, in June. LIVE – Updated at 18:16 Summit with Russian president ends after about two hours amid fears ... Read more »

Beachy keen treasures for your favorite surfer girl

From luxury surf boards to sandals, the best beach-inspired gifts for your favorite sun goddess. NY Post photo composite From luxury surf boards and sunglasses to sandals and jewelry, here ... Read more »

DOJ sues Texas over new voting districts, citing discrimination against Black, Latino voters

The Department of Justice on Monday filed a lawsuit against Texas, alleging Republican state lawmakers discriminated against Black and Latino voters and have “again diluted the voting strength of minority ... Read more »

Judge sets July 18 for Bannon ‘contempt of Congress' trial

President Donald Trump’s former adviser Steve Bannon will go to trial July 18 on criminal charges that he defied a subpoena from the House committee exploring the causes of the ... Read more »

Brooke Shields Calls Teenage Barbara Walters Interview ‘Practically Criminal'

© Provided by TheWrap Barbara Walters Brooke Shields was interviewed a lot after she posed in a provocative Calvin Klein campaign at the age of 15, but her sit-down with ... Read more »

Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman arrives in the UAE

© Mohamed Al Hammadi / Ministry of Presidential Affairs ABU DHABI, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES – December 07, 2021: HH Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi ... Read more »

New UAE weekend will help employees strike a better work-life balance, residents say

© Provided by Khaleej Times File photo Social media and messaging apps were set abuzz with the UAE’s ground-breaking announcement of the new working week that grants government sector employees, ... Read more »

Lorry carrying apples catches fire in Sharjah

© Provided by The National Firefighters tackle a blaze in Sharjah that damaged at least four vehicles. Photo: Sharjah Civil Defence A lorry carrying a shipment of apples caught fire ... Read more »

Ford Maverick may become Bronco-like sub-brand with additional vehicles

As Ford continues to build out its “Icons,” as it likes to call them, with the Mustang and Bronco, CEO Jim Farley sees room for another sub-brand of sorts with ... Read more »

London Underground: Driverless Tube trains is a 'fantasy' that ‘can't and won't happen'

London’s transport unions have slapped down proposals for driverless Tube trains, despite fierce pressure from central government. Plans being pushed by Ministers to ditch drivers on the London Underground network ... Read more »

Cataract operations cut risk of dementia by 30 percent

© Getty Doctor performing cataract surgery Cataracts affect most older adults at risk of dementia, but researchers have found strong evidence that the operation is linked to a lower chance ... Read more »

Homebase slash 50% off their 10ft inflatable Santa just in time for Christmas

The festive season is drawing closer and if you’re thinking about decking the halls, then you might want to head over to Homebase. The popular home and garden retailer is ... Read more »

Munster to register 22 new players for Champions Cup squad

© Ryan Byrne INPHO Tony Butler is one of 22 players put forward for registration. MUNSTER HAVE NOMINATED an additional 22 players to be registered for their Champions Cup squad, ... Read more »

Tanla to provide solutions to secure, encrypt international messaging traffic on Vodafone Idea network

© Provided by Zee Business Tanla and Vodafone Idea on Tuesday announced a pact under which Tanla will provide solutions to secure, encrypt and enhance performance for international messaging traffic ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic