Some states are changing the laws that govern community libraries

some states are changing the laws that govern community libraries

Attempts to ban books in school districts around the country have increased in recent years. Now, some states are working on enacting laws to give politicians more power over public libraries. Rick Bowmer/AP hide caption

toggle caption Rick Bowmer/AP

When the Kentucky Legislature started mulling a bill that would tighten control over public libraries earlier this year, librarians across the state called their lawmakers pushing for its defeat.

In the past, legislators would at least have heard them out, says Jean Ruark, chair of the advocacy committee of the Kentucky Library Association. Not this time.

“It seemed as though our efforts fell on deaf ears. There was a big outcry about the passage of that and they did it anyway,” Ruark says.

At a time when public school libraries have increasingly become targets in the culture wars, some red states are going further, proposing legislation aimed at libraries serving the community as a whole. A few of the bills would open librarians up to legal liability over decisions they make.

While some of these bills have quietly died in committee, others have been signed into law, and librarians worry that the increasingly partisan climate is making them vulnerable to political pressure.

“We’re seeing more indirect efforts to control what’s available to the community or to put in laws that would direct how the library staff collects books,” says Deborah Caldwell Stone, director of the American Library Association’s Office for Intellectual Freedom.

“A lot of this legislation is really concerning, largely because of the breadth and scope of it, but also because it removes local control from communities,” says Patrick Sweeney, executive director at EveryLibrary, an advocacy group that tracks the legislation.

The bill passed in Kentucky allows local library boards to be appointed by county officials. Sponsors argued that the move makes libraries, which are funded by local property taxes, more accountable to taxpayers.

But opponents say the legislation will undermine the independence of local librarians, which are supposed to serve the public as a whole.

“It’s giving all of this power to partisan elected officials in counties, and if their constituents start telling them they want to ban books, this would allow them to do it. This is incredibly dangerous,” says Kentucky state Rep. Patti Minter, a Democrat who opposed the bill.

The bill was first passed by the Republican-controlled legislature and vetoed by Gov. Andy Beshear, a Democrat. But Republicans were able to muster enough additional support to override the veto, and the bill takes effect at the start of 2023.

Other states have reached further. In Iowa, a bill was proposed allowing city councils to overturn librarians’ decisions about what books to buy and where they’re displayed.

In Oklahoma, a bill was signed into law requiring public libraries to install filters on digital databases to prevent children from seeing obscene material. Anyone who deliberately flouts the law would face legal liability.

Most libraries already have filters in place, and Oklahoma state Rep. Todd Russ, a Republican, says he expects the bill to rarely if ever result in legal action.

“We’re trying to be good partners here, he says. “We’re not trying to create all these class action lawsuits. We want to work with them to help create good protection, common sense stuff.”

But other states, including Iowa and Idaho, have proposed similar bills, stripping away the legal immunity that librarians have traditionally enjoyed for the decisions they make.

Moreover, legal actions against librarians are not unheard of.

Parents in one Wyoming county recently filed criminal complaints with the local sheriff arguing that library staff members were “pandering obscenity” to minors because they carried books on LGBTQ themes, says Caldwell-Stone. After an investigation, the local prosecutor decided not to press charges.

LGBTQ books typically generate the most controversy, especially in rural areas, says Caldwell-Stone. The mayor of Ridgeland, Mississippi, cut funding for the local libraries earlier this year after complaining about “sexual content” in some material featured by the library.

His decision made headlines, and money poured into the library through a crowdfunding campaign that more than made up for the money lost.

But libraries can’t depend on such campaigns long-term, and librarians such as Ruark worry that in the current political climate, the pressure on them is only going to turn up.

“I think people are concerned about what it’s going to do,” she says, “but they also feel powerless to make it be any different.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Henna tattoo 'mistake' forced traveller to tie hands together as she was 'burning alive'

A holidaymaker was left in agony after severe suffering an allergic reaction to her henna sleeve tattoo which left her feeling like she was 'burning alive'. Alexandra Hallman, from Santa ... Read more »

11 MPs mired in sleaze claims as Boris Johnson presides over 'degrading of ethics'

Westminster has been rocked by yet more allegations of abuse after it emerged Tory MP Chris Pincher had resigned over his conduct in a bar. Mr Pincher said he had ... Read more »

Severed head of husband whose wife poisoned herself found set in concrete inside barrel

The severed head of a husband whose wife poisoned herself has been found set in concrete inside a barrel – on the day of her funeral. The gruesome discovery came ... Read more »

Woman hails £6 miracle in a bottle that means you’ll ‘never sweat again’ this summer

If you're one of the unlucky people who has suffered from excessive sweating, you might have tried everything to make yourself feel better, to no avail. Well, there's one more ... Read more »

Son uninvites parents from wedding as they're 'not good enough' - so they sell his house

Weddings are counted as one of life's most important celebrations, and couples often want to share the special day with their nearest and dearest. But parents who expected to celebrate ... Read more »

England boss Gareth Southgate sent Harry Kane task if he wants World Cup glory

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

Harry Hill's real name, personality away from cameras and unexpected former job

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

Love Island girls left reeling over who boys dump - and fans 'know who it is'

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

Welcome to Venice! That’ll be €10

The money raised from the scheme will be spent on reducing the garbage collection bills paid by Venetians | Alberto Pizzoli/AFP via Getty Images ROME — Venice is to become ... Read more »

Rlys freight grows 11% on year in June at 125 MT, gains from loading coal

Amid rising coal demand and efforts to diversify its freight basket, loading by the Indian Railways grew 11.3 per cent on year in June to reach 125.5 million tonnes (MT). ... Read more »

Yamuna cleaning: Delhi govt to link 39 unauthorised colonies to sewer lines

A train moves on the tracks at the Old Bridge over the Yamuna River in east Delhi | PTI The Delhi government on Friday announced to lay sewer lines in ... Read more »

Autoline Daily 2022: Top Industry News for July 1

Tesla Market Share About to Plummet; Lead In 12V Batteries 50-60 Years Old; Stellantis Converts Plant to EV Motors Read more »

Joe Cordina eager for Shakur Stevenson unification bout after stunning world title win

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

Fred Couples claims he will never speak to Phil Mickelson again over LIV Golf switch

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic cruises into Wimbledon fourth round with commanding Centre Court display

Novak Djokovic's seamless run at Wimbledon continued as the men's No 1 seed breezed past Serbian compatriot Miomir Kecmanovic in straight-sets. The defending champion was at his ruthless best to ... Read more »

Adele at BST Hyde Park 2022: Support acts, what time she will be on stage and set list explained

Icons including The Rolling Stones and Elton John have already headlined Read more »

Sierra Leone launches re-denominated currency to strengthen value

Critics and the opposition say the re-denomination of the leone is confusing and adds no value. Read more »

Holland Park School issued termination notice after Ofsted assessment

Holland Park School / Daniel Hambury/Stella Pictures H olland Park School has been issued a termination notice after being downgraded by Ofsted earlier this month. The Regional Schools Commissioner’s Office ... Read more »

Tory whip suspended from Chris Pincher after formal investigation launched

The allegations are the latest in a series of Conservative sleaze scandals. Chris Pincher (Aaron Chown/PA) / PA Wire T he Conservative whip has been suspended from Chris Pincher after ... Read more »

Disgraced MP Chris Pincher loses Conservative Party Whip

Disgraced MP Chris Pincher T he Conservative whip has been suspended from Chris Pincher after an investigation was launched into allegations he drunkenly groped two men at a private members’ ... Read more »

Steve Wright confirms BBC Radio 2 exit after 23 years on air: ‘Onwards and upwards’

Steve Wright is leaving BBC Radio 2 Steve Wright has announced that he is leaving BBC Radio 2 after 23 years on the air. The 67-year-old helms the afternoon slot ... Read more »

First look at Love Island’s Casa Amor as chaos is set to ensue for the couples

Love Island’s Casa Amor is officially open (Picture: ITV) Love Island’s couples are set to face they biggest test of the series so far as Casa Amor returns for 2022.  ... Read more »

Every PS5 game coming in 2022 and beyond: from God Of War to Spider-Man 2

Spider-Man 2 is so far the only first party PlayStation game scheduled for 2023 (pic: Sony) Sony has a lot of big PS5 releases in the works but has only ... Read more »

Tory MP has whip suspended after claims he ‘drunkenly groped two men’

Chris Pincher said he ‘got too drunk and embarrassed himself ‘ (Picture: PA) A Tory MP who allegedly groped two men has been suspended from the party while an investigation ... Read more »

Greater Anglia rail strike dates: Which trains will be cancelled or delayed by walkout and how long it lasts

The 24-hour walkout has been organised by the Aslef union in a pay dispute – with the network serving eastern England, north-east London and the Stansted Express route Read more »

Chris Pincher: Tory MP has whip withdrawn during investigation over groping claims

Former chief whip has been sacked from the party following allegations by two men Read more »

Stranger Things 4 Vol. 2 Actually Broke Netflix

Netflix To say that anticipation was high for “Stranger Things” Season 4, Volume 2 would be an understatement.  Fans have waited on bated breath for a month, anxiously contemplating who would ... Read more »

BVB, Frankfurt, Stuttgart: Sieben Tests bei Sky Sport News

Der Sportnachrichtensender Sky Sport News wird im Juli insgesamt sieben Testspiele von Vizemeister Borussia Dortmund, Europa-League-Sieger Eintracht Frankfurt sowie dem VfB Stuttgart live übertragen. Dies teilte der TV-Sender am Freitag ... Read more »

‘Urgent’ action needed in Europe over monkeypox spread: WHO

WHO’s Europe director calls on governments and civil society ‘to scale up efforts’ to reverse the spread of the virus. Read more »

Top TweetDeck for Mac alternatives to ease power users’ pain

These TweetDeck for Mac alternatives are worth checking out. Photo: Rajesh With Twitter killing off TweetDeck for Mac today, users who didn’t plan ahead might be scrambling for options to ... Read more »

White House awards highest civilian honor to Steve Jobs

Steve Jobs gives one of many keynote addresses. Photo: Ben Stanfield/Flickr CC The White House said Friday it would award late Apple co-founder Steve Jobs the Presidential Medal of Freedom ... Read more »

Ecuador government, protesters sign deal

PROMISING AGREEMENT Ecuador’s Minister of Government Francisco Jimenez (right) and the president of the Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities in Ecuador (Conaie), Leonidas Iza (foreground) shake hands with each other and ... Read more »

Australia 'deeply concerned' about HK rights

CURTAILED FREEDOM? This file photo shows police using cordon tape to control crowds in the Causeway Bay district of Hong Kong on June 4, 2022, near the venue where Hong ... Read more »

2 drug suspects nabbed; P1-M shabu confiscated

DINALUPIHAN, Bataan: Police arrested two suspected peddlers of illegal drugs and confiscated from their possession 150 grams of suspected shabu worth P1.02 million and a handgun during a buy-bust here ... Read more »

BBM inaugural speech homage to unity–analysts

AS President Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. was sworn into office on Thursday, experts said his speech highlighted the same messages that had anchored his electoral campaign — unity and inclusivity. ... Read more »

Rotary Intl D3830 invites members to 'imagine rotary'

ROTARY International President Jennifer Jones has invited every member to “imagine a rotary” where each member acts to make his/her dreams become a reality and they make the most of ... Read more »

US urged to cease contact with Taiwan

WAR MACHINE This file photo shows a Taiwan-made CM-34 Clouded Leopard armored vehicle driving through its paces at a military base in Nantou county, central Taiwan, on June 16, 2022. ... Read more »

US blasts 'erosion of autonomy' in HK

SYMPATHETIC ALLY (From left) US Secretary of State Antony Blinken, US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin and US National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan look on as they listen during a ... Read more »

Manila Clock Tower declared prime tourist spot

(UPDATE) THE iconic Manila City Hall clock tower has been formally declared as a premier tourist spot in the nation's capital. The declaration was contained in an ordinance signed by ... Read more »

Ketanji Brown Jackson sworn in

HISTORIC APPOINTMENT In this handout image released by the US Supreme Court, retired Justice Stephen G. Breyer administers the Judicial Oath to Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson, while her husband Patrick ... Read more »