Singapore foreign minister's apology lays bare angst over elite school obsession and class divide

Singapore’s foreign minister Vivian Balakrishnan. Photo: AFP

When Singapore’s foreign minister Vivian Balakrishnan remarked on an opposition politician’s educational background to a party colleague in parliament on Tuesday, he did not expect what he said to go viral.

But his asides were caught on microphone – and with the session being live-streamed, an audio clip with the comments “He’s illiterate”, “Seriously, how did he get into RI?” and “Must be a lousy school” quickly made the rounds.

Online, public attention focused more on the exchange than the serious debate taking place in parliament, on the need for Singapore to remain open to foreigners.

RI, for Raffles Institution, is a household acronym in the country of 5.7 million – 20 per cent of the current cabinet attended the school, as did the country’s late independence leader Lee Kuan Yew.

It is unclear whether all three comments were made by the same person, but Balakrishnan on Wednesday said he had called the politician – Leong Mun Wai, one of the Progress Singapore Party’s two parliamentary representatives – to apologise for “my private comments to a colleague”.

“I disagree with him on the (debated) issue, but I should not have said what I said. Mr Leong has accepted my apology,” Balakrishnan wrote in a Facebook post.

For some Singaporeans, the episode reflects a stark reality in an academically driven society – that one’s worth and capability are measured by the schools they went to. This belief has fuelled an ongoing obsession with brand-name schools that offer educational advantages and social connections that can propel success even in a meritocratic system.

Some social media users shared examples of how, in social gatherings or during job interviews, they were asked about which school they attended, with the answer being seen as a mark of their intellect and leadership ability.

© Provided by South China Morning Post Raffles Institution was attended by 20 per cent of Singapore’s current cabinet. Photo: Handout

For others, the minister’s remarks are at odds with the ruling People’s Action Party’s assertion that there are multiple pathways to success and one’s schooling does not define their life outcomes.

To former government strategy officer turned consulting firm owner Devadas Krishnadas, the comments were revealing of the leadership’s “belief in a ‘natural aristocracy’, destined to rule Singapore on the sheer basis of their academic achievements”.

In a post on LinkedIn, Krishnadas said he felt a “visceral disquiet” from the questions the episode had raised. “How are we viewed by certain PAP leaders? How are we valued by them?” he wrote.

Top schools

RI was founded by the British colonialist Stamford Raffles in 1823. The school’s modern-day iteration comprises a boys-only high school and a co-educational junior college section.

RI’s sister school, the girls-only Raffles Girls’ School (RGS), is equally well known. RI and RGS have for decades been viewed as among the top Asian feeder schools for leading global universities, with many attending these institutions on government scholarships.

Leong, the opposition politician, graduated from RI in 1977 and won a government scholarship to study in Japan. The 62-year-old worked in the finance sector there and in Hong Kong, and now runs a venture capital firm in Singapore.

Leong has been active in calling for a “rebalancing” of the foreign-local workforce ratio, including imposing levies on expatriates to ensure locals get a better shot at jobs. In particular, he has criticised the Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA), a free-trade pact with India, pointing to how it allows for intra-corporate transfers among multinational firms that are heavily slanted in India’s favour and alleging that it fuels unfettered immigration.

The PAP government has pushed back against such claims, saying they are baseless and fomenting anti-Indian sentiment in the multiracial nation.

Tuesday’s debate arose following a motion filed by Leong, and saw several ministers rise to challenge the opposition politician’s sharp criticism of CECA. At times, he appeared unprepared for the grilling, stating repeatedly that he required additional data from officials before he could take a decisive stance on the pact’s merits.

(I am) curious to know who are the other persons who were involved in the conversation and the reason why they held the institution that I attended in contemptLeong Mun Wai from the Progress Singapore Party

After the marathon parliamentary session on Tuesday, which went from 11am until 12.30am the next morning, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong praised lawmakers who defended the city state’s openness to foreigners, saying they had taken “a firm and unequivocal stance against racism and xenophobia”.

In a statement to the media on Thursday, Leong said he had accepted Balakrishnan’s apology but was “also curious to know who are the other persons who were involved in the conversation and the reason why they held the institution that I attended in contempt”.

Leong was referring to how the comments were made as manpower minister Tan See Leng, who had just finished his response to a question from Leong, returned to his seat with Balakrishnan on his left and finance minister Lawrence Wong one seat down.

Tan’s comment “I am from Monk’s Hill” – referring to the now-defunct government high school he attended – was also captured by the microphone.

‘Closed social circles’

To tame competition for elite school places, Singapore’s authorities have stressed that “every school is a good school”, and have promoted social mixing across schools while ordering top institutions to take in more students from different backgrounds.

But sociologist Tan Ern Ser said no matter the mantra, society would have its own markers of what constituted “good”.

“I reckon whether or not every school is officially a good school, people, together with like-minded others, may still subscribe to their own ranking metrics, which may differ from the official version,” said Tan from the National University of Singapore (NUS).

A 2017 study on social capital by the Institute of Policy Studies think tank found that someone who went to an elite school might have ties to those from elite and non-elite schools, but a person who attended a non-elite school had hardly any ties to people from elite schools.

Officials, including Prime Minister Lee, have in the past expressed concern about this trend. In 2018, he said the government was aware of anxieties surrounding class divisions that arose from educational backgrounds and other social cues.

If social mobility was frustrated, “soon the elite group would start to only look after their own interests, and fail in their duty to lead and care for the rest of society”, said Lee, who attended Catholic High School, one of the country’s elite institutions.

The situation is not unique to Singapore. “Old boys or gendered networks that foster in-group elitism are a common feature of many societies. We see this also with political elites in the UK, for example,” said Nanyang Technological University sociologist Laavanya Kathiravelu.

Twenty of Britain’s 55 prime ministers were educated at Eton College, an elite all-boys boarding school, while in China, The Experimental High School Attached to Beijing Normal University is a top institution attended by children of politicians and elite businesspeople.

Tan, the sociologist, said school pride and strong alumni networks among elite school graduates could mean a tendency to form “closed social circles that do not overlap with others”.

This may have been why some users on the Reddit forum quipped that Balakrishnan’s comments were motivated by competitive spirit.

Foreign minister Balakrishnan attended RI’s fierce rival, the Anglo-Chinese School, before studying medicine at the National University of Singapore on a President’s scholarship.

A commenter on the Reddit forum asked why schooling would be an issue for someone of the 60-year-old minister’s age. “I don’t understand why many older people still discuss what secondary school/(junior college) they went to,” it read. “It happened 40 years ago, big deal.”

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (www.scmp.com), the leading news media reporting on China and Asia.

Copyright (c) 2021. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Is A.J. Brown playing on Monday night? Fantasy injury update for Bills-Titans Week 6 Monday Night Football (Updated)

Late-week injury report downgrades are never good, especially when it’s for a star player on Monday Night Football. However, that’s the situation with A.J. Brown ahead of the Bills-Titans showdown. ... Read more »

Lieberman Recounts How Bush Offered to Help Him Win Senate Race Amid Iraq War Support

Former U.S. Senator Joe Lieberman describes in his upcoming book how he was able to win reelection in the 2006 Connecticut Senate race as an independent candidate, and that someone ... Read more »

Minus Four Degrees: Ibu, anak tekad bentuk industri seni pembuatan aiskrim Malaysia

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Sarah Tan dan ibunya, Kim Ngoh, adalah wanita di belakang Minus Four Degrees, sensasi aiskrim terbaharu PJ. (Muhaimin Marwan @ FMT Lifestyle) PETALING JAYA: ... Read more »

Amazon Black Friday deals 2021: When does it start and what UK offers can you expect?

The online giant is known for its huge discounts on everything from vacuum cleaners to TVs (iStock/The Independent) The Black Friday 2021 sales are inching closer every day, with thousands ... Read more »

No precedent for ABC's $200k payment in Louise Milligan defamation dispute, auditor general says

Photograph: Luis Ascui/AAP The auditor general has said he is unable to judge the appropriateness of the ABC’s decision to pay $200,000 for costs incurred by reporter Louise Milligan in ... Read more »

Open records refusal causes concern

Oct. 18—A southeast Oklahoma town's refusal to fulfill an Oklahoma Open Records Act request for a settlement agreement with the former police chief caused concern with a district attorney and ... Read more »

Britain's Tesco opens checkout-free store in London

FILE PHOTO: A woman wearing a face mask pushes a shopping cart at a Tesco supermarket in Hatfield, Britain LONDON (Reuters) – Britain's biggest retailer Tesco will on Tuesday open ... Read more »

Elijah McClain's family settles lawsuit against Aurora for 2019 death

The city of Aurora is preparing to pay the family of Elijah McClain as part of the legal settlement of a federal lawsuit related to the 23-year-old's 2019 death at ... Read more »

Martin Kove on Dancing with the Stars: Everything you need to know about Cobra Kai actor

© Provided by The Independent Martin Kove, best known for playing John Kreese, the villain in The Karate Kid franchise, was among the 15 competitors taking part in season 30 ... Read more »

Companies risk £2.6bn loss building UK gas power plants

© Provided by City AM Companies building new UK gas power plants risk losing £2.6 billion because they will be forced to abandon them before they can regain their investment, ... Read more »

Ex-soldier on trial over fatal shooting in Northern Ireland dies after getting COVID

A British army veteran on trial for charges linked to a fatal shooting during the Northern Ireland Troubles has died after contracting coronavirus. © PA Dennis Hutchings, 80, pictured arriving ... Read more »

More than a third of UK music industry workers lost jobs in 2020

More than a third of UK music industry workers lost their jobs last year – 69,000 in total – as venues closed, festivals were scrapped, tours ground to a halt ... Read more »

Grenfell: Value Engineering review – gruelling, unfinished tragedy

Grenfell Tower housed many of the “have-nots” in a borough of great and conspicuous wealth, as we know from news analysis. The Tabernacle theatre, less than a mile away from ... Read more »

Huma Abedin describes feeling ‘rage' after husband Anthony Weiner confessed sending lewd pic

Huma Abedin felt “rage” after her now-estranged husband Anthony Weiner confessed to sending a lewd picture to an acquaintance in 2011, she writes in a forthcoming memoir. © Getty Images ... Read more »

The Senate confirmation process is broken — Senate Democrats can fix it

© Greg Nash The U.S. Capitol is seen from the East Front Plaza on Tuesday, October 12, 2021. Key parts of President Biden’s agenda are falling victim to arcane Senate ... Read more »

Trump Lawsuit Aims to Stop Jan. 6th Committee from Accessing Former White House Files, Accuses Biden of ‘Political Ploy'

Former President Donald Trump asked a federal court late Monday to block the release of White House documents related to the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol. © Provided ... Read more »

Getöteter schwarzer US-Jogger Arbery: Mordprozess hat begonnen

© Keystone/FR142748 AP/Lewis M. Levine Mehr als eineinhalb Jahre nach dem gewaltsamen Tod des schwarzen Joggers Ahmaud Arbery im US-Bundesstaat Georgia hat der Mordprozess gegen die drei weissen Angeklagten begonnen. ... Read more »

Data shows ship crossed over oil pipeline that ruptured

1 / 3California Undersea Oil PipelinesFILE – In this Oct. 11, 2021, file photo, a family, background, is under an umbrella as workers continue to clean the contaminated beach in ... Read more »

ACLU demands reform after Black girl arrested in Hawaii

HONOLULU (AP) — Honolulu police officers and officials with Hawaii’s public school system discriminated against a disabled Black child by handcuffing, arresting and interrogating the 10-year-old girl for a “run-of-the-mill” ... Read more »

Sensex up for 7th day, nears 62k

© Provided by The Times of India Mumbai: Rising for the seventh consecutive session, the sensex gained 460 points on Monday and closed near the 62k mark at 61,766, a ... Read more »

Wanted in cheating case Pune cops arrest assistant of ‘pvt detective' seen in selfie with Aryan

© Provided by The Indian Express Pune City Police have arrested Sherbano Qureshi, the assistant of wanted accused Kiran Gosavi, the self-styled detective cited as an “independent witness” by the ... Read more »

Sebi nod for Penna Cement's Rs 1,550 cr IPO

© Provided by The Times of India Hyderabad: Cement maker Penna Cement Industries on Monday said it has received the go-ahead from markets regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India ... Read more »

T-Hub's new CEO to expedite T-Fund initiative

© Provided by The Times of India Hyderabad: State-led startup incubator T-Hub on Monday said Srinivas Rao Mahankali, who has joined as its new CEO this month, will be working ... Read more »

