##Seoul in conundrum over NK preemptive strike option

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

#Seoul faces conundrum over NK preemptive strike option
Kicker — N. Korea’s mounting threats increase necessity of preemptive plan

By Ji Da-gyum

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

If South Korea faces an imminent attack from nuclear-armed North Korea, what is the most viable military option to defend the country and prevent incalculable and irreparable damage?
Seoul-based experts say South Korea would have no option but to consider launching a preemptive strike, although the anticipatory use of force would come with a certain price. That price could far outweigh potential gains, experts say.
But the bigger problem is Pyongyang‘s mounting artillery, missile and nuclear threats that not only make a preemptive strike plan more indispensable, but also restrain Seoul’s preemptive strike capabilities.
As North Korea’s nuclear and missile prowess is proportional to the threat of preemptive nuclear attack, South Korea cannot and should not give up on a preemptive strike plan.
The correlation clearly depicts South Korea’s deteriorating security situation and the conundrum concerning a preemptive strike that the country has long wrestled with.

Heated debate on preemptive strike

Global Tech News Daily

A preemptive strike has drawn public attention in Seoul, as the issue is at the center of political disagreement with around 40 days left until the presidential election.
The main opposition People Power Party’s presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol this month raised the necessity of launching a preemptive strike with the Kill Chain system, when asked how to prevent missile threats by North Korea.
Yoon said it was virtually impossible to intercept a missile carrying a nuclear weapon if it travels at a speed of Mach 5 or greater, reaching the Seoul area within just a minute.
The campaign of the ruling Democratic Party of Korea’s Lee Jae-myung launched blistering criticism and maintained that “there has been no leader who directly and publicly addressed a preemptive strike on North Korea.” The camp said a preemptive strike was an “extremely risky scenario” given that “there are high chances that it would turn into an all-out war.”
But not surprisingly, South Korea has continued to develop and secure independent preemptive strike capabilities while developing the Kill Chain system as part of a three-axis system since 2012. The triad consisted of the Kill Chain, the Korea Air and Missile Defense and the Korea Massive Punishment and Retaliation, which has since been renamed the “Nuclear-WMD Response System.”
The Moon Jae-in administration has incorporated the Kill Chain and the KMPR into a “strategic strike system,” which seeks “deterrence by both denial and punishment to deter and counter omnidirectional, asymmetric threats,” the 2020 Defense White Paper said. To that end, the military has continued to build “forces equipped with long-distance surveillance capabilities and precision strike capabilities.”

Preemptive vs. Preventive strike

Global Tech News Daily

Then, what is a preemptive strike? And what is its significance?
In general, a preemptive strike is recognized as an anticipatory use of force to defend a country against a perceived imminent but not actually armed attack.
The US Defense Department defined a preemptive strike as an “attack initiated on the basis of incontrovertible evidence that an enemy attack is imminent,” as part of the Bush Doctrine of the George W. Bush administration.
But a preventive strike is initiated based on the belief that “military conflict, while not imminent, is inevitable, and that to delay would involve greater risk.”
The Six-Day War between Israel and neighboring Arab states in June 1967 is a rare example of such a preemptive attack, conducted by Israel. The US invasion of Iraq in 2003 was a preventive war to destroy Saddam Hussein’s purported weapons of mass destruction.
It is crucial to recognize the difference between a preemptive and preventive strike. A preemptive strike can be justified as an act of preemptive self-defense under certain circumstances, although there has been no universal and undisputed yardstick for judging the legitimacy.
Article 51 of the UN Charter stipulates that the charter does not proscribe the “inherent right of individual or collective self-defense if an armed attack occurs against a Member of the United Nations.”
But as there have been divergent interpretations of an armed attack, questions still remain on the morality and legitimacy of a preemptive war.

Feasibility of preemptive strike plan

There are multitudinous factors that restrain Seoul’s preemptive strike capabilities, including tardy progress in the transfer of wartime operational control.
Yang Uk, an associate research fellow at the Asan Institute, pointed out that there are three main pillars — “detect first, decide first and strike first” — that would enable South Korea to launch a preemptive attack against North Korea’s imminent attacks.
But South Korea’s weakness in intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance, or ISR, capabilities against North Korea and its overdependence on the US’ ISR assets pose major hindrances.
More importantly, the South Korean president’s ability to decide to launch a preemptive strike, which would entail a heavy political burden, is also a key determinant.
“The stage of making a decision is also greatly instrumental,” Yang said. “This is not just a military determination, but both a military and a political resolution.”
Park Won-gon, a professor of North Korean Studies at Ewha Womans University, pointed to North Korea’s development of solid-propellant missiles with enhanced survivability as one of the major restraints.
Solid-fuel ballistic missiles can be stored, transported and fired with a shorter-preparation time from transporter-erector-launchers, giving South Korea only a 15-minute window to respond.
“Seoul has to detect signs (of imminent attacks), identify targets, make a decision and launch a strike within less than 15 minutes,” Park said. “It would be immensely difficult to carry out an attack on the actual battlefield.”
Additionally, North Korea‘s pursuit to miniaturize nuclear warheads and develop and variegate dual-capable missiles able to deliver both conventional and nuclear payloads has made it extremely challenging for Seoul to discern whether Pyongyang intends to launch nuclear attacks.
“Seoul would be unable to identify whether missiles deliver conventional or tactical nuclear warheads even when signs of imminent missile launches are detected,” Park said, pointing to the KN-23 and KN-24 short-range ballistic missiles launched this month as an example of newly developed dual-capable missiles.
The geographical proximity between the two Koreas and thousands of artillery and rocket systems deployed across the full length of the Demilitarized Zone would impose another restriction, said Choi Hyun-ho, a military columnist at the JoongAng Ilbo.
American think tank Rand Corp. estimated that North Korea has deployed 4,800 medium-range artillery pieces with a maximum range of 25 kilometers across the DMZ in its “North Korean Conventional Artillery” report in 2020. Approximately 950 long-range artillery pieces that can reach Seoul with its population of around 10 million people and the surrounding area are deployed near the North’s city of Kaesong.
The US think tank warned that North Korean artillery strikes “could cause thousands of casualties in just a minute and more than 100,000 in an hour.”
“We must completely and simultaneously neutralize medium- and long-range artillery threats if we launch a preemptive strike. But it doesn’t seem feasible,” Choi said.
Choi also pointed out it is practically improbable to incapacitate or destroy innumerable missiles in North Korea at one go.
North Korea’s strategic placing of long-range missiles along its border with China would also aggravate South Korea and the US’ decision-making process.
“Pyongyang has deployed most of the long-range missiles along the North Korea-China border, which makes it extremely tough and complicated for South Korea and the US to launch a preemptive strike,” Choi said.
“In a word, North Korea has multifarious options (to deter South Korea’s preemptive strike),” Choi added. “But Seoul has countless constraints.”

Sole military option against N.Korea’s attacks

Then, should South Korea abandon a preemptive strike plan?
Experts view a preemptive strike as the sole military option in the case of an imminent attack from Pyongyang, especially since North Korea has diversified its delivery vehicles to carry nuclear weapons.
“It is not feasible yet. But we have to prepare for a preemptive strike as there are no other military options,” Park said. “It is inevitable and imperative to develop the feasibility (of the plan).”
Yang underlined that a preemptive strike would be the one and only option against North Korea‘s imminent asymmetric and nuclear attacks on South Korea, which would inflict irreparable and incalculable damage.
“If North Korea uses weapons capable of delivering nuclear warheads, we ought to assume that the country will launch a nuclear attack,” Yang said. “North Korea should take the risk as a nuclear-armed state.”

