Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

“If the institutional testing framework is not built, Thu Duc City will be very difficult to break through because it is impossible to build a ‘nest’ for sparrows, but the ambition is to attract eagles,” said Dr. Vu Thanh Tu Anh.

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

“Specific mechanism” is a phrase reminded by leaders of Ho Chi Minh City for 2 months since Thu Duc City officially came into operation. This is seen as a solution to remove a series of bottlenecks for a new city to really break through.

Chairman of Thu Duc City People’s Committee also affirmed that building a specific mechanism is the central goal of the first phase of the new city. However, the proposal of decentralization and authorization that the Thu Duc city government reported to Ho Chi Minh City on March 27 has not convinced many departments and branches. Ho Chi Minh City People’s Committee Chairman Nguyen Thanh Phong commented on the proposal with specific targets but has not determined economic structure and development model.

While Thu Duc City is determining the direction for a specific mechanism to propose to the Central Government, Dr. Vu Thanh Tu Anh, Director of the Fulbright School of Public Policy and Management, said that Thu Duc City needs a “test framework. Institutions”. If you do not do this, Thu Duc City is very difficult to break through because it is not possible to build a “nest” for sparrows, but the ambition to attract eagles.

Zing has an interview with Dr. Vu Thanh Tu Anh, analyzing more carefully about the specific mechanisms that Thu Duc city needs.

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

– To realize a series of breakthrough goals, the Ho Chi Minh City government repeatedly affirmed that it will decentralize and decentralize as much as possible to Thu Duc City. In your opinion, with the city model in the city, how should HCMC decentralize and decentralize to Thu Duc city?

– Talking about decentralization, we have to step back to understand why decentralization and decentralization bring any benefits.

In the public finance theory of the relationship between levels of government, a fundamental principle of governance is that whichever level is closer to the people, that level should be the decision-maker. From the central level to the local level, the distance is so far that the central government cannot understand what the people of Ho Chi Minh City or Thu Duc City think. Therefore, from the central to the provincial level, the city must be decentralized.

Meanwhile, the “distance” from Ho Chi Minh City to Thu Duc City is very close, so the advantage of information is negligible when decentralizing. We have to understand that before deciding how to decentralize. However, if decentralization without careful consideration, it is only superficial.

The most important thing is that when wearing new clothes, with a hierarchy and a new model, will Thu Duc City really become a new “being” or still just an old organism wearing a new coat? This is a key issue of Thu Duc City.

Even if Ho Chi Minh City has the utmost decentralization and decentralization for Thu Duc, in the current Vietnamese context, the space and scope of decentralization for Thu Duc will still be limited on all three important aspects: Human financial, financial, and political.

It is necessary to ask questions such as: Who is the person in charge of decisions? How will fiscal authority be divided between the central government and Ho Chi Minh City and between HCMC and Thu Duc City? Does Thu Duc’s authority to mobilize and spend budget is different or must comply with the general framework of the State?

From these questions, we can see the fact that the decentralization problem for Thu Duc City is the negotiation between Ho Chi Minh City and the Central Government, and the decision is centrally located.

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

– With such a decentralized and decentralized scope and scope, according to you, what specific mechanism does Thu Duc city need to have a driving force to make breakthroughs in economic development?

– The most important solution is that the Central Committee agrees for Thu Duc to make an institutional testing framework (policy sandbox) – which is a kind of experiment on a new policy, and this framework is only within Thu Duc City, not applied for the rest of HCMC.

In the planning of Thu Duc City, there are many different types of functional centers such as financial centers, science – technology, sports – culture, logistics port clusters … each field will have its own policy tests. Here, I talk deeply about the financial center.

For example, what is the prerequisite for Thu Thiem to become an international financial center?

The first is the liberalization of capital accounts and the freely convertible currency to facilitate capital inflows in and out. If bringing money in easy and difficult, then why should investors come here without going to Singapore or Hong Kong or even Shanghai (China) – places that have been liberalizing capital accounts.

Second, if the exchange rate mechanism is rigid, it will not create the flexibility in monetary policy.

The third is the regulations on foreign workers. For example, what percentage of the workforce is up to a foreigner at most? If it is an international company, this number will be many times larger than the current regulations, especially in the initial stage.

Then the administrative procedures related to recruitment, extension of labor visa contracts, no double taxation … Up to now, the Vietnamese law for these issues has many limitations.

Fourth is about income tax and financial transaction tax. What if I want to compete with Singapore and tax twice as much as Singapore? After we come back, but the incentive policy is not equal to the previous ones, how can we attract investors?

The fifth is the testing mechanism for the development of Startups (startups) and Fintech (financial technology). This framework of institutions and policies relates to data centers and cybersecurity so that businesses can leverage secure international cloud computing systems and services to develop AI (artificial intelligence) and Big Data (big data).

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

The aforementioned mechanisms are completely outside the jurisdiction of Ho Chi Minh City. The most important conditions depend on the central government. That is the authority of the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Planning and Investment, the State Bank, the Ministry of Labor, Invalids and Social Affairs and other ministries.

The best Thu Duc City can hope for is the central government allowing the city to become an institutional testing framework. Without the support of the ministries to jointly submit the reforms to the Prime Minister and then to the National Assembly, it is difficult to hope that Thu Duc City can make a breakthrough.

With this “institutional testing framework”, once investors see the potential, the city will not have to spend billions of dollars to build infrastructure. Investors will be willing to take advantage of the mechanism and potential of an emerging market like Vietnam. Thus, we do not have to ask for any money, but just create a mechanism. And this mechanism is, again, central.

In short, if the Central Government considers Thu Duc City as a national pilot model, then there can be a new mechanism, but if it is just a new city of Ho Chi Minh City like any other city There are not many chances of success.

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

– Is there a limit to this institutional testing framework?

It is true that this test framework cannot be indefinite. It is important to find a suitable configuration and to balance the benefits and risks. What is suitable? To determine it takes 2 steps.

The first step is to collect input from the market. This data could come from a frank, open dialogue with potential investors. From there, draw the terms that will attract large investors, or as we often describe it as “clearing the eagle”.

Former Pudong (Shanghai) policymakers also say “phoenix pole” – that is, building a new “nest” for phoenix to live in. Obviously the “nest” for the sparrow no eagle wants to come.

Meanwhile, our approach today is still “I give to you, give you the mechanism, and whether that mechanism is suitable for you is not another matter”. Now, we have to do the opposite.

Thu Duc City has to contact foreign investors, major financial institutions, even hire consulting companies to help me understand the current conditions of Vietnam, the incentive packages must be like. Which? That is the first step – catching the pulse of the needs and emotions of the market.

The next step, we must go back to seeing what market conditions require, what can be done immediately, what needs a roadmap, what cannot be done due to mechanisms or security and political factors. Based on the data of both the supply side and the demand side, we can analyze where the two sides meet, thereby, determining the configuration and route of the framework. There are very open but there are those that have to be limited.

To do this requires public-private partnerships in terms of institutional framework development. In addition, we also need to refer to international experience.The test framework also needs to balance benefits and risks, but from the point of view of testing, there may be errors and risks, objectives is the best risk management to achieve the highest expected benefit.

Unfortunately, the prevailing management view in Vietnam today is that although it is allowed to experiment, “risks are not allowed”, and when unfortunately there is a risk, who makes that person responsible. With this mechanism, no civil servant or management agency dares to “commit”, or when assigned the responsibility, do it in moderation or even push for others.

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

– Recently, the Ho Chi Minh City People’s Council passed a resolution on the budget for Thu Duc City. Accordingly, Thu Duc City is kept 18% of the total budget revenue, the rest is paid to the Central and Ho Chi Minh City does not keep any money. Is this a specific mechanism that HCMC gives to Thu Duc City?

– It is the highest mechanism that Ho Chi Minh City can do for Thu Duc City. Ho Chi Minh City does not need the budget of Thu Duc City, but needs the spread from the success of Thu Duc City.

The development goal of a city is not just a budget, but much broader than that. That Thu Duc City can create vitality and vitality for Ho Chi Minh City. If keeping 50% of the budget and the city does not develop, it will not do anything.

From the vitality of Thu Duc, it will create the spread of technology, finance, management, skills … that is, it will make the rest of Ho Chi Minh City change flesh. That’s the important thing.

Another important impact is that the success and spread of Thu Duc create new high-level job opportunities and help increase the living standards of the people. And finally the image of Ho Chi Minh City as it becomes the leading place of Southeast Asia and Asia. That is what Ho Chi Minh City should be aiming for.

However, apart from 18% of the budget, it is necessary to give Thu Duc City a mechanism to mobilize other financial resources. With only 18% of the budget, it is impossible to hope to become a breakthrough, pillar or driving force of Ho Chi Minh City.

It should be noted that this policy testing framework is a controlled experiment, within the framework of Thu Duc City and has a time, maybe 3-5 years. At the end of the trial period, it is necessary to evaluate which policies should be continued or extended, and which policies should be eliminated.

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

– In the process of operating an unprecedented model, with many specific mechanisms such as Thu Duc City, the authorities of Ho Chi Minh City and Thu Duc City, what should be done to ensure the monitoring process, not creating space for participation. Corrupt?

– The important thing is that the Thu Duc City People’s Council must operate effectively.

For example, the proportion of full-time representatives of the People’s Council is not only at the current level of 20-30%, but at least 50% or even 100%, the better. Because when he was in charge, he focused on his work, that really created the control mechanism for the public agency.

This also means that Thu Duc City needs a specific monitoring mechanism. And this oversight is within the city’s capabilities, not asking the Central Government, which of course needs Congress to turn on the “green light.” If only monitoring in the current form will not take effect and even cause conflicts of interest, so corruption cannot be controlled. Secondly, Thu Duc City must have a competitive bidding mechanism or transparent and public appraisal of investment projects, there should be an independent investment appraisal council for key projects.

This is the place that is expected to have many large investment projects. To avoid car traces falling during the construction of Thu Thiem new urban area, it is necessary to have an independent and transparent appraisal council. This approach will help reduce a lot of costs later, even create a harmony with the interests of the people, especially when compensation and site clearance. If only the State as at present, when a conflict occurs, there will be a lack of objective voice of the third party to settle the interests of the parties.

This appraisal board will operate on the budget of the city. But the government must ensure it does not interfere with the council’s decisions, and the council must ensure openness, transparency, and accountability.

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

Third, Thu Duc city must have an economic court system, or an effective economic arbitration system. For example, now, what law do two disputing foreign investors use?

Or what law does a local government sue by a foreign company?

If using Vietnamese law, it is not certain that foreign investors have come. But with the arbitration mechanism, they can use the laws of other countries. Thus, the conflict will not be pushed up to a too serious issue such as bringing to court, but can be handled more softly, still ensuring the rule of law, transparency and efficiency. I think this is an extremely important requirement, especially regarding intellectual property and financial disputes – extremely complicated things.

It can be seen that the specific mechanism for Thu Duc city depends quite a lot on the decisions of the Central Government. But the important thing is that Ho Chi Minh City has to “save itself” with its dynamism and creativity, and it will be very difficult to just rely on the central government. Fortunately, there is plenty of room for the city to self-improve and reform.

For example, the story of the construction planning of Thu Thiem new urban area was approved in 1996, which is only a few years after Pudong in Shanghai. If anyone ever went to Thu Thiem and Pho Dong in the 1990s and now for a comparison, it is a godsend.

That fact shows that what Ho Chi Minh City needs at the central level is a strong pilot mechanism, after which the city just does its job well, the results will naturally be good, not dependent on resource pulls. Center.

– Thank you Sir.

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

Specific mechanism for Thu Duc city: Nest for sparrows, no eagles want to come

Source: ndh.vn – Translated by fintel.vn

News Related


Construction materials prices surge as demand recovers

Duc Chien in Hanoi’s downtown Ba Dinh District recently completed the construction of a new house, but the cost ended up 30 percent higher than his original estimate. “The contractor asked to hike… Read more »

Local airlines raise ticket prices from May 9

Local airlines including Vietnam Airlines, Pacific Airlines, Vasco and Bamboo Airways are scheduled to raise their respective system administration fees by VND100,000 (US$4.37) per flight, which will be incorporated into current air ticket… Read more »

Vietnam equity market close to Singapore’s levels: HSBC

Turnover of Vietnam’s equity market rose to US$725 million in April from US$596 million a month earlier – a year ago it was only US$130 million. The latest figure is now almost at… Read more »

Bamboo Airways first Vietnamese carrier to secure US direct flight slots

At the San Francisco International Airport, the daily flights are expected to land at 10 a.m. (U.S. time) and depart at 1 p.m.; and the landing and takeoff times at the Los Angeles… Read more »

Bamboo Airways secures US direct flight slots

At the San Francisco International Airport, the daily flights are expected to land at 10 a.m. (U.S. time) and depart at 1 p.m.; and the landing and takeoff times at the Los Angeles… Read more »

India does not impose anti-dumping tax on Vietnamese man-made fibers

Artificial staple fiber products from Vietnam are not subject to anti-dumping tax in the Indian market. According to aggregate data from Vietnam Customs, the total export turnover of artificial staple fibers under investigation… Read more »

IMF forecasts Vietnam’s economy will grow very positively

Mr. Jonathan Ostry, Deputy Director of the Asia and Pacific Division of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) discussed the issue of improving Vietnam’s growth quality to ensure sustainable development. Mr. Jonathan Ostry, Deputy… Read more »

Popular train routes suspended amid fresh Covid-19 outbreak

Hanoi Railway Transport JSC, the northern operator, has cancelled trains from Vinh, capital of central Nghe An Province, to Hanoi starting Friday. It also announced the suspension of trains connecting Hanoi with northern… Read more »

Favourite historical sites in Dien Bien province

A part of the panorama at the Dien Bien Phu Victory Museum (Photo: VOV) NDO – Throughout May, historical sites in the northern mountainous province of Dien Bien will bring meaningful experiences to… Read more »

Visiting Dien Bien Phu Campaign Headquarters in Muong Phang

The headquarters of the Dien Bien Phu campaign were hidden in the old forest at the foot of Pu Don Mountain in Muong Phang Commune, nearly 40 km from Dien Bien Phu City.… Read more »

Tourist destinations close beaches as Covid-19 infections spike

Authorities in Hai Phong City, home to famous beaches like Do Son and Cat Co, have ordered a swimming ban from Friday after nearby Hanoi reported a surge in transmissions in the last… Read more »

Dong Thap proposed to supplement need for public investment capital to nearly 4,508 billion VND

Dong Thap Provincial People’s Committee has just sent Official Letter No. 115 to the Ministry of Planning and Investment on the review report on the mid-term public investment plan for the period 2021-2025… Read more »

Tourists cancel Hanoi, Da Nang trips as Covid-19 outbreak escalates

Nguyen Thanh Tung, an English teacher living in Ho Chi Minh City’s Binh Thanh District, and his mother on Wednesday postponed their next week trip to Hanoi though they had booked flight tickets… Read more »

Project connecting highway Noi Bai – Lao Cai is considered and adjusted for investment policy

The People’s Committee of Lao Cai province has just been asked to receive the opinions of the Ministry of Planning and Investment, carry out investment procedures and report to the Prime Minister for… Read more »

Construction material ‘price storm’: Many bidders won bid but not dare to sign contract

Information at a meeting with the Department of Construction of Ca Mau province recently, the representative of the project management board said that many contractors won the bid but did not sign the… Read more »

Ho Chi Minh City consider shortening investment procedures for construction of commercial housing projects

On May 5, Mr. Le Hoang Chau, Chairman of Ho Chi Minh City Real Estate Association (Horea), said Mr. Le Hoa Binh, Vice Chairman of the City People’s Committee, together with leaders of… Read more »

Endangered primate released into Bach Ma National Park

Phan Hieu, a local resident in the central province’s Huong Thuy Town found the primate near Ta Trach Lake and quickly contacted local forest rangers to take charge. The forest area around the… Read more »

Campaign launched to promote Japanese tourism in Vietnam

NDO – The Japan National Tourism Organisation (JNTO) in Vietnam launched a campaign entitled “I love Japan” on May 5, aiming to maintain the interest and love for Japanese tourism as well as… Read more »

Quang Ninh, Hai Phong tourist attractions shut amid Covid-19 surge

Authorities in Quang Ninh, which is nearly 150 km east of Hanoi, have closed all tourist attractions, relics and historical sites, including Ha Long Bay, a UNESCO heriage site, and its neighbor bay… Read more »

Chu Mom Ray Park: An impressive ASEAN heritage in the Truong Son range

Chu Mom Ray Park spans the districts of Sa Thay and Ngoc Hoi, adjacent to Cambodia’s Virachey National Park and a nature reserve in Laos NDO – Located around 30 kilometres from Kon… Read more »

Developing ecotourism infrastructure in Tram Tau

Photo: Tram Tau hot spring in Yen Bai NDO – As a highland district of Yen Bai province, Tram Tau is endowed with terraced fields and natural hot mineral sources. Currently, tourists can… Read more »

Downgraded Hue temple recalls era of Nguyen Dynasty ancestor worship

The temple complex, located in the southwest corner of the Imperial Citadel in Hue, was built in 1804 under King Gia Long of Nguyen Dynasty (1802-1945), Vietnam’s last royal family. The complex covers… Read more »

Travel hotspots cash in on high tourist numbers amid national holiday

Lao Cai, home to famous highlands town Sa Pa, received 64,000 visitors during the national holiday (April 30-May 3), four times higher than the same period last year, provincial data shows. The northern… Read more »

Singapore extends stay-home period for travelers from Vietnam to 21 days

The extension, to take effect from Friday, will apply to visitors arriving from all countries and territories, except Australia, Brunei, mainland China, New Zealand, Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Macau, The Strait Times newspaper… Read more »

Busy opening of industrial park to welcome waves of investment

Since last year, the shift in production from China as well as the tendency for businesses to invest in Vietnam to benefit under free trade agreements has resulted in a sharp increase in… Read more »

Government requires careful assessment of current capacity of national power system

The Government Office announced the conclusion of the Deputy Prime Minister Le Van Thanh at the meeting on the national electricity development planning period 2021-2030, with a vision to 2045 (electricity planning VIII).… Read more »

Holiday air travel demand surges despite Covid-19 threat

During the holiday (April 30-May 3), 21 airports managed by the Airports Corporation of Vietnam (ACV) accommodated 11,000 flights, an increase of 45 percent against 2019’s same period. The country’s largest airport Tan… Read more »

Prevention of and fight against COVID-19 epidemic at the border

The mobile team of Bo Heng Border Guard Station, Dak Lak Provincial Border Guard. NDO – At the end of April 2021, a number of cases of COVID-19 in the community in Mondulkiri… Read more »

Quang Nam seafood market a basket of vibrancy

Hundreds of fishing boats gather along the Tam Tien coast, carrying fish and shrimp to shore at dawn. Local fishermen say more than 15 years ago, Tam Tien was a mere docking station… Read more »

Pedestrian streets, night markets closed amid surge in Covid-19 community transmissions

The Central Highlands province of Lam Dong has closed the pedestrian zones and night market in its resort town Da Lat since 7 p.m. Monday until further notice. Da Lat, much loved for… Read more »

Turkey lifts PCR test requirement for Vietnamese visitors

In addition to Vietnam, those from Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, the U.K., Latvia, Luxembourg, Ukraine, Thailand, South Korea, Israel, Japan, Estonia, mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan are also eligible for entry under… Read more »

Bustling Dong Tac Fishing Port

The joy when the ship arrives to port. NDO – Dong Tac Fishing Port in Phu Dong Ward, Tuy Hoa City (Phu Yen Province) is always bustling with busy ships heading to sea… Read more »

Van Long lagoon: An untouched destination in Ninh Binh province

Van Long lagoon: An untouched destination in Ninh Binh province NDO – With a total natural area of more than 3,500 hectares, Van Long lagoon in the northern province of Ninh Binh is… Read more »

Covid-19 deals fresh blow to Saigon’s tourist street

It is 7 p.m. and Nguyen Thu Huyen, an employee at a discotheque on Bui Vien Street in District 1, sits in a dark corner in front of her closed establishment trying to… Read more »

Hanoi strengthens measures against COVID-19 at tourist attractions

A staff at the Van Mieu – Quoc Tu Giam relic takes measures to prevent apnd control COVID-19 for visitors. NDO – Facing the complicated developments of COVID-19 in the community, local monuments… Read more »

Hai Van Pass among world's 10 most popular on Instagram

The U.S. travel publication compiled the list of the world’s most stunning routes based on Instagram data analysis. With over 55,000 pictures tagged #HaiVanPass on Instagram, the world’s largest photo sharing network, the… Read more »

Vietnamese lensmen win UK contest prizes with appetizing entries

Tran Viet Van won first prize in the contest’s Street Food category with a shot of four young girls enjoying che (sweet soup) on a street in Hoi An, a UNESCO heritage site… Read more »

Cua Dai Beach: pandemic rubs salt into erosion wound

It’s 9 a.m. and Nguyen Thi Be, who has been selling coconuts for a decade on the 7.5-km-long beach five kilometers from downtown Hoi An, sits on a hammock and surfs on her… Read more »

Deep herring salad in Nha Trang

Deep herring salad Deep herring is a type of forage fish, living near the coast and swimming in large schools. Nha Trang deep herring salad can be found anywhere in town. Deep herrings… Read more »

Enhancing tourism development in the new normal state

Domestic tourists visiting Bich Dong pagoda in Ninh Binh province. (Photo: Xuan Lam/ND) NDO – The complicated development of the COVID-19 pandemic has left both types of international tourism, inbound and outbound, almost… Read more »

Five delectable Chinatown snacks

Chive cakes Chinese chive cakes are made from rice flour and served either flat and round or square. Traditionally, rice flour is mixed with warm water, then hand-kneaded until the dough reaches a… Read more »

Hanoi works to 'refresh' tourism image to lure visitors

Visitors at the Hanoi Tourism and Cuisine Festival 2021 (Photo: hanoimoi.com.vn) NDO – As one of the country’s tourism markets, Hanoi is rolling every effort to ‘refresh’ the image of tourism to lure… Read more »

Vietnamese tourists pay stronger attention to sustainable tourism

Avani Quy Nhon resort honoured by the golden certificate of Green Growth 2050. (Photo: Booking.com) NDO – According to a survey by Booking.com, one of the world’s leading digital travel companies, nearly 100%… Read more »

Average CPI in 4 months increased by 0.89%, the lowest since 2016

According to the socio-economic report in April and the first 4 months of the year announced by the General Statistics Office this morning (April 29), the consumer price index (CPI) in April decreased… Read more »

Vietnam exported 18.4 billion USD of phones and components in 4 months

Socio-economic reports in April and the first 4 months of the year announced by the General Statistics Office this morning (April 29) showed that the total export turnover reached US $ 25.5 billion,… Read more »

Prime Minister asked to build a specific mechanism to develop Thua Thien Hue as a city directly under the Central Government

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has just directed the promulgation of a number of mechanisms and policies specific to Thua Thien Hue province. A corner of Thua Thien Hue province. Photo: Government Newspaper.… Read more »

More localities suspend festivals as Covid-19 risks loom large

Hai Phong, around two hours east of Hanoi, decided to suspend its annual Red Flamboyant Flower Festival 2021 which was scheduled to take place from May 11-13 to feature 66 cultural, tourism and… Read more »

Dong Nai attracts 18 FDI projects with total capital of nearly 250 million USD

From the beginning of the year to April 20, 2021, the industrial park in Dong Nai province attracted 18 new FDI projects with a registered investment capital of USD 249.23 million and a… Read more »

VNAT attaches priority to ensuring safe environment during upcoming holiday

Director General of the Vietnam National Administration of Tourism Nguyen Trung Khanh speaking at the event. NDO – The strict implementation of the Prime Minister’s directions on COVID-19 prevention and control is an… Read more »

Over half of surveyed travel firms expect normal business next year

While 22 percent of the survey respondents hoped their business would recover by the end of this year, the remaining 22 percent did not make any prediction. The survey was done recently by… Read more »