RBI fines SBI, StanChart nearly Rs 3cr

© Provided by The Times of India Mumbai: The RBI has imposed a penalty on SBI and Standard Chartered Bank. SBI has been fined Rs 1 crore for non-compliance with ... Read more »

FM, RBI keen to continue stimulus

© Provided by The Times of India Mumbai: The finance ministry and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) are on the same page on the issue of continuing pandemic-era stimulus. ... Read more »

Retail, hospitality keepjob mkt on growth path

© Provided by The Times of India Chennai: The onset of festive season, declining Covid cases and continued digitisation-led growth in tech industry saw the white-collar job market expand by ... Read more »

PNB Hsg stock falls 5% on aborted Carlyle deal

© Provided by The Times of India Mumbai: Shares of PNB Housing Finance fell 5% to be locked in the lower circuit limit after the company said that it scrapped ... Read more »

Morrisons investors set to rubber stamp $10 billion CD&R takeover

FILE PHOTO: A flag flies outside a Morrisons supermarket in New Brighton LONDON (Reuters) – Shareholders in supermarket group Morrisons are expected on Tuesday to approve a 7 billion pound ... Read more »

Missing woman found dead in police van 12 days after she vanished, Alabama cops say

A 29-year-old Alabama woman who had been missing for 12 days was found dead inside a police van on Oct. 7, authorities said. A police officer noticed a pair of ... Read more »

Fox News Anchor Thoroughly Dragged For Boosting Anti-Vax Talk After Powell's Death

No vaccine can cure getting ratio’d on Twitter. © AFP via Getty Images US-POLITICS-PRESS BRIEFING On the morning of former Secretary of State and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of ... Read more »

Supply chain issues ‘will get better' for Monster Beverage, analyst says

Stifel Analyst Mark Astrachan joins Yahoo Finance Live to discuss why he’s bullish on Freshpet, Estée Lauder and Monster Beverage as well as breakdown the state of consumer staples amid ... Read more »

Trump files lawsuit to block release of Capitol riot records

© Provided by Al Jazeera Former President Donald Trump is fighting a congressional investigation of his conduct on Janaury 6 [Ben Gray/AP Photo] Former President Donald Trump filed a lawsuit ... Read more »

Scottish witch who sees Halloween as her Christmas reveals why she won't cast love spells – even though her powers can scare off men she dates

A traditional British witch who regards Halloween as her Christmas has cast a very special spell on the modern world – by attracting more than 50,000 followers to her Instagram ... Read more »

Companies will have to deal with supply chain issues ‘for the foreseeable future': Analyst

Eric Oak, S&P Global Market Intelligence Panjiva Research Analyst joins the Yahoo Finance Live panel with the latest on the Supply Chain crisis. Video Transcript ZACK GUZMAN: Also want to ... Read more »

US to skip Russia-organized talks on Afghanistan

© Getty Images US to skip Russia-organized talks on Afghanistan The State Department on Monday said the U.S. would not be taking part in talks on Afghanistan being held by ... Read more »

LPL teams went 0-8 against LEC and LCS squads during the second round robin of Worlds 2021 group stage, 4-11 overall

© Provided by Dot Esports The LPL representatives went almost flawless during the first round of matches in the group stage of the 2021 League of Legends World Championship. The ... Read more »

MacBook Pro with M1 Pro and M1 Max: 10 things you need to know

Apple has officially introduced the MacBook Pro 14 and MacBook Pro 16 powered by its own developed pro chips – the M1 Pro and the M1 Max. The latest models ... Read more »

Vieira's Palace style already clearer than Arteta's at Arsenal

© PA Images Mikel Arteta watches on at the Emirates for Arsenal Patrick Vieira has created a Palace identity in three months. It’s two years and counting for Mikel Arteta ... Read more »

China's economic growth slumps to just 4.9% amid energy crisis

China’s economic growth slumps to just 4.9% amid energy crisis China’s economy recorded its most sluggish growth in a year for the third quarter of 2021, weighed by an energy ... Read more »

ACT eases quarantine requirements

The ACT will scrap quarantine requirements for residents returning from NSW from November 1.  © Lukas Coch/AAP PHOTOS More businesses will be allowed to open from October 29 in the ... Read more »