Storyboard | Are advertising agencies getting ‘vendor-zoned'?

Asia's Tech News Daily

#ad agency client relationship, #advertising agency, #Bang in the Middle, #BBDO India, #FCB Group India, #Ogilvy India, #Pratap Bose, #Storyboard, #The Social Street, #vendor

Agency insiders say that among the factors ailing legacy ad agencies today is the fact that many independent writers and small shops make creatives, including TVCs, for about a third of what the agency would charge. Many startups also don’t see the upsides of long-term brand-thinking.

‘Friendzone’ is described as the state of being friends with someone when you would prefer a romantic relationship with them. Now, it seems, something similar is playing out in the relationships between clients and agencies.

Legacy advertising agencies are increasingly in danger of becoming ‘vendor-zoned’ by clients and independent writers, content creators and smaller creative outfits. In such cases, clients bring in specialists and the ad agencies are assigned coordination and execution-related duties, significantly altering and diminishing client-agency relationships.

Advertising executives that Storyboard spoke to said that this trend is becoming stronger by the day.

Famous adman Howard Gossage once said, “Nobody reads advertising. People read what interests them, and sometimes it’s an ad.” Gossage died over half a century ago, but his words are perhaps more relevant today than ever before. Make things people want to watch, talk about and share.

A popular independent writer who has worked with several big brands tells Storyboard, on the condition of anonymity, that mainline creative agencies haven’t transformed themselves. “They still haven’t moved on from the world of TVCs,” he says, adding that it’s “the age of content” be it for the big or small screen. “This needs a certain style and tone. Big creative shops haven’t cracked it yet.” That is, cracked content that will garner visible likes, shares, and comments, and enter the trending charts.

The elephant in the room

In truth, agencies getting dangerously close to the vendor-zone is a result of many things. Issues that have been a long time in the making which have put legacy agencies in a challenging spot. Brands’ increasing dependence on digital is the final nail in the coffin, says ad veteran Meenakshi Menon, who is an entrepreneur and founder, Spatial Access. According to her, media agencies were more embracing of tech than creative agencies. The problem arose when creative agencies did not have the willingness to claim upsides while depressing their fixed fees.

“It became a win-win for clients. From lower fees to even lower fees. This is why they (agencies) started to look for revenue in other places. Unrealistic margins on film production. Huge kickbacks on events. Unreasonable commissions on celebrities. All of these back-to-the-wall tactics backfired and the creative agency ended up frittering away their relevance because their creative product was slipping,” she adds.

According to several agency insiders that Storyboard spoke to, many independent writers and small shops take one-third of what an agency from a network company charges. One can make a commercial, from scripting and production to post-production, in as little as Rs 20 lakhs, said the chief of a Mumbai-based content company.

But not all content builds brands  

Naresh Gupta, co-founder and chief strategy officer of Bang In The Middle, believes this practice is prominent in certain categories of brands including startups as they chase a different business metric. He points out that the traditional agency model kicks in when the brand wants to do deep strategic thinking.

“New-age companies are chasing numbers which most agencies won’t get because agency resources are not trained in that. They are trained in creative consumer impact and driving behaviour,” Gupta says.

In a recent case, a unicorn startup had a bespoke team of writers work on its wildly popular campaign with a mainline legacy agency. Branding experts and ad executives, however, were a divided house, with many questioning what it does for the brand?

Gupta says, “Most startups don’t think that they need long-term brand thinking and they are looking at short-term conversation-driven thinking. They don’t carry campaigns for a long period. In my opinion, this is not sustainable because businesses are not built like that but that’s how it is.”

The talent conundrum

The creative community in advertising thinks there is a talent-deficit even on the brand’s side. Advertising old-hand and former co-founder of marketing communication agency The Social Street, Pratap Bose, is of the opinion that the quality of clients (in terms of stature), especially at the brand manager and new CMO level, is drastically falling.

“They come with little experience, don’t understand the whole gamut of communication, and see us as vendors. They don’t have that historical reference. Gone are the days of good and long partnerships. When I was at Ogilvy, Vodafone, Cadbury, Unilever, and Asian Paints client relationships were 20 years or more and that continues to the day, but those are few and far between,” he notes.

On the other hand, Tarun Singh Chauhan, partner, TSC Consulting, thinks the agency side of the business needs to do a better job of retaining “experienced” talent. Here’s why: “Today, there is a lack of quality discussions with clients from the agency side of the world. Gone are the days where the agency met the top management to strategize marketing plans.”

Chauhan equates the Indian ad industry to a BPO setup. “This is happening because clients are paying agencies not for the value they are providing but for the number of people on the account.”

A counter view

Executives from mainline network companies feel that despite the business challenges, agencies continue to create work that is a signifier of exemplary-partnership that builds tremendous value for clients.

Suraja Kishore, CEO, BBDO India, shares the example of the agency’s partnership with Sharat Verma, chief marketing officer and VP, Fabric Care, P&G India, and his team. BBDO India, the brainchild behind Airel’s #ShareTheLoad campaign, started working on the account in 2015. Since then the brand and the agency have not only fetched several accolades for the campaign but have also created a social movement of sorts. Kishore says the relationship is based on “shared radical belief”.

He further tells Storyboard that the rise of boutique agencies and independent writers is one of the best things to have happened to the industry. “Emergence of the multi-media landscape provides infinite opportunities to connect with consumers, therefore we need more people who are passionate about building value for brands and business through ideas and imagination,” he adds.

The silver lining

To a certain degree, the Covid-19 pandemic has helped bring agencies and clients closer.

Kapil Arora, co-chairman and CEO, 82.5 Communications, an Ogilvy Group company, points out that the last two years have brought about a sort of cathartic effect to even the most transactional agency-client relationships.

“Conversations have gone back to being about business, not just about the brand or next brief. Depth and partnership are both sought and delivered. Indeed, in these lockdown trenches, partnerships have only gotten stronger,” Arora adds.

In fact, in the current times of high unpredictability, clients are looking for deep partnerships and greater support from partner agencies to find new ways to connect with consumers, says Rohit Ohri, chairman and CEO, FCB Group India. He adds, “A lot of clients lean on agencies’ global network for knowledge, understanding global markets, and how consumers are behaving,” which goes a long way in cementing healthy relationships that help grow brands and businesses. FCB Group has over decade-long partnerships with clients such as ITC, Nerolac, Amul, and Zodiac.

Never waste a crisis, they say. And the pandemic seems to have helped put the spotlight back on the value of solid partnerships for some agencies.

But will it keep agencies away from the vendor-zone in the future?

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Storyboard18 | Why Center Fresh went full "filmy" in its long-format brand film

Anjali Sivaraman and Shantanu Maheshwari in the Center Fresh commercial ‘Parda’. Don’t let masks and the pandemic stop you from falling in love. That, it seems, is the message in ... Read more »

Comedian Kunal Kamra says his Bengaluru shows cancelled after threats

Kunal Kamra’s show in Bengaluru has been cancelled. Comedian Kunal Kamra on Wednesday said his upcoming stand-up shows, scheduled to be held in Bengaluru, have been cancelled after the organisers ... Read more »

Ajith Kumar asks fans to stop calling him 'Thala'

Actor Ajith’s film, “Valimai”,will be released in January 2022. Tamil star Ajith, better known as “Thala” Ajit, on Wednesday asked his fans to not use the prefix “Thala” anymore with ... Read more »

How Mohanlal's 'Marakkar' became the first Indian film to earn Rs 100 crore even before its release

‘Marakkar: Lion of the Arabian Sea has Mohanlal in the lead. It also stars Keerthy Suresh and Sunil Shetty. (Film poster) A day after Malayalam superstar Mohanlal tweeted the trailer of ... Read more »

World AIDS Day 2021: From Freddie Mercury to Charlie Sheen, celebrities who battled HIV

World AIDS Day 2021: Freddy Mercury and Charlie Sheen are among the celebrities who were diagnosed with HIV. (Image credit: Pinterest and Reuters) The late Queen frontman Freddie Mercury — ... Read more »

Hello World | Parag Agrawal's elevation as Twitter chief is yet another reminder for India to fix the brain drain

An alumnus of IIT Bombay, Parag Agrawal is the new CEO of Twitter. Note to readers: Hello world is a program developers run to check if a newly installed programming language ... Read more »

IPL Retention 2022: This RCB member is sad at being skipped in retention, says he's 4th

IPL retention 2022: Mr Nags, played by Danish Sait, is the mascot of Royal Challengers Bangalore. Royal Challengers Bangalore on Tuesday retained three players, including their former captain Virat Kohli, ... Read more »

Immigration Series: All about moving to Mauritius

Records of Indians immigrating to Mauritius date back to 1834, when 36 men from Bihar and Bengal set sail for the island nation to work as indentured labour. Currently, 68% of Mauritians ... Read more »

This Australian man broke a 10-year Guinness World Record for the loudest burp

Neville Sharp attempts to create a Guinness World Record for the loudest burp (male). (Image credit: Guinness World Records) For years, Neville Sharp had been claiming that his burps were ... Read more »

How Will Retail Sales Fare In the Coming Year?

In an ever-changing formation, the trends of retail sales in 2022 are expected to be bringing the freshness of the good old days of 2019. However, this is certainly sure ... Read more »

Anand Mahindra says 'new roar' as Paris municipal cops get bikes with India link

Peugeot Metropolis is now being used by the Paris municipal police. (Image credit: Photo tweeted by @pakwakankar) Mahindra group-owned Peugeot Motorcycles have been added to the fleet of the Paris ... Read more »

World AIDS Day: About 57% Indians don't use any form of contraception, finds survey

Representative image A survey released on the eve of World AIDS Day has revealed that about 57 percent of India do not use any form of contraception such as condoms. Conducted ... Read more »

Realme GT 2 Pro launch confirmed in December with Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 chip

The Realme GT 2 Pro camera module’s horizontal bar houses a triple-camera setup with two LED flash cutouts. It is said to have two 50MP camera sensors, which are likely ... Read more »

World Aids Day 2021: History, theme, significance

HIV, a major public health issue, affects millions of people across the world. The virus attacks the immune system and reduces its resistance to other diseases, putting the life of ... Read more »

Xiaomi 11i HyperCharge launch in India with 120W charging rumoured; RAM, storage, colour options leaked

Xiaomi 11i HyperCharge is said to be a rebadged version of the Redmi Note 11 Pro+, which was launched in China earlier this year. Xiaomi 11i HyperCharge launch in India ... Read more »

Elon Musk introduces $50 Tesla Cyberwhistle, says 'don't buy silly Apple Cloth'

Elon Musk, on Tesla’s Cyberwhistle, said, “Don’t waste your money on that silly Apple Cloth, buy our whistle instead!” Billionaire Elon Musk has asked people to “blow the whistle on ... Read more »

Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 launched with many world's-first features; to power flagships from Xiaomi, Realme, Vivo

Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 launched at the Snapdragon Summit is Qualcomm’s flagship platform for smartphones in 2022. The new Snapdragon chip comes as a successor to the Snapdragon 888 ... Read more »

Hundreds of FedEx Packages Were Found Dumped in a Ravine, Driver Under Investigation

There’s the old adage about letters seemingly getting ‘lost in the mail’ or the all too familiar and unfortunate reality of packages being delayed thanks to the pandemic and supply ... Read more »

Labor Board Official Orders Revote on Forming Union for Alabama Amazon Warehouse Workers

A labor board official has ordered a revote for Amazon warehouse workers in Alabama regarding forming the company’s first unionized warehouse in the United States. PATRICK T. FALLON | Getty Images The ... Read more »

Musk Laments 'Supply Chain Nightmare' Facing Cybertruck Production

Tesla Chief Executive Elon Musk on Monday lamented the ongoing supply chain difficulties facing the release of the company’s much-delayed Cybertruck and said he will share updates about the new electric vehicle when the company reports its ... Read more »

Elon Musk Speaks Out on New Twitter CEO

The social-media world went into a frenzy Monday after Twitter CEO and founder Jack Dorsey announced that he would be stepping down from his role at the media company. picture ... Read more »

Lululemon Hits Peloton With a Lawsuit for Its 'Knockoff' Designs

Last week, Peloton sued fellow athletic brand Lululemon after the latter threatened to take legal action if Peloton kept selling its new clothes. On Monday, Lululemon followed through on its ultimatum and filed ... Read more »

Redmi Note 10, other budget smartphones under the series go out of stock on

To make way for the next generation, it seems like Xiaomi has limited the stock of the Redmi Note 10 series in India via its official channels. The upcoming Redmi ... Read more »

Vegan en Vogue: Here's Why Some of the Biggest Events of the Year are Nixing Meat from Their Menus

For nearly two years, virtually every cultural event has been canceled, or at least dramatically scaled back for the sake of COVID-19 safety precautions. After a year of parties and ... Read more »

Stephen Colbert Ribs Jeff Bezos and His 'Penis Rocket'

On Monday night, The Late Show host Stephen Colbert used his opening monologue to skewer consumer habits amid yet another holiday-shopping season. Michael M. Santiago | Getty Images Colbert wished his ... Read more »

Budweiser's First NFT Collection Sells Out Within an Hour

On Monday, Budweiser joined the non-fungible token craze with the launch of its first collection of unique pieces of digital art — depictions of beer cans that sold for hundreds of dollars ... Read more »

Forget the "New Normal." There's No Normal in Marketing.

Over the past 18 months, companies navigating the pandemic have dealt with numerous changes to seemingly every facet of work. Beyond shifts in daily routines, work lives, and social behavior, ... Read more »

This Crypto-Fueled Internet Collective Raised More Than $40 Million to Buy a Rare Copy of the Constitution

The United States Constitution is more than just another document: It’s the foundation upon which this entire country has been built. In the most significant possible sense, it’s what attempts to ... Read more »

The Use Of Recycled Plastics In Packaging Of Food And Drinks Needs To Be Re-Deliberated: Experts

LawWiser, India’s first video-only knowledge-sharing platform for the legal community, today released a consultation paper on ‘The Dilemma of Recycling Plastics in India’. The objective of this consultation paper is ... Read more »

Vehicles Rental Industry Is booming With Technological Advancements

With the evolving technology and innovative ideas, it has been made easy for emerging startups to enter the market and establish their identity in the respective domain that they cater ... Read more »

Key Agritech Trends To Expect In 2022

Investors’ interest in agritech startups has increased tremendously today as agritech is one of the few sectors that not only survived but thrived during the pandemic.  According to industry reports, ... Read more »

Watch: New Navy chief takes mother's blessings on taking charge

Admiral Hari Kumar was serving as the Flag Officer Commanding-in-Chief of the Western Naval Command before his elevation. Admiral R Hari Kumar took over as the country’s Navy chief, succeeding ... Read more »

Rihanna declared national hero of Barbados as island becomes republic

Rihanna was honored as a National Hero at Barbados’s Presidential Inauguration Ceremony. Fireworks filled the sky over Barbados on Tuesday as the Caribbean island nation declared itself the world’s newest ... Read more »

OnePlus 9 price in India is lower than OnePlus 9R ahead of rumoured OnePlus 9RT launch

Customers can also claim the OnePlus 9 discount offer on the company’s official website. OnePlus 9 price in India at launch was set at Rs 49,999. The premium smartphone under ... Read more »

What's the fuss about Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal's tweet from 11 years ago?

Parag Agrawal was appointed as the chief executive officer (CEO) of Twitter on Monday. Parag Agrawal, who took over as the new head of Twitter, shot from relative obscurity as ... Read more »

Storyboard18 | ‘I can tell a story, and the moral of that story can be your product or service': aiyyoshraddha

Shraddha Jain is popularly known on the Internet as aiyyoshraddha. Shraddha Jain spent nine years as a radio jockey and then some time working in the television industry where she ... Read more »

What Does 2022 Hold For India's D2C Market?

India’s D2C market is on an all-time rise and is not set to slow down anytime soon. While the COVID-19 pandemic certainly gave way to business disruptions across verticals, categorically ... Read more »

Redmi Note 11T 5G launched in India to take on Realme 8s 5G, Lava Agni 5G

Redmi Note 11T 5G specifications include a MediaTek Dimensity 810 SoC and a 5000 mAh battery. Redmi Note 11T 5G launched in India is Xiaomi’s new budget 5G smartphone under ... Read more »

Elliot Page, 'Juno' star, shows off six-packs in shirtless mirror selfie

Elliot Page came out as transgender in December 2020. Actor Elliot Page on Monday showed off his six-packs in a selfie on Instagram, almost a year after he came out ... Read more »

"Agrawal ji ka beta": As Parag Agrawal becomes Twitter CEO, memes galore

Parag Agrawal, 37, holds a PhD in computer science from Stanford University and a bachelor’s degree in computer science and engineering from Indian Institute of Technology-Bombay. Minutes after Parag Agrawal ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic