SpaceX Starlink satellites responsible for over half of close encounters in orbit, scientist says

© Provided by Space An artist’s illustration of SpaceX’s Starlink internet satellites in orbit.

Operators of satellite constellations are constantly forced to move their satellites because of encounters with other spacecraft and pieces of space junk. And, thanks to SpaceX’s Starlink satellites, the number of such dangerous approaches will continue to grow, according to estimates based on available data.

SpaceX’s Starlink satellites alone are involved in about 1,600 close encounters between two spacecraft every week, according to Hugh Lewis, the head of the Astronautics Research Group at the University of Southampton, U.K. These encounters include situations when two spacecraft pass within a distance of 0.6 miles (1 kilometer) from each other.

Lewis, Europe’s leading expert on space debris, makes regular estimates of the situation in orbit based on data from the Socrates (Satellite Orbital Conjunction Reports Assessing Threatening Encounters in Space ) database. This tool, managed by Celestrack, provides information about satellite orbits and models their trajectories into the future to assess collision risk. 

Space Junk Clean Up: 7 Wild Ways to Destroy Orbital Debris

Lewis publishes regular updates on Twitter and has seen a worrying trend in the data that reflects the fast deployment of the Starlink constellation. 

“I have looked at the data going back to May 2019 when Starlink was first launched to understand the burden of these megaconstellations,” Lewis told “Since then, the number of encounters picked up by the Socrates database has more than doubled and now we are in a situation where Starlink accounts for half of all encounters.”

The current 1,600 close passes include those between two Starlink satellites. Excluding these encounters, Starlink satellites approach other operators’ spacecraft 500 times every week. 

Related: New spacecraft sustainability rating targets space junk

In July’s update of the conjunctions involving #Starlink & #OneWeb as predicted by #SOCRATES ( we can see the continuing (exponential) rise in the number of close passes < 1 km. Now approaching 500 per week for #Starlink (80 per week for #OneWeb) [1/n] 2, 2021

See more

In comparison, Starlink’s competitor OneWeb, currently flying over 250 satellites, is involved in 80 close passes with other operators’ satellites every week, according to Lewis’ data.

And the situation is bound to get worse. Only 1,700 satellites of an expected constellation of tens of thousands have been placed into orbit so far. Once SpaceX launches all 12,000 satellites of its first generation constellation, Starlink satellites will be involved in 90% of all close approaches, Lewis’ calculations suggest.

And another for @cosmos4u: the number of conjunctions < 1 km predicted by SOCRATES per week, with and without #Starlink: 3, 2021

See more

The risk of collision

Siemak Heser, CEO and co-founder of Boulder, Colorado, based Kayhan Space, confirms the trend. His company, which develops a commercial autonomous space traffic management system, estimates that on average, an operator managing about 50 satellites will receive up to 300 official conjunction alerts a week. These alerts include encounters with other satellites as well as pieces of debris. Out of these 300 alerts, up to ten would require operators to perform avoidance maneuvers, Hesar told

Kayhan Space bases their estimates on data provided by the U.S. Space Surveillance Network. This network of radars and telescopes, managed by the U.S. Space Force, closely monitors about 30,000 live and defunct satellites and pieces of debris down to the size of 4 inches (10 centimeters) and provides the most accurate location data of the orbiting objects. 

The size of this catalog is expected to increase ten times in the near future, Hesar added, partly due to the growth of megaconstellations, such as Starlink, and partly as sensors improve and enable detection of even smaller objects. The more objects in the catalog mean more dangerously close encounters. 

“This problem is really getting out of control,” Hesar said. “The processes that are currently in place are very manual, not scalable, and there is not enough information sharing between parties that might be affected if a collision happens.”

Hesar compared the problem to driving on a highway and not knowing that there has been an accident a few miles ahead of you. If two spacecraft collide in orbit, the cloud of debris the crash generates would threaten other satellites travelling through the same area.

“You want to have that situational awareness for the other actors that are flying in the neighbourhood,” Hesar said.

Related: The worst space debris events of all time

Bad decisions

Despite the concerns, only three confirmed orbital collisions have happened so far. Earlier this week, astrophysicist and satellite tracker Jonathan McDowell, who’s based at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics in Cambridge, Massachusetts, found evidence in Space-Track data that the Chinese meteorological satellite Yunhai 1-02, which disintegrated in March this year, was actually hit by a piece of space debris. 

The worst known space collision in history took place in February 2009 when the U.S. telecommunication satellite Iridium 33 and Russia’s defunct military satellite Kosmos-2251 crashed at the altitude of 490 miles (789 kilometres). The incident spawned over 1,000 pieces of debris larger than 4 inches (10 cm). Many of these fragments were then involved in further orbital incidents. 

Lewis is concerned that with the number of close passes growing, the risk of operators at some point making a wrong decision will grow as well. Avoidance maneuvers cost fuel, time and effort. Operators, therefore, always carefully evaluate such risks. A decision not to make an avoidance maneuver following an alert, such as that made by Iridium in 2009, could, however, clutter the orbital environment for years and decades. 

“In a situation when you are receiving alerts on a daily basis, you can’t maneuver for everything,” Lewis said. “The maneuvers use propellant, the satellite cannot provide service. So there must be some threshold. But that means you are accepting a certain amount of risk. The problem is that at some point, you are likely to make a wrong decision.”

Hesar said that uncertainties in the positions of satellites and pieces of debris are still considerable. In case of operational satellites, the error could be up to 330 feet (100 meters) large. When it comes to a piece of debris, the uncertainty about its exact position might be in the order of a mile or more. 

“This object can be anywhere in this bubble of multiple kilometres,” Hesar said. “At this point, and for the foreseeable future, avoidance is our best recourse. People that say ‘I’m going to take the risk’, in my humble opinion, that’s an irresponsible thing to do.”

Starlink monopoly 

Lewis is concerned about the growing influence of a single actor — Starlink — on the safety of orbital operations. Especially, he says, as the spaceflight company has entered the satellite operations world only recently. 

“We place trust in a single company, to do the right thing,” Lewis said. “We are in a situation where most of the maneuvers we see will involve Starlink. They were a launch provider before, now they are the world’s biggest satellite operator, but they have only been doing that for two years so there is a certain amount of inexperience.”

SpaceX relies on an autonomous collision avoidance system to keep its fleet away from other spacecraft. That, however, could sometimes introduce further problems. The automatic orbital adjustments change the forecasted trajectory and therefore make collision predictions more complicated, according to Lewis.

“Starlink doesn’t publicize all the maneuvers that they’re making, but it is believed that they are making a lot of small corrections and adjustments all the time,” Lewis said. “But that causes problems for everybody else because no one knows where the satellite is going to be and what it is going to do in the next few days.”

Follow Tereza Pultarova on Twitter @TerezaPultarova. Follow us on Twitter @Spacedotcom and on Facebook. 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


How to transfer your WhatsApp chats from iPhone to Android

Welcome to TNW Basics, a collection of tips, guides, and advice on how to easily get the most out of your gadgets, apps, and other stuff. One of the biggest pain ... Read more »

WhatsApp appears to be working on adding identity verification for WhatsApp Pay users

Photo credit: Mourizal Zativa / Unsplash WhatsApp launched a service earlier this year called WhatsApp Pay with relatively minimal requirements to allow users to transfer and receive payments. However, codes found in a ... Read more »

Netflix's first proper Cowboy Bebop trailer should put your doubts to rest

After teasing fans with a recreation of the original anime’s iconic intro and a special “Lost Session” video, Netflix has finally dropped a proper trailer for its upcoming Cowboy Bebop ... Read more »

Oci Q3 net income up 2829.7 pct. to 177.6 bln won

SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — Oci Co. on Wednesday reported its third-quarter net profit of 177.6 billion won (US$151.8 million), up 2829.7 percent from a year earlier. The company said ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S22 specs: Ultra model to use ‘improved' main camera and new Sony sensors, leaker says

Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra | Photo credit: Salman Majeed / Unsplash A long-time reliable leaker has released the supposed technical specs of the Galaxy S22 Ultra cameras. While Samsung will reportedly use improved ... Read more »

Otto Wichterle: Czech chemist who invented soft contact lenses is recognised in Google Doodle

Google celebrated life and legacy of Otto Wichterle on his 108th birthday (Google) On his 108th birthday, Google’s Wednesday doodle honoured the life and legacy of Otto Wichterle, a Czech ... Read more »

(LEAD) Kia Q3 net jumps on base effect, chip woes remain

(ATTN: REWRITES throughout; ADDS photo)By Choi Kyong-ae SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — Kia Corp., South Korea’s second-biggest carmaker, said Wednesday its third-quarter net profit rose sharply due to a lack ... Read more »

COP26: How ordinary people are trying to help stop climate change, from electric boats to hydrogen buses

We have come to understand that the climate crisis is everyone’s problem. Around the country, people are taking the message seriously – not just at home, but in their local community, too.   From ... Read more »

China Telecom: US revokes licence of top Chinese ISP over ‘national security' concerns

File: China Telecom says the US move is disappointing, adding that they will plan to pursue all available options while continuing to serve their customers (AP) The US has revoked ... Read more »

Apple rolls out iOS 14.8.1 and iPadOS 14.8.1 updates with security fixes

Earlier this year, Apple announced that iPhone users will have a choice to either update to iOS 15 or stay on iOS 14. However, sticking to iOS14 did not mean ... Read more »

Non-financial firms see 2020 sales drop for first time in 10 years amid pandemic

SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — Non-financial companies in South Korea saw their combined sales shrink for the first time in 10 years in 2020 affected by an overall slump in ... Read more »

Heidi Klum poses in orange lingerie for new Fendi x SKIMS collaboration

Heidi Klum, 48, got cheeky on Instagram Tuesday while posing in an orange lingerie set from Fendi’s new collaboration with Kim Kardashian’s SKIMS. Read more »

AMD forecasts strong revenue on data-center, gaming chips demand

Advanced Micro Devices Inc on Tuesday projected higher fourth-quarter revenue than market expectations, betting on its ability to overcome a weak supply chain to meet strong demand for chips used ... Read more »

Government notifies framework for traffic management of drones in lower airspace

The Civil Aviation Ministry has notified a traffic management framework for drones under which public and private third-party service providers will manage their movement in the airspace under 1,000 feet. ... Read more »

SK Group chief pays respects over death of late ex-President Roh

SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — SK Group Chairman Chey Tae-won visited a funeral home in Seoul on Wednesday to pay respects over the death of late former President Roh Tae-woo, ... Read more »

Samsung Electro-Mechanics Q3 net profit up 47.3% to W353.5b

(123rf)Samsung Electro-Mechanics Co. on Wednesday reported its third-quarter net income of 353.5 billion won ($302 million), up 47.3 percent from a year earlier. The company said in a regulatory filing ... Read more »

Garena Free Fire Redeem Codes for October 27, 2021: How to redeem daily codes

Garena Free Fire is an action-adventure battle royal game. It is one of the highly-rated mobile games on the Play Store and has gained popularity in recent times in the ... Read more »

Samsung Electro-Mechanics Q3 net profit up 47.3 pct. to 353.5 bln won

SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — Samsung Electro-Mechanics Co. on Wednesday reported its third-quarter net income of 353.5 billion won (US$302 million), up 47.3 percent from a year earlier. The company ... Read more »

US orders Chinese phone carrier out

US regulators are expelling a unit of China Telecom Ltd., one of the country's three major state-owned carriers, from the American market as a national security threat amid rising tension ... Read more »

Nuggets' MVP center Nikola Jokic leaves game vs. Jazz with knee injury

Nikola Jokic didn’t return after suffering a knee injury on Tuesday. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski) Nikola Jokic left Tuesday's game against the Utah Jazz with a knee injury and didn't return. ... Read more »

8 Harim affiliates fined W3.8b for providing undue biz favors to Orpum

Harim Group logo (Harim Group)South Korea’s antitrust regulator said Wednesday it has imposed a combined fine of 3.8 billion won ($3.3 million) on eight affiliates of Harim Co. for providing ... Read more »

US exploring how banks can hold and trade cryptocurrency like traditional assets, FDIC chairman says

A top US bank regulator said US officials are looking to provide a clearer path for banks and their clients that are looking to hold cryptocurrencies, in order to keep ... Read more »

Family of Indigenous woman who shot dead alleged rapist ‘in self defence' appeals to judge for mercy

Maddesyn George with mother mother Jody George – ‘I just wish she was with me now’ (Courtesy family) The family of a Native American woman who shot dead her alleged ... Read more »

Democratic Lawmaker Tells 'Cheap Mistress' Trump What Republicans Say Behind His Back

Rep. Sean Patrick Maloney (D-N.Y.) trolled Donald Trump during an MSNBC interview by pointing out that a number of Republicans who raise money off the former president’s name want nothing ... Read more »

An artificial intelligence tool is helping retailers and manufacturers weather the holidays by simulating supply chain issues before they happen

Visitors watch a digital twins simulation service system for sports venues by Intel at the Apsara Conference, a cloud computing and artificial intelligence (AI) conference, in Hangzhou, in China’s eastern ... Read more »

Yubico is making secure authentication even more affordable

Yubico is expanding its lineup of security keys with a brand new model for individuals that enables secure authentication on devices featuring USB-C and NFC. The company’s new blue Security ... Read more »

Pokemon Go developer's new AR Pikmin Bloom game has arrived

Earlier in the year we learned that Niantic, the creators of smash-hit mobile AR game Pokemon Go, were working with Nintendo again on a similar title in the Pikmin universe. ... Read more »

Amazon app quiz October 27, 2021: Get answers to these five questions to win Rs 30,000 in Amazon Pay balance

Win Rs 30,000 in your Amazon Pay balance today! You just have to answer 5 questions and a bit of luck. Amazon is back with its daily dose of app ... Read more »

Korea Zinc Inc Q3 net profit up 17.5 pct. to 200.3 bln won

SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — Korea Zinc Inc. on Wednesday reported its third-quarter net profit of 200.3 billion won (US$171.6 million), up 17.5 percent from a year earlier. The company ... Read more »

Can Hong Kong's Li Ka-shing, the tycoon dubbed ‘superman', save the planet with ‘edible plastic', seaweed food cartons?

Horizons Ventures, the private investment arm of Hong Kong’s best known billionaire, Li Ka-shing, said its investments in sustainability projects from “edible plastic” to fake leather and plant-based chicken nuggets ... Read more »

Hyundai-Rotem Q3 net profit up 36.3 pct. to 6.2 bln won

SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — Hyundai-Rotem Co. on Wednesday reported its third-quarter net income of 6.2 billion won (US$5.3 million), up 36.3 percent from a year earlier. The company said ... Read more »

TikTok, YouTube and Snapchat defend impact on kids at US hearing

US TikTok Vice President and Head of Public Policy Michael Beckerman (right) testifies in a Senate hearing about kids’safety online on Capitol Hill 2021, with Snapchat Vice President of Global ... Read more »

Samsung SDS Q3 net profit up 23.9 pct. to 199.4 bln won

SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — Samsung SDS Co. on Wednesday reported its third-quarter net profit of 199.4 billion won (US$170.8 million), up 23.9 percent from a year earlier. The company ... Read more »

(URGENT) S. Korea reports 9 additional coronavirus deaths, total now at 2,797: KDCA

(END) Read more »

Pan Ocean Q3 net income up 325.2 pct. to 179 bln won

SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — Pan Ocean Co. on Wednesday reported its third-quarter net income of 179 billion won (US$153.4 million), up 325.2 percent from a year earlier. The company ... Read more »

Chiefs of Samsung SDI, Stellantis meet in Hungary following U.S. battery plant deal

SEOUL, Oct. 27 (Yonhap) — The chiefs of South Korean battery maker Samsung SDI Co. and global automaker Stallantis N.V. have met in Hungary, company officials said Wednesday, days after ... Read more »

(URGENT) 2,066 more patients released from coronavirus treatment, total now at 329,658: KDCA

(END) Read more »

DTAC's Q3 profits dip sharply

SET-listed mobile carrier Total Access Communication (DTAC) reported 13.9 billion baht in third-quarter service revenue, excluding interconnection charges (IC), down 2.1% quarterly and 2.8% year-on-year, weighed down by the impact ... Read more »

Number of women execs at major firms tops 300 this year

(Yonhap)The number of female executives at South Korea’s top 100 firms increased in 2021 from a year earlier to surpass the 300 mark for the first time, data showed Wednesday. ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: How will the rest of this outbreak play out?

Fresh modelling has highlighted the need for a “circuit-breaking” fortnight at level 4 If Auckland’s daily Covid-19 case numbers track toward a disastrous health system overload. But if transmission rates ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic