Small force, big effect: How the planets could influence the sun

Small force, big effect: How the planets could influence the sun

A new theory supports the controversial hypothesis that the planets affect solar activity. It puts forward a mechanism by which the very small influence of the planets could exert its rhythm on such a large system as the Sun. If the theory is confirmed, it could possibly be used to predict solar activity more accurately. This would be of great interest, as large solar flares can cripple electronic infrastructure.

In 2012, Eawag and ETH researcher Professor Jurg Beer published the hypothesis that the planets could influence the activity of the Sun. Together with researchers from Spain and Australia, he had reconstructed the cycles of solar activity for the last 10,000 years with the help of beryllium data from ice cores and compared them with the movement of the planets around the Sun.

The correlation was astounding. Solar activity and planetary motion have similar rhythms, thereby suggesting a relationship. This raised hopes of being able to predict the cyclical fluctuations in solar activity based on the known planetary motions. This would be of great interest, because in times of great solar activity, large solar eruptions occur more frequently, which can paralyse power grids as well as communication and navigation satellites.

New explanation for a controversial hypothesis
However, Beer’s hypothesis is highly controversial in the scientific community. Many researchers are convinced that the influence of the planets is far too small to have a demonstrable effect on solar activity. But now Carlo Albert, head of Eawag’s Mathematical Methods in Environmental Research group, together with research colleagues from Switzerland and Spain, has found an explanation of how the tiny effect of the planets could nevertheless influence the activity of the much larger Sun: stochastic resonance. Under certain conditions, the phenomenon can amplify weak, mostly periodic signals in such a way that they have significant consequences.

So what does this mean for the Sun and the influence of the planets? Solar activity has a clear 11-year cycle. This is known and undisputed. However, there are other cycles.

“With simple mathematical models, we were able to show that the Sun basically has two stable states of activity in the 11-year cycle: an active state with large amplitude and high solar activity, and a quieter state with small amplitude and lower solar activity,” Albert explains.

Scientists refer to this as a bistable system. “We assume that the Sun jumps back and forth between these two states due to turbulences in its interior.” Since the turbulences are random, one would expect these changes to happen completely irregularly and unpredictably.

Planets set the pace
“However, the measurement data we have on solar activity suggest that the change of states does not happen purely at random, but often has a rhythm of around 200 years,” says Albert. So that would be a further 200-year cycle superimposed on the 11-year cycle. Jurg Beer and his colleagues had suspected the influence of the planets as the cause of this additional rhythm. But this influence is extremely small. Albert and his colleagues have now found a possibility in which this influence could be increased.

Under suitable conditions, noise in a bistable system can massively amplify the influence of a periodic driver – this is called stochastic resonance. The turbulences inside the Sun (the noise) would then amplify the weak influence of the planets (the periodic driver). The planets would thus exert their beat on the Sun’s random jumping back and forth between the two states of activity and influence the rhythm of solar activity.

The researchers have now published this new theory on a possible mechanism in the renowned scientific journal Astrophysical Journal Letters. In a next step, they will now investigate to what extent this can be used to calculate observations of solar activity over the past centuries. This would corroborate the theory and also enable a further step, namely the prediction of solar activity for the coming decades and centuries.

Are we observing a transition to a phase of weak solar activity?
Such a forecast would be of great interest. After all, as far as solar activity is concerned, we are currently experiencing an exciting time. “According to Jurg Beer’s hypothesis, which is now supported by our theory, we are at the end of an active phase with a large amplitude of the 11-year cycle. We should slowly be heading for a calmer phase,” says Albert.

Such phases are also called grand minima. And there are indeed signs that the 11-year cycle is weakening. “At the moment, I’m observing every few days how solar activity is developing,” says Albert. “However, it will be several years before we know for sure whether the Sun is really in a new grand minimum.”

The development of solar activity is particularly interesting because the last occurrence of a grand minimum about 400 years ago is associated with the Little Ice Age in large parts of Europe, even if this connection has not yet been clearly proven.

“Due to climate change, a slowdown in solar activity would of course be desirable,” says Albert. “Unfortunately, if it actually occurs, it will hardly be able to compensate for human-caused warming, but at best will only be able to temporarily slow it down a little. So there is still no way around radically reducing greenhouse gas emissions.”

Research Report: Can Stochastic Resonance Explain Recurrence of Grand Minima?

News Related


How to catch a perfect wave: scientists take a closer look inside the perfect fluid

Scientists have reported new clues to solving a cosmic conundrum: How the quark-gluon plasma – nature’s perfect fluid – evolved into matter. A few millionths of a second after the ... Read more »

China brings astronauts back, advances closer to "space station era"

Having worked in the space station core module Tianhe for three months – the longest-ever human space mission in the Chinese history, three “taikonauts” of the Shenzhou-12 crew returned to ... Read more »

Mushballs stash away missing ammonia at Uranus and Neptune

Mushballs – giant, slushy hailstones made from a mixture of ammonia and water – may be responsible for an atmospheric anomaly at Neptune and Uranus that has been puzzling scientists. ... Read more »

This is what it looks like when a black hole snacks on a star

While black holes and toddlers don’t seem to have much in common, they are remarkably similar in one aspect: Both are messy eaters, generating ample evidence that a meal has ... Read more »

How planets may be seeded with the chemicals necessary for life

Analysis of unique “fingerprints” in light emitted from material surrounding young stars has revealed “significant reservoirs” of large organic molecules necessary to form the basis of life. Dr John Ilee, ... Read more »

What's going on with the ozone?

World governments agreed in the late 1980s to protect Earth’s ozone layer by phasing out ozone-depleting substances emitted by human activities, under the Montreal Protocol. The phase out of these ... Read more »

Chinese astronauts complete three-month space mission

Three Chinese astronauts have completed the country’s longest crewed mission and started their journey home on Thursday after 90 days at the Tiangong space station conducting spacewalks and scientific experiments. ... Read more »

Synspective signs launch agreement with Exolaunch to launch 3rd SAR Satellite "StriX-1" on Soyuz-2

Synspective Inc., a SAR satellite data and analytic solution provider, announced a new Launch Agreement with a small satellite launch services provider, Exolaunch, to launch Synspective’s third demonstration SAR satellite ... Read more »

Now we're cooking with lasers

Imagine having your own digital personal chef; ready to cook up whatever you want; able to tailor the shape, texture, and flavor just for you; and it’s all at the ... Read more »

China prepares to launch Tianzhou-3 cargo spacecraft

The combination of the Tianzhou-3 cargo spacecraft and a Long March-7 Y4 carrier rocket has been transferred to the launching area of the Wenchang Spacecraft Launch Site, the China Manned ... Read more »

Have we detected dark energy

Dark energy, the mysterious force that causes the universe to accelerate, may have been responsible for unexpected results from the XENON1T experiment, deep below Italy’s Apennine Mountains. A new study, ... Read more »

Russian actress says 'too late' to fear ISS launch

Russian actress Yulia Peresild said Thursday it was “too late” for fear ahead of her launch into space, as Moscow races against Hollywood to film the first movie in orbit. ... Read more »

SpaceX's Inspiration4 civilian crew hopes mission will inspire world

When the first all-private orbital space mission is launched this week, it will be powered by philanthropist and ambitious businessman Jared Isaacman’s vision of making the world a better place. ... Read more »

Australia nuclear sub deal will help peace in Indo-Pacific: UK PM

British Prime Minister Boris Johnson on Thursday sought to play down Chinese fears that a deal to provide Australia with nuclear-powered US submarines threatened regional stability. Johnson told parliament the ... Read more »

Two Flight Engineers' stay extended in ISS

Two International Space Station crew members have had their stay onboard the orbiting lab extended to nearly a year. Meanwhile, space biology and life support maintenance kept the Expedition 65 ... Read more »

NASA provides laser for LISA mission

Finding the biggest collisions in the universe takes time, patience, and super steady lasers. In May, NASA specialists working with industry partners delivered the first prototype laser for the European ... Read more »

Dino-killing asteroid set the stage for evolution of modern snakes

For the majority of species living during the Cretaceous period, the asteroid responsible for Mexico’s Chicxulub crater spelled doom. But for those that survived, the catastrophe offered opportunity. According to ... Read more »

India to revise FDI policy for space sector, says ISRO chief Sivan

India will soon come out with a new foreign direct investment (FDI) policy for the space sector, Indian Space research Organisation Chairman K. Sivan said on Monday. In his address ... Read more »

SpaceX Inspiration4 lifts off on first all-civilian orbital mission

The SpaceX mission Inspiration4 — the first all-private orbital spaceflight — lifted off from Florida on Wednesday night, carrying four civilians led by philanthropist and pilot Jared Isaacman. The Falcon ... Read more »

Russian Soyuz rocket launches 34 new UK satellites

A Russian Soyuz rocket has blasted into space carrying 34 new satellites from British operator Oneweb, which aims to provide broadband internet everywhere in the world. The rocket, operated by ... Read more »

SpaceX sends all-civilian crew into orbit

A SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket carrying four space tourists blasted off Wednesday night from the Kennedy Space Center in Florida for the first mission to orbit the globe with an ... Read more »

Xplore and Keck Observatory announce innovative collaboration

Xplore Inc., a commercial space company providing Space as a Service has announced a collaboration with the W. M. Keck Observatory in Waimea, Hawai’i. The Keck Observatory, the world’s leading ... Read more »

Space Babes

Houston, we have a problem! Love and sex need to happen in space if we hope to travel long distances and become an interplanetary species, but space organizations are not ... Read more »

Two astronauts return to ISS after 7-Hour Spacewalk

Two international astronauts, Japan’s Akihiko Hoshide and France’s Thomas Pesquet have returned safely to the International Space Station (ISS) after completing a spacewalk that spanned nearly seven hours, NASA said. ... Read more »

Better weather forecasting through satellite isotope data assimilation

As the global climate continues to change and extreme weather events increasingly threaten regions all over the world, accurate weather forecasting is becoming more important than ever. In a new ... Read more »

Quasars as Cosmic Standard Candles

In 1929, Edwin Hubble published observations that galaxies’ distances and velocities are correlated, with the distances determined using their Cepheid stars. Harvard astronomer Henrietta Swan Leavitt had discovered that a ... Read more »

Adaptable optical communications to facilitate future low-earth orbit networks

As government and commercial small-satellite constellations continue to proliferate in low-earth orbit (LEO), DARPA has unveiled a new effort to create a novel optical communications terminal to interconnect diverse constellations ... Read more »

New ocean temperature data help scientists make their hot predictions

We’ve heard that rising temperatures will lead to rising sea levels, but what many may not realise is that most of the increase in energy in the climate system is ... Read more »

A gem of a lab will bring the world of quantum physics into the light

The novel design for a next-generation diamond sensor with capabilities that range from producing magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of single molecules to detecting slight anomalies in the Earth’s magnetic field ... Read more »

Modern snakes evolved from a few survivors of dino-killing asteroid

A new study suggests that all living snakes evolved from a handful of species that survived the giant asteroid impact that wiped out the dinosaurs and most other living things ... Read more »

Scientists explore method to produce composites with 'shape memory'

Skoltech researchers have investigated a promising type of composite materials in terms of their shape memory behavior: how they resume their original shape following deformation if exposed to the right ... Read more »

Jet stream changes could amplify weather extremes by 2060s

New research provides insights into how the position and intensity of the North Atlantic jet stream has changed during the past 1,250 years. The findings suggest that the position of ... Read more »

TROPICS pathfinder satellite produces global first light images and captures Hurricane Ida

On August 8, NASA’s TROPICS Pathfinder satellite captured global first light images as well as a look inside the structure of Hurricane Ida before and after it made landfall. The ... Read more »

New research takes us closer to figuring out supermassive black holes

Galaxies host supermassive black holes, which weigh millions to billions times more than our Sun. When galaxies collide, pairs of supermassive black holes at their centres also lie on the ... Read more »

Rerun of supernova blast expected to appear in 2037

It’s challenging to make predictions, especially in astronomy. There are however, a few forecasts astronomers can depend on, such as the timing of upcoming lunar and solar eclipses and the ... Read more »

SpaceX launches Starlink satellites into orbit from West Coast

Elon Musk’s SpaceX successfully launched a stack of Starlink satellites into space Monday night, the first such launch since May. The Falcon 9 rocket lifted off through a cloud of ... Read more »

Ballistic air guns and mock moon rocks aid in search for durable space fabrics

The surface of the Moon is a harsh environment with no air, low gravity, dust, and micrometeorites-tiny rocks or metal particles-flying faster than 22,000 mph. These conditions can pose a ... Read more »

CuPID CubeSat will get new perspective on Sun-Earth boundary

When you help build a satellite the size of a shoebox, you learn pretty much everything about it, says Emil Atz, a PhD candidate in Mechanical Engineering at Boston University. ... Read more »

TPY-4 Radar earns official US Government Designation

As the world’s most capable and flexible ground based multi-function long-range radar, Lockheed Martin’s TPY-4 has received its official U.S. Government nomenclature – AN/TPY-4(V)1 – officially marking the radar’s maturity ... Read more »

China launches Zhongxing-9B satellite

China successfully launched a new direct broadcast satellite (DBS) from the Xichang Satellite Launch Center in southwest China’s Sichuan Province Thursday. The satellite, Zhongxing-9B, was launched at 7:50 p.m. (Beijing ... Read more »