Sorry former Pentagon expert, but China is nowhere near winning the AI race

Asia's Tech News Daily

Microsoft, artificial intelligence, Google, Baidu, Amazon, China, DARPA, Apple

Nicolas Chaillan, the Pentagon’s former Chief Software Officer, is on a whirlwind press tour to drum up as much fervor for his radical assertion that the US has already lost the AI race against China.

Speaking to the in his first interview after leaving his post at the Pentagon, Chaillan said:

We have no competing fighting chance against China in 15 to 20 years. Right now, it’s already a done deal.

Chaillan’s departure from the Pentagon was preceded by a “blistering letter” where he signaled he was quitting out of frustration over the government’s inability to properly implement cybersecurity and artificial intelligence technologies.

And, now, he’s telling anyone who will listen that the US has already lost a war to China that hasn’t even happened yet. He’s essentially saying that the US is a sitting duck who’s safety and sanctity is predicated on the fact that China is choosing not to attack and destroy us.

., the Pentagon’s former chief software officer, who resigned over the military’s reluctance to address the US’s “kindergarten” cybersecurity and AI capabilities compared to China’s, gave a dire warning to the American people, on Thursday’s “Wake Up America.”

— Newsmax (@newsmax)

And, let’s be clear, Chaillan’s not talking about a hot war. Per the FT article, he said “whether it takes some kind of war or not is anecdotal.”

This is what you call propaganda.

Here’s why:

  1.  The idea that the US is losing any sort of AI race to China is laughable
  2.  Chaillan’s outrage is purely performative

The score: It doesn’t matter how you measure things, the US is not losing the AI race to China.

Among China‘s top AI companies you’ll find Baidu, a business with about .

Let’s put that into perspective. Google is worth over . That’s 18 times more than Baidu. And that’s just Google. Amazon, Apple, and Microsoft are also worth a trillion and they’re all AI companies as well.

There is no measure, including talent draw and laboratory size, by which you could say China is even in the same class when it comes to AI companies.

And when it comes to AI research coming out of universities, the US again leads the world by a grand margin.

Not only does the US attract students from all over the world, but it also houses some of the world’s most advanced AI programs at the university level. Between the cognitive research done at places like NYU and Harvard and the machine learning applications for engineering being invented at MIT, Carnegie Mellon, and their ilk, it’s incredibly difficult to make an argument that China‘s academic research outclasses the US’.

That’s not to denigrate the amazing work being done by researchers in China, but there’s certainly no reason to believe China‘s going to overtake the West in a matter of time by sheer virtue of its academia.

And that just leaves public-sector and military AI. What’s interesting about China is that, nationally, its government gives far more support for AI research than any other nation.

that China‘s massive investments in public sector research combined with its authoritarian approach to controlling what the public sector and academia do, could lead to a situation where China leapfrogs the US.

This, however, is conjecture. The reality is that US companies don’t need government investments. Unlike the US government, Amazon isn’t in massive debt to its shareholders. Amazon is one of the most profitable enterprises in the history of humanity.

And there’s no law saying Amazon must work with the US government. It’s free to continue making money hand over fist and pushing the philosophical limits on what wealth is or how economies work whether it chooses to play ball with the Pentagon or not.

The point is this: In China, all research is military research.

The FT article makes it apparent that Chaillan’s real problem is with democracy:

He also blamed the reluctance of Google to work with the US defence department on AI, and extensive debates over AI ethics for slowing the US down. By contrast, he said Chinese companies are obliged to work with Beijing, and were making “massive investment” into AI without regard to ethics.

In some weird “give up your freedoms for the greater good way” his words might make sense. Except for one thing: the one major player in the global AI game that we haven’t spoken about yet is the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, more commonly referred to by its acronym .

DARPA is the US government’s version of the laboratory Q leads in the James Bond universe. It’s always looking for technologies – literally any technologies, no matter how strange or unlikely – to exploit for military use.

But there’s nothing fictional about DARPA or its work. Either DARPA or a DARPA-adjacent agency of similar reform is at the financial heart of thousands upon thousands of university studies and technology projects in the US every year.

For perspective: DARPA literally invented the internet, GPS, and the graphical user-interface.

I mention all of this to point out that there is no domain by which you can say the US is not leading the world in AI. I’m not saying that as a patriot (disclosure: I’m a US citizen who lives abroad and a US Navy veteran). I’m saying it because it’s demonstrably true.

In fairness, Chaillan’s clarified his words since the FT article. On LinkedIn :

For those who saw this article, I want to clarify one thing. I never said we lost. I said as it stands and if we don’t wake up NOW we have no fighting chance to win against China in 15 years. I also said that they’re leading in AI and Cyber NOW. Not in 10 years as some reports mention.

Of course 750 pages government funded reports always tell us we have more time than we have so no one is held accountable for missing the already past due target.

Those are just common sense fact. We are competing against 1.5B folks here. Either we are smarter and more agile or we lose. Period.

Never let the truth get in the way of a good story eh? Per the FT article:

We have no competing fighting chance against China in 15 to 20 years. Right now, it’s already a done deal; it is already over in my opinion,” he said, adding there was “good reason to be angry”.

The bottom line is that Chaillan’s spreading propaganda. He’s employing a centuries-old racist trope called the “China Bogeyman.” The US has used it for decades to justify its bloated defense budget to the public.

The idea is that US citizens should be scared of China not because of its academic, economic, or military technologies. But because of the sheer fact that there are 1.5 billion people in that country who aren’t Americans.

Chaillan’s using the China Bogeyman and his former positions as an IT boss for the Air Force and the Pentagon as a political tool. Whether his goal is to run for office or a to get a lofty consulting position at a conservative-leaning organization, it’s clear what the purpose of Chaillan’s outlandish statements are: to pressure the public into believing their safety relies on doing whatever it takes to ward off the imminent threat posed by the mere existence of 1.5 billion people in China.

It’s a baseless argument against the development of ethical AI and policies restricting the US from creating and using harmful AI technologies.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


DocuSign falls as much as 39.3% in early trading after downbeat Q4 guidance

© Igor Golovniov/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images Igor Golovniov/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images E-signature company DocuSign dropped as much as 39% in regular trading on Friday. The company gave downbeat fourth-quarter guidance, as it ... Read more »

Finland battles 'exceptional' malware attack spread by phones

The messages started beeping Finns’ mobiles late last week, prompting the National Cyber Security Centre to issue a “severe alert”. HELSINKI (BLOOMBERG) – Finland is working to stop a flood ... Read more »

7 new movies and TV shows on Netflix, Amazon Prime, HBO Max and more this weekend

We’ve been warning you all for the past few weeks, but Christmas has well and truly arrived on streamers in 2021. This weekend will see several new festive movies and ... Read more »

Simple £3 energy trick could save you £200 on heating bills - here's how it works

Energy bills are rising across the UK, putting more strain on struggling households just as temperatures start to drop. But there are some simple things you can do around the ... Read more »

Everyone's been talking about AWS, and Google Cloud is jealous

Just as the curtain falls on Amazon Web Services’ re:Invent 2021 event, Google Cloud has announced a series of new cloud regions, not just in the US, but around the ... Read more »

Microsoft to stop forcing Edge on Windows 11 users

Microsoft has changed the way Windows 11 handles switching default web browsers, thankfully, reversing an unpopular decision it made when the OS was still in pre-release testing (back in August). ... Read more »

Robots doing brain surgery: CEO describes the latest in medical AI

The development of the Moderna (MRNA) coronavirus vaccine relied on it. The early discovery and modeling of COVID-19 outbreaks depended on it. And new drugs for the disease benefited from ... Read more »

Video: £100k Robot displays life-like facial expressions and 'could go to meetings'

Ameca is billed as the "world's most advanced human shaped robot". CEO of Engineered Arts Will Jackson says the machine could take someone's place in a meeting, and costs more than £100,000. Read more »

Duke of Cambridge joins forces with Apple for audio episode to get people walking outdoors

The special Christmas episode of Time to Walk with the Duke of Cambridge will air on Apple Fitness+ on Monday, December 6 – Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images Europe The Duke ... Read more »

Best electric heaters to keep you warm all winter

Electric oil heater, oil-filled radiator on the floor. 3D rendering. (Getty Images) Yahoo Life’s editors are committed to independently selecting wonderful products at great prices for you. We may receive ... Read more »

Tesla recalls one in every four Model Ys it has made in the first 1o months of the year to fix faulty steering

Tesla will recall more than 20,000 of its bestselling made-in-China Model Y sport-utility vehicles (SUVs) to fix a steering issue. The US electric vehicle (EV) giant will recall 21,599 Model ... Read more »

When Amazon came to town: Swindon feels strain as new depot sucks up jobs

Photograph: Graeme Robertson/The Guardian Firm has hired 2,000 staff in a matter of months in Wiltshire town, with ripple effect on other businesses On an industrial estate outside Swindon, it’s ... Read more »

COVID-19: First encounter with virus shapes body's future immune response to new infections, research shows

Instead of having a one-size-fits-all approach, developers could, researchers suggest, tailor make vaccines according to a person's infection history. Read more »

China wants to turn Macau from a casino den into a tech base for the Greater Bay Area

China is forging a new identity for Macau, the world’s largest casino den, as a regional technology hub, according to Chinese technology industry executives and officials. As the former Portuguese ... Read more »

Hey Google, here's a blueprint for a Pixel smartwatch to rival the Apple Watch

The cat’s out of the bag, once more. After a few years of silence, we are again seeing reports about Google working on its own Pixel-branded smartwatch. We just know ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell's 58-page rule book for staff at Jeffrey Epstein's mansion revealed

Ghislaine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell wrote a household manual for staff at Jeffrey Epstein’s Florida home, instructing employees to “see nothing, hear nothing, say nothing”, a former housekeeper revealed in testimony ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell trial – live: Defence to quiz former Epstein employee after graphic sex toy testimony

Day five of the trial of British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell starts in New York City, as the 59-year-old answers to charges related to her alleged involvement in financier Jeffrey Epstein’s ... Read more »

Need a doctor? Google can now help you find places that accept your health insurance

Looking for a new doctor who takes your health insurance? An update to Google search might make that easier. Google announced updates to search results providing more information on doctors, ... Read more »

Alcohol, anorexia and chronic colloidal silver ingestion revealed as cause of death in mummified Love Has Won cult leader

The autopsy report of Colorado cult leader Amy Carlson aka “Mother God” has revealed that the leader of religious group Love Has Won died due to a history of alcohol ... Read more »

Want to trade in your smartphone? Take these steps first: Talking Tech podcast

Hit play on the player above to hear the podcast and follow along with the transcript below. This transcript was automatically generated, and then edited for clarity in its current ... Read more »

Little Mix speak out on 'terribly emotional' hiatus decision

Watch: Little Mix 'taking break' after Confetti tour next year Little Mix have opened up on the “terribly emotional” decision to take a hiatus from the performing. This week saw ... Read more »

Trove of new dinosaur fossils in Italy helps rewrite prehistory of the Mediterranean region

An adult and two juvenile individuals of the dinosaur ‘Tethyshadros insularis’ showing the different appearances exhibited by immature and mature specimens (Davide Bonadonna) A trove of new dinosaur skeletons unearthed ... Read more »

Omicron: Britain plans to vaccinate 25 million in two months – but can it be done?

What impact the new omicron variant will have is still unknown. But with early data suggesting it could be the most transmissible form of the virus yet – and that ... Read more »

Oppo Inno Day 2021 date announced, may include new flagship launch

Chinese smartphone giant Oppo has announced the schedule of its annual ’Oppo Inno Day’ through a press release, which will be held on December 14 and 15 this year in ... Read more »

Electric toothbrush duo reduced by £85 in Amazon's Christmas sale

This toothbrush deal is too good to miss. (Getty Images) Yahoo Life's editors are committed to independently selecting wonderful products at great prices for you. We may receive a share ... Read more »

A single VPN drop-out exposed breach scandal that cost Ubiquiti $4bn

A brief VPN outage has led to the arrest of a former Ubiquiti developer, who has reportedly been charged with stealing data and trying to extort his employer while pretending ... Read more »

Cheap AMD GPUs could finally arrive from January 2022

AMD is rumored to have a pair of wallet-friendly graphics cards in the pipeline, and the latest speculation has floated release dates for the RX 6500 XT and RX 6400 ... Read more »

How to add a widget to your Mac in macOS Monterey

The release of macOS Monterey has brought an impressive list of new features for users to enjoy. In this guide, we’ll be focusing on widgets, a feature that’s seen a ... Read more »

The Samsung Galaxy S21 FE is rumored to cost the same as the S20 FE

The Samsung Galaxy S21 FE is expected to finally make its debut next month, and according to the latest rumor, it’s going to go on sale at the same price ... Read more »

Homeowner £1,800 out of pocket by rogue builder who left bubbles in his ceiling

Homeowners are being left thousands of pounds out of pocket by rogue tradespeople advertised on social media. Members of the public are paying upfront for home renovation projects – only ... Read more »

Huawei could launch HarmonyOS for global customers next year: Report

Chinese technology company Huawei has seen its share of trouble globally but in the native market, the company is still a big player. The company’s own HarmonyOS, which has been ... Read more »

Scientists Have Found The Two Most Effective Covid Booster Jabs

(Photo: Yui Mok – PA Images via Getty Images) The Pfizer and Moderna vaccines are the most effective Covid booster jabs. a new study has found, but all boosters could ... Read more »

William records audio walking tour for Apple

The Duke of Cambridge has followed in the footsteps of Dolly Parton and Naomi Campbell and recorded an audio walking tour to encourage the public to get active for their ... Read more »

This is what Reliance chairman Mukesh Ambani has to say on data privacy and cryptocurrency bills

Billionaire Mukesh Ambani on Friday backed the proposed data privacy and cryptocurrency bills, saying India is putting in place the most forward-looking policies and regulations.Ambani, who has been a votary ... Read more »

New Data Shows Startups Prefer Keyword-Based Descriptive Domain Names

For the past few decades, it was assumed that rising startups would opt for exact brand match domain names ending in the legacy top-level domain (TLD) .com as soon as ... Read more »

Indian doctor with no travel history tests positive for omicron: ‘This may be everywhere already'

Indian doctor with no travel history tests positive for omicron: ‘This may be everywhere already’ A 46-year-old Indian doctor with no travel history is among the two people who have ... Read more »

13 Things To Try If Your Allergies Are Worse Than Ever This Year

If your allergies are bothering you more than normal, these product suggestions and expert-backed tips may help ease your symptoms. (Photo: PeopleImages via Getty Images) If you’re really feeling it ... Read more »

Meta pushes high-profile Facebook account holders to enable Facebook Protect features

Photo credit: Timothy Hales Bennett on Unsplash Meta appears to be making more effort to push Facebook users handling high-profile pages to enable Facebook Protect features. Those who fail to turn on the ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S21 FE price leaks, and it's reportedly just $100 cheaper than Galaxy S21

Samsung Galaxy S20 | Photo credit: Daniel Romero on Unsplash With the possibility of the Samsung Galaxy S21 FE launching in a month, more details about the anticipated mid-range phone have leaked once ... Read more »

Polar Grit X Pro review

Two-minute review The Grit X Pro showcases the best that Polar has to offer in terms of sports tracking and rich data analysis – and adding more navigation features means ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic