Security guard acquitted of indecently assaulting child while on duty

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

A Sydney shopping centre security guard has sensationally had his conviction for indecently assaulting a young girl while on duty quashed on appeal.

Mohammad Hassan Al Bayati was in 2019 jailed for up to four-and-a-half years after a jury found him guilty of assaulting and exposing himself to the then three-year-old girl in a stairwell at the Direct Factory Outlet at Homebush.

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

Mr Bayati has consistently maintained his innocence and after serving more than two-and-a-half years behind bars, the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal on Friday ordered that his convictions be quashed after it found that his indecent assault conviction was not supported by the evidence.

Following a second trial in May 2019, a jury found him guilty of indecent assault, committing an act of indecency and taking a child to obtain advantage.

Global Tech News Daily

He was jailed by NSW District Court Judge John Pickering for four-and-a-half years with a two-and-a-half year non-parole period.

His non-parole period expired in July last year.

Global Tech News Daily

Justices Lucy McCallum, Peter Hamill and Richard Cavanagh on Friday ruled that his indecent assault conviction be quashed and that he be acquitted.

They also ordered his convictions for the other two lesser counts be quashed and that he face a retrial on those charges.

However, it is now up to the Director of Public Prosecutions to decide whether Mr Al Bayati will face a third trial given his non-parole period has now expired and that he has served several years in prison.

Security guard acquitted of indecently assaulting child while on duty

Camera IconMohammed Hassan Al Bayati during his police interview. NSW Police. Credit: Supplied

The court heard that Mr Al Bayati had been captured on CCTV taking the girl by the hand and leading her into a stairwell.

The girl was found in the centre’s play area, along with a sibling, while their mother did Christmas shopping in December 2016.

Mr Al-Bayati received a call to assist a “lost child” and led her by the hand to a service corridor and stairwell.

He and the child disappeared from the view of CCTV cameras for 11 minutes when he was alleged to have assaulted her.

The court heard that he was only charged with indecent assault during pre-trial arguments and only after Judge Pickering suggested he could be charged with indecent assault.

Mr Al Bayati argued on appeal that he was subject to a miscarriage of justice because the crown should not have been allowed to amend its indictment.

As well, his barrister argued Judge Pickering was disqualified from hearing arguments about an amended indictment due to his own statements.

The Court of Appeal found that Judge Pickering “entered the arena” by “blurring” the lines between judge and prosecutor.

The three judges also found that the indecent assault charge was not supported by the evidence presented to the court.

“The child denied on several occasions that the applicant touched her,” the court said in its judgment.

“The first complaint she made to her father did not, according to his account, suggest there was any touching that might have amounted to an indecent assault.”

Security guard acquitted of indecently assaulting child while on duty

Camera IconCCTV of Mohammed Hassan Al Bayati with the young girl. Ten News. Credit: Channel 10

The court heard that after the alleged incident, the girl was returned to her mother who had arrived at the play area.

Later, the girl told her father that the “man at shops want to kiss my bum bum.”

The Court of Appeal found that the conviction for indecently assaulting the girl was only supported by hearsay evidence from the mother of what her husband had told her.

As well, DNA evidence – which was a one in 750 match for Mr Al Bayati’s DNA – found on the girl’s underwear could have been the result of secondary transfer after he was holding her hand, the court heard.

“Our review of the evidence leaves us with a substantial and reasonable doubt as to the applicant’s guilt on the third count,” Justices McCallum, Hamill and Cavanagh said in their judgment.

“This is a doubt that the jury should also have experienced. We have taken into account the role of the jury in the criminal trial process and the advantages it enjoys in making collective determinations on behalf of the community.

“Even allowing for those matters, the verdict on the third count cannot be permitted to stand.”

Mr Al Bayati will now be arraigned in the District Court early next month with the Director of Public Prosecutions to decide whether he faces a third trial.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Gay men allegedly lured to Melbourne park via dating app and beaten

Three gay men have been assaulted at a Melbourne park after allegedly been catfished by a group of teenage boys on a dating app. The trio were allegedly lured to ... Read more »

‘We knew the truth': Cleo's parents reveal toll of internet trolls during 18-day kidnapping nightmare

Cleo Smith’s parents battled dark times during their daughter’s 18-day kidnapping nightmare, no more so when they were blamed for her disappearance. In a series of high-profile media interviews over ... Read more »

AFL: Carlton re-signs John Nicholls medallist Sam Walsh on long-term deal

Carlton has removed reigning club champion Sam Walsh from the out-of-contract market, extending the All-Australian midfielder for four more years. Walsh will serve as one of two vice-captains, along with ... Read more »

‘Garbage': Scott Morrison scraps major election promise

Scott Morrison has broken a major promise made three years ago, with plans for a federal anti-corruption watchdog sent to the scrap heap. Attorney-General Michaelia Cash on Monday confirmed the ... Read more »

Tyler Wright didn't win in Hawaii but made a big statement

Tyler Wright left Pipeline without the major trophy but adamant the historic event showed women “deserve to be out here”. The two-time world champion was bundled out of the Billabong ... Read more »

Ongoing industrial action set to cause commuter chaos across Sydney's rail network for at least two weeks

Sydney commuters are being warned of major delays as an already reduced public transport timetable is set to be hit by ongoing industrial action from Monday. Members of the Rail, ... Read more »

Government announces ABC's new billion dollar funding package

The Morrison government has announced a three-year $4.2 billion funding package for the ABC and SBS just months out from the federal election. Communications Minister Paul Fletcher made the announcement ... Read more »

Government's major announcements on RATs

Rapid Antigen Tests have emerged as a battleground issue heading into the federal election with the Morrison government promising to make them tax deductible. After coming under pressure from Labor ... Read more »

Triple bushfires rip through Western Australia

Firefighters battled through the night defending homes in what was a treacherous 24 hours for communities in Western Australia. The bushfires ripped through the south-western part of the state, damaging ... Read more »

Earthquake rattles residents in Far North Queensland

A minor earthquake has been recorded off the Far North Queensland coast with local residents reporting having felt the rumbling. The 3.9 magnitude quake was recorded about 60kms south-east of ... Read more »

Rapid Antigen Tests ‘vital' for people with disability

Thousands of people living with a disability are set to receive Rapid Antigen Tests (RATs) following public pressure and criticism over a lack of access for some of Australia’s most ... Read more »

National day to find forgiveness following deaths of four children

The family of four children killed in a horror drink driving crash have urged forgiveness as they remembered their lost loved ones in a moving ceremony. Antony, 13, Angelina, 12, ... Read more »

‘Couldn't care less': Scott Morrison responds to damaging leaked texts

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has broken his silence on the leaking of more damaging text messages. Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce was forced to issue an apology for a message ... Read more »

Federal election 2022: How 13,000 Aussies could decide the next PM

Just a little more than 13,000 Australians have the potential to decide the next election. With the nation due to head to the polls in less than four months, the ... Read more »

NSW Covid infections drop again to 7893, 28 deaths recorded

Daily coronavirus infections in NSW are at their lowest since the Christmas period, while hospitalisations and ICU admissions also continue to ease from the staggering Omicron peak in mid January. ... Read more »

Victoria records 7169 new Covid-19 cases and six deaths

Victoria has recorded 7169 new Covid-19 infections and six deaths after seeing its deadliest day on Saturday. The state has seen a steady decline in Covid infections in recent weeks, ... Read more »

Prime Minister Scott Morrison issues statement on Queen Elizabeth

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has issued a statement honouring Queen Elizabeth on her platinum jubilee, the 70 year anniversary of her accession to the throne. The Queen is the first ... Read more »

Would you do this job in exchange for $100?

Would you work a 64-hour week for the prospect of earning $100? That’s the reality of Alexi and Talipope, who came to Australia from Samoa to work under the government’s ... Read more »

Man charged after urinating on Hyde Park Anzac Memorial

A late-night toilet stop has resulted in a man being hit with a criminal charge after he allegedly urinated on the Anzac Memorial in Sydney’s CBD overnight. The 25-year-old Randwick ... Read more »

Farmers disappointed over Woolworths milk change

Australian farmers have reacted to a news Woolworths will phase out its 10-cent dairy levy, saying that more should be done to support dairy farmers. The levy will be scrapped ... Read more »

Footscray cemetery: man seen loitering at scene where human heads were taken

Police are hunting a man who was seen fleeing a Melbourne cemetery where two human heads were reportedly stolen from coffins this week. The bizarre crime – which occurred at ... Read more »

Parramatta Road pile-up: Two hospitalised after horror six-car crash

A man has been arrested and multiple people hospitalised after a six-car pile-up on a busy Sydney road that occurred shortly after a high-speed police chase was terminated. Parramatta Road ... Read more »

Barnaby Joyce: Deputy PM pulls out of ABC Insiders appearance amid texting furore

Beleaguered Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce has bailed on a scheduled TV interview after fessing up to sending text messages that were scathing of Prime Minister Scott Morrison. Mr Joyce ... Read more »

Queensland Covid: Case numbers rise, death toll climbs by record 21

Queensland has experienced its deadliest day of the pandemic so far after 21 people died with the virus – more deaths than were recorded in NSW. The latest fatalities in ... Read more »

Barnaby Joyce: Deputy Prime Minister says he offered to resign after embarrassing ScoMo text leak

Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce has revealed he offered to quit after an embarrassing text leak that revealed he called Prime Minister a “hypocrite and a liar”. Mr Joyce fronted ... Read more »

M80 Ring Road fire: Massive truck fire closes freeway in Melbourne

A truck carrying oil has burst into flames on a major freeway in Melbourne’s northwest, shutting down traffic. The B-double truck caught fire about 6.30am on Saturday, with commuters facing ... Read more »

Marion Barter: Inquest unravelling shock details surrounding schoolteacher, mum's disappearance 25yrs ago

It’s been 25 years since Marion Barter was last seen alive. As a teacher she’d been crowned with a prestigious Queensland Teaching Excellence Award for her work at The Southport ... Read more »

New Wanderers coach Mark Rudan ready for meeting with his former club Western United

Western Sydney Wanderers coach Mark Rudan feels “nothing” for Western United as he prepares to take on his former club on Saturday night. Rudan’s two-year tenure at United ended disastrously, ... Read more »

Former police officer charged with distributing child pornography

A former NSW Police officer has been charged with distributing child pornography. The 46-year-old man was arrested at Burwood Police Station on Friday morning. The man was a senior constable ... Read more »

Serial killer Regina Arthurell applies for bail after alleged sexual touching

A notorious convicted triple-killer accused of a series of a sex crimes has made an application for bail, but details about the court hearing cannot be reported after a magistrate ... Read more »

Demons premiership star Ben Brown thrilled to avoid surgery in second AFL pre-season at Melbourne

Second-year Demon Ben Brown doesn’t want to jinx himself but he’s enjoying one of the best pre-seasons of his life. The most notable feature of Brown’s summer is he avoided ... Read more »

Parliamentary committee blasts ASIC for ‘under-assessing' gravity of Sterling Group scam risks, acting too slow

The corporate watchdog has been lashed by a parliamentary committee over a rent-for-life scam that ripped off seniors and left some homeless, concluding it has “serious concerns” about how the ... Read more »

Google loses Fortnite stay case against Epic Games

The developers of hit game Fortnite have had a win against Google in court after the tech giant lost its bid to have a case against it thrown out. Epic ... Read more »

Prime Minister Scott Morrison washes apprentice's hair during Melbourne visit

Scott Morrison has washed a young woman’s hair during a whistlestop tour of Melbourne’s southeast as he tries to woo voters before the election. The Prime Minister carried out the ... Read more »

Top Iraq War commander explains deadly attack on ISIS leader

A top former commander of Australian forces in Iraq has called the death of ISIS leader Abu Ibrahim al-Hashimi al-Qurayshi a “really good achievement”. Former major general Jim Molan, who ... Read more »

Double murderer Luke David Fawcett sentenced to life behind bars with a lengthy minimum term

A double murderer who allegedly rehearsed one of his killings on camera while wearing a black latex suit has been handed a lengthy prison sentence. Luke David Fawcett, 29, stood ... Read more »

Cleaner who allegedly murdered 92yo didn't look deranged: court

A cleaner accused of murdering her elderly client did not look “deranged” just hours before the alleged violent incident inside the 92-year-old’s Sydney home, a court has been told. Hanny ... Read more »

‘You are in danger': Bushfire threatens lives and homes in WA tourist region

Lives and homes are under threat from an out-of-control bushfire in a tourist region of Western Australia. An emergency warning has been issued for people in an area bounded by ... Read more »

Concerns Stuart Highway subsurface ‘like jelly', no timeframe when it will be operational

There are concerns the subsurface of the frequently used highway that connects regional South Australia and the Northern Territory could be “like jelly” and leave commuters stranded if they drive ... Read more »

Scott Morrison ridiculed for pre-election ‘stunt'

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has copped a savage sledge for posing for a pre-election photo opportunity, before admitting one sector was in “crisis”. The Prime Minister visited the Labor-held Dunkley ... Read more »