Sturgeon under fire as Scotland spends three times more on rail services than England

Nicola Sturgeon

Nicola Sturgeon has been accused of wasting taxpayers’ money after figures showed that Scotland is spending three times as much as England on keeping railway services running during Covid.

Holyrood has paid almost £60 for every passenger journey since the pandemic struck compared with £22 south of the border, according to analysis by The Telegraph.

In Scotland, this equates to £1.86 for every kilometre each passenger has travelled, compared with 69p in England.

Rail operators on both sides of the border were effectively nationalised to prevent them going bust during the first lockdown, costing billions of pounds of public money. Politicians are now struggling to work out how to handle the ongoing financial burden of running services, amid fears that mass commuting will never return after Covid.

Ms Sturgeon’s administration decided on Monday to keep its two operators on emergency rail contracts until the end of the year. By contrast, in Westminster operators have been transferred onto less lucrative terms to try to limit the burden on taxpayers.

MSP Graham Simpson, the Scottish Conservatives’ shadow transport minister, said: “Scottish taxpayers are shelling out three times more for an SNP rail service that hasn’t operated on a Sunday in seven months and plans to slash hundreds of services.

“Rail users aren’t seeing value for money and the SNP-Green government needs to ensure that under nationalisation the rail services work for the passenger, not the operator.”

The decision came as the SNP fights a bitter industrial dispute with the RMT guards union. Passengers have suffered weekend rail disruption for several months as a result.

In Westminster, the Department for Transport is under orders from the Treasury to cut a rail subsidy that has ballooned to more than £10bn across England. The burden on the public purse is to be reduced through an increase in demand as more commuters return to work, coupled with budget cuts.

Bosses in England are in talks with union leaders to axe thousands of jobs and reduce service levels in order to balance the books.

The Scottish approach means operators continue to be funded predominantly through a fixed fee, as opposed to one earning money based on their performance. Industry sources said that Scottish ministers had resisted a cut to services to avoid worsening their dispute with the RMT.

However, insiders added, this meant that the services’ operator Abellio is racking up big losses. Abellio will be replaced by a state-run company in sprint.

According to the latest figures released by Transport Scotland, taxpayers are paying about £850m a year to keep rail services running north of the border.

Though this is considerably less than the £8.3bn spent by Westminster , Scotland only had 14.5m passenger journeys in the year to March 2021, according to figures released by the Office of Rail and Road (ORR) – compared with 373.5m in England.

Scottish trains racked up about 450m rail passenger kilometres according to another metric used by the ORR, compared with more than 12bn in England.

A Transport Scotland spokesman said: “The economics of the Scottish network are quite different from those of England, which includes higher revenue per journey from longer distance journeys into London and the intercity routes generally.

“ScotRail provides services across many rural and remote areas of Scotland. A better comparison would be with similar parts of the English network, for example, Northern Trains, rather than an England-wide average.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Best wireless headphones 2021

Best wireless headphones Buying Guide: Welcome to What Hi-Fi?’s round-up of the best wireless headphones you can buy in 2021. © Provided by What Hi-Fi? Apple AirPods Max Wireless headphones ... Read more »

The best tools for hybrid working

The pandemic has changed many things around the world, not least in the world of work, where the idea of spending all your time in an office now seems rather ... Read more »

Apple AirPods 3rd gen review: The perfect balance of audio quality and features for a fair price

We considered how well they fit, how good the call quality is, their build quality and value for money (iStock/The Independent) When it comes to wireless in-ear headphones, nothing made ... Read more »

Redmi Note 11, Redmi Note 11 Pro and Redmi Note 11 Pro+ launched in China: Specs, camera and everything we know

Redmi has launched three new smartphones Redmi Note 11, Redmi Note 11 Pro and Redmi Note 11 Pro+ in China. The new lineup is the successor to Redmi Note 10 ... Read more »

Snoop Dogg podría haber filtrado rumores de GTA 6 sobre Dr Dre

El rapero reconvertido en streamer Snoop Dogg es el curioso portador de (posibles) noticias sobre GTA 6. La estrella de la costa oeste ha revelado que su antiguo compañero de ... Read more »

Jeremy Corbyn: Second vote on Scottish independence will happen ‘in a few years'

A second vote on Scottish independence will happen “in a few years”, former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has said. Mr Corbyn, who stood down as leader in 2019 and has ... Read more »

Technology has tackled prejudice where governments could not, says will.i.am

Will.i.am has praised the power of technology, saying it has done “what companies and governments and cities were not able to do” when it comes to battling discrimination. Talking as ... Read more »

Beat Saber teasing Facebook Connect update – what else do we expect to see?

We’re counting down to today’s Facebook Connect Oculus Quest event, and we’re starting to get a good idea of what we’re likely to see. Following leaks earlier this week that ... Read more »

The best noise-cancelling headphones of 2021: our top ANC headphones for every budget

The best noise-cancelling headphones can seriously improve your listening experience – whether you’re immersing yourself in your favorite music or tuning out the world to focus on a podcast. Noise-cancelling ... Read more »

What's riding on Cop26 for the UK?

Cop26 is bringing together 30,000 delegates from around the world, which makes it the largest summit the United Kingdom has ever hosted. Here are five things that would make Cop26 ... Read more »

Best waterproof speakers 2021: the top outdoor speakers for any budget

Going on vacation and thinking of picking up the best waterproof speaker you can buy in 2021? Our guide has you covered. Sunny holidays can often feature a lot of ... Read more »

Have ABBA retired because their new music was a disaster?

ABBA’s two new singles haven’t got anywhere near the coveted no1 spot in the charts – Alamy My, my – ABBA have just revealed they’re breaking up. The week before ... Read more »

Chip shortage puts the brakes on Volkswagen

Volkswagen cut its outlook for deliveries, toned down sales expectations and warned of cost cuts, as a shortage of computer chips caused the world’s No. 2 carmaker to report lower-than-expected ... Read more »

PM hosts King of Jordan at Downing St

Prime Minister Boris Johnson hosts King Abdullah of Jordan for bilateral talks in 10 Downing Street. Read more »

France seizes British trawler in post-Brexit row

France seized a British trawler fishing in its territorial waters without a license on Thursday (October 28). It also issued a warning to a second vessel as a dispute over ... Read more »

Hundreds march through Manchester over drink spikings in clu

Hundreds of people have marched through Manchester after boycotting bars and nightclubs to highlight the issue of drink spiking. It comes after almost 200 of cases including drink spiking and ... Read more »

Future Retail moves Delhi High Court against SIAC order

Future Retail along with its promoters has moved the Delhi High Court requesting to stay and set aside the order passed by the Singapore-based arbitration tribunal SIAC on October 21, ... Read more »

Apple announces Safari 15.1 for macOS Catalina and Big Sur with traditional tab design

Apple has changed the layout of tabs in Safari to give it a classic look for macs running on macOS Big Sur and Catalina with Safari 15.1. Previously, Apple released ... Read more »

Stop these 4 risky online behaviors if you want to avoid falling victim to fraud

As tech-savvy as we tend to be these days – relying heavily on the internet for everything from communication, information and productivity to entertainment, shopping, and banking – many Americans ... Read more »

NRA refuses to confirm reports of ransomware hack

The National Rifle Association (NRA) has released a statement saying that it is against its policy to discuss matters of security, a day after a ransomware gang claimed to have ... Read more »

Sony has sold about 13.4 million PS5 units

Sony has sold a total of 13.4 million PS5 units to date, as per the records released by the company. According to the records, the company sold 3.3 million units ... Read more »

Exploring the technology behind Samsung's stunning OLED panels

Foldable display technology could have very easily been nothing more than a gimmick. When it was first announced several years ago, it certainly seemed as though that was the route ... Read more »

All-new MacBook Pro is $100 off in early Back Friday laptop deal and going fast

Barely weeks after launch, the new Apple MacBook Pro 14 is now just $1,899 thanks to Adorama’s early Black Friday laptop deals – a full $100 discount and the first ... Read more »

Diablo Immortal lets you become the ultimate bad guy – the dungeon boss

Diablo Immortal is entering closed beta with a planned full release in the first half of 2022, and there are some sizeable changes coming as the developers tweak systems while ... Read more »

8 new Diablo Immortal features to know about ahead of the Android closed beta

From a rather rocky first reveal, Diablo Immortal has slowly become one of the most hotly anticipated games on the horizon – definitely from a mobile perspective, at least. And ... Read more »

Solar wing jammed on NASA spacecraft chasing asteroids

This image provided by the Southwest Research Institute depicts the Lucy spacecraft approaching an asteroid. It will be first space mission to explore a diverse population of small bodies known ... Read more »

England prop Ellis Genge welcomes chance to work with Richard Cockerill again

England prop Ellis Genge has welcomed the opportunity to resume working with the mentor who helped launch his career. Next month Richard Cockerill will be involved in his first autumn ... Read more »

New PlayStation PC brand suggests Sony is serious about porting exclusives to PC

Sony’s drive to port some of the best PlayStation games over to the PC appears to have changed up a gear, with the formation of a new brand specifically for ... Read more »

Computer a mess? 5 steps to quickly clean up digital junk

Digital junk piles up too quickly. Look no further than your phone and all those blurry photos and old screenshots in your gallery. What you don’t see are the invasive ... Read more »

Is the Great Neutrino Puzzle Pointing to Multiple Missing Particles?

Years of conflicting neutrino measurements have led physicists to propose a “dark sector” of invisible particles — one that could simultaneously explain dark matter, the puzzling expansion of the universe, and other mysteries. Read more »

These are the 25 best gifts of 2021, according to our experts

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Figuring out the right gift is not an easy task, especially ... Read more »

15 cozy gifts from HSN to spark joy this season

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. The season of sweaters, soups and socks is upon us. Cozy ... Read more »

Apple AirPods tips and tricks: How to get the most out of Apple's wireless earphones

© Provided by Pocket-lint Apple AirPods tips and tricks How to get the most out of Apples wireless earphones image 1 (Pocket-lint) – Apple’s AirPods are like Marmite: you’ll either love ... Read more »

Dell Alienware Aurora desktops announced with AMD Ryzen 5000 and Intel Alder Lake CPUs

Dell announced two new desktops under its Alienware sub-brand today. The Dell Alienware Aurora R13 and Alienware Aurora Ryzen Edition R14 are powered by the latest Intel Alder Lake and ... Read more »

Loyal as a dog — study shows dogs signal commitment in men's dating profiles

Men and women who are seeking relationships online are asked to indicate what they want in a relationship, whether they are seeking “just friends,” “uncommitted relationships” or “long-term leading to ... Read more »

Emma Raducanu into Transylvania Open quarter-finals with straight sets win over Ana Bogdan

Raducanu recorded the second WTA Tour win of her career – AP Emma Raducanu backed up her maiden WTA Tour win with a straight-sets victory over Ana Bogdan to reach ... Read more »

It's the size of an iPhone. But this 1080p HD pocket projector serves up cinema-quality pictures

TLDR: The Prima 1080p HD Pocket Projector can cast a bright HD quality image at up to 200 inches across for all your viewing needs. It’s also now under $200. ... Read more »

Learn the basics of Google advertising and all the tricks for using it right for just $15

TLDR: The Google Ads Marketing Bootcamp Bundle breaks down all the tactics for using the world’s largest digital ad network to reach more customers and raise your brand profile. Consumers ... Read more »

Xbox series X stock - live: Today's restock updates from Amazon, Game, Argos and more

LIVE – Updated at 15:06 © iStock/The Independent xbox IB2 Update: The Xbox series X is now sold out at Box. The Xbox series X remains sold out across all UK retailers, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic