Sir Ian Taylor - Nine questions for the Prime Minister about Covid tests in NZ

Sir Ian Taylor - Nine questions for the Prime Minister about Covid tests in NZ


I have to declare a potential conflict of interest.

I voted for the current Government on the basis that I believed the Prime Minister when she said this would be one of the most transparent governments – ever.

I have watched with growing concern the daily announcements from the “single source of truth” podium at the Beehive where a narrative of “trust us – we know best” has been allowed to grow, almost without question. Those who have questioned it are moved to the back of the queue – or simply ignored.

That mantra has now moved into the parliamentary process where laws are being passed under urgency without any level of transparency, or due process. “We know best” appears to be the sole justification for this extraordinary circumvention of the democratic process.

On September 12 I wrote an open letter to the Prime Minister with an offer to bring help from part of her team of 5 million that up until then had been left sitting on the bench. The offer was genuine, and I really thought that it would open the door to some new thinking that matched the rapidly changing environment that is the hallmark of Covid. In the more than two months since that first offer I have not heard from her, or her office.

Recently, and at no cost to the Government, a significant group from the bench stepped up to fund a trial with specific goals to provide additional advice, for free, to the Prime Minister’s office. We also commissioned an independent review by Ernst & Young. Both reports have been offered to the Government for their consideration with no response to date. Links to both can be found below.

I take seriously the privilege and responsibility that comes with having the right to vote.

The counter to that is that politicians have to take seriously the reasons they gave us to earn that vote.

So, in the spirit of transparency, through these columns, I am going to share specific questions I am sending to the Prime Minister, the Deputy Prime Minister, Covid Recovery Minister Chris Hipkins and director-general of health Dr Ashley Bloomfield because, from what I have learned over the past couple of months, it appears this group is who they are referring to when they talk about “the single source of truth.” I am hoping that they might become the single source of answers as well.

These first questions all relate to the decision made by Bloomfield around testing.

1: Why did it take until yesterday to acknowledge that people in Mangere, one of the most vulnerable communities in the country, are being expected to wait in isolation for up to five days to get a result from the one nasopharyngeal test that you have so far approved – as the gold standard? Is it true the number affected is in the thousands?

2: Why is the Canadian nasopharyngeal PCR test the only PCR test you are subsidising with taxpayer funds when there is a New Zealand PCR test that can deliver up to 10,000 results a day to help relieve that pressure?

3: Is it true that instead of contracting the alternative Kiwi solution, as you have done with the Canadian option, you are backing legislation going through Parliament that will give you the power to simply nationalise the IP of this Kiwi company, at a price you will determine?

4: Why has an alternative saliva PCR test that you awarded the same Canadian company for $60 million been abandoned – or deferred to some time in the future – depending on which government office you are listening to?

5: What is your response to the Auditor-General’s questioning of the process you undertook in the awarding of this contract with regard to the potential conflicts of interest of four out of the five panellists who awarded the contract?

6: There is another Kiwi PCR test that has received millions in funding from the US government that can deliver a result in 27 minutes. Why haven’t you accepted their offer to trial this system in an MIQ facility where they can gather valuable evidence of their effectiveness alongside your current five-day turnaround product?

7: Now that you plan to open the borders to the world in April, have you considered that the timing means people from the northern hemisphere will be coming out of their winter, a winter that has caused a significant uplift in Covid cases, into our winter where we will almost certainly experience our own winter surge, not just of Covid but of new variants of the flu?

8: As we see the totally expected arrival of a new variant out of Africa, are you still confident that your single focus on vaccination as being the answer to keeping us safe is going to see you adhering to that April deadline, or will we see another shift in plans because you haven’t addressed our best line of defence – testing?

9: Given the growing concerns of the effectiveness of the vaccine over time, not to mention the arrival of the new variant, why have you not prioritised an evaluation of the Orbis Immunity test that has been developed at Auckland University as part of the work that has been funded by The Dodd-Walls Centre for Photonics and Quantum Technologies?

You know – a group of scientists!

I look forward to your responses so that I can share them with complete transparency with others who may be looking for that as well.

In my next column I will address the question of trust. We gave you that trust when this began, have you done enough to keep it?

To access the Ernst & Young report from the 151 Off the Bench trial, and the offer I have made to various officials to share our findings from that trial, you will find them freely available at:

News Related


Mark Zuckerberg's cryptocurrency project Diem eyes asset sale

Meta partnered with Silvergate Bank to potentially issue a Diem USD stablecoin (Image Courtesy: Reuters) The Diem Association (formerly named Libra), home to Meta Platforms Inc honcho Mark Zuckerberg‘s ambitious ... Read more »

Foreign Executives in Isolated Hong Kong Head for the Exit Flight bans, quarantine stays for arrivals and school closures jeopardize the city's status as a business hub

People walk past closed bars in an empty Lan Kwai Fong nightlife area earlier this month. (Reuters) Stringent rules to try to keep Hong Kong free of Covid-19 are driving ... Read more »

Percy Thomson Gallery in Stratford announces new director

A new gallery director has been appointed at Stratford’s Percy Thomson Gallery. Chairman Bruce Ellis says the gallery’s trustees are delighted to announce the appointment of Laura Campbell. “Laura takes ... Read more »

Oil dips on profit-taking ahead of Fed update

(Image: Reuters) Oil prices eased on Wednesday as investors booked profits ahead of an update from the U.S. Federal Reserve, although fears over tighter supply amid tensions in Ukraine and ... Read more »

Not Every Space SPAC Is a Star

With billionaires flying to space and building the biggest-ever spaceships, more and more investors are looking toward the space economy. In 2020, private investment in spacetech hit a record $8.9 ... Read more »

Innobic plans range of food products for the elderly, sick

Mr Chalat, left, and Mr Buranin sign a memorandum of understanding to jointly develop new food products for the elderly and patients in care who cannot eat normally. Innobic (Asia) ... Read more »

RuPaul's Drag Race Down Under winner Kita Mean considering move to Australia

She may be the Kiwi drag queen who triumphed in the first season of RuPaul’s Drag Race Down Under, but Kita Mean is now eyeing a move to Australia. Speaking ... Read more »

The Future of CBD In the Skincare Industry As a Natural Remedy

To many, it probably seems surprising to find out that CBD has not as yet been explored to its full potential in the skincare industry. Even leading skincare brands are ... Read more »

Brian Tamaki bail appeal: Will be released from prison 'very shortly'

Destiny Church leader Brian Tamaki has won his appeal against being remanded in custody. It is expected he will be released from prison soon. A Facebook Live video was posted ... Read more »

Cryptocurrency Prices Today: Recovery mode on as Avalanche rises 6.55%, Solana 3.88%

Cryptocurrency (Representative image) The global cryptocurrency market capitalisation reached $1.66 trillion (up 1.68 percent) during the last 24 hours while the market volume over the last 24 hours hit $80.34 ... Read more »

Tata Sky becomes Tata Play to offer OTT services, adds Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, Disney+Hotstar

(Representational image) Tata Sky the direct-to-home (DTH) company has rebranded itself as Tata Play as it plans to expand its television-cum-OTT (over-the-top) offerings in combined packages. The DTH company which ... Read more »

Budget 2022 | Policymakers are trying to find a way to put the economy back on track, says Ankit Yadav of Market Maestroo

Ankit Yadav is the Wealth Manager (USA) and Director at Market Maestroo Ankit Yadav, wealth manager (USA) and director at Market Maestroo, feels agriculture will get more benefits from the ... Read more »

Maxim Gorin Explains How to Create a Social Media Policy for Your Business

Social media has become the front-facing communication source for many businesses, but with great responsibility. You need to ensure that your company employs the correct etiquette to avoid potential lawsuits. ... Read more »

Asian shares cautiously higher as investors await Fed policy update

Asian Markets_markets_Stocks Asian share markets got off to a cautious start on January 26, after another volatile Wall Street session, as investors braced for the outcome of the Fed’s meeting ... Read more »

Palmerston North Zumba instructor Marlene Bonner salsas way to milestone

Marlene Bonner’s black singlet says it all – less talk, more dance. She’s just celebrated six years teaching Zumba in Palmerston North. Bonner trained as a Zumba instructor 10 years ... Read more »

Reliance doubles down on media, likely to unveil its big strategy soon

Representative image Reliance Industries seems to be zooming in on the media business with a strong push to both broadcasting as well as digital media. The company is also planning to ... Read more »

Wall Street ends down as markets whipsaw ahead of Fed meeting

Representative image US stocks gyrated in afternoon trading to close lower with interest rate sensitive tech stocks weighing most heavily as uncertainties surrounding an increasingly hawkish Federal Reserve and rising ... Read more »

Severe thunderstorm warning lifted for Hawke's Bay

MetService has lifted a severe thunderstorm warning for Hawke’s Bay. The warning was received at 3.08pm and was valid until 3.52pm. At 2.52 pm, its weather radar detected severe thunderstorms ... Read more »

Government should prove it is telling the truth about rapid antigen test supplies, says testing provider

The Government says it is not requisitioning stocks of rapid antigen tests (RATS), it is only “consolidating” orders of tests heading into the country, but at least one distributor of ... Read more »

Vigil to be held for Charlise Mutten amid horror new allegations

A vigil will be held for Charlise Mutten tonight, a day after more horrifying allegations emerged about the nine-year-old girl’s death. It has been more than a week since 31-year-old ... Read more »

Responsible Online Gambling: Myth or Reality?

Gambling is one of these hobbies where others might look at you with a bit of judgement. The risk of losing money and the potential of developing an addiction have ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: Central and North Otago A and P Shows affected

The move to Red in the traffic light system has claimed another casualty in the form of the Central Otago A&P Association’s annual show in what would have been its ... Read more »

Focus: Covid-19 Outbreak | Wednesday 26th January Wrap

The Ministry of Health has confirmed that there are 23 new community cases of Covid-19. Video / NZ Herald Read more »

Experts Predict Rapid Growth of Market for Plant-Based Seafood

Major growth is coming to the plant-based seafood industry as companies find willing investors for the meatless food products that continue to rise in popularity. One of the most significant ... Read more »

Australian Open 2022: Kiwi tennis star Michael Venus lashes out at Nick Kyrgios after quarter-final defeat

Kiwi tennis star Michael Venus is the latest player to voice their disdain for the Nick Kyrgios crowd at the Australian Open after being ousted by the Aussie fan favourite ... Read more »

California redwood forest returned to Native American tribes

The descendants of Native American tribes on the Northern California coast are reclaiming a bit of their heritage that includes ancient redwoods that have stood since their ancestors walked the ... Read more »

Travel and Omicron: Can we still travel for the long weekends in red?

For many Kiwis, travel plans have already been made for the upcoming Auckland Anniversary weekend and Waitangi weekend. Then, on Sunday, January 23 at 11.59 pm, all of New Zealand ... Read more »

Realtors pay bigger-than-average bonuses after 12 months of record sales in Hong Kong defied city's Covid-19 outbreak and gloomy job market

Hong Kong’s realtors will increase the bonus cheques of their clerical staff this year, after 12 months of record property transactions that defied the city’s gloomy labour market and a ... Read more »

Microsoft beats quarterly revenue estimates on cloud strength

Satya Nadella, CEO, Microsoft Microsoft Corp exceeded analysts’ expectations for second-quarter revenue on January 25, propelled by strong demand for its cloud-based services from more businesses migrating to hybrid work ... Read more »

Warren Buffett plans in-person Berkshire annual meeting as Omicron wave crests

Warren Buffett. Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway Inc plans this year to let shareholders attend the company’s annual meeting for the first time in three years, amid signs the Omicron wave ... Read more »

Covid-19 Omicron outbreak: Wellington's Round the Bays won't go ahead as planned

Wellington’s Round the Bays event will not go ahead as planned next month after the country moved into red under the Covid-19 traffic light system. Organisers posted on the event’s ... Read more »

High commodity prices sees fewer farms put up for sale

Data just released from the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand shows there were 256 fewer farm sales for the three months to December last year than for the three ... Read more »

Inquest: Prison staff recount how Hawke's Bay Regional Prison inmate died

Prison staff have described the moment a restrained and hooded Kolby Heta wobbled on his feet and went limp before dying in Hawke’s Bay Regional Prison. An inquest into Heta’s ... Read more »

Child weightlifter dubbed 'Supergirl' is all grown up

At age 9 Naomi Kutin became affectionately known as “Supergirl” after she broke a world record by squat lifting 97kg. Kutin stared lifting just months before her record-breaking attempt, as ... Read more »

Surf Club established by volunteers to be demolished after 40 years' service

A “significant new chapter” in the history of Tairua’s Surf Club is unfolding with the demolition of the old clubhouse to be replaced with a brand new building. Tairua Surf ... Read more »

US house leaders unveil chips, China competition bill

US President Joe Biden (File image: AP Photo) US House of Representatives leaders on Tuesday unveiled a bill aimed at increasing US competitiveness with China and supporting the US chip ... Read more »

Two Auckland car dealers in legal stoush over $83,000 Aston Martin

It’s a long road to justice for two Auckland car dealers who are at legal loggerheads over an $83,000 luxury sportscar found to have defects, with the case soon to ... Read more »

Tencent, NetEase push Hong Kong stocks higher as investors shrug off Fed rate rise concerns

Hong Kong stocks snapped a two-day losing streak, with tech stocks leading the charge, shaking off jitters of a hawkish Federal Reserve. Oil-related stocks rose on geopolitical tensions. The Hang ... Read more »

GM's $7 billion investment intensifies EV battle with Ford, Tesla

General Motors (Representative Image: Reuters) General Motors Co said Tuesday it will invest $7 billion in Michigan, much of that aimed at dramatically boosting production of full-size electric pickups, intensifying ... Read more »

Wheels parked up but fundraising goes on

Wellington Anniversary Weekend was supposed to be filled with events and activities, including the Wheels in Wanganui treasure hunt fun run, with vehicles of all descriptions out on the streets ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic