Scotland's NHS crisis: SNP doing exactly the opposite of what's required to fix health service – Jackie Baillie

Whenever an ambulance passes with blue lights flashing, people can be forgiven for wondering whether there will be room for the patient in the hospital.

how to, scotland's nhs crisis: snp doing exactly the opposite of what's required to fix health service – jackie baillie

Scotland’s NHS crisis: SNP doing exactly the opposite of what’s required to fix health service – Jackie Baillie

The problem in Scotland’s hospitals is not getting people admitted to them, it is that too few patients are leaving. Staff know this. Doctors from the Royal College of Emergency Medicine tell me that extra investment should not be in accident and emergency because the problem is delayed discharge.

It is advice the government ought to heed. In 2015, Shona Robison, then Health Secretary, announced that delayed discharge from hospitals, also known as bed blocking, would be eradicated by the end of that year. Like so many of the SNP government’s promises on health that claim now lies in tatters. The number of hospital beds occupied by people who are ready to be discharged has reached a record high, for the third month in a row, of 1,950 in Scotland.

Freeing up capacity in hospitals has a knock-on effect on A&E waits and ambulances queuing at the door. It seems obvious and clinicians like Dr Iain Kennedy, the British Medical Association Scotland’s current chair, are clear that the problem is the exit, not the entrance, to our hospitals.

Successive SNP ministers have failed to tackle delayed discharge despite being told repeatedly that the solution lies in a proper social care service to look after people when they leave hospitals. We really need to reset how society values the social care sector. There needs to be parity of esteem between health and social care and that begins with parity of pay.

Currently social care workers have been offered a pay raise of 40p taking them to £10.90 an hour – a 3.8 per cent increase. A band-three health worker, a post comparable to a social care worker, will see double that percentage pay rise.

If we want to stem the exodus of workers from social care to supermarkets, then we must value them for what they do and we must pay them. This is why a £15-an-hour social care wage has been front and centre of Scottish Labour’s budget proposals for the last three years.

Labour recognises it is difficult to jump straight to £15 an hour so we are asking for £12 an hour now and negotiation with trade unions to get to the full sum. Unless we deal with poor pay and arrest the haemorrhaging of staff from social care, the whole system will collapse.

Parity does not end with pay though. Supermarkets, in competition for the same workforce, know exactly what number of vacancies they have, and so does the NHS. I can tell you that there are 6,400 nursing vacancies across Scotland and a 14 per cent vacancy rate in consultant posts across the country. The figures are readily available.

What I cannot tell you is how many vacancies there are in social care because the government does not publish figures. Until there is parity of esteem, social care will continue as a Cinderella service just as we become increasingly reliant on the sector.

It is also a predominantly female workforce and for a female First Minister to simply pay lip service to this is just no longer acceptable. They have the money, it is a question of having the political will to address social care and actually begin to help the recovery of the NHS.

The message that emerged clearly from the emergency roundtables Anas Sarwar and I organised on the NHS and on social care is that everybody thinks investment needs to go to services that sustain people in their communities and keeps the front door of the hospital clear for those in the most need.

The SNP government has done exactly the opposite. They’ve stripped money, more than £65 million, out of primary care and are simply failing to fund social care. Bereft of ideas of their own, the government has grasped at the concept of a national care service. This is absolutely right in principle. After all, it was Labour’s idea and we’ve been talking about it for more than a decade.

But the SNP doesn’t have any vision about what they want the service to deliver. Instead of a discussion about how to improve social care and how you enable people to live fuller lives in their communities, what we have is a bill that’s all about structures.

The latest estimate is £1.3 billion to set this up and not a penny of that will actually go directly into improving anyone’s care package. The SNP is in danger of creating a national care service which serves the people who run it, not the people it is meant to care for. Understandably there is a lot of anger over the proposals from councils and the voluntary sector, and bewilderment from older people who wonder what this so-called service actually means.

There are things the government could do now with that money which would be more effective. Social care workers could get a pay rise. Scrapping non-residential care charges, a bill of £60 million, would make a huge cost-of-living difference to those who are having to contribute to their care packages.

The government’s whole approach is wrong-headed – instead of funding crisis, we should be funding prevention. However, the government is busy stripping away money from community projects like Men’s Sheds which help people who otherwise would need much more complex interventions and services. The amount of funding that goes to the voluntary sector is small, but they do such a huge amount with it.

Funding primary care and social care properly is the answer – paying for people who are practitioners in our communities, primary carers like GPs and occupational therapists, and social care staff – and it will ensure that more people avoid that blue light ride to hospital.

Jackie Baillie is MSP for Dumbarton and Scottish Labour spokesperson for health

News Related


The West London neighbourhoods plagued with drunks, drug addicts and graffiti

West London neighbourhoods are plagued by drunks, druggies and people spraying graffiti as the council has revealed officers were called out to more than 150 cases in just three months. ... Read more »

Ellie Williams fundraiser says he's 'done everything he can' to recover £22k raised after 'grooming gang' lie

The man behind a ‘justice’ fundraiser for Ellie Williams says he doesn’t know what to do next after trying to retrieve thousands of pounds believed to have been sent to ... Read more »

Yung Gravy sued by Rick Astley for ‘theft of voice’

Photograph: Michael Putland/Hulton Archive Is it possible for a rickroll to go too far? Twenty-six-year-old rapper Yung Gravy may be about to find out. Born Matthew Hauri, the musician – ... Read more »

Woman pregnant with twins left furious after father ghosts her messages and suddenly sends her letter saying he is married with kids

A pregnant woman who learned the father of her babies has another family has taken to the internet to seek advice on the matter. Taking to Mumsnet – a forum ... Read more »

Rod Stewart's generous offer as he calls on other celebrities to help

Kind Watch shines a light on the kindest acts from celebrities each week. At HELLO! we are passionate about the power of kindness and the impact it can have on ... Read more »

Controlling Bodmin thug Rhys Philpin battered partner and dragged her through glass

Rhys Philpin was described as a ‘monster’ by his former partner A violent thug attacked his girlfriend before proceeding to wreck her life over a long period of time. Rhys ... Read more »

Labour to launch major review into private home rents

Labour Party Conference 2022 A major review of the private rental market is set to be announced by Labour. Lisa Nandy will lay out Labour’s housing reforms plan at the ... Read more »

New Arsenal signing was booed by team-mates in training - "Really stressful"

Sol Campbell caused controversy when he moved from Arsenal to Tottenham There are just a few more days before the January transfer window slams shut. Already, a host of high-profile ... Read more »

Parents of girl killed after inhaling deodorant want greater danger warnings

Paul Green with his daughter, Giorgia, who died aged 14 after inhaling deodorant in her bedroom (Family Handout/PA) The father of a 14-year-old girl who died after inhaling deodorant has ... Read more »

Video: BREAKING NEWS: Sean Dyche IS the new Everton manager, with deal done for ex-Burnley boss to fight to save Toffees from relegation after Marcelo Bielsa said no... and with an announcement prepared today 

Read more »

Harrison Ford, 80, is 'hoping' to act alongside wife Calista Flockhart, 58, in a movie but admits they 'haven't found one yet'

Harrison Ford wants to work on a film with his wife Calista Flockhart, but they are holding out for the right project. The 80-year-old actor said at the premiere of his new Apple ... Read more »

Nicolo Zaniolo 'REJECTS a move to Bournemouth' after telling his agent he's 'not interested in continuing negotiations'... leaving his future at Roma in limbo after asking to be sold

Bournemouth made an approach for wantaway Roma star Nicolo ZanioloThey are believed to have met Roma's asking price for the 23-year-oldHis agent met with Cherries representatives but talks won't go further   Read more »

Christophe Galtier reveals PSG have FOUR vice-captains amid leadership row at the club... but Lionel Messi is NOT one of them - with Mbappe, Ramos, Kimpembe and Verratti part of group supporting Marquinhos

Christophe Galtier has clarified the leadership structure within his PSG squadControversy arose when the PSG boss named Kylian Mbappe as deputy skipperBut Galtier since clarified that Mbappe is just one of club's four vice-captainsSergio Ramos, Presnel Kimpembe, and Marco Verratti are the other deputies  Read more »

Poilievre challenges Trudeau to fix 'broken' Canada or 'get out of the way'

Conservative Party leader Pierre Poilievre speaks at a caucus meeting on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, January 27, 2023. REUTERS/Patrick Doyle OTTAWA – Step up or step down. That ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Ally McCoist leaves social media to his eldest sons as he's praised for his co-comms, but he enoys listening to the opinions of 'excellent' colleagues Graeme Souness and Roy Keane

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Ally McCoist is a fan favourite for game co-commentaryHowever, he avoids the world of social media, leaving it to his eldest two sonsHe enjoys listening to the opinions of 'excellent' Graeme Souness and Roy Keane Read more »

Labour politician uses one of Trump's favourite phrases to criticise Nadhim Zahawi

A Labour politician used a phrase popularised by Donald Trump to criticise Nadhim Zahawi amid his ongoing tax row. Speaking on the BBC’s Question Time, Mayor of West Yorkshire Tracy ... Read more »

England edge thriller to reach Women’s U19 T20 World Cup final

Grace Scrivens helped England through to the first Under-19 T20 World Cup final (ECB) Grace Scrivens claimed the final wicket as England edged past Australia in a low-scoring thriller to ... Read more »

Patients' safety 'compromised' by 'inadequate staffing' at Berkshire mental health unit

More than 50 former patients have previously told Sky News they were failed by the care they received at units run by The Huntercombe Group, now part of Active Care Group. The government this week ordered a rapid review into in-patient mental health services in England. Read more »

The Last of Us RENEWED for season 2: HBO's video game adaptation will return after becoming second most-watched series debut in a decade with 22 million viewers

HBO’s latest hit series The Last of Us has been renewed for a second season, it has been confirmed. The announcement comes after show achieved a record-breaking debut on the ... Read more »

British woman is found dead along with Swedish man in a tourist apartment in Portugal, sparking police investigation 

A British woman has been found dead along with a Swedish man in a tourist apartment in Portugal. This is a breaking news story. More to follow   Read more »

Jeff Zients: Joe Biden announces his next White House chief of staff

US President Joe Biden has announced Jeff Zients as his next White House chief of staff, choosing an experienced technocrat who headed his administration’s response to the Covid-19 pandemic. Jeff ... Read more »

Exclusive: Sean Dyche hoping to bring Coventry City player to Everton in big-money transfer swoop

Championship – Coventry City v Blackburn Rovers Everton are interested in signing Coventry City’s Viktor Gyokeres before the transfer deadline, Football League World can reveal. The Premier League strugglers are ... Read more »

Get the look: The Best Fashion and Beauty Moments in Taylor Swift's Lavender Haze Music Video

Just when we thought Miley Cyrus and Flowers had given us the ‘independent woman’ encouragement we all need from time-to-time, Taylor Swift comes along and releases the video to her ... Read more »

Firefighter dies after blaze at historic Jenners building in Edinburgh

A firefighter who helped tackle a huge blaze at the historic Jenners building in Edinburgh has died. Barry Martin, 38, joined emergency services as they raced to the former department ... Read more »

Climate protesters spared jail after smashing Barclays windows

Climate protesters Rosemary Webster, Carol Wood, Lucy Porter, Zoe Cohen and Sophie Cowen outside Southwark Crown Court, London (Kirsty O’Connor/PA) (PA Wire) A group of climate protesters who caused £100,000 ... Read more »

Nurse struggling to afford heating after EDF switched her smart meter to prepayment

UK power prices are at record levels as freezing temperatures cause a surge in demand (Photo: Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg via Getty Images) A nurse is struggling to be able to turn ... Read more »

London fish and chip shops snubbed in list of UK's best - here's 3 amazing chippies and restaurants that should've made it

Everyone knows the quiet but profound joy of the humble chippie. Soused in vinegar, splattered with mayonnaise or mushy peas, fish and chips’ straightforwardness is a comforting delight to many. ... Read more »

Moises Caicedo ready to make transfer U-turn after Arsenal bid rejected

Moises Caicedo is prepared to hand in a transfer request – just days after the midfielder claimed he was “focused” on Brighton. The Ecuador international, 21, is one of the ... Read more »

Woman vividly describes what she saw after spending '5 years in heaven'

A woman who was clinically dead for 15 minutes has vividly recounted what she saw while she was in ‘heaven’ which she says felt like five years in total. In ... Read more »

Fishing ban enforced and fish removed from lake where hundreds of fish died last summer

Fishing has been banned at a “polluted” lake to allow for the ecosystem to fully recover from last summer’s extreme heatwave conditions, which led to the deaths of hundreds of ... Read more »

Ancient statue of Hercules emerges from Rome sewerage repairs

An ancient Roman statue of Hercules has been discovered during repairs to the sewerage system underneath a park in Rome. The statue, which apparently dates back to the Roman imperial ... Read more »

Leicester City receive 'concrete offer' for James Maddison transfer

James Maddison of Leicester City warms up prior to the Premier League game against Brighton & Hove Albion Leicester City have reportedly received a ‘concrete bid’ from an unnamed club ... Read more »

Fiona Bruce clashes with BBC Question Time guest in defence of Nadhim Zahawi

jwplayer-thumbnail-2966264.jpg Things got rather heated on BBC Question Time when Fiona Bruce got into a debate with a guest about Nadhim Zahawi’s taxes. Political commentator Konstantin Kisin and the presenter ... Read more »

BBC EastEnders star James Bye reunites with former co-star Davood Ghadami for mysterious new project

EastEnders star James Bye has shared that he has reunited with his former co-star and close pal Davood Ghadami. The Martin Fowler actor, 38, said that he was back at ... Read more »

Video: Alex Murdaugh told cops a farmhand 'who is undercover FBI' was responsible for killing his wife and son - and that his son has been 'attacked a lot and received threats' ever since killing a girl in 2019 boat crash

Read more »

Video: Pennsylvania woman, 26, shoots and kills her parents then herself in yard of their home in murder-suicide they ALL consented to: Posted bizarre YouTube clips claiming to be next in line to English crown and future Antichrist

Read more »

Ramadan 2023: When is it and what does it celebrate?

The blessed month of Ramadan, a time of reflection, contemplation, and celebration for Muslims all over the world, is almost here. The annual observance of this special month is regarded ... Read more »

Will the Government raise state pension age to 68 sooner than planned - and what should those about to retire do about it? This is Money podcast

Those aged between 43 and 54 may have been concerned by rumours this week that the Government is planning to increase the state pension age to 68 much sooner than ... Read more »

Charles must 'suck it up and carry on' after Harry book as Duke running out of ammunition

The storm caused by the Duke and Duchess of Sussex’s barrage of damaging claims against the Royal Family will blow over, a royal historian has predicted, as the King has ... Read more »

Video: Pensioner, 96, pleads guilty to death by dangerous driving after 84-year-old man killed while out walking

Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự