Sir Ian Taylor: The warning we should have heeded in May 2020

Sir Ian Taylor: The warning we should have heeded in May 2020


Prime Minister thank you for your response to the initial nine questions I sent through a few days ago. I did note with some interest that the response appears to be similar to the one the mayor of Queenstown received when he expressed his concerns about how the recently announced isolation requirements were killing what remained of the regions tourism industry.

Like him, I was told I could expect a response from Minister Hipkins shortly.

This response aligns with another that has been shared with me from a number of people who have offered to bring their expertise off the bench to help as well. It comes in various forms but basically, it reads – “thanks – but no thanks.” Most of those have come from Dr Bloomfield and the MOH. In other words, “Trust us we know what we are doing.”

Trust is something that is earned and the early responses you made to a situation we had never faced before earned the trust of the entire country. But we then wasted more than 16 months of being covid-free to ready ourselves for the inevitable arrival of Covid into Aotearoa.

You may recall presentations Sam Morgan made to you in early 2020 about the “Covid Card.”

I was on the periphery of those discussions and recently I checked the notes I took when Sam first called me about his concerns of the direction we were heading. This was in May 2020.

In summary, they read:

“Hope it doesn’t happen but there is a huge chance that in a year to a year and a half a new variant of Covid will arrive in the country. It will almost certainly show up first in South Auckland in a church or some similar gathering of the community. Because English is a second language for many in that community the covid advice being written by officials out of Wellington will not resonate at all. Because most don’t have phones, let alone mobile phones, the ‘one solution fits all’ of a Covid tracing app is going to make tracing contacts incredibly difficult, if not impossible.”

He went on to observe:

“The virus will spread through the community because of the communal living, it will then get into the homeless people in the streets and from there it will be untraceable. The covid tracing team will be stretched to breaking point and they will never find the original source that had crossed the border, where so many of this community work.”

When I mentioned this to one of your health advisers recently the response was – “well that’s all very well in hindsight!”

It was May 2020!

It was not hindsight. It was planning for a future that we hoped would not come but one we needed to be ready for if it did. It’s something that businesses have to do every day.

Building a testing infrastructure with a range of flexible testing options, including rapid antigen testing that we can use at home, at work and in our schools, should have been part of that planning. We can’t change the fact that we didn’t do this when we should have but isn’t it time that the MOH started to listen to the advice and offers of help that are coming off the bench? Since posing my 9 questions I have been contacted by a number of experts in this field who have offered help only to receive the standard “thanks but no thanks” reply.

Trust is a two-way street and once again the MOH delivered a “we know best” rapid antigen test protocol when it finally agreed to allow them to be sold in pharmacies – but then made it a requirement that you had to be tested by the pharmacist in the shop. You weren’t going to trust us to actually use them ourselves – like the rest of the world does – and you were now asking pharmacists to bring into their premises people who potentially had Covid to mingle with their normal clients while they waited for their results.

So question 1 this week:

How has that “we know best” approach worked to date?

The locked-down border that you controlled 100%, leaked. We still don’t know where, but we do know that there are now thousands of Covid cases in the country – just as Sam Morgan predicted almost two years ago.

Sir Ian Taylor: The warning we should have heeded in May 2020

Sir Ian Taylor at his home in Auckland. Photo / Brett Phibbs

The short sharp lockdown strategy has now extended to over 100 days in Auckland and divided the country in ways we could never have imagined. And yes, there are now thousands of people, with Covid, isolating at home, with their families.

The PR line continues to extol the virtues of MIQ – usually along the lines that we have brought around 190,000 people through the border in the past two years. Before Covid, that number was 20,000, a week.

The numbers we should be talking about are the number of Kiwi citizens who have been trapped overseas, some for more than a year, many missing the early years of their children growing up, others without visas, many with no means of support. It has not gone unnoticed that we no longer hear the tag line – “be kind”

I would understand this approach if there was no other way to address it. But there is and it’s out here waiting for your officials to actually live up to one of the tag lines you have borrowed from Māori – He Waka Eke Noa – we are all in this together. In the Māori world, those aren’t just words – we live them.

Finally – back to my nine questions that I am awaiting a response from Minister Hipkins on.

He can now drop question three – the one about using urgency to change the law.

A law firm sent me a note to say you had already done that on November 19th by adding a clause to the Covid 19 Public Health Response Amendment Bill (No 2) that effectively gives Dr Bloomfield the power to seize the assets of a privately owned company and pay for their services at a commercial rate that he will determine. They can appeal that decision to the District Court – but no further. There is no right of appeal to the higher court.

Which leads me to questions number two and three.

Do you think that it is a reasonable use of urgency given that it seems we are in this position because of a decision Dr Bloomfield and the MOH made about taxpayer funds being used to subsidise just the one, Canadian owned, nasopharyngeal PCR test which is now running up to five days late in delivering its results when there was a Kiwi solution on offer as well?

Is it likely that it is this kiwi company that will have its assets seized under this new law?

News Related


Record limit? Drunk Raglan man accused of blowing nearly 10x blood alcohol limit

A Raglan man has allegedly registered one of the highest blood alcohol limits in New Zealand. The 30-year-old mechanic was stopped on Main Rd on January 21 when he returned ... Read more »

Solo climber Charles Dubouloz conquers Grandes Jorasses

Charles Dubouloz spent six days and five nights enduring -30C temperatures as he journeyed up the 4,208-metre-high Grandes Jorasses in the Mont Blanc massif. Upon reaching the top, the 32-year-old ... Read more »

Red hot! Sam Frost shows off her incredibly toned figure in a tiny bikini at the beach just weeks after quitting Home and Away

She’s the former Home and Away star who quit the long-running soap two months after copping backlash in October when she revealed she hadn’t had the Covid-19 vaccine.  And it seems ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: Outbreak may leave rural hospitals precarious staffing levels

By Rowan Quinn of RNZ Rural communities could be left without local medical services for a time when Omicron hits. Staffing is precarious in many small towns – and doctors, ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: New Auckland locations linked to suspected Omicron cases

Three more Auckland locations of interest have been announced by the Ministry of Health – all linked to suspected Omicron cases. The Krispy Kreme on Ronwood Ave in Manukau, South ... Read more »

Porirua named most expensive rental market in New Zealand

Porirua has been named the most expensive rental market in the country – with a median weekly rent of $700 a week. Rentals are hot property in the city. Housing ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: Stranded Australians and New Zealanders anxious about when they can return home

People stuck on either side of the Tasman between the “two most locked-down places in the world” say they have no idea when they will be able to return home. ... Read more »

Kāhu ki Rotorua: Homegrown BMX champ Tuhoto-Ariki Pene signs with Mondraker

Public Interest Journalism funded through NZ On Air Click here for English translationHe ahakoa he taitamariki nei a Tuhoto-Ariki Pene nōna katoa ngā whakawhiwhinga o te ao tūāroa nei, e ... Read more »

Dunedin man known for his charity thieved ailing father for gambling addiction

For four years a Dunedin man known for his charity work secretly fleeced his ailing father of nearly $150,000, a court has heard. The 91-year-old died in 2019 never knowing ... Read more »

Opinion: Paul Hickey - Life in red, school initiative and love stories

Well here we go again! Lockdown NZ season 3 is here with a whole lot of new shocking plot twists for the new year, and we are all unwilling participants ... Read more »

Rotorua creatives can get funding help to bring arts to community

Rotorua creatives can be given a helping hand with lifting the community’s spirit through the arts thanks to funding. Creative New Zealand has increased funding for the current Rotorua District ... Read more »

'Begin to fail': Billionaire investor Jeremy Grantham's chilling prediction

A financial expert has sparked fears with the grim prediction that inflation, slowing growth and labour shortages are here to stay. Last week, British billionaire investor Jeremy Grantham made headlines ... Read more »

Great Te Arawa Stories website handed over to Rotorua Library as custodian

Rotorua Library is excited and proud to become the custodian of a Te Arawa stories website, designed to support e-learning as part of an initiative to improve educational outcomes in ... Read more »

Summer interns at Rotorua Lakes Council get hands-on experience

Rotorua Lakes Council has welcomed eight rangatahi who are eager to learn and get stuck in through its intern programme, to work within the organisation over the 2021/2022 summer period. ... Read more »

He kāwai whakapapa e kore e unuhia atu - Teen offering leaves legacy

Rua died in 1952 at the age of 66. His name is on the roll of honour at the bridge at Whakarewarewa. Read more »

Rotorua's Lakefront's half basketball court design to share rich culture

A special design is set to adorn the Lakefront’s half basketball court, and local artist Lyonel Grant is pleased to be part of the lakefront development. The painting of the ... Read more »

Rotorua Citizens Advice Bureau busiest in country in last financial year

Our local Citizens Advice Bureau is often a busy hub of queries, information and help – and the Rotorua bureau was the busiest in the country in the last financial ... Read more »

Volunteers encouraged to help keep capturing early Rotorua memories

For years people’s treasured early memories of Rotorua have been captured in the pages of the Rotorua Retro series, and now people are encouraged to put their hands up to ... Read more »

Napier City Council proposes selling all 377 of its council houses

Napier City Council is considering selling all of its 377 council owned units because it is struggling to meet the costs of maintaining and upgrading them. The council says raising ... Read more »

Unjabbed ICU doctor who confronted Sajid Javid over compulsory jabs for NHS staff launches legal action against government's vaccine mandate and insists he is prepared to lose his career to 'stick with my values'

Dr Steve James is spearheading a judicial review against NHS vaccine mandateMandate requires all NHS frontline staff to get two Covid-19 vaccines by April 1 Dr James and 7 other medical professionals are arguing mandate is 'unlawful' He said he is willing to lose his career over the mandate to 'stick with' his 'values'  Read more »

Air New Zealand brings back flight credit over projected omicron disruption

Air New Zealand has brought back its credit flexibility scheme over project disruption from omicron. The airline is allowing passengers with flights booked during February to cancel fares in exchange ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: At least 12 people infected after attending Soundsplash Festival near Hamilton

OMICRON LATEST:* Locations of interest: Auckland Airport domestic terminal visited by Covid case* ‘Creeping authoritarianism’: Seymour column in UK says NZ is now a ‘hermit kingdom’* A conversation with the ... Read more »

World remembers Holocaust as anti-semitism rises in pandemic

Survivors recalled their agony to a world they fear is forgetting, Israel’s parliamentary speaker wept in the German parliament and politicians warned of a resurgence of anti-semitism on Thursday’s International ... Read more »

Monaco palace issues worrying update on Princess Charlene's recovery

Princess Charlene of Monaco will miss out on one of the country’s biggest royal celebrations today, as the palace issued a worrying update about her health. While the palace said ... Read more »

Rugby league: Kiwis great Olsen Filipaina in intensive care battling kidney failure

New Zealand rugby league great Olsen Filipaina is in an intensive care unit in Australia battling a severe bout of kidney failure. Filipaina, one of the NRL’s top performers in ... Read more »

'Utter hell': Sydney woman opens up about horror find before bed

Elise Sproll had just completed a work presentation in New Zealand and was flying home to Sydney for an early 33rd birthday celebration when she discovered something that turned her ... Read more »

Investigations continue into toilet block fire

Investigations continue into the toilet block fire in Mount Maunganui last evening. Three fire crews from Mount Maunganui and Tauranga were called to the blaze at the toilet block on ... Read more »

Booster shots APPROVED for millions of Australian teenagers - just in time for the start of the school year 

Teenagers will soon be able to get a COVID-19 booster shot after the medical regulator granted provisional approval for the Pfizer vaccine. Previously, only people 18 years and older had ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Airport one of four new Auckland locations linked to suspected Omicron cases

Four new locations of interest in Auckland have been linked to suspected Omicron cases. One of them is the Auckland Airport domestic terminal, visited by a person with Covid on ... Read more »

Rotorua Community Hospice overjoyed with support from Farmers and customers

Rotorua Community Hospice is overjoyed by the record result of $30,051.27 raised from the local Farmers store in its Christmas Charity Campaign. Hospices throughout the country have once again been ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Ballantynes Department Store in Christchurch temporarily closes

The Ballantynes Department Store in central Christchurch has temporarily closed its doors out of caution due to Covid-19. A spokesperson said although the store is not currently a location of ... Read more »

Covid 19 Australia: Pharmacists dub RAT mess 'reckless and negligent'

Pharmacists in Australia have sounded the alarm over Prime Minister Scott Morrison’s “free” rapid antigen test programme, revealing the A$10 rebate doesn’t even cover the wholesale cost of the tests ... Read more »

Trainstation and ex-UK strongman draw crowd to NZE event

On January 22, Mike Smith of Trainstation Te Awamutu hosted the inaugural NZE (New Zealand Equipped) meeting under the GPC federation. Equipped powerlifting, a growing sport worldwide, is an advancement ... Read more »

Deputy prime minister Grant Robertson plays down Government's spending's role in inflation

Government spending is not contributing a significant amount to inflation, Deputy Prime Minister Grant Robertson says. Yesterday, Statistics New Zealand revealed inflation had hit 5.9 per cent in 2021, the ... Read more »

First black woman justice on high court 'long overdue', Biden says

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden today affirmed his pledge to nominate the first black woman to the US Supreme Court, saying it was “long overdue”. He praised retiring Justice ... Read more »

Plan don't panic: How Northlanders can prepare for the pandemic

The Government has confirmed that gaps on store shelves are likely as Omicron spreads, so what can Northlanders expect and how can they prepare – without panicking? In a media ... Read more »

Ukraine crisis: Russia sees little optimism in US response

The Kremlin says there is “little ground for optimism” in resolving the crisis over Ukraine after the US rejected Russia’s main demands, but that dialogue was still possible. Tensions have ... Read more »

Stewart Island Rakiura tourist levy may be tripled to cover rising costs

By RNZ Southland district councillors will consider raising the visitor levy to Stewart Island/Rakiura to $15. The levy is paid by visitors over 18 and has sat at $5 since ... Read more »

Lift in Fonterra's milk price range good news for New Zealand

Content brought to you by Fonterra A lift in the forecast farmgate milk price is not only good news for farmers but also the entire country, managing director of co-operative ... Read more »

Auckland transport: Progress on light rail route, second harbour crossing decision in 2023

The Government has chosen its preferred option for a new mass transit service from the city centre to Māngere. It’s a light rail line that will run in tunnels all ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic