Stepmother jailed for murdering boy, 6, as family say authorities ‘failed' him

A six-year-old boy murdered by his stepmother after being subjected to “sadistic” and “appalling” cruelty, was “failed by the very authorities” tasked with keeping him safe, his grandmother has said.

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes was left with an unsurvivable brain injury while in the sole care of “evil” 32-year-old Emma Tustin.

She was jailed for life with a minimum term of 29 years at Coventry Crown Court on Friday, after being convicted of murder by assaulting defenceless Arthur in the hallway of her Cranmore Road home in Solihull, on June 16, 2020.

Arthur, whose body was also covered in 130 bruises, died in hospital the next day.

“Manipulative” and “calculating” Tustin was unanimously convicted after an eight-week trial trial, with the boy’s “pitiless” father Thomas Hughes, 29, found guilty of his manslaughter, after encouraging the killing.

Hughes’ “infatuation” for Tustin had “obliterated” any love for his son, the sentencing judge said.

He was jailed for 21 years, during the pair’s sentencing hearing.

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes with his father, Thomas Hughes, and stepmother, Emma Tustin (West Midlands Police/Family/PA)

It emerged at trial that Arthur had been seen by social workers just two months before his death, after concerns were raised by his paternal grandmother Joanne Hughes, but they concluded there were “no safeguarding concerns”.

In her victim impact statement, which she read in court ahead of the sentencing, Ms Hughes said Arthur, as a “happy, contented, thriving seven-year-old” would “be alive today” had her son not met Tustin.

The secondary school teacher added: “It is also clear that Arthur was failed by the very authorities that we, as a society, are led to believe are there to ensure the safety of everyone.”

An independent review is now under way into the authorities’ contact with Arthur before his death.

Arthur, in happier times, on a visit to McDonald’s (Family/West Midlands Police)

That work will include examining other potential missed opportunities to intervene, including an anonymous call Tustin’s own stepfather John Dutton claimed in court to have made to social services, and contact with the police from Hughes’ brother about Arthur’s bruises.

The Independent Office of Police Conduct (IOPC) is set to publish a report into West Midlands Police’s contact with the case, in due course, but has said it “found no indication any individual behaved in a manner that justified disciplinary proceedings”.

As the sentencing began Mr Justice Mark Wall QC said Tustin had been brought to court for her sentencing but had “refused to come up” to the dock.

Instead he addressed his remarks to Hughes and Tustin’s empty chair.

It also emerged during the hearing how Tustin twice made attempts to take her own life during the trial which jurors were previously told had been periodically delayed for “health” reasons.

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes (Family/PA)

Mr Justice Wall started by saying the trial had been “without doubt one of the most distressing and disturbing cases I have had to deal with”, adding neither Hughes not Tustin had shown any remorse.

The judge said Arthur had been, at the time Tustin was introduced into his life, a “healthy, happy young boy”.

But less than three months after moving in with Tustin at the start of the first national lockdown, the little boy was left “broken” from exposure to a campaign of “acute or prolonged abuse,” he said.

Tustin was also convicted of two counts of child cruelty, including salt-poisoning and withholding food and drink from Arthur.

She had admitted two other cruelty counts, wilfully assaulting Arthur on three occasions and isolating him, including by forcing him to stand in the hallway for up to 14 hours a day as part of a draconian punishment regime.

Labourer Hughes was also convicted of the cruelty offences which Tustin had admitted but was cleared of withholding food and drink, or of poisoning his own son with salt.

rthur Labinjo-Hughes with his natural mother, Olivia Labinjo-Halcrow (Olivia Labinjo-Halcrow/PA)

Tustin was jailed for 10 years each, and Hughes nine years each, for the cruelty charges they admitted or were convicted of, all to be served concurrently.

The judge said Tustin had poisoned the boy with a “significant” amount of salt just hours before fatally assaulting the youngster, and had also been administering “smaller doses of salt for some time” to his meals.

“He was forced to live a solitary and lonely life within your home, including being made to stand to attention alone in the hallway of the house for most of the day,” he added.

Emma Tustin (West Midlands Police/PA)

Jailing the pair, he said: “This cruel and inhuman treatment of Arthur was a deliberate decision by you to brush off his cries for help as naughtiness.”

The judge added the couple’s behaviour was “appalling” and also, at times, acts that were “spiteful and sadistic” in their banal cruelty.

He drew attention to Hughes “ripping up” his son’s beloved Birmingham City Football Club shirts and buying ice creams for him and Tustin but skipping buying one for his starving son.

“They are but examples of how you relished in making him suffer,” he added.

The judge said it was a “shocking feature” of the case that Tustin and her own children lived “a perfectly happy, normal life” in the same home “while this appalling cruelty to Arthur was taking place”.

Tustin also recorded 200 audio files and videos of Arthur’s suffering and punishment, often sending them to Hughes to back her false claims he was being “naughty”.

Thomas Hughes. (West Midlands Police/PA)

The judge said anyone could have seen the boy’s responses were a “cry for help from a deeply unhappy child”, whom Tustin was, by then, deliberately starving and refusing water.

And he told Hughes, who had claimed in evidence he only realised after Arthur’s death how abusive his own behaviour was, that these were “self-serving lies”.

He said Tustin made a “calculated” decision to kill, adding: “I am sure that at the moment you launched this attack on him you intended that he should die.”

“You are a manipulative woman who will tell any lie, and shift the blame onto anyone, to save your own skin,” he added.

“You wanted Thomas Hughes so he could provide for you and your own children but did not want to be troubled by Arthur any longer.”

The judge called Hughes’ “encouragement” of his girlfriend’s actions “chilling”, including sending a text message 18 hours before the attack saying “just end him”.

He added: “You were Arthur’s father, in a position of trust and bore primary responsibility for protecting him.

“He was extremely vulnerable and you lied to his school in last days of Arthur’s life to protect both you and Ms Tustin.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Gold, silver prices today: Precious metals witness dip on MCX | Check latest rates here

Both gold and silver are trading on the lower side of the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX) on Thursday, January 27, 2022. Witnessing a drop of Rs 569 or 1.16 per ... Read more »

Key bond market deals: PNB Metlife India, RCF, NIIF infra Finance

© Provided by CNBCTV18 Here’s a look at the key bond market deals on Thursday. Non-Convertible Debentures: PNB Metlife India Insurance accepts bids worth INR 400 crore on 10-year subordinated ... Read more »

Oil companies map retail expansion with tech

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: For years, a large parcel of empty land along Coimbatore-Trichy road would attract a young IndianOil executive’s attention. Today, the site ... Read more »

New Jersey political consultant admits to murder-for-hire plot

Sean Caddle recruited a team to kill Michael Galdieri in exchange for thousands of dollars. Sean Caddle/Twitter A one-time New Jersey political consultant has admitted to orchestrating a murder-for-hire plot ... Read more »

Apple's iPhone retakes top spot in China smartphone market: research

© SPENCER PLATT Apple’s iPhone is back on top in China after six years Apple reclaimed its position as the top smartphone seller in China after six years, clocking a ... Read more »

'It's a massacre': survivors recall N. Ireland's 'Bloody Sunday'

© Paul Faith The British paratroopers were ‘fierce looking, (they) terrified you really’, said former priest Denis Bradley Denis Bradley was only 26 when he witnessed British paratroopers shoot dead ... Read more »

Wie stimmst du am 13. Februar ab?

Bald stehen wieder Abstimmungen an. Hast du dich schon entschieden? Nimm hier an unserer Umfrage teil. © 20min/Celia Nogler Am nächsten Abstimmungssonntag kommen vier Vorlagen an die Urne. Tier- und ... Read more »

Sensex plunges over 1,000 points, Nifty below 17K as Fed signals rate hike in March

NEW DELHI: It was a terrible Thursday morning for domestic equity investors who woke up to a global carnage led by the US Fed commentary on ‘persistent’ inflation, its signal ... Read more »

Protest over RRB results: Student unions call for ‘Bihar Bandh' on Friday | 10 points

© Provided by Hindustan Times Smoke comes out from a train’s carriage after angry mobs set it on fire in protests over RRB results, in Bihar’s Gaya on Wednesday. (AFP ... Read more »

Uttar Pradesh assembly elections 2022: Process of filing nomination for 4th phase begins today

© Provided by Zee News NEW DELHI: The process of filing nominations for the fourth phase of assembly polls in Uttar Pradesh will begin with the state election commission issuance ... Read more »

US delivers written response to Russian demands over Ukraine crisis

© Provided by The Statesman US delivers written response to Russian demands over Ukraine crisis The United States has delivered a written response to Moscow amid growing tension between Russia ... Read more »

UN envoy urges Taliban to enhance engagement with international community

© Provided by The Statesman UN envoy urges Taliban to enhance engagement with international community The UN’s top envoy in Afghanistan, Deborah Lyons on Wednesday urged the Taliban to demonstrate ... Read more »

Tired of the Sun Playing Peek-a-Boo This January? Here's Why Delhi's Bone-Chilling Winter Refuses to End

© Provided by News18 Tired of the Sun Playing Peek-a-Boo This January? Here’s Why Delhi’s Bone-Chilling Winter Refuses to End Every year, Delhi brings out its woolens and quilts in ... Read more »

PM Modi to host first India-Central Asia Summit today

© Provided by The Statesman PM Modi to host first India-Central Asia Summit today Prime Minister Narendra Modi will on Thursday host the first India-Central Asia Summit to take ties ... Read more »

Imran Khan govt has made Pakistan hotbed of corruption: Opposition leader

© Provided by The Statesman Imran Khan govt has made Pakistan hotbed of corruption: Opposition leader Chaudhry Qamar Zaman Kaira, the leader of the opposition Pakistan Peoples Party has said ... Read more »

Haryana extends Covid-19 restrictions till February 10; theatres, gyms to remain shut

© Provided by Zee News Chandigarh: Haryana government on Wednesday announced the extension of the COVID-19 restrictions in the state till February 10. “The COVID guidelines released through government orders ... Read more »

Afghanistan emerging as a deep security hole. Can Iran's revolutionary generals see it?

© Provided by The Print Iran was a key beneficiary of the post-Taliban order and a junior partner in the Pakistan-led anti-American coalition that eventually succeeded on 15 August 2021. ... Read more »

Aussie children CAN be vaccinated against their parents' wishes - as doctor explains how it's completely legal

A Melbourne paediatrician claims doctors can vaccinate children as young as 12 without their parents’ consent – and stay within the law. An article in the Medical Journal of Australia ... Read more »

Video: Abbie Chatfield breaks her silence as photo surfaces of her dancing at a pub on Australia Day... after she condemned influencers for celebrating on a day of mourning

Read more »

Najib gagal hidupkan semula saman terhadap bank, bekas pegawai kerana cuai

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Mahkamah Rayuan mendapati tiada merit dalam rayuan dibuat bekas Perdana Menteri Najib Razak. PUTRAJAYA: Mahkamah Rayuan hari ini menolak permohonan Najib Razak menghidupkan semula ... Read more »

Macaulay Culkin and Brenda Song Are Engaged After 4 Years of Dating

Taking the next step! Macaulay Culkin and Brenda Song are engaged after four years together, a source confirms to Us Weekly. © Shutterstock (2) Mandatory Credit: Photo by Broadimage/Shutterstock (9919824ds) ... Read more »

Sue Gray news – live: Legal checks delay Partygate report as Rees-Mogg insists PM will survive scandal

LIVE – Updated at 03:27 MPs and the British public will have to wait at least another day to hear from Boris Johnson about the findings of Sue Gray’s Partygate ... Read more »

Samsung sets revenue records with stronger product sales

© Photo by Vjeran Pavic / The Verge Samsung Electronics broke both its quarterly and annual records for revenue in the fourth quarter of 2021, making 13.87 trillion won (~$11.5 ... Read more »

Shehnaaz Gill birthday special: Sidharth Shukla throwing Sana in the pool after celebrations will remind you of SidNaaz's happy times – watch video

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com It is Shehnaaz Gill’s birthday today. The gorgeous actress and singer has come a long way in the entertainment industry. Her popularity witnessed a major jump ... Read more »

Dulquer Salmaan shares glimpses of his beautiful moments with wife Amal & they set vacay and couple goals

© Provided by Pinkvilla Dulquer Salmaan and his Amal Sufiyaa visited the famous Rathnambore Fort for a family vacation. The actor, who is currently under home isolation due to COVID-19, ... Read more »

Ram Charan and Keerthy Suresh dance on Naatu Naatu at pre-release event of Good Luck Sakhi; video goes VIRAL

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com Keerthy Suresh starrer Good Luck Sakhi is all set to release in theatres on 28th January 2022. Recently, the makers of the film had organised a ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15 Day 114 Written Update: Shamita has no interest in Karan Kundrra, says I am only Bapat's

In just three days, we will witness the grand finale of Bigg Boss 15. Among the five finalists, one contestant will lift the coveted trophy, and we are all excited ... Read more »

Japan's Mitsubishi, energy body join Gates' nuclear project

TOKYO — Mitsubishi Heavy Industries and the Japan Atomic Energy Agency have signed an agreement to participate in a next-generation nuclear energy project with TerraPower, a company started by Bill ... Read more »

Mum shares her 'miracle' shower cleaning buy that left her foggy shower screen crystal clear: 'It's literally amazing'

Mum discovers $12 cleaning product that leaves her shower looking crystal clearShe uses 'CLR' remover to make her shower screen glass look as good as newThe mum poured equal amounts of hot water and CLR into an empty spray bottleShe soaks the screen, scrubs it, rinses it with water & uses a squeegee to finish  Read more »

Incredible moment brave dad saves neighbour's puppy from being crushed to death by a monster python

A Melbourne father-of-two saved a young family's pet puppy 'Panda' from snake Stewart Brasier had just cracked open a beer when he heard a commotion  He jumped back fence of his Sunshine Coast Airbnb to find pup being crushed The pub owner wrestled the snake off the dog much to relief of Staffy's owners  Read more »

PKR guna logo sendiri bukti PH ‘berpecah', kata penganalisis

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Penganalisis menolak alasan bahawa bendera Pakatan Harapan (PH) kurang dikenali berbanding PKR. PETALING JAYA: Keputusan Pakatan Harapan (PH) untuk membenarkan PKR menggunakan logo sendiri ... Read more »

7 penyelamat terus usaha cari budak Orang Asli hilang 2 minggu

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today PETALING JAYA: Usaha mencari seorang kanak-kanak perempuan Orang Asli yang hilang hampir dua minggu lepas diteruskan dengan mereka yang dekat dengan usaha menyelamat berkenaan ... Read more »

Kerajaan lancar Pelan Keselamatan Jalan Raya Malaysia

© Provided by Sinar Harian PUTRAJAYA – Kerajaaan melancarkan Pelan Keselamatan Jalan Raya Malaysia (PKJRM) 2022-2030 dengan menetapkan sasaran pengurangan jumlah kematian akibat nahas jalan raya sekurang-kurangnya pada kadar 50 ... Read more »

COVID-19: Changes to periods from coronavirus vaccines 'small' and quickly reverse' says expert

A study in the US found a single dose was not linked to a change to a woman's cycle, while the second jab delay a period by an average of 0.45 days. If a woman got both doses in a single cycle, the delay was 2.32 days. Read more »

Covid-19: Kadar kebolehjangkitan negara meningkat 1.13 pada Rabu

© Provided by Sinar Harian SHAH ALAM – Kadar kebolehjangkitan (Rt) Covid-19 di dalam negara merekodkan lonjakan sehingga mencecah 1.13 pada Rabu selepas menunjukkan persamaan pada Isnin dan Selasa pada ... Read more »

Bersatu Johor kenal pasti pengganti Muhyiddin di DUN Gambir

© Provided by MalaysiaNow Bersatu telah mengenal pasti calon yang berkelayakan untuk bertanding bagi Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Gambir, dalam Pilihan Raya Negeri (PRN) Johor. Ketua Penerangan Bersatu Negeri Johor ... Read more »

#KpopTwitter2021: Filipinos are one of the most passionate and active K-pop fans in the world

With a massive 7.8 billion Tweets globally in 2021, #KpopTwitter once again showed its power by breaking its previous record of 6.7 billion Tweets in 2020. Registering a notable 16% ... Read more »

BBM willing to make his SALN public

FORMER senator and presidential hopeful Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. said on Wednesday he was willing to make his Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN) public but warned those ... Read more »

NTC grants ABS-CBN frequencies to AMBS, SMNI, Aliw

— The National Telecommunications Commission has given both the analog and digital broadcast frequencies previously held by ABS-CBN Corp. to Villar-led Advanced Media Broadcasting System, Inc. The NTC also assigned ... Read more »

China to 'perfect' legal rules against unfair competition

© Reuters/Aly Song FILE PHOTO: A man stands at a crossroads in Lujiazui financial district in Pudong, Shanghai BEIJING (Reuters) – China will pick up the pace in “perfecting” legal ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic