State AGs are 'stepping into the police reform business' to hold officers accountable

In the past month, attorneys general in three states have sought a court-ordered overhaul of local police departments, increasingly filling the role the federal government has played for decades of holding accountable police departments that are deemed to be behaving badly.

© CQ Roll Call/Sipa/AP/Bloomberg/Getty Images Attorneys General Kwame Raoul of Illinois, left, Phil Weiser of Colorado and Rob Bonta of California used their authority to investigate local police departments.

State officials have been initiating investigations into local police departments, recognizing that the federal government can’t take on every case nationwide. Their move into this area of police reform is in part filling a gap created by the Trump administration, which all but stopped opening pattern or practice investigations into local police departments.

© David Zalubowski/AP/FILE “The only option was to use our authority,” Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser said of the investigation into the Aurora Police Department.

While these investigations are regarded as even more important amid heightened public scrutiny of law enforcement, there is disagreement on whether federal involvement in local policing leads to tangible reform, experts say.

© Rich Pedroncelli/AP/FILE California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced an agreement in August with the city of Bakersfield to overhaul its police department.

“Just as the Justice Department has learned and is still learning how to use this tool effectively, I have no doubt that states will face the same challenges and I think they will be able to learn to some extent from what the feds have done,” said Christy Lopez, a Georgetown University law professor who led the Justice Department’s investigation of the Chicago Police Department.

In Illinois, Attorney General Kwame Raoul announced an investigation into the Joliet Police Department in September after an in-custody death and its potential cover-up was documented by USA Today.

In California, Attorney General Rob Bonta announced an agreement in August with the city of Bakersfield to overhaul its police department after an investigation initiated by the Justice Department in 2016.

In Colorado, the state’s attorney general last week released the findings of an investigation that his office began last year after the death of Elijah McClain at the hands of Aurora police officers and paramedics. In Illinois and Colorado, state legislatures only recently gave the attorneys general the authority to investigate local police departments.

© Noreen Nasir/AP/FILE Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul initiated a formal investigation into the Joliet Police Department.

“We started this investigation under the prior (presidential) administration, and they had a categorical policy of not conducting these investigations,” said Colorado Attorney General Philip Weiser. “They were trying to dismantle existing consent decrees and not conducting new pattern and practice investigations. When we started this in the summer of 2020, (a federal investigation) wasn’t an option. The only option was to use our authority.”

Scrutiny’s on law enforcement in more ways

Consent decrees are an uncommon tool of last resort used by the Department of Justice to reform hesitant police departments, first by investigating how they work and then using the findings of the investigation to force their city or county government into an agreement to change. The Department of Justice has done a few dozen of these investigations in the last two decades, after Congress gave it that authority in 1994.

© David Zalubowski/AP/FILE Elijah McClain’s death prompted an investigation into the Aurora Police Department in Colorado.

“Generally speaking, the department is supportive of state attorneys general exercising their authority to address systemic problems in local police departments,” a DOJ official told CNN.

During the four years of the Trump administration, the DOJ conducted one investigation into one unit of one police department. The DOJ, under President Joe Biden, has announced investigations into the Minneapolis, Louisville, and Phoenix police departments. Still, together, experts say, they represent a tiny fraction of the thousands of police departments that exist as parts of local, county, and state governments across the country.

“Already in the Biden administration you’ve got Minneapolis, Louisville, Phoenix. Out of 18,000 police departments, that’s a drop in the bucket,” said Chuck Wexler, executive director of the Police Executive Research Forum (PERF), a national police research and policy organization that advises police leaders on best practices. “I think what you’re seeing is division of labor. Some attorney generals are stepping into the police reform business.”

© Frederic J. Brown/AFP/Getty Images/FILE Greg Terry, chief of the Bakersfield Police Department, said “almost immediately we became proactive” after investigation was launched.

State attorneys general investigating police departments is just one of the many ways that scrutiny is being put on law enforcement in the post-George Floyd era. On Wednesday, a group of former and current Black women officers filed a class-action lawsuit against the Washington, DC police claiming racial and sexual discrimination, a hostile workplace and a culture of intimidation.

The 10 women say that while on the job at the Metropolitan Police Department (MPD) they were treated with contempt and subjected to a male-dominated “culture of race and sex discrimination” and “intense pervasive retaliation” when they complained about it, according to the lawsuit.

On the federal level, however, bipartisan talks around overhauling policing laws ended without a deal earlier this week. Six months of negotiations were stalled due to several key sticking points, including qualified immunity, a controversial federal doctrine established by case law that can shield officers and other government employees from civil liability.

State AGs launch probes into police

Police departments targeted by investigations launched by attorneys general are typically in large cities and often follow scandals or high-profile deaths of people in police custody. It’s common for investigators to find problems with training, supervision, or policies.

After the investigation, there’s typically an agreement negotiated between the municipality that oversees the police department and the Department of Justice. That agreement is known as a consent decree, and there’s usually a lawyer or law firm paid by the city to make sure the department implements reforms as outlined in the agreement.

Not every state gives its attorney general authority to initiate investigations, and in some states, attorneys have sought court-ordered reform of departments through lawsuits.

In recent years, at least three state attorneys general have initiated investigations. Illinois and Colorado each gave their attorneys general the authority to investigate local police departments for problematic patterns, and California’s attorney general has had that authority for years.

In 2016, Vice President Kamala Harris, who at the time was the attorney general of California, started an investigation into the Bakersfield Police Department and the Kern County Sheriff’s Office. The police department agreed to some changes last month, including changes to the way officers use and document force and the way supervisors review force.

“It was a comprehensive investigation, collaborative one . . . as they reviewed all of the uses of force, all the officer-involved shootings, citations, just a host of documents over a period of years,” said Greg Terry, chief of the Bakersfield Police Department. “Almost immediately we became proactive in seeking outside policy consultants to look at use of force policies, increased level of training and supervision and oversight of officers.”

A spokesperson for the union representing rank-and-file Bakersfield police officers didn’t respond to a request for comment.

Weiser, a special prosecutor appointed by Colorado Gov. Jared Polis last year, released the findings of a year-long investigation into the Aurora Police Department last week. The investigation was launched after the death of McClain, a 23-year-old Black man who was stopped by police while walking home from a store, placed in a carotid hold and then injected with ketamine.

According to the investigation’s findings, the agency “has a pattern and practice of racially biased policing, using excessive force, and failing to record required information when it interacts with the community,” the report states. Weiser will seek a federal consent decree that will require “specific changes and ongoing independent oversight,” his office announced.

A spokesperson for the Aurora Police Department declined to make the chief or other member of the command staff available for comment.

The trouble with consent decrees

Illinois Attorney General Raoul announced an investigation into the Joliet Police Department after a USA Today report documented officers who had taken custody of an arrestee who swallowed drugs, the conduct of the arresting officers, and an allegation of retaliation against a sergeant who provided information about the case to the media without his department’s permission.

“After receiving the request from Joliet’s mayor and city officials, my office began a preliminary review of Joliet Police Department records and other information,” Raoul said. “It is clear that a formal investigation is needed to look at whether the department has engaged in patterns or practices of unlawful or unconstitutional policing.”

Raoul said that in the coming weeks, his office will conduct a “thorough, impartial and independent review of whether reforms are needed under the law.”

Spokespersons for the Joliet Police Department, and the union representing rank-and-file officers, didn’t respond to a request for comment.

But consent decrees and federal involvement in local policing isn’t universally accepted as a good thing, or that it even leads to reform. Peter Moskos, a former police officer and now a professor at John Jay College in New York, said the investigation in Baltimore was “horrible” and designed to justify federal oversight.

The Justice Department revealed a “pattern-or-practice of constitutional violations,” including excessive force and racially biased arrests. The probe ultimately led to the implementation of a federal consent decree in 2017 mandating systemic reform.

“It’s not a real report, it’s just checking boxes to show systemic patterns of abuses to be able to implement a consent decree. In theory I’m not against them, I just haven’t seen them working. Then you can’t get out from under them,” he said. Moskos also noted that consent decrees deal primarily with the department, but not crime.

Lopez of Georgetown University — who was a longtime Civil Rights Division career attorney with the Justice Department — said the Baltimore investigation was comprehensive, involving numerous interviews, reviewing thousands of documents, and analyzing data to determine a “pattern or practice of unconstitutional conduct.”

“We really need to get better at how we measure the impacts of consent decrees,” Lopez added. “From what we can tell, it takes years for the full impacts to be felt, but there are some indications that you start to feel the impacts earlier than that,” Lopez said.

‘You have to have best practices’

The investigation into the Aurora Police Department found that “Aurora does not create and oversee appropriate expectations for responsible behavior, which leads to the use of excessive force and the violation of the civil rights of its residents,” according to a press release from the attorney general, announcing the findings.

A spokesperson for the union representing rank-and-file officers did not respond to a request for comment.

Like federal investigations, Weiser said the Colorado investigation ended with an outside entity monitoring an agreement between the state and the city of Aurora. Weiser said the goal of the investigation was to look at the “global picture” of the department, and not bring criminal prosecutions against individual officers.

“Excessive and unnecessary force can happen when situations could have been handled in cooler manner but is unnecessarily and unduly escalated. One way it happens, someone shows up and the way they present is in a way that raises the temperature,” he said. “This situation could’ve involved no force but ends up involving significant force. That’s unnecessary, excessive. Lots of situations weren’t criminal, just problematic policing.”

Wexler of PERF said it’s important that everyone involved should know what’s expected of everyone else, and there needs to be some way to hold everyone to expectations.

“What we’ve learned from the last 25 years, there needs to be accountability. In terms of process and outcomes and expectations, at the federal level, that’s been a source of some concern,” Wexler said. “I’m talking about everyone. Whether the (Department of Justice), the monitor, the federal judge, there’s lots of people involved. The process has to be understood, it has to be fixed in terms of when it can be evaluated.”

Wexler said that the lack of a single national standard for anything related to policing creates issues for police departments which are often required to implement some change to their policies and conduct as a result of the investigations.

“There are no national guidelines. If you’re talking about traffic stops, early warning systems, de-escalation, dealing with mental health issues, dealing with the homeless … you have to have best practices,” he said. “There are no national guidelines. It becomes an issue.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Huge rise in domestic abuse cases being dropped

Campaigners against male violence have called for amendments to the policing bill (Tolga Akmen/AFP via Getty Images) Cases of domestic abuse are being dropped at rapidly increasing rate, official figures ... Read more »

Avenue Supermarts' standalone net profit surges to Rs 449 crore in Q2FY22 results

© Provided by Zee Business Avenue Supermarts Ltd, which owns and operates retail chain D-Mart, has reported its standalone net profit after tax at Rs 448.90 crore for the quarter ... Read more »

Philippines receives over 200,000 doses of Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine

© National Task Force Against COVID-19 Philippines receives over 200,000 doses of Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine (October 16, 2021) The Philippines welcomed 207,090 doses of government-purchased COVID-19 vaccine developed by Pfizer ... Read more »

When is COP26? Glasgow climate change summit dates, schedule and what COP actually stands for

The UK will host the 26th United Nations Climate Change Conference of the Parties – more snappily known as COP26 – starting next month. The COP is an annual meeting ... Read more »

Dead person found in Asker

The emergency services moved out to Hogstadvannet in Asker after a dead person was found on Saturday morning. “A person was found dead, in the water,” operations manager Rune Hekkelstrand ... Read more »

Man dies after shooting in Brampton's north end

© Don Curran / Global News Police on scene near Dixie Road and Peter Robertson Boulevard in Brampton. Peel Regional Police say a man has died following a shooting in ... Read more »

When is October half-term 2021? Date of the next school holidays around UK explained

Schools are now open again across the UK. Pupils in Scotland returned to the classroom in August, those in Northern Ireland went back a few weeks later, and now students ... Read more »

Can I get a false negative PCR test? How reliable Covid tests are after 43,000 people given incorrect results

More than 40,000 people infected with Covid-19 were wrongly told they did not have the virus due to an error at a testing laboratory, health officials have said. NHS Test ... Read more »

B.C. ready to vaccinate thousands of children when Health Canada gives OK: top doctor

VANCOUVER — British Columbia’s top doctor has issued an order requiring children five and older to wear masks in public spaces, expanding a mandate for those aged 12 and up ... Read more »

When is Remembrance Sunday 2021? Armistice Day date, events and why we commemorate the end of WWI with poppies

Remembrance Sunday falls in November every year, giving the nation a chance to honour Britain’s war dead. As well as the wearing of poppies, it is traditionally marked with wreath-laying, ... Read more »

Sask. COVID-19 long hauler and restaurant worker faces harassment enforcing proof-of-vaccination policy

© Matt Duguid/CBC Matthew Cardinal is a Regina restaurant worker receiving verbal abuse and threats of physical violence over Saskatchewan’s proof-of-vaccination requirement. Matthew Cardinal, 35, is a COVID-19 long hauler ... Read more »

Donald Trump-backed challengers to Republican lawmakers are lagging in the battle to fill their fundraising war chests

© Pool/Getty Images Sen. Lisa Murkowski (L), Former President Donald Trump (R). Pool/Getty Images Donald Trump has backed challengers to Republican lawmakers who voted for his impeachment or conviction. Four ... Read more »

Pete Buttigieg hits back at Fox News host's criticism of his paternity leave

US transportation secretary Pete Buttigieg, who has been on paternity leave since mid-August with newborn twins, called right-wing attacks on his paternity leave “strange” and from “a side of the ... Read more »

Jan. 6 rally supporter gives $150K to GOP AGs

A supporter of Former President Donald Tump who also gave money for the rally he spoke at on Jan. 6 has donated $150,000 to the Republican Attorneys General Association (RAGA)’s ... Read more »

Eve reveals pregnancy on Instagram: 'We finally get to tell everyone!'

Eve is definitely feeling satisfaction… © Karwai Tang/WireImage/Getty Images Eve and Maximillion Cooper attend Fashion For Relief London 2019 at The British Museum on September 14, 2019 in London. The ... Read more »

The Soviet space engineer who inspires Elon Musk

In September, a Russian man and his son rented a Tesla and set off to meet Elon Musk following a personal invitation from the billionaire entrepreneur to visit SpaceX’s factory ... Read more »

Art or 'childish graffiti'? Redressing Queen Victoria and Disraeli statues sparks fury on the Mersey

Queen Victoria was dressed in a cotton and hessian dress by Karen Arthur & Laurence Westgaph – David Edwards The monument to Queen Victoria in Liverpool has cast an imposing ... Read more »

Reports lodged in Perak, Putrajaya on anti-vaxxers causing public nuisance

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA LUMPUR: Police received two reports in Perak and Putrajaya respectively against anti-vaccination groups for causing public nuisance. Bukit Aman Criminal Investigation Department director ... Read more »

Pope pledges to continue being a 'pest' in defence of the poor

© Reuters/GUGLIELMO MANGIAPANE FILE PHOTO: FILE PHOTO: Pope Francis holds weekly general audience By Philip Pullella VATICAN CITY (Reuters) – Pope Francis said on Saturday he realises some people, including ... Read more »

Iranian court upholds new jail term for Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe

© Provided by Al Jazeera Richard Ratcliffe and his daughter Gabriella have been campaigning for the release of Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe since she was arrested in Tehran in 2016 [File: Kirsty ... Read more »

Isu arak: PAS gesa KDN perlu lebih tegas kawal industri arak

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Isu yang tular kini mengenai arak berjenama Timah hakikatnya telah wujud di negara ini sejak 2013 lagi, kata Ketua Penerangan PAS Kamaruzaman Mohamad. (Gambar ... Read more »

Giant Rome rally urges ban on extreme right

© Alberto PIZZOLI Organisers said the rally drew at least 100,000 people Tens of thousands of Italians called for a ban on the extreme right as they rallied in Rome ... Read more »

1 deputy killed, 2 injured in shooting at Houston bar

A constable deputy was killed and two others were injured in a shooting early Saturday while they were working an extra job at a bar in Houston, according to police. ... Read more »

Nuñez sentenced to 21 years for his role in beating death of teen

Oct. 16—State District Judge Matthew Wilson sentenced Jordan Nuñez to 21 years in prison Friday for failing to intervene while his father beat and tortured 13-year-old Jeremiah Valencia to death ... Read more »

Pundit claims Salah is ‘best in world' as wonder-goal draws comparisons to Brazil legend

Mohamed Salah produced another masterclass as the Egyptian underlined his status as one of the best players in the world as his two-goal display helped sink Watford 5-0 at Vicarage ... Read more »

Everton Women announce Willie Kirk's departure after poor start

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo  Willie Kirk has left his role as manager of Everton Women after a disappointing start to the season. After a promising summer transfer ... Read more »

Watford 0-5 Liverpool: Premier League – as it happened

LIVE – Updated at 14:41 © Photograph: Andrew Powell/Liverpool FC/Getty Images Mohamed Salah scores an incredible fourth goal for Liverpool. Minute-by-minute report: Roberto Firmino scored a hat-trick, while Mohamed Salah ... Read more »

Pundits claims Mo Salah is ‘best in world' as wonder-goal draws comparisons to Brazil legend

Mohamed Salah produced another masterclass as the Egyptian underlined his status as one of the best players in the world as his two-goal display helped sink Watford 5-0 at Vicarage ... Read more »

Emiliano Martinez starts for Villa 36hrs after playing for Argentina

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Aston Villa goalkeeper Emiliano Martinez and midfielder Douglas Luiz will play in today’s Premier League clash against Wolves just 36 hours after featuring ... Read more »

Why Are All the Grandparents Freaking Out About Christmas Presents and Supply Chains All of a Sudden?

© Licensed from Adobe If your Boomer-generation parents or grandparents have recently started panicking about the availability of Christmas presents and sharing urgent concerns about “supply chains,” then you’re not ... Read more »

Man ‘impersonated a police officer to kidnap girl of 14 in Sussex'

Photograph: Nigel Bowles/Alamy A man has been charged with sexual offences after allegedly kidnapping a teenage girl while impersonating a police officer. David Peter Young, 32, a chef from Ifield, ... Read more »

Jussie Smollett case will go to trial

A judge denied a request to dismiss Empire actor Jussie Smollett's criminal case after he allegedly lied to police officers over being a victim of a hate crime in January ... Read more »

Jaguars vs. Dolphins odds, picks, how to watch, live stream: 2021 NFL in London predictions from top model

The Jacksonville Jaguars (0-5) will head to England for the eighth time to take on the Miami Dolphins (1-4) on Sunday. The Jaguars have lost 20 consecutive games dating back ... Read more »

Lamar Jackson reacts to surprise Louisville number retirement: 'Y'all just made my day'

Lamar Jackson will be the last player to wear No. 8 at Louisville. The university surprised Jackson with that announcement, and captured his reaction to the news. Jackson went back ... Read more »

Clay Martin's intervention during live play isn't uncommon, but definitely looked unusual

© Provided by NBC Sports During Thursday night’s game between the Buccaneers and the Eagles, Fox cameras caught referee Clay Martin keeping Philadelphia defensive end Derek Barnett and Tampa Bay ... Read more »

Missouri governor is calling for criminal charges against a journalist who found social security numbers exposed on a public website

© Provided by INSIDER Missouri Gov. Mike Parson Jeff Roberson/AP The governor of Missouri is calling for criminal charges against a reporter who found social security numbers exposed online. The ... Read more »

Britney Spears Admits She's Scared Of Stepping Wrong and a Music Career as Conservatorship Changes

There have been rumors that pop icon Britney Spears wanted to hang up the mic, and now in a recent Instagram post, she’s confirmed it’s true. In a long caption, ... Read more »

Arts Avenue - Bel Canto Chorus

Bel Canto Chorus stops by Arts Avenue to talk about their concert on Sunday, Oct. 16. © Provided by WISN Milwaukee Music Director Richard Hynson and the chorus will be ... Read more »

Piers Morgan pays tribute to Sir David Amess as MP seen grinning at daughter's wedding just weeks before stabbing murder

PIERS Morgan has shared a photograph of a murdered MP attending his daughter's wedding just a month before his death. Sir David Amess is seen beaming alongside wife Julia and ... Read more »

Here's What To Do if Taking Vitamins Doesn't Agree With Your Stomach, According to a G.I. Doc

© Photo: Getty Images/ Grace Cary upset stomach from vitamins In a perfect world, everyone would get all the nutrients they need from food and there would be no need ... Read more »