Some $6.2b in JobKeeper paid to businesses with more than $10m in turnover, but whose revenue did not fall during pandemic

© Provided by ABC Business JobKeeper has been described as a “sugar hit” for some firms that got the wage subsidy while making profits. (ABC Canberra: Clarissa Thorpe)

About $6.2 billion in JobKeeper wage subsidies were paid to businesses with more than $10 million in turnover that did not experience a minimum 30 per cent fall in turnover in the first six months of the scheme.

To receive the fortnightly $1,500 wage subsidy for each employee for six months to September 2020, firms with less than $1 billion in annual turnover needed to have recorded an actual downturn in March (when compared to the prior year) or tell the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) that their revenue would decline by 30 per cent or more in April or the June quarter.

Firms with more than $1 billion in sales required a 50 per cent turnover decline.

Labor, independent senator Rex Patrick and the Greens have called for a public register which shows how much firms with more than $10 million turnover received in JobKeeper, a move that the federal government has to date resisted.

Analysis of Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO) data by governance advisory firm Ownership Matters, suggests that businesses with more than $10 million in turnover represent about 2 per cent by number of recipients, but may have received up to 20 per cent of the payments made under the scheme.

“We estimate that the transparency register before the Parliament would disclose the recipients of around $20 billion of JobKeeper payments, across 20,000 businesses employing an average of 40 employees each,” Ownership Matters director Dean Paatsch said.

Treasurer Josh Frydenberg says JobKeeper was an economic lifeline that helped keep about 1 million businesses afloat and 3.8 million Australians in a job at the height of the pandemic.

He said when the federal government introduced JobKeeper, “Australia was staring into an economic abyss”.

Mr Frydenberg has consistently defended the $89 billion JobKeeper scheme, saying it was “well targeted” and that, if payments had been based instead on a business’s actual decline in turnover or a percentage of a person’s actual wage, “it would have taken months to deliver the support” and as many jobs would not have been saved.

“Additionally, updated Treasury analysis shows businesses which did not experience the fully anticipated decline in turnover in the June quarter were still forced to shed staff, with some 85,000 employees stood down on zero hours,” he told ABC News.

He said that 99 per cent of these businesses were small businesses, with an average of just four employees.

“Without JobKeeper, many more jobs would have been lost and businesses forced to close their doors.”

While Labor MP Andrew Leigh was supportive of the JobKeeper scheme, he has described its implementation as the biggest waste of taxpayer money in Australian history.

PBO data shared with Dr Leigh showed that more than $13 billion in JobKeeper payments were given to businesses (all sizes, not just those under $10m turnover) that recorded increases in revenue.

Ownership Matters based its estimates on turnover data disclosed by the PBO and new information disclosed at a Senate Economics Committee hearing into the proposed Bill that would establish the register.

Treasury officials revealed that approximately $10 billion in JobKeeper (11 per cent of the program) was paid to not-for-profits, which were excluded from the analysis.

During the first six months of JobKeeper, in which $70.9 billion was spent, PBO data revealed that 18 per cent went to firms with rising sales.

Analysis of the PBO data by Ownership Matters estimated that a further 22 per cent was paid to businesses that did not experience the anticipated 30 or 50 per cent decline in sales.

Very few not-for-profits exceeded forecasts, so the PBO data suggests that firms with more than $10 million in turnover received about $6.2 billion — or just over 22 per cent — of the estimated $28.8 billion that was paid to firms that did not experience a 30 or 50 per cent downturn, Ownership Matters found.

‘I find it astonishing … it’s the public’s money’

Mark Heydon runs a picture-framing business out of Melbourne and has been one of the millions of small businesses that benefitted from JobKeeper.

“When the pandemic first hit, I felt that we had two or three months in us to survive,” he said.

“Then the government announced the JobKeeper package, which was fantastic. At the time, it saved our staff. It kept us moving.

After September 2020, the JobKeeper payment was tapered down — to $1,200 fortnightly and again, in January, to $1,000 fortnightly — and the federal government required firms to show an actual decline in turnover to be eligible.

The scheme ended on March 28, 2021.

Mr Heydon claimed the wage subsidy for his staff between March and November 2020, but then stopped claiming as his business was no longer experiencing significant revenue declines.

“We got very busy through November and we realised, projecting forward, that we weren’t going to be under 30 per cent [turnover],” Mr Heydon said.

“In fact, we’re going to make some money in December. So, at the end of November, we let the tax department know that.”

While he acted honestly, Mr Heydon is frustrated that other firms, including foreign-controlled companies, have been legally pocketing JobKeeper while increasing wages and profits.

Mr Heydon also fears some firms may have cooked the books to qualify for the wage subsidy, although the ATO has given evidence to parliamentary hearings that it has gone after firms that it suspects acted dishonestly, while not recouping $180 million paid to businesses it deemed had made “honest mistakes”.

“I find it astonishing … that we’re paying pandemic emergency sums out of taxpayers money out of Australia to foreign companies who then, in turn, pay themselves bonuses and dividends,” Mr Heydon said.

“It’s not even the government’s money. It’s the public’s money.”

“We’re at a competitive disadvantage, because we don’t receive the amount of tax concessions that large businesses seem to be able to find. We stick by the rules.”

While Mr Heydon is appreciative of the scheme, and understands the government needed to get the money out the door quickly, he says that, after the first few months, there should have been a requirement to show an actual decline in turnover in order to keep receiving the money.

“You’ve got to rein it in and put some parameters on it,” he said, adding that he is in support of a public registry that gives greater transparency for firms with more than $10 million turnover that claimed JobKeeper.

He says those firms that claimed the wage subsidy while making profits during the pandemic should be forced to pay it back, in the same way that single mothers who have received extra COVID-19 support payments from Centrelink are being made to pay back.

“We’re talking billions of dollars here that we’ve lost to the Australian economy,” he said.

“Chase it — get the money back. Get the money back from the people who you’ve overpaid. Simple as that.”

‘It’s really frustrating, it’s really irritating’

He’s not the only small business that is frustrated.

Aimee Brown runs a chiropractic business out of Perth. She personally worked extra hours during the pandemic to keep her business afloat and, as a result, saw an uptick in turnover, meaning she never qualified for the JobKeeper scheme.

She said she only received a one-off, state government grant during lockdowns when she had to stand down her staff.

While she has been able to survive and grow her business by personally working longer hours, she said, “Things have absolutely been tough”.

Seeing other businesses that qualified for JobKeeper, despite lifting their revenue and profits, she said she felt a “whole range of emotions”.

“It’s really frustrating. It’s really irritating to know that there’s so many small businesses out there that are suffering that aren’t eligible for anything, and are having to close down because they couldn’t get support,” she said.

“And then there’s these big businesses that weren’t necessarily eligible, and there’s just no repercussions for them.”

Like Mr Heydon, Ms Brown also wants the government to make those firms pay the money back.

Earlier this month, the ATO told the Senate Economics Committee that $180 million of the $470 million owed to the agency in wrongful payments, mostly from small businesses, was never recouped because employers had made “honest mistakes” — they had claimed JobKeeper “in good faith” and had already passed it on to their employees.

However, the ATO did recover $194 million in “overpayments” from other entities it found were ineligible. 

Meanwhile, more than 11,000 individuals on Centrelink who were overpaid COVID-19 support payments are being forced to pay back about $32.8 million in debt.

“There needs to be accountability — these [firms] have to pay it back,” Ms Brown said.

“The people [who] get paid Centrelink [wrongly] have to pay it back.

“If I was to claim my childcare benefit wrongly … I’d get a letter in the mail saying I’ve got to pay it back. To me, [JobKeeper] is no different.”

‘Sugar hit’ when economic Armageddon never eventuated

Ownership Matters co-founder Dean Paatsch said that about 90 per cent of the $240 million of JobKeeper that had been returned or pledged for return has come from public companies who have bowed down to public pressure to pay back the money if they made profits during the period.

“The benefit of transparency is that it gives people a behavioural nudge, to do the right thing,” he argued.

“These companies, it has to be said, were absolutely legally entitled to receive that benefit. But it turned out that, as the pandemic eased, it was just simply a sugar hit to their profits.

“And some of them have decided to do the right thing and return it.”

He said that New Zealand already had a public transparency register.

“In New Zealand, we know that every single recipient of the JobKeeper scheme was listed on a public website.

“New Zealand [firms] repaid JobKeeper at a rate 22 times higher than Australian [ones].

“If Australian businesses had repaid JobKeeper at the rate of our New Zealand cousins, we would have received $4.9 billion … by now.”

Mr Paatsch said that, while JobKeeper was a good scheme that kept many businesses afloat and workers in jobs, it could have been designed better.

He suggested that, at the three-month mark, the government could have, like its New Zealand counterparts, retested and said that only businesses that had experienced a 40 per cent decline could remain in the scheme.

“That could have been implemented in Australia. But we chose not to,” Mr Paatsch said.

“JobKeeper was the system that was designed for an Armageddon that never occurred in Australia.

“For the vast bulk of businesses, except those in Victoria, pandemic restrictions eased after June, yet, [the government] kept paying JobKeeper for August, September, through July, August and September.”

Mr Leigh said that, while he supported the concept of JobKeeper, the scheme was “put together very hastily”.

“The government should have been able to monitor the money that was going out the door to firms with rising earnings.

“[The government] knew within a few months that billions of dollars was being paid to firms that didn’t need the money. It should have stopped that money going out the door.

“When you are spending taxpayer money, you need to be careful, prudent and frugal. You need to treat taxpayer money with the same respect that you would treat money coming out of your own wallet. And that just didn’t happen in this instance.”


Video: People with intellectual disabilities ‘under-utilised and shut out from workplaces’ (ABC NEWS)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Two Creepy McDonald's Secrets We Just Learned From a Drive-Thru Employee

© Provided by Eat This, Not That! mcdonalds drive thru Even if you often roll through the McDonald’s drive-thru, you’re likely not aware of just how closely the chain is ... Read more »

Hollyoaks Chelsee Healey is unrecognisable on night out as fans are wowed by her glam makeover

HOLLYOAKS star Chelsee Healey has left fans open-mouthed after posing for a new picture during a posh night out. Chelsee, 33, looks so different from her Hollyoaks character of Goldie ... Read more »

Interpol denies receiving Red Notice alert from Syria for Lebanese party leader

© AP Samir Geagea, head of the Lebanese Forces party. Photo: AP Interpol has denied receiving a Red Notice alert for the head of the Lebanese Forces party from the ... Read more »

Voting options expand in Albuquerque, Santa Fe elections

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – In this Oct. 8, 2018, file photo, Albuquerque Mayor Tim Keller speaks during a news conference at ABQ Studios in Albuquerque, N.M. Progressive ... Read more »

M1 Pro and M1 Max: Here's how Apple is kicking Intel out of the Mac computer

Apple on Monday revealed its M1 Pro and M1 Max processors, giving us a look at its highest-end chips so far and the brains inside its redesigned MacBook Pro, which ... Read more »

AirPods 3: All the features missing from Apple's 2021 earbuds

Apple’s third-gen AirPods were a highlight of Apple’s “Unleashed” event on Monday, which also saw the debut of a redesigned MacBook Pro line that brings back multiple ports and higher-end ... Read more »

Katy shows off sensational legs in in shimmering orange split dress

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Katy Perry was a smoldering sensation in a new Instagram snap she posted Tuesday promoting American Idol. The 36-year-old pop star has been ... Read more »

Evanna Lynch says her eating disorder recovery is a 'healing process'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Harry Potter star Evanna Lynch has revealed that her recovery from her eating disorder, which she battled aged 11 and 12, is a ... Read more »

Morrisons shareholders approve £7bn takeover after bidding war

Morrisons shareholders have formally approved a £7bn takeover by US private equity firm Clayton, Dubilier & Rice (CD&R) after a bidding war. © Other Morrisons employs 110,000 people. Pic: Morrisons ... Read more »

A nurse made his entire day's wages trading crypto on his lunch break, so he quit his day job and now makes 7 figures

© STR/NurPhoto via Getty Images Bitcoin. STR/NurPhoto via Getty Images A 31-year-old quit his pediatric nursing job to trade cryptocurrencies, Bloomberg reported. Now, he makes seven figures, owns a vacation ... Read more »

Nikola allowed to proceed with $2 billion patent lawsuit against Tesla

© Image: Nikola Hydrogen trucking startup Nikola is being allowed to continue its three-year-old $2 billion patent lawsuit against Tesla. A federal judge shelved the suit earlier this month after ... Read more »

Yulo to defend title in World Championships

© The Manila Times Carlos Yulo FILE PHOTO CARLOS “Caloy” Yulo of the Philippines is all set to defend his title in men’s floor exercise on Wednesday at the 50th ... Read more »

Google's Pixel 6 is coming today, but should you buy a Pixel 3, 4 or 5 instead?

Recently, I faced a dilemma: My Google Pixel 3 XL was on its last legs. Its battery was a pale shadow of its former self. Its USB-C port failed to carry ... Read more »

These 3.5-Foot Elsa and Anna Inflatables Will Make Your ‘Frozen' Dreams Come True

Believe it or not, it’s already time to start thinking about which old holiday decorations will return and what new ones will be incorporated into your setup this year. Gemmy ... Read more »

MacBook Pro 2021 vs. MacBook Air 2020: New M1 chips complicate your laptop choice

With the new 14-and 16-inch MacBook Pro models introduced by Apple  on Monday, the entire MacBook laptop line has shifted to Apple’s own M-series chips, and away from Intel . This shift means ... Read more »

Walmart Black Friday deals 2021: Shop early discounts

The holiday shopping season is kicking off, and Walmart has just announced a full slate of Black Friday deals — including some great discounts that are already live. You can ... Read more »

This Oprah-Loved Cookware Brand Just Dropped the Prettiest New Color — & It's the Perfect Holiday Gift

If you’ve been hoping to upgrade your cookware, now’s your chance. Our Place just released a new color for their cult-classic Always Pan, and it’s too chic to pass up. The ... Read more »

Newfoundland and Labrador says soft drink tax coming in 2022 will be Canada's first

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — In an effort to boost health outcomes in an ailing province, the Newfoundland and Labrador government unveiled details Tuesday of what it says will be the ... Read more »

P&G raising prices to offset higher commodity, freight costs

NEW YORK (AP) — Proctor & Gamble is raising prices on a range of goods as higher commodity and freight costs are set to take a bite out of its ... Read more »

New Kensington mother of 4 grateful family was not home when car crashed into house

Oct. 19—Renata Diaz calls the living room of her New Kensington home her “bright place.” But Diaz was grateful that she and her four young children — ranging from her ... Read more »

House Explosion Rocks Scottish Town of Ayr

Emergency services in Ayr, Scotland, responded to an explosion at a residential property in the town’s Kincaidston area on Monday evening, October 18, police and fire officials said. Ayrshire Police ... Read more »

UP police, SIT release photos of suspects of Lakhimpur violence; announce ‘rewards' for information

© Provided by Hindustan Times Photos of suspects in Lakhimpur Kheri violence case released by Uttar Pradesh police and the Special Investigation Team. (ANI Photo) Aimed at furthering the investigation ... Read more »

Someone disagrees with how expensive house prices have gotten: the appraisers who put values on them

© David Sacks/Getty Images Someone disagrees with how expensive house prices have gotten: the appraisers who put values on them Home prices are soaring, and appraisers can’t keep up. It’s ... Read more »

T20 World Cup: Bangladesh beat Oman by 26 runs, keep Super 12s hopes alive

© Provided by Zee News Al Amerat: Bangladesh kept their hopes of advancing to Super 12s stage alive with a nervy 26-run win over co-hosts Oman in their Group B ... Read more »

‘My friends died in their sleep': Uttarakhand rain fury leaves trail of despair

© Provided by Hindustan Times Houses get partially submerged in floodwater due to incessant rainfall, in Rudrapur, Uttarakhand, on Tuesday. (ANI) Dehradun/Haldwani: Early on Tuesday morning, 20-year-old Kashiram and five ... Read more »

Google Pixel 6, Pixel 6 Pro Put Google's AI Smarts In Your Pocket With Tensor Chip

© Provided by News18 Google Pixel 6, Pixel 6 Pro Put Google’s AI Smarts In Your Pocket With Tensor Chip Google Pixel 6 series is finally here! The company, at ... Read more »

Married At First Sight UK's Luke rules out reuniting with Morag

Married At First Sight UK‘s Luke Dawson has opened up about his relationship with on-screen wife Morag Crichton, and what the future holds. © Channel 4 Married At First Sight ... Read more »

Hindu houses, temples, shops destroyed but no action: Taslima Nasreen slams Sheikh Hasina

Author Taslima Nasreen and Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. India Today TV Consulting Editor Rajdeep Sardesai spoke to Bangladeshi-Swedish writer Taslima Nasreen over the ongoing violence against Hindus in Bangladesh. ... Read more »

T20 World Cup: Hopefully Team Can Use Loss Against New Zealand as a Motivation to Push Little Extra, Says KL Rahul

© Provided by News18 T20 World Cup: Hopefully Team Can Use Loss Against New Zealand as a Motivation to Push Little Extra, Says KL Rahul Star opener KL Rahul on ... Read more »

HP to launch awareness campaign on drug abuse in Nov

© Provided by The Statesman HP to launch awareness campaign on drug abuse in Nov Himachal Pradesh Additional Chief Secretary J C Sharma on Tuesday said a drug awareness campaign ... Read more »

Jelani Day funeral: Family still looking for answers on what led to his death

The funeral for 25-year-old Jelani Day, an Illinois graduate student whose body was identified nearly a month after he was reported missing, was held Tuesday in Danville, Illinois. © Family ... Read more »

Dior Is Releasing the Most Fashionable Workout Equipment We've Ever Seen — Here's a Sneak Peek

Dior and Technogym are here to deliver high-fashion workout equipment. © Provided by Travel + Leisure Courtesy of Dior In October, Technogym, a brand known in the luxury hospitality space ... Read more »

Paris Hilton calls on Biden, Congress to take action against the ‘troubled teen industry'

Paris Hilton wipes her eyes after speaking at a committee hearing at the Utah State Capitol, on Feb. 8, 2021, in Salt Lake City. AP Photo/Rick Bowmer Paris Hilton is calling ... Read more »

Alexandre Arnault and Géraldine Guyot Marry at a Star-Studded Ceremony in Venice

© Photo: Backgrid Fashion royalty doesn’t get married every day. So when Alexandre Arnault, the second eldest son of LVMH chairman and chief executive officer Bernard Arnault—who is also the ... Read more »

Hochul dodges on Buffalo mayoral race endorsement, condemns Democratic chair's KKK comments

ALBANY — Gov. Hochul stopped shy of calling on the state Democratic party boss to resign Tuesday after he invoked former Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke while discussing the ... Read more »

Jamie Foxx Says He Is Not 'the Marrying Type' in New Book: 'Maybe in a Few Decades'

© Provided by People Amy Sussman/Getty Jamie Foxx doesn’t have marriage in the books. In his new memoir, Act Like You Got Some Sense, the Oscar winner and singer writes ... Read more »

The biggest announcements from Google's Pixel 6 event

Google just wrapped up its Pixel 6 Fall Launch event, where it announced two new phones as well as a wealth of features that are supported by its new Tensor ... Read more »

You can now take long screenshots on Microsoft Edge Canary for Android

The latest build of Edge Canary for Android supports taking long screenshots of websites. © Provided by Windows Central What you need to know Microsoft Edge Canary for Android now ... Read more »

Shoppers Say This $10 L'Oreal Collagen Cream 'Acts As a Filler' to Smooth and Plump Skin

© Provided by Health Amazon – Design: Alex Sandoval Chances are, you’ve probably heard of the buzzy, anti-aging, skincare ingredient collagen. If you’re not super familiar with it, you should ... Read more »

Anthony Watson: England winger's knee injury confirmed as ruptured ACL

© Getty Images Anthony Watson suffered the injury during a 71-17 defeat to Saracens – Getty Images England winger Anthony Watson has suffered an ACL rupture, his club Bath have ... Read more »