States spent at least $89 million on COVID-19 vaccine lotteries. None of them worked, new research suggests.

Asia's Tech News Daily

© David Zalubowski/AP Heidi Russell, of Aurora, Colorado, was the fifth and final $1 million winner in the state’s vaccine lottery. David Zalubowski/AP

  • States’ vaccine lotteries did not raise COVID-19 vaccination rates, new research suggests.
  • The tens of millions of dollars spent on those lotteries were not a good use of funds, economists say.
  • The finding could inform plans for future public-health emergencies.

In the spring, when Ohio announced it was holding a $1 million lottery to encourage residents to get vaccinated for COVID-19, many governors’ ears perked up. Could incentivizing people to get shots – rather than mandating them – actually work?

At first, the answer seemed to be yes. In Ohio, the vaccination rate spiked 33% in May, with 119,394 people age 16 and up receiving the vaccine in the week after the lottery was announced. That’s compared to 89,464 shots given the week prior, an Associated Press analysis found.

Before long, more than a dozen states had announced their own versions of Ohio’s “Vax-a-Million,” including “VaxCash” in Maryland and “Vax and Scratch” in New York.

But that early trend didn’t seem to hold. Research published in JAMA Health Forum on Friday suggests that none of the states’ lotteries were effective at raising vaccination rates.

To reach that conclusion, researchers analyzed state-level COVID-19 vaccination data between April and July 2021, when shots were widely available and while 19 states were running vaccine lotteries. Their results indicated that the association between those states’ announcements and their respective vaccination rates was “very small in magnitude and statistically indistinguishable from zero.”

“There’s a lot of hype around these programs, and we can’t find any evidence that they helped,” Andrew Friedson, a coauthor of the research and associate professor of economics at University of Colorado Denver, told Insider.

That’s despite huge sums spent on these programs.

“Each state’s doing several drawings, and these drawings are around a $1 million a pop, although some of them are less. With 19 states, you’re looking at a large amount of money that’s been spent on this,” Friedson said.

The researchers only included cash lotteries in their analysis, leaving out non-cash items like drawings to win a hunting license, which was a vaccine prize in Arkansas. They also didn’t take into account private sweepstakes, such as the $1 million cash prizes that Kroger awarded to five people who got vaccinated in Kroger supermarkets.

© Tony Dejak/AP A man walks by signs for Ohio’s COVID-19 mass vaccination clinic at Cleveland State University on May 25, 2021. Tony Dejak/AP

Nor did the paper calculate exactly how much money states cumulatively spent on lottery programs. So Insider combined Friedman’s estimate of lottery spending in 11 states ($50 million) with data provided by six additional state health departments ($39.4 million).

The rough grand total: At least $89.4 million.

Two states – Massachusetts and Maine – not included in Friedman’s estimate did not respond to Insider’s request, so that total is likely an underestimation. Additionally, a spokesperson for North Carolina’s health department pointed out that the state’s lottery money came from federal coronavirus relief funding.

“No state funds have been used to pay for the prizes,” she told Insider.

‘This may not be the first innovation we want to reach for’

Friedson called the results of the paper disappointing, since many people were rooting for these programs.

“There’s an opportunity cost to spending money. Every dollar that you’re spending on a lottery, you could have been spending on something else. That’s the really economist-y answer,” he said, adding, “so to the extent that we have policies that could have helped people, that we could have been spending money on, these were not a great use of funds.”

Still, it’s a learning opportunity, Friedson said: “Sadly, this is not gonna be the last time we’re going to have a national public-health campaign.”

Whenever the next public-health emergency arrives, whether it’s a campaign for COVID-19 booster shots or another pandemic, it’s important to know what doesn’t work as well as what does.

“With regard to policies to try to raise vaccination rates, this may not be the first innovation we want to reach for,” Friedson said.

© Ted S. Warren/AP Staff Sgt. Travis Snyder receives the Pfizer vaccine at Madigan Army Medical Center at Joint Base Lewis-McChord in Washington state on December 16, 2020. Ted S. Warren/AP

So which incentives, if any, do work?

As an economist, Friedson said, suggesting an alternative approach that would work is beyond his purview. For the scientists focused on that, it’s a process of experimentation.

“The short answer is, we don’t know until we try these things,” Friedson said.

Previous research may hint at an answer.

A review of scientific literature about interventions to address vaccine hesitancy, published prior to the pandemic, did not find strong evidence that monetary rewards have much effect on vaccination rates. But those campaigns largely focused on children, not adults.

That said, Nichole Lighthall, an assistant psychology professor at the University of Central Florida, told ABC News in May that guaranteed cash rewards, such as the $100 savings bonds that West Virginia offered residents for getting vaccinated, may work better than lotteries.

“People like to gamble, but people love to get money for sure even more,” she said.

There’s a possibility, though, that Americans’ beliefs about COVID-19 vaccines are too deeply rooted for a reward to be effective, in larger part because of the way some leaders and groups politicized them.

“If you buy into the idea that vaccines are dangerous – and I can’t stress enough that that this idea is wrong – but if you believe that there’s something sinister going on with this vaccine, it’s unlikely that a payment is going to convince you, regardless of how big it is,” Friedson said.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

The 16 Best Fleece-Lined Joggers to Snuggle Up In

© Provided by Marie Claire US Best Fleece-Lined Sweatpants It’s almost 2022, and we’re still dressing nicely exclusively from the waist up. While some people opt for a pair of ... Read more »

Bidens honour Pearl Harbour's fallen in visit to World War Two memorial

President Joe Biden and first lady Jill Biden have marked the 80th anniversary of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbour with a sombre visit to the World War Two Memorial ... Read more »

Pip The Troll Creator Hilariously Reacts To His Appearance In The MCU

Rich Fury/Getty This article contains spoilers for Marvel’s “Eternals.” Fans of Marvel’s 1970s-era “Eternals” comic got a great treat during the mid-credit scene of Marvel’s big-screen adaption of the franchise. ... Read more »

Biden told Putin that 'things we did not do in 2014, we are prepared to do now' if Russia escalates in Ukraine, top adviser says

The White House says President Joe Biden told Russian President Vladimir Putin on Tuesday that the United States is prepared to launch strong economic measures should Russia invade Ukraine — ... Read more »

Pennsylvania Military Museum ceremony marks 80th anniversary of Pearl Harbor attack

The Pennsylvania Military Museum in Boalsburg held a Pearl Harbor commemoration on Tuesday — the 80th anniversary of the attack. Tyler Gum, director of the museum, shared history and reminded ... Read more »

Police arrest 17-year-old Everett student after gun found on school grounds

The main entrance of Everett High School in Lansing. [LSJ file photo] LANSING — A 17-year-old male student was arrested at Everett High School Tuesday after officials found a gun ... Read more »

Lecturer ‘who couldn't stop being loud' wins unfair dismissal case

After being accused of shouting at a student in 2019, Dr Annette Plaut was suspended and then sacked from the University of Exeter later that year. – Jay Williams Celebrated ... Read more »

Vaccine Stocks: Omicron Partially Eludes Pfizer-BioNTech In New Study

Vaccine Stocks: Omicron Partially Eludes Pfizer–BioNTech In New Study Vaccine stocks were muted Tuesday after test results indicated omicron might elude some of the protection provided by Pfizer’s Covid shot. Read more »

WATCH LIVE: Body found in New Port Richey ID'd as Kathleen Moore, Pasco sheriff says

A New Port Richey man was arrested in the death of a missing Pinellas woman Monday. Court documents follow the investigation into their relationship and what ultimately led to the ... Read more »

Bay Area remembers Pearl Harbor 80 years ago

The Bay Area remembers Pearl Harbor 80 years ago. James Torrez attacks Read more »

Soccer-Perfect Liverpool eliminate Milan as Origi and Salah seal comeback win

1 / 3Soccer-Perfect Liverpool eliminate Milan as Origi and Salah seal comeback winChampions League – Group B – AC Milan v Liverpool MILAN, Italy (Reuters) – Liverpool came from behind ... Read more »

Bank predicts $3.6 million windfall from Manafort loans

A bank that loaned former Trump campaign manager Paul Manafort $16 million expects a $3.6 million surplus from foreclosure on Manafort’s properties, even though the loans played a role in ... Read more »

Omo, Kim Da Mi And Choi Woo Shik Have Worked Together Before And It's For A *Thriller* Movie

© Provided by Cosmopolitan Philippines Thanks to Itaewon Class, Kim Da Mi became one of my favorite Korean actresses of all time. Her character in the drama is fierce, determined, and although she’s a ... Read more »

Muntinlupa vaccinates over 8,000 in a day

© The Manila Times MUNTINLUPA City exceeded its daily target on Day Two of the “Bakunahan Bayanihan” campaign with more than 8,000 individuals inoculated. The Muntinlupa City Health Office (CHO) ... Read more »

Campaign launched to drum up business for pandemic-battered Manitoba retailers

© Lyzaville Sale/CBC Shoppers line up outside a Winnipeg Walmart location in late November 2020. The Manitoba Chambers of Commerce launched a “BuyLocalMB” campaign Tuesday to encourage shoppers to make ... Read more »

Aftonbladet: Man arrested for the murder of a 12-year-old girl in Sweden

According to the newspaper Aftonbladet, a man has been arrested in Stockholm under suspicion for the murder of a 12-year-old girl. She was killed in Botkyrka last year. The newspaper ... Read more »

GOP senator says Biden's 'radical' Treasury pick could 'turn banking into... the DMV'

Bill Hagery explains how much Saule Omarova would control if chosen as Comptroller of the Currency Read more »

DICT successfully launched six Emerging Technologies Workshops in partnership with Huawei Philippines

The Department of Information and Communications Technology (DICT), in partnership with Huawei Philippines, successfully hosted six Emerging Technologies Workshops for government employees this year. © Provided by LionhearTV More than ... Read more »

Indigenous papal postponed to 2022 amid concerns around Omicron COVID-19 variant

OTTAWA — Indigenous leaders and residential school survivors will not travel to the Vatican as planned this month to meet with Pope Francis because of the latest threat posed by ... Read more »

ITV's Christmas TV for 2021 – including The Masked Singalong and the return of Bradley and Barney Walsh and their iconic RV…

Photo credit: ITV Get ready for Christmas classics and festive fun this Yuletide, as ITV have confirmed what will be on air this holiday season. Here is a list of ... Read more »

Dad of ‘Rust' armorer ‘not worried' about possibility of daughter going to prison

Thell Reed spoke to ABC News about the tragic accident. Courtesy of ABC News The father of Hannah Gutierrez-Reed, the 24-year-old armorer of “Rust,” said he doesn’t believe his daughter ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb shock as Snoochie Shy brutally kicked out of camp – and fans are fuming

SNOOCHIE Shy was kicked out of I'm A Celebrity tonight – leaving fans fuming. But the 29-year-old DJ, model and presenter didn't seem too down about it, telling her campmates: ... Read more »

Opinion: Cool, calm and collected — Merkel leaves but her political style remains

© Provided by dw.com Angela Merkel wisely chose when to leave office People initially underestimated the German chancellor — but she has led four governments and mastered a series of ... Read more »

The joke's on us, South Africa. The cruel logic of Omicron travel bans — debunked

Wealthy nations were quick to ban southern African nations from entering their borders when the Omicron variant of Covid-19 was identified — but not against each other. Unfortunately, this type ... Read more »

University of Pretoria study finds that some hand sanitisers are substandard

© https://www.123rf.com/stock-photo/coronavirus.html?oriSearch=black+business&sti=nwa579di4v817os8iw|&… © chai89/123rf.com CAPE TOWN – Some commercial off-the-shelf hand sanitisers in Tshwane are substandard and do not contain the recommended alcohol content. A University of Pretoria study has ... Read more »

Surge in piracy costing W. Africa nations: UN

© PIUS UTOMI EKPEI Special forces of the Nigerian navy during the five-day joint military exercise on fighting piracy between Nigeria and French navy. The surge of maritime piracy in ... Read more »

Ordinary South Africans reflect on the Constitution

Friday, 10 December 2021 marks 25 years of our country’s Constitution. Maverick Citizen will publish articles throughout the week commemorating the occasion with various reflections from ordinary South Africans and ... Read more »

Global calls grow for the lifting of the southern African travel ban

Omicron is now spreading inside Britain. Doesn’t this mean London should lift the controversial travel ban on South Africa and other southern African countries, as the horse has already bolted? ... Read more »

Vaccine mandates in the retail industry pick up, but many companies remain reluctant to enforce the jab

Barring two large retailers in South Africa, the broader retail industry has mostly tiptoed around the issue of mandating its workers to be vaccinated against Covid-19 while the country is ... Read more »

Cloudy skies, scattered rains over Visayas, Caraga, Bicol due to the shear line

© Arun Sankar/AFP rain thumbnail umbrella thumbnail weather thumbnail Shaun Curry/AFP The shear line will be affecting the eastern section of Visayas while the northeast monsoon will be affecting Luzon ... Read more »

Pagcor finances evacuation center project in Eastern Samar

© The Manila Times Eastern Samar Vice Gov. Maria Caridad Sison-Goteesan (7th from right) and Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corp. (Pagcor) acting Vice President for Corporate Social Responsibility Ramon Stephen ... Read more »

U.S. CEO fires 900 employees over three-minute Zoom call

© Provided by Global News Vishal Garg, the CEO of Better.com, appears in a screengrab of video shared of the Zoom call. The CEO of Better.com might want to consider ... Read more »

Normalcy by June if Omicron stays less virulent, says expert

© Provided by The Times of India MUMBAI: Life could get back to normal by June 2022 if Covid’s latest avatar, Omicron, turns out to be less virulent than other ... Read more »

'Brazen' N.S. prison assault calls for sentences that deter prison violence: Crown

HALIFAX — A prosecutor presented evidence of rising violence in Nova Scotia’s jails Tuesday as he called for tough sentences against inmates who took part in a “brazen” and orchestrated ... Read more »

BJP-led civic bodies to take action against ‘illegal' liquor shops in Delhi

The BJP-led municipal corporations are at loggerheads with the Delhi government over the new excise policy that allegedly allows the opening of new liquor shops in residential areas. South Delhi ... Read more »

The Holidays Are A Good Excuse To Finally Buy That Dyson (Especially When It's On Sale)

There are vacuums and then there are Dyson vacuums — these decked-out cleaning machines come as lightweight cordless sticks, heavy-duty corded rollers, and even smaller nifty handhelds that eliminate dust ... Read more »

Ludhiana: Man mowed down near DMCH hostel

© Provided by Hindustan Times The incident had taken place on December 6 while the victim was crossing the road. Bystanders say the accused was driving at high speed and ... Read more »

ICMR's new rapid tests set to be cheaper, give results in 30 mins

© Provided by The Times of India PUNE: A soon-to-be-introduced and visually interpreted rapid Covid test – developed by the Indian Council of Medical Research-National Institute of Virology and transferred ... Read more »

Danny Miller: Who is Emmerdale star on I'm a Celebrity 2021?

© ITV im_a_celebrity_get_me_out_of_here_sr21_04.jpg Danny Miller is one of this year’s competitors on I’m a Celebrity… Get Me Out of Here! The 30-year-old actor – who became a father in October ... Read more »

Like-minded parties outside UPA must unite to fight BJP, says Pawar

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Amid rumblings in the opposition camp, Nationalist Congress party of Sharad Pawar Tuesday said that there are more like-minded parties outside ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic