Stacey Abrams’ latest conspiracy theory is about unborn babies' hearts

stacey abrams’ latest conspiracy theory is about unborn babies' hearts

Stacey Abrams’ latest conspiracy theory is about unborn babies’ hearts

Stacey Abrams has just said something that was absolutely insane. It’s possible she misspoke — the media is already running cover for her. But they shouldn’t, because beneath her wild conspiracy theory are other false assertions and bad science.

Let’s unpeel this onion, layer by nutty layer.

First, there’s the face-value conspiracy theory:

Taken literally, she is saying that ultrasound machines were designed to deceive patients by people who wanted to “convince people that men have the right to take control of a woman’s body.”

One is tempted to add the “without evidence” to her assertion, but it’s too unhinged a statement to even warrant that epithet. No sane person believes that General Electric and Siemens designed their ultrasound machines in order to subjugate women.

It’s possible that she misspoke. This was a panel, after all, and maybe she meant that the ultrasound doesn’t pick up the “thump-thump” sound of a heartbeat (which is true but irrelevant), or that the very notion fetal heartbeat was “designed” to subjugate women (which would also be false).

So let’s consider that second claim by looking at sources outside the pro-life movement. Searching medical journals, you find plenty of references to a fetal heartbeat, even at six weeks. A 2011 article in the Journal of Prenatal Medicine, noted: “At the end of the fourth week of gestation, the heartbeats of the embryo begin.”

The authors, obstetricians in Italy, continued, “The heart, whose development starts at the 3rd week of gestation, has rapid and irregular contractions capable of pumping the blood inside the vessels.” Journal articles with statements like this are everywhere.

Here’s a 2009 journal article about “the normal range of embryonic heart rate and fetal heart rate at six to 11 weeks of gestation….” Would Abrams argue that a six-week in-utero baby has a “heart rate” but no “heartbeat?” That would be quite an assertion. Or would she say this journal article, whose primary author is a Polish doctor specializing in fetal cardiology, is in on the conspiracy to control women’s bodies?

So that dismantles the claims that a “fetal heartbeat” is some sort of misogynistic trick to oppress women. “Fetal heartbeat” or “embryonic heartbeat” are common medical descriptions of something that doctors and scientists all over the world have written to describe.

The next possible defense of Abrams is that even if the phrase “fetal heartbeat” isn’t just a conspiracy to oppress women, it’s still somehow a misnomer. But this is also wrong. We can show that by establishing there is a fetal heart at six weeks, and that it beats.

The fact that unborn babies have hearts at six weeks is not really up for debate. Again, check that article from the Journal of Prenatal Medicine, which states that the heart’s “development starts at the third week of gestation.”

This Atlantic article, which tried to claim something similar to what Abrams said, had to run a massive correction that began thus: “This article originally stated that there is ‘no heart to speak of’ in a six-week-old fetus. In fact, the heart has already begun to form by that point in a pregnancy.” So yes, the baby at 6 weeks has a heart.

Does it beat? Well, it contracts, pumping blood. Recall that “at the end of the fourth week” the heart “has rapid and irregular contractions capable of pumping the blood inside the vessels.” And that’s what a heartbeat is.

The next layer down in this Abrams conspiracy theory onion is that claim that the sound of the heartbeat is “manufactured.” That’s not wrong so much as it is meaningless. Abrams could say that a transvaginal ultrasound isn’t recording the sound of the heartbeat, but that’s not quite true either. The only thing an “ultrasound” records is sound, echoing off of tissue — hence the name.

But Abrams could change that to say that the heartbeat isn’t audible — which would be totally meaningless. The heartbeat of a tiny baby inside amniotic fluid, inside a womb, inside a woman’s torso isn’t really audible to the human ear. But that’s a million miles from what Stacey Abrams is claiming. It shouldn’t be too surprising that her election denialism goes hand in hand with other conspiracy theories.

 

Washington Examiner Videos

Tags: Opinion, Beltway Confidential

Original Author: Timothy P. Carney

Original Location: Stacey Abrams’ latest conspiracy theory is about unborn babies’ hearts

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Soccer predictions, best bets today: Betting tips, expert picks for games on Monday, October 3

Soccer predictions, best bets today: Betting tips, expert picks for games on Monday, October 3 Desperate clubs is the theme of the most high-profile matches on tap for Monday in ... Read more »

Chicago police fatally shoot armed man

Chicago police investigate an officer-involved shooting where a man was killed on Sunday, Oct. 2, 2022, in the 400 block of West Blackhawk Street. CHICAGO — A man was killed ... Read more »

Stock watch: Who’s rising, who’s falling after Kentucky football’s loss at Ole Miss

Kentucky Wildcats wide receiver Barion Brown (2) runs the ball in the fourth quarter of Saturday’s game against Ole Miss. Kentucky football’s record is no longer unblemished. But even in ... Read more »

Archaeologists Unearth Hercules Statue From Ancient Philippi

Philippi Located in northeastern Greece, the village of Filippoi is home to just over 11,000 people. It’s a modest municipality with a storied history — it shares its location with ... Read more »

Texas human smuggling by plane becoming more common as migrants 'try to avoid detection': border officials

The Texas Department of Public Safety (DPS) says human smuggling attempts by aircraft are becoming more common in the border state. Over the last 30 days, Texas DPS has stopped ... Read more »

1 teen dead, 2 hurt after stolen Maserati crashed in St. Petersburg

ST. PETERSBURG — They slipped out of their homes and into the Saturday night darkness without their parents knowing. Around 3:30 a.m. the next morning, the three teen boys came ... Read more »

Woman who recruited migrants, arranged DeSantis's flights to Martha's Vineyard revealed

Woman who recruited migrants, arranged DeSantis’s flights to Martha’s Vineyard revealed The woman who allegedly lured undocumented migrants onto flights from Texas to Martha’s Vineyard for a secretive public awareness ... Read more »

'Big Short' Investor Michael Burry On How Current Market Differs From Dot-Com Bubble Burst: 'Only Way Out Is By Trampling Each Other'

Legendary investor Michael Burry, who famously bet against the housing market in the run-up to the 2008 financial crisis, is known to be skeptical about passive investing. On Sunday, “The Big Short” ... Read more »

JD.com Tycoon Settles Rape Suit Hours Before US Trial Begins

(Bloomberg) — Billionaire JD.com founder Richard Liu has reached a settlement with Liu Jingyao, the Minnesota student who accused him of rape in 2018, bringing to a close a civil ... Read more »

Yolanda Hadid Jokes She's ‘Worst Mom Ever' in Almond-Eating TikTok Video

Yolanda Hadid's TikTok video has received mixed reactions, with some calling it "toxic" Read more »

Manchester City vs Manchester United player ratings out of 10

We’re entering new territory when it comes to grading anything that has to do with Manchester City, making Man City vs Manchester United player ratings a real hassle. As bad ... Read more »

Residents at Florida retirement community struggle with massive flooding

A Seminole County firefighter works to clear a drain at an intersection in Hacienda Village, a 55- plus manufactured homes community in Winter Springs, Florida, on Sunday, Oct. 2, 2022. ... Read more »

Patrick Mahomes breaks NFL QB record not even Tom Brady reached

10/2/22 Patrick Mahomes is without a question an elite quarterback, and he’s showing that anew this season, with one excellent performance after another. In Week 4’s assignment against the Tampa ... Read more »

Palestinians: Israel military kills 2 during West Bank raid

Palestinians: Israel military kills 2 during West Bank raid Palestinian officials say the Israeli military has killed two Palestinians in the occupied West Bank TEL AVIV, Israel — The Israeli ... Read more »

‘They never made it to the hospital’: Aunt of teen brothers slain in Oakland says masked shooter attacked birthday gathering

Brothers Angel Soleto and Jazy Soleto of Berkeley were killed after a masked shooter opened fire at a birthday gathering in Oakland, a relative said. The two Berkeley High School ... Read more »

Concealed carry insurance business booming as more Americans pack heat

Concealed carry policy sales have surged over the past few years Read more »

Stop saying ‘hello’ orders Indian state

image And other stories from the stranger side of life Civil servants have been told to stop saying “hello” in the Indian state of Maharashtra, reported The Times. The state ... Read more »

NSA Worker Tried To Sell US Secrets To Foreign Official Who Turned Out To Be An FBI Agent

NSA Worker Tried To Sell US Secrets To Foreign Official Who Turned Out To Be An FBI Agent A former National Security Agency (NSA) worker is accused of trying to ... Read more »

French airport group ADP confirms 2022, 2023 travel outlook for Paris

Paris Charles de Gaulle airport in Roissy-en-France near Paris PARIS (Reuters) – French airport group ADP confirmed its Paris air traffic outlook for 2022 and 2023, driven by a recovery ... Read more »

Central Florida struggles with Ian’s ongoing sewage crisis

Water gushed Sunday morning, Oct. 2, 2022, from a sewage manhole cover along Winter Park’s Lakemont Avenue just west of Winter Park High School, in Florida. The liquid had the ... Read more »

Conor Gallagher ‘desperate’ to play for and be successful at Chelsea

Conor Gallagher ‘desperate’ to play for and be successful at Chelsea A new head coach is often a chance for players to impress anew, to convince of their qualities, to ... Read more »

‘Always the worst thing’: Bailey Zappe gets brutally honest on Patriots’ OT loss to Packers in his first NFL game

10/2/22 Rookie quarterback Bailey Zappe was suited up for his first NFL game ever on Sunday. By the New England Patriots’ third offensive drive against the Green Bay Packers, he ... Read more »

More action at port possible, says striking union

The strike at Felixstowe will run until 5 October The union on strike at the UK’s busiest container port warned there could be further industrial action. Workers at the Port ... Read more »

First look: Detroit Lions at New England Patriots odds and lines

Detroit Lions quarterback Jared Goff (16) looks to pass against the Seattle Seahawks during the first half at Ford Field. The Detroit Lions (1-3) visit the New England Patriots (1-3) Sunday ... Read more »

Wisconsin Football: Coaching Candidates to Replace Paul Chryst

A complete breakdown of which coaches could be candidates to Paul Chryst at Wisconsin. Wisconsin fired coach Paul Chryst on Sunday. Defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard will work as the team’s ... Read more »

Video shows a rare brawl between a pod of orcas and 2 humpback whales in the Pacific Ocean

Bigg’s orcas clash with humpback whale “Reaper” Mollie Naccarato, Sooke Coastal Explorations, PWWA Whale watchers spotted an unusual encounter between transient orcas and humpback whales off the coast of Washington. ... Read more »

Magic Kingdom Dining: The Complete Guide

I’ll be honest – the Magic Kingdom dining situation isn’t my favorite. It’s not that the food isn’t good, it’s just that I love the dining at the other parks ... Read more »

The Three Poisons In Buddhism Explained

A row of Buddhist statues Most of us have heard of the infamous Seven Deadly Sins that, according to Catholicism, forge the pillars of all sinful behavior here on Earth ... Read more »

"I couldn’t do anything!" - Michael Jordan once named the only player he couldn't dominate

Michael Jordan loved the competition and he often dominated his rivals. But shockingly, he wasn’t able to do so against one player. Michael Jordan © RVR Photos-USA TODAY Sports View ... Read more »

Killings of 5 Men in California Are Related, Police Say

Detectives have located an unidentified "person of interest" in the killings Read more »

North Carolina man allegedly robs West Virginia Subway, assaults employees

North Carolina man allegedly robs West Virginia Subway, assaults employees SISSONVILLE, W.Va. (WOWK) — A North Carolina man was arrested on Saturday for allegedly robbing a Subway in Sissonville and ... Read more »

Instant Reaction: Rumors of Raiders Demise Greatly Exaggerated

The doom and gloom thrown out about the demise of the Las Vegas Raiders was proven greatly exaggerated today, after they beat the Denver Broncos. LAS VEGAS, Nev.–The rumors of ... Read more »

Politics of rebuilding intensify as Florida's devastation is laid bare

Political aftershocks of Hurricane Ian’s rampage through Florida are escalating over huge federal aid needed to restore devastated communities and the question of whether those most vulnerable to extreme weather ... Read more »

Cooper Rush does something no one has ever done

Cooper Rush does something no one has ever done Cowboys quarterback Cooper Rush may not create a controversy in Dallas, but he has made some history. According to he NFL, ... Read more »

Family chased by gun-wielding driver

Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station deputies detained a gun-wielding woman at approximately 11 a.m. at the Mobil gas station on the 27700 block of McBean Parkway on Sunday. The victims, ... Read more »

Tom Brady Had 6-Word Message For Patrick Mahomes After Game

Patrick Mahomes got the best of Tom Brady and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Sunday night. Kansas City topped Tampa Bay, 41-31, in a rematch of the 2020 season’s Super ... Read more »

On Coast Guard flight over battered SW Florida coast, massive damage is evident

A Coast Guard flight crew member looks out the window as she’s positioned to watch for any danger on a flight to Southwest Florida on Sunday, Oct. 2, 2022. From ... Read more »

Starlux Airlines To Double Capacity By Year End And Add Aircraft

Starlux Airlines To Double Capacity By Year End And Add Aircraft On Friday, shares in Taiwan’s newest international carrier, Starlux Airlines, started trading on the local stock exchange. Starlux Airlines ... Read more »

Brazil's Bolsonaro and the right outperform, defying polls

Brazil's Bolsonaro and the right outperform, defying polls Brazil’s election has provided the world yet another example of polls missing the mark, with incumbent Jair Bolsonaro considerably outperforming expectations to ... Read more »

LA Angels Beat Texas Rangers 8-3 for Seventh Straight Win

Ronald Martinez, Getty Images The Los Angeles Angels wrapped up the home portion of their seventh consecutive losing season by hitting superbly, pitching more than adequately and extending their longest ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network