Political leader’s public endorsement

But opinions diverge as to whether it is appropriate for a presidential candidate to explicitly support a preemptive strike plan.
Kim Young-jun, a professor at the Korea National Defense University, pointed to the peril of Yoon capitalizing on a preemptive strike for “political gains” in the electoral race.
An influential politician or a political leader’s public endorsement of a preemptive strike would cause disadvantages to their foreign policy direction, particularly at this point. In short, the costs of such a move would far exceed its benefits.
“Presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol limits his diplomatic options at a time when South Korea is preparing for the next five years,” Kim said. “Yoon seems to be seeking to win people’s votes, but he is now giving up his diplomatic tools.”
Kim explained the US and the former Soviet Union had not threatened each other with preemptive strikes during the Cold War, although both sides prepared for a plan.
Park underscored that Seoul should face up to reality. Pyongyang has pursued development of dual-capable missiles and tactical nuclear weapons, as well as more survivable and maneuverable ballistic missiles that can penetrate and incapacitate missile defenses.
South Korea should look at the big picture and have a comprehensive discussion of North Korea’s mounting missile and nuclear threats, rather than clouding the picture and making a preemptive strike a political issue.
Park pointed out that it was essential to assess North Korea’s intention and threats and South Korea’s missile defense capabilities, and seek ways to reinforce military capabilities at this juncture.
“It is very regrettable that the ruling and opposition political parties argue over the statement while such discussion is absent.”
Nonetheless, experts say stressing the need to launch a preemptive strike to deter North Korea’s existential and rapidly growing threats to defend the country is unavoidable.
“We are asking the question equivalent to whether the US president can press a nuclear button in case of nuclear attacks by an enemy,” Yang said. “No one wants to go ahead with the option. But at the end of the day, we will be attacked or face another war unless we demonstrate our capability of launching (a preemptive) strike at any moment.”
(dagyumji@heraldcorp.com)

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Soaring oil prices, weakening won weigh on Korea's economy

International oil prices feared to hit $100 a barrel By Yi Whan-woo A toxic mixture of soaring oil prices and a weakening Korean won are expected to put a further ... Read more »

Korean companies capitalize on sustainable consumption

Samsung Electronics said Monday that it developed a new material by recycling abandoned fishing nets like the one pictured above for its new Galaxy devices. Courtesy of Samsung Electronics By ... Read more »

Woori Financial nominates new head of banking arm

Woori Bank’s headquarters in Seoul / Yonhap By Lee Min-hyung Woori Bank CEO nominee Lee Won-duk Woori Financial Group nominated Senior Deputy President Lee Won-duk as the next leader of ... Read more »

ShillaJen fiasco raises bar for bio firms' IPOs

SillaJen shareholders protest in front of the Korea Exchange (KRX) on Yeouido, Seoul, Jan. 18. Newsis By Anna J. Park The country’s bourse operator Korea Exchange (KRX) is set to ... Read more »

Samsung SDI lags behind LG, SK in overseas ventures

Samsung SDI headquarters in Yongin, Gyeonggi Province / Courtesy of Samsung SDI By Park Jae-hyuk Samsung SDI, which is less active than LG Energy Solution (LGES) and SK on in ... Read more »

President Moon urges calm amid surge in Omicron variant infections

President Moon Jae-in speaks during a Central Disaster and Safety Countermeasure meeting at Cheong Wa Dae, Monday. Courtesy of Cheong Wa Dae Korea introduces new COVID-19 control scheme focused on ... Read more »

Questions remain over Kolon heir's managerial succession

Kolon Global Vice President Lee Kyu-ho By Park Jae-hyuk Kolon Global Vice President Lee Kyu-ho is still facing a tall task to prove his management ability, despite Kolon Group’s accelerated ... Read more »

Lotte Insurance appoints new CEO

Lotte Insurance CEO Lee Eun-ho / Courtesy of Lotte Insurance By Anna J. Park Lotte Insurance, a Korea-headquartered insurance firm with expertise in non-life insurance, appointed a new CEO, Lee ... Read more »

Facing omicron wave, schools shift to ‘normalcy'

Students attend an elementary school in Seoul, Monday. The Ministry of Education announced new measures for schools set for the new semester in March, including new testing protocols and four-stage ... Read more »

Top nuclear envoys of S. Korea, US, Japan to meet in Hawaii for talks on NK

Passersby watch a TV news report on North Korea’s launch of an intermediate-range ballistic missile at Seoul Station in central Seoul on Jan. 30, marking the seventh round of the ... Read more »

