Should gravesites be disturbed for the purpose of studying them?

Asia's Tech News Daily

questions increasingly being asked, excavation, growing ethical concern, built one atop the other, end up underground, Norway, their living descendants, protection, Saami, Gjellestad Ship, what role do living ancestors play

Whether gravesites – and human remains in general – should be disturbed (even for research purposes), and how they should be handled, are questions increasingly being asked in the scientific community.

With the recent excavation of an ancient ship, the Historical Museum reopening with shiny new doors, and the Viking Ship Museum undergoing a multi-million kroner facelift, history is very much in Norway’s current cultural spotlight.

But the world of archaeology – discovering historical treasures hidden underneath the ground – is undergoing a paradigm shift, with new scrutiny on the field.

Namely, there is a growing ethical concern about whether gravesites, often excavated to help understand the past, should ever be disturbed – even to study them.

History is literally buried under our feet

Archaeology is the study of human life through the recovery and analysis of material objects. Part of this recovery means, for the most part, a literal digging up of the earth. Thanks to pop culture phenomena like Indiana Jones, many of us have stereotypical views of an archaeologist half-buried in soil, excavating some priceless piece of treasure from a long-lost civilization. Lara Croft – the tomb raider – offers another romanticized view.

Away from the stereotypes, excavations are the lifeline of this science. Throughout the ages, cities and settlements are often built one atop the other, and through other human and natural processes, end up underground. So, to discover the past, archaeologists must dig up the ground they are standing on. And this often includes excavating human remains.

An example of this in recent times was a team from the University of Leicester discovering the body of King Richard III (he of Shakespearean fame). He was not, as widely assumed, buried somewhere at Bosworth Field – but under a parking garage of the local City Council Social Services office.

The study and analysis of human remains are vital for unraveling history. Archaeologists, sociologists, anthropologists, historians, and many other professions connected to history need to examine the dead – how they lived and how they died – to gather information, data, and evidence about our past. Yet disturbing the dead, regardless of whether they died a month or a millennium ago, has been and always will be controversial.

Disrespecting the dead: A form of cultural exploitation?

With an ongoing debate about the repatriation of cultural artifacts in museums raging worldwide – Norway included – there is, in general, a renewed focus on the morality of history.

For many detractors, archaeologists and others who excavate graves and handle skeletal remains are not (only) studying history but (also) disturbing the dead. And their living descendants. Experts such as museologists, bioarchaeologists, and biological anthropologists, whose job includes handling biological and skeletal remains of humans, have come under growing criticism.

During the colonial and imperial histories of many European nations, history was often solely the study of people, and not for people. Graves were desecrated and remains were brought back to Europe for so-called “scientific purposes” from the four corners of the earth. As a result, today many urban, and especially Western, museums have a historic or ethnographic section – which, at best, houses ethically sourced cultural items and, at worst, stolen artifacts – including human remains.

Moral questions have been raised for any gravesite being disturbed by any person – especially when there’s a tipped scale in the power dynamics between the culture of the researching entity and the archeological site. But given the West-led cultural exploitation of indigenous people the world over, the study of graves today is especially viewed, by some, as a child of colonialism. A common scenario includes Europeans traveling (usually uninvited) across the global south and disturbing the (sometimes sacred) graves of locals’ ancestors, family members, and communities.

questions increasingly being asked, excavation, growing ethical concern, built one atop the other, end up underground, Norway, their living descendants, protection, Saami, Gjellestad Ship, what role do living ancestors play

The Museum of Cultural History: where many of Norway’s material and personal artifacts reside. Photo: Berit Roald / NTB

Norway’s structured and formalized system for excavations

Essentially, this heated debate, which has reached Norway, has two sides. On one are those who see gravesites as a place to be studied, with respect, and view this research as important for understanding and preserving the past. On the other are those who see the disturbance of the dead (especially by cultural outsiders) as morally wrong.

In Norway, laws exist striving to protect and preserve a range of “cultural heritage,” amongst them gravesites and human remains. The Cultural Heritage Act (1978) aims to give protection to all buried deposits, buildings, and other cultural objects before 1538 and all Saami archaeological sites before 1900.

Per the act, excavations can only be carried out by five universities (Oslo, Bergen, Stavanger, Trondheim, and Tromsø) or the National Agency responsible for post-Medieval heritage – and with the support, guidance, and permission of local government authorities.

A dark archeological past in Norway

The structured and formal archeological excavation process in Norway is perhaps the result of a troubled past.

From about the mid-19th to the mid-20th centuries, Norway actively dug up Saami graves for “scientific research.” This was very much in line with other European countries’ methods of carrying out scientific, historical, and archaeological studies, many of which were underpinned by dubious racial and ethnic theories. In Norway, Saami remains, despite protests from local populations, were to be studied and analyzed as a different ‘race.’

Yet the fact remains that little is known about some parts of Saami history, and gravesites remain a literal treasure trove of hidden histories and meaning. So, historians and archeologists nowadays have constant contact and consultations with local populations to minimize offense, grief, and distress.

questions increasingly being asked, excavation, growing ethical concern, built one atop the other, end up underground, Norway, their living descendants, protection, Saami, Gjellestad Ship, what role do living ancestors play

Archaeologists work on uncovering the secrets of the Gjellestad Ship. // Photo: Kulturhistorisk museum / NTB

The Gjellestad Ship and Norse remains

One of the largest archaeological finds of the past few years in Norway was the Gjellestad Ship. When local residents first started digging for a drainage ditch, they had no idea what they would uncover. Buried deep in the ‘Jell Mound’ was a 21-meter ship. The Gjellestad Ship is thought to have been used by wealthy people living in Norway (sometime between the 5th and 6th centuries CE) to guide them to the afterworld safely.

The ship has already seen several intruders. It was pillaged in the past – perhaps for plunder or for a political purpose – but now, an academic archaeological team from the Norwegian Institute for Cultural Heritage leads the excavation.

A reburial following the study is unlikely. Old Norse remains (from the Viking Age and earlier) uncovered now are not reburied, according to Asgeir Svestad, a professor at the University of Tromsø. Reburials, he admitted, can be problematic especially as gravesites can help develop new knowledge today.

Though the dead were buried a millennium and a half ago, they are still the remains of someone’s ancestors, someone’s family members, and someone’s loved ones. So, when does a human skeleton, or a gravesite, go from being sacred to scientific? Who decides whether they can be disturbed and what role do living ancestors play?

Gravesites: Handle with care

For the study of history to progress, expand and grow, archaeologists need to do their job. Part of this job involves excavating once-sacred burial areas, gravesites, and skeletal remains. In Norway, a highly formalized system ensures that only those with the best of intentions, and clear academic credentials, can undertake any sort of excavation. Furthermore, a constant dialogue with local communities, governments, and educational institutions aims to ensure ethical archeological practices.

So, overall, should graves be disturbed in order to study them? For a nation with such a love of its history, the answer would seemingly be yes.

Yet would that answer change if you knew it was your ancestors’, family members,’ or loved ones’ graves being excavated?

Like the graves themselves, this debate is layered with meaning.

The opinions expressed are those of the author and are not held by Norway Today unless specifically stated.

About the author:

Jonathan is a lover of the written word. He believes the best way to combat this polarization of news and politics, in our time, is by having a balanced view. Both sides of the story are equally important. He also enjoys traveling and live music.

Source: #NorwayTodayTravel

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Megan Stalter review – a true star turn from the super-silly comic

Photograph: Tristram Kenton/the Guardian ‘You guys are a horrible audience!” Like Patti Harrison at this address a few weeks ago, or US compatriot Kate Berlant, Megan Stalter doesn’t think it’s ... Read more »

Russian Prime Minister Mishustin arrives in Dubai to attend Expo 2020

During the exhibition Expo 2020, each country presents its achievements in the field of science, culture, industry and technology Read more »

New daily infection record in Bergen: 344 corona cases registered in the last 24 hours

A total of 344 new corona-infected people have been registered in Bergen in the last 24 hours – a new daily record.  “We currently have no indications that this is ... Read more »

Strictly's Amy Dowden shares emotional health update after being hospitalised

Strictly Come Dancing professional Amy Dowden has shared an update on her health after being rushed to hospital with a “scary” Crohn's flare-up. She is now living with Tom and ... Read more »

Day-by-day checklist of every hoop you need to jump through for your ski holiday

ski holiday day 2 pcr omicron what you need to do testing travel – Getty After widespread closures last winter, ski resorts are waiting with open arms to welcome guests, ... Read more »

Psychedelic cats, Louise Bourgeois' dreams and the world's first coffee house – the week in art

Exhibition of the week Derek JarmanThe visionary film-maker was also a powerful artist. This is a full survey of a great British radical.• Manchester Art Gallery until 10 April Also ... Read more »

The best party pads to book this New Year's Eve

Pearl’s Place (Mark Watts Photography/Unique Homestays) Presuming (read: praying) that the omicron variant doesn’t pull a fast one and ruin this year’s festive season, it’s time to get organised for ... Read more »

International media cover omicron outbreak in Oslo

The omicron coronavirus variant outbreak at a Christmas dinner party in Oslo attracted a lot of attention in the international media. The British newspapers Evening Standard and Sky News write ... Read more »

This week in photos: Subs in Vladivostok, rescued elephant and lava on La Palma island

Take a look at the world in pictures from a TASS photo gallery Read more »

Long queues reported at the testing station at Svinesund

Long queues at the border station at Svinesund were reported on Friday morning, as all travelers must now be tested for coronavirus and omicron infection upon entry. From Friday, all ... Read more »

Moulin Rouge! stars Liisi LaFontaine and Jamie Bogyo on taking Satine and Christian's romance to the West End

(Jay Brooks) Just a few weeks into Moulin Rouge!’s West End run, it seems that London’s theatregoers are already fully embracing the show’s decadent spirit. “Monday night is a really ... Read more »

New UK rail travel platform promises to plant a tree for every train ticket sold

Photograph: David Noton Photography/Alamy The company – which offers the same fares as other rail sites – aims to match the government’s target of planting 90-120 million trees a year ... Read more »

Reopening of US travel brings international boost for UK services, PMIs show

Some firms said a rebound in international business travel also led to growing export sales (PA Wire) The US border reopening and general relaxing of travel restrictions led to British ... Read more »

Celebrate in style! Best Christmas packages at London's finest hotels

(The Dorchester) Christmas can be a lot. The trains home packed, the shopping lists endless, the families frankly overwhelming. Every year you think, ‘Next time, it will be different.’ Next ... Read more »

Omicron strain not causing severe illness for the vaccinated, says South African minister

South Africa’s health minister stressed that the new variant is "more transmissible" Read more »

NAV director fears increased unemployment benefits make it less attractive for laid-off people to look for jobs

Increased unemployment benefit rates during the pandemic have led to laid-off people not working hard enough to get a new job, Innlandet NAV director Bjørn Lien fears. The authorities increased ... Read more »

Moscow court remands Russian national on high treason charge

The case files are classified and aren’t subject to disclosure Read more »

KRF politician pays back 155,000 kroner to the Norwegian parliament

In November, the Norwegian parliament (Storting) received NOK 155,000 of severance pay that KRF’s Rigmor Andersen Eide paid back after failing to report income. Eide was granted severance pay from ... Read more »

Booster jab against COVID-19 may be needed with weakened immunity, Health Minister says

To date, 9,736,037 coronavirus cases have been confirmed in Russia, Read more »

Why Edinburgh is perfect for a festive break

Edinburgh Castle and Christmas market festive holiday – Travelpix Ltd/Stone RF If your European Christmas market plans have been thrown into disarray, then you might want to consider a trip ... Read more »

The Britons booking stays at the former homes of their ancestors

warwick castle suite ancestry holidays family tree For Faith Moulin, 72, it was 'really quite moving' to stay in a small holiday rental attached to 14th-century Godinton House in Kent, ... Read more »

Norwegian, SAS, Flyr, and Widerøe are introducing mandatory use of face masks on flights

Multiple airlines are introducing face mask requirements on their flights. On Thursday, SAS announced that face masks would be required on its flights. On Friday, Norwegian, Flyr, and Widerøe will ... Read more »

Trafalgar Square's ‘flea bitten' Christmas tree is roasted: ‘It looks like it has a bad hangover'

© PA Trafalgar Square Nothing screams Christmas more than dazzling city lights, classic films, mulled wine and an aesthetically pleasing tree. Unfortunately, it seems as though Trafalgar Square did not ... Read more »

Life of Pi review: Dream-like fable makes for a dazzling night of theatre

Life of Pi features sublime puppetry (Johan Persson) Dazzling. That’s the word for this stage adaptation of Yann Martel’s bestseller about a 16-year-old Indian boy adrift in a lifeboat with ... Read more »

Travel news latest: US confirms new testing policy for all overseas arrivals

testing at US airport – David Paul Morris/Bloomberg The White House has confirmed new testing rules for British visitors to the United States will come into force on Monday December ... Read more »

Mum who thought her six-year-old daughter had a co-ordination disorder discovered she was constantly falling over because she had a brain tumour

A mum who thought her daughter had the co-ordination disorder dyspraxia after she kept falling over, so was blindsided when the six-year-old was diagnosed with a brain tumour, is delighted ... Read more »

Trafalgar Square's Christmas Tree Just About Sums Up The Year We've Had

The Christmas tree in Trafalgar Square this year (Photo: Getty/Twitter @ArchRose90) The huge Christmas tree put up in Trafalgar Square this year has not exactly impressed the public so far. ... Read more »

Statistics Norway: Adults in low-income families with children in Norway rarely have a job

Adults in low-income families with children in Norway rarely have jobs, and when they do, they are often short-term jobs with low wages and short working hours. Immigrants are overrepresented ... Read more »

Ombudswoman highlights violation of rights of Russian-language community in US

Because of multiple searches and interrogations the Coordinating Council of Russian Compatriots of the USA was forced to suspend its operations, Tatiana Moskalkova notes Read more »

RDIF CEO attributes delay in WHO's approval of Sputnik V to bureaucratic issues

The Russian Health Ministry maintains very positive contact on cooperation with the WHO, Kirill Dmitriev pointed out Read more »

Omicron variant carries threefold higher risk of reinfection - South African experts

In particular, experts pointed to evidence for Omicron’s ability to evade immunity from prior infection Read more »

The European Union is considering the approval of a new corona vaccine from Valneva

The European Medicines Agency (EMA) is now considering approving a corona vaccine from the French-Austrian company Valneva. The EMA committee has started the review of VLA2001, a COVID-19 vaccine under ... Read more »

Russia's Omicron clinic network CEO demands WHO to ban new Covid strain name

According to Padar, lawyers assess the perspectives of the lawsuit positively, because the situation may affect the network’s income Read more »

UN General Assembly adopts Olympic Truce resolution for Beijing Games

The document, entitled "Building a peaceful and better world through sport and the Olympic ideal," calls on countries to observe the Olympic Truce from seven days before the start of the Beijing Games until seven days after the end of the Paralympic Games Read more »

Nord-Fron: Deer hunter who shot two llamas by mistake fined 15,000 kroner

A hunter who shot two llamas that he thought were deer will be fined NOK 15,000. In addition, his weapon has been confiscated. Police lawyer Einar Gauslaa Bergem at the ... Read more »

Record number of corona patients hospitalized in Bergen

A total of 25 people with COVID-19 are hospitalized in Bergen, the highest number of corona patients in the city so far.  On Wednesday, an infection record was set in ... Read more »

Norwegian immunologist: The vaccination of children should start immediately

Children between the ages of five and eleven should get vaccinated against corona now, immunologist Anne Spurkland says. She believes that, as the omicron variant has been confirmed in Norway, ... Read more »

Tivoli Gardens in Copenhagen open despite pandemic

The amusement park in Denmark remains open for Christmas this year. Amid reported rising concern about the omicron variant, Denmark’s Tivoli Gardens opened to the public two weeks ago. Tivoli ... Read more »

Nordic Choice Hotels affected by computer virus

Nordic Choice Hotels has notified the National Security Authority that the hotel chain’s IT systems were affected by a computer virus on the night of December 2. “The virus primarily ... Read more »

Bergen temporarily stops drop-in vaccination

Bergen Municipality will temporarily stop drop-in vaccinations from December 6. Therefore, people who want to get the corona vaccine will have to book an appointment once again.  “Appointments are more ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic