Southland man who filmed employee in shower gets permanent name suppression

Southland man who filmed employee in shower gets permanent name suppression

The decision to grant permanent name suppression to a Southland man who filmed his 18-year-old employee having a shower has left the victim’s family disgusted.

The 38-year-old man was sentenced yesterday in the Invercargill District Court after he admitted attempting to make an intimate visual recording in relation to an incident in October last year.

Judge John Strettell sentenced the man to 12 months’ supervision and granted him permanent name suppression after considering a psychologist’s report expressing concerns for his safety.

Speaking to the Otago Daily Times outside court, the victim’s family said they were shocked and disappointed by the court’s decision.

Financial reparation was discussed, but the family did not want any money from the man — they just wanted to see justice done.

They said they were worried the same fate could be suffered by another family.

“My son didn’t deserve that. My son was brave enough to speak up to prevent this happening with any other boy — but now we can’t tell anyone about it.

“He [the defendant] has 12 months of someone checking on him, while my son has the rest of his life to live with that.

“Today was about us getting a closure and being able to deal with it, but this did not help anything.”

The 18-year-old victim was working away from Invercargill when the man tried to film him twice in the shower.

While he was his employer, the defendant was also a close family friend and was a kind of “big brother” to the victim, the court heard.

The victim’s father read out his son’s victim impact statement in court yesterday.

The victim described how he felt betrayed by the man and he could not leave his house for a month after the incident.

He still had flashbacks about the episode, the court heard.

The victim and his family asked the judge to not grant the man name suppression, as they believed having his name published would deter him from doing the same thing to other boys.

It would also allow the victim to speak freely about what happened to him and move on.

Defence lawyer Richard Little said this was his client’s first offence and he was undertaking psychological treatment.

He was depressed, being medicated and the publication of his name would cause him even more hardship.

Little said his client would never commit the same offending again.

“The court can have confidence that he will stick to what he says.”

Judge Strettell acknowledged the traumatic effect the episode would have in the life of the victim and thanked the family for their statements.

He said the conduct of the man breached community standards, but he was satisfied the publication of his name could cause a serious psychological impact on the defendant.

“There is a real and serious possibility of self-harm. I cannot discount that.”

He sentenced the man to 12 months of supervision with any conditions imposed by Corrections to be followed.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Covid-19 Delta outbreak: New Zealand A&P Show cancelled again

The New Zealand Agricultural Show has been cancelled for the second consecutive time. The organisers have decided not to go ahead with event planned to begin in Canterbury on November ... Read more »

Fire crews called to emergency at Christchurch Airport

Fire crews are on standby for an emergency at Christchurch Airport. A Fire and Emergency NZ spokesperson said they did not know what the emergency was yet. Flight ANZ771M has ... Read more »

Shopper's lucky escape - Dunedin woman almost crushed by toppled pole

A woman narrowly missed being crushed by a lamppost as she was loading shopping into her car at a Dunedin supermarket yesterday. The woman’s close call came when the pole ... Read more »

Power outage on West Coast caused by human error

An outage that left thousands of West Coast residents without power for several hours was caused by human error. The outage last Thursday began at about 9.20am and affected Westport, ... Read more »

Covid 19: Holiday parks discussing vaccine mandates for campers

One of New Zealand’s largest resort groups is considering options for how to accommodate unvaccinated campers in preparation for summer. TOP 10, which runs fifty campgrounds across the country, said ... Read more »

Driver who attacked police in Dunedin gets community detention

A drink-driver in an unsafe vehicle kicked and spat at officers then damaged a police car after being arrested, a court has heard. Robert William McRae, 29, appeared in the ... Read more »

Man charged in relation to shooting of 19-year-old in Invercargill

A man appeared in the Invercargill District Court yesterday afternoon in relation to the shooting of a 19-year-old man in the city on Saturday. A police spokeswoman said the 25-year-old ... Read more »

Social cricketer who assaulted umpire and opponent says he has anxiety

A social cricketer who attacked two opponents says he cannot do his community work because of his anxiety. William John Campbell, 39, was sentenced to nine months’ supervision and 60 ... Read more »

Suicide numbers in south second-highest in more than a decade

The South has recorded its second-highest number of suicides in more than a decade, sparking concern about how the region’s vulnerable are being cared for. Chief Coroner Judge Deborah Marshall ... Read more »

Flood costs farming couple $1m as recovery grinds on

By Conan Young of RNZ It’s been four months since the Ashburton District was slammed with a one-in-200-year flood and still, the clean up continues. With most of the $4 ... Read more »

Timaru tragedy: Murder-accused mum Lauren Dickason back in court after tragic death of three daughters

A woman charged with murdering her three young daughters at their Timaru home has been excused from today’s court appearance as her mental health assessments continue. A trial date has ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Top six districts for vaccination in South Island but hurdles remain

Vaccination rates in the South are among the best in New Zealand for meeting the threat of Covid-19, but a challenge looms in reaching rural areas. The Queenstown Lakes district ... Read more »

Two dead, five injured in two serious crashes in South Island

Two people have died in two separate crashes in the South Island. Police confirmed a person died early this morning after an incident on State Highway 7, Weka Pass Rd, ... Read more »

Up for sale: Iconic Britten Stables on the market

The luxurious home once belonging to world-renowned motorcycle designer John Britten is up for sale in Mona Vale in Christchurch. The centrepiece is its spectacular glass conservatory; the curved marble ... Read more »

Timaru tragedy: Murder-accused mum Lauren Dickason back in court this morning

The woman charged with murdering her three young daughters at their Timaru home last month is scheduled to appear in court again this morning. Lauren Anne Dickason, 40, allegedly killed ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: South Island businesses frustrated at lack of level change

By Samantha Gee of RNZ There has been some reprieve with an easing of restrictions for hospitality businesses, but after almost a month in level 2 many South Island businesses ... Read more »

Invercargill teen shot four times in the back, police asking public for help

Police are appealing for information from the public after a teenager was shot four times in the back and is in a critical but stable condition in hospital. The man, ... Read more »

Christchurch businessman facing 40 charges related to sexual abuse of child has another 40 charges dropped

A Christchurch businessman who was facing 80 charges relating to child sex abuse including multiple counts of raping a little girl and filming himself has had half the counts against ... Read more »

Man claims holding door closed caused erratic driving in Dunedin

A man spotted driving erratically in Dunedin said he was holding his damaged door closed after reversing into a post. Police were called at 9am on Sunday after reports of ... Read more »

Canterbury's country cricket season under way with rising star's spectacular double century

The new country cricket season got under way on Saturday with Weedons edging out a hard-fought win over Sefton, and rising star Rhys Mariu blasting a spectacular double century to ... Read more »

Covid-19 coronavirus Delta outbreak: South Island will stay at level 2 for now

The South Island will not move from alert level 2 down to alert level 1 today, Deputy Prime Minister Grant Robertson says. It comes after two fresh community cases were ... Read more »

Death of Mason Pendrous in Canterbury University dorm room - coroner releases final report

A final Coroner’s report has been released into the death of a Canterbury University student who was found weeks later in his dorm room. And while the cause of Mason ... Read more »

Mason's legacy: No answers around Christchurch uni dorm death, but comfort in sweeping education and law changes

A final Coroner’s report has been released into the death of a Canterbury University student who was found weeks later in his dorm room. And while the cause of Mason ... Read more »

Five helicopters dispatched to bring large burn-off under control near Hanmer Springs in North Canterbury

Helicopters have been dispatched to tame an out-of-control burn-off in North Canterbury. About five helicopters were spotted by a passerby with monsoon buckets used to dampen down a large fire ... Read more »

Aotearoa-New Zealand name change debate: Ngai Tahu leader says don't rush name change

A Ngai Tahu leader has called for a rethink on a movement to change New Zealand’s official name to Aotearoa, saying it risks overlooking the South Island. A name change ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Campaign to get 90 per cent of Cantabrians vaccinated ramping up

A campaign to ensure 90 per cent of Cantabrians have had at least one vaccination against Covid-19 by Labour Weekend is ramping up with a pop-up clinic for the Samoan ... Read more »

Proof of small Maori settlement found in Marlborough's Waikawa Bay

An old Māori tool and “fireplace” have been unearthed at Marlborough’s Waikawa Bay, as pipework is carried out next to the seashore. A senior archaeologist hired to watch over the ... Read more »

Man arrested after spitting in Countdown supermarket guard's face

By RNZ A security guard at a Christchurch supermarket is being tested for Covid-19 after a customer spat at him after being refused entry. Countdown spokeswoman Kiri Hannifin said the ... Read more »

Missing three-year-old found near Dunedin beach

A parent’s worst nightmare came to a happy ending after a three-year-old boy went missing from a Dunedin household, with footprints found leading to the beach. There was a huge ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus Delta outbreak: 'Piece of the puzzle we're looking for' - outbreak linked to Sydney returnee; 11 new cases, 2 in hospital

There are now 21 Delta Covid cases in Auckland, including two in hospital. Nineteen are in the Auckland quarantine facility. Twelve of the 21 have been confirmed as part of ... Read more »

Contact from baby-poisoner a 'kick in the guts'

An woman who poisoned her son while he was in intensive care says she will not regret having the child even if she never sees him again. The defendant contacted ... Read more »

Covid lockdown: 'Moronic' supermarket shoppers seen sprinting for supplies

Kiwis have ignored calls to shop normally as the latest Covid-19 lockdown was announced, with many racing to supermarkets and stocking up on supplies – even “sprinting” to items to ... Read more »

Christchurch Airbnb party fatal stabbing: Property owners 'devastated'

The owners of a Christchurch holiday home where 16-year-old Zion Purukamu was fatally stabbed and two other teenagers hospitalised during a party say they are “devastated”. A scene examination continues ... Read more »

Christchurch Airbnb party fatal stabbing: Property owners feel 'completely conned'

The owners of a Christchurch holiday home where 16-year-old Zion Purukamu was fatally stabbed and two other teenagers hospitalised during a party say they are “devastated”. A scene examination continues ... Read more »

Police name 16-year-old fatally stabbed at Christchurch Airbnb party

Police have this afternoon identified Zion Purukamu as the 16-year-old who was killed in a stabbing incident in Christchurch last night. Purukamu was from the Christchurch suburb of Hoon Hay. ... Read more »

Timaru car crash that killed teens one of 13 in NZ with five or more victims

The crash that claimed the lives of five Timaru teenagers last weekend is the 13th in New Zealand where five or more people have been killed in the past 20 ... Read more »

Buyer tries to stop US billionaire Peter Thiel selling luxury Queenstown home to rival purchaser

A Queenstown resident has taken a caveat out against US billionaire Peter Thiel’s multi-million dollar clifftop home in a bid to stop it being sold to another buyer. Brian McGee ... Read more »

Invercargill mayoralty: Sir Bob Harvey speaks out on Sir Tim Shadbolt's 'hoarding', offers to mediate

A former mayor and lifetime friend of Sir Tim Shadbolt is “begging” Invercargill City Council not to trash the memorabilia of New Zealand’s longest serving mayor. Sir Bob Harvey, who ... Read more »

Local government expert on unfolding Invercargill council / mayoral saga

A local government expert is calling on ministerial intervention for the Invercargill City Council after a tumultuous week in the deep south. On Tuesday, deputy mayor Nobby Clark indicated Mayor ... Read more »

Memorials for Olympic cyclist Olivia Podmore in Cambridge, Christchurch

A memorial next week to remember Olympic cyclist Olivia Podmore has been scheduled so fellow cyclists still in MIQ can attend and celebrate her life. Podmore, 24, who represented New ... Read more »