'Robot chefs' unveiled at boot camp to cut troops' workloads, improve meals

This composite photo, released by South Korea’s defense ministry on Monday, shows cooking robots carrying out repetitive tasks (R) at the Army’s 28th Recruit Training Regiment in Nonsan, 213 kilometers ... Read more »

Ruling party's attempt to revive late progressive icons backfires

A video uploaded Saturday on the official YouTube channel of the Democratic Party of Korea shows former President Roh Moo-hyun with a voice mimicking him asking support for the party`s ... Read more »

Celltrion's inhaled COVID-19 treatment found to be safe in clinical trial

The government said Saturday it will begin supplying Celltrion’s COVID-19 antibody treatment to medical facilities in mid-February. Yonhap Korean pharmaceutical giant Celltrion said Monday that its inhaled version of an ... Read more »

S. Korea, US not mulling additional THAAD deployment: defense ministry

Military vehicles transport missiles to the site of the THAAD base in the town of Seongju, North Gyeongsang Province. (Yonhap)South Korea and the United States are not considering the deployment ... Read more »

‘Now is the time to pass anti-discrimination law'

Rep. Jang Hye-young of the Justice Party (Shot and edited by Team Konnect)South Korea’s upcoming presidential election is just one month away. But overshadowed by other issues such as housing ... Read more »

Korean battery makers take up 30.4% of global market share in 2021

LG Energy Solution employees pose with the company’s battery product. Courtesy of LG Energy Solution The combined global market share of three major South Korean battery makers declined last year ... Read more »

Moon, Turkmen president exchange letters marking 30th anniversary of relations

A view of Cheong Wa Dae in Seoul (Yonhap)President Moon Jae-in and Turkmen President Kurbanguly Berdymukhamedov exchanged letters celebrating the 30th anniversary of diplomatic relations between the two countries, Cheong ... Read more »

PM hints at possible increase in extra budget for pandemic-hit merchants

Prime Minister Kim Boo-kyum speaks at a meeting of the parliamentary committee on budget and accounts at the National Assembly in Seoul on Monday. (Yonhap)Prime Minister Kim Boo-kyum hinted Monday ... Read more »

Govt. launches team to support vulnerable N. Korean defectors

Ministry of Unification (Yonhap)The South Korean government launched an interagency team Monday tasked with helping North Korean defectors suffering from economic and psychological difficulties after resettlement here. The nine-member team, ... Read more »

Moon urges more neighborhood hospitals to join fight against omicron wave

President Moon Jae-in speaks at a COVID-19 response meeting on Monday, in this photo provided by Cheong Wa Dae. (Cheong Wa Dae)President Moon Jae-in on Monday called for more neighborhood ... Read more »

Korea's new COVID-19 cases above 35,000 for 3rd day as Omicron's spread picks up

People wait in line to be tested for COVID-19 at a makeshift testing center in Seoul on Feb. 7 as the country’s new caseload hit a fresh high of 35,131 ... Read more »

[Graphic News] Lottery sales hit all-time high in 2021 amid COVID-19 pandemic

Lottery sales in South Korea rose 10.3 percent on-year to reach an all-time high last year amid the COVID-19 pandemic, data showed. Sales of lottery tickets stood at 5.98 trillion ... Read more »

N. Korea marks 6th anniv. of Kwangmyongsong-4 satellite launch

DPRK`s National Aerospace Development Administration (NADA)North Korea on Monday celebrated the sixth anniversary of what it claims to be a major satellite launch, its state media said, highlighting Pyongyang’s resolve ... Read more »

Yoon leads Lee 43.4% to 38.1%: poll

This compilation image shows (from L to R) presidential candidates Lee Jae-myung, Yoon Suk-yeol, Sim Sang-jeung and Ahn Cheol-soo. (Yonhap)Main opposition presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol is leading his ruling party ... Read more »

N. Korea stays silent on much-anticipated parliamentary meeting

North Korean leader Kim Jong-un presides over a politburo meeting of the Workers’ Party at the headquarters of the party’s Central Committee in Pyongyang on Jan. 19, 2022, in this ... Read more »

Korea's foreign reserves decline for 3rd straight month in January

gettyimagesbank Korea’s foreign reserves shrank for the third straight month in January due to a decline in dollar-converted value of holdings in other currencies, central bank data showed Monday. The ... Read more »

Self-employed at risk of default as government set to end COVID-19 relief program

A street food vendor cooks tteokbokki, or spicy Korean rice cakes, at a market in Seoul on Jan. 20. Yonhap By Lee Min-hyung Small business owners are under mounting pressure ... Read more »

Capital gains tax on stock investors emerges as key voting issue

The presidential candidates pose before their first joint TV debate at broadcaster KBS’ studio on Yeouido, Seoul, Feb. 3. From left are Sim Sang-jung of the minor Justice Party, Lee ... Read more »

2 in 3 young people positive about plant-based meat consumption

Dishes made with plant-based meat / Courtesy of Shinsegae Food By Kim Rahn More than two out of three young people are positive about consuming plant-based meat, mainly because they ... Read more »

Spin-off shows for hit reality shows and drama series on rise

A still from the reality show, “We Don’t Bite: Street Woman Fighter” / Courtesy of tvN By Lee Gyu-lee Networks are making use of their hit shows and drama series ... Read more »

FTC to decide on conditional approval of Korean Air-Asiana merger

Korean Air’s headquarters building in Seoul. Korea Times file By Kim Hyun-bin The country’s top antitrust watchdog is expected to announce its final decision to push forward with a conditional ... Read more »

Competition heating up among conglomerates to recruit talented staff

Getty images By Kim Hyun-bin Major conglomerates are starting to hire new and experienced employees, including in the highly competitive semiconductor and battery industries. Samsung is currently the only company ... Read more »

Samsung, LG struggle over performance-based bonuses

Unionized workers at Samsung Electronics apply to the National Labor Relations Commission for arbitration, at the Government Complex Sejong, Friday. Yonhap By Park Jae-hyuk Performance-based bonuses have become a major ... Read more »

[Herald Interview] Politics startup seeks to bring power of data to people ahead of elections

Ryu Ho-hyon, Oxopolitics CEO and founder (left) and Ryu Chan-hyun, the COO and co-founder of the company. (Oxopolitics) Transparent and unbiased data will help potential voters and politicians make rational ... Read more »

US rate hikes, COVID-19 spike escalate anxiety on KOSPI

U.S. Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell holds on online-only news conference from the Federal Reserve building in Washington, Jan. 26. Screenshot from the U.S. Federal Reserve video broadcast via Reuters-Yonhap ... Read more »

Korea's nuclear phase-out policy losing further ground

A nuclear plant in Uljin, North Gyeongsang Province Korea Times file By Lee Kyung-min Korea should take into account a recent move by the European Commission (EC) to recognize nuclear ... Read more »

COVID-19 cases surpass 1 million; Omicron infects 38,000 in 1 day

People line up at a city park in Gangnam District in Seoul, Feb. 6, for PCR testing to confirm whether they are infected with COVID-19. Newsis Government offers Paxlovid to ... Read more »

Election remains foggy with Lee, Yoon neck and neck in polls

Candidates Lee Jae-myung of Democratic Party (left) and Yoon Suk-yeol of People Power Party prepare for TV debate held Thursday. (Joint Press Corps) Even after the first TV debate held ... Read more »

S. Korea says hanbok is indisputably part of its culture, urges China's respect

This file photo is not related to the article. (Yonhap)South Korea plans to continue global efforts to publicize hanbok, the traditional Korean attire, as its signature culture, a government official ... Read more »

Presidential candidates to register with election watchdog on Feb. 13-14

Election officials stage a campaign at a square in Daegu, 300 kilometers southeast of Seoul, on Jan. 27, 2022, to promote voting in the March 9 presidential election. (Yonhap)With the ... Read more »