Schoolgirl's suicide was not directly linked to acne drug Roaccutane, coroner rules

Asia's Tech News Daily

Annabel Wright, 15, was found in her bedroom by family members in May 2019 Her parents argued that acne drug Roaccutane was to blame for her deathHowever, a coroner rejected the claims and recorded a conclusion of suicide 

A coroner has ruled out a direct link between a 15-year-old girl’s suicide and the teenager being prescribed a drug to treat her acne.

Jonathan Leach said the evidence from experts on a potential link between Isotretinoin and self-harm was that there was ‘no settled and agreed view’.

Annabel Wright was found in her bedroom by family members at her home near Ripon, North Yorkshire in May 2019 after being prescribed the drug six months previously.

Mr Leach recorded a conclusion of suicide after hearing that the teenager had sent messages to friends on Snapchat saying she was in a low mood and ‘life is not worth living’.

Her parents Simon and Helen Wright accused authorities of ‘willful ignorance’ over the effects of the drug Roaccutane, and warned other families would experience the heartbreak of the ‘toxic drug’.

The family had been hoping for a verdict that Annabel took her own life while the balance of her mind was disturbed by the medication. 

Annabel Wright, 15, was found in her bedroom by family members at her home near Ripon, North Yorkshire in May 2019 after being prescribed the drug six months previously

Annabel Wright, 15, was found in her bedroom by family members at her home near Ripon, North Yorkshire in May 2019 after being prescribed the drug six months previously

Her parents Simon and Helen Wright accused authorities of 'willful ignorance' over the effects of the drug Roaccutane, and warned other families would experience the heartbreak of the 'toxic drug'

Her parents Simon and Helen Wright accused authorities of ‘willful ignorance’ over the effects of the drug Roaccutane, and warned other families would experience the heartbreak of the ‘toxic drug’

After her death, police also found a picture Annabel had drawn of Kermit the Frog hanging from a noose.

She had also ‘scratched’ her wrists with a razor in January 2019, shortly after she had been heard laughing on the phone to her friends in her bedroom.

The teenager’s parents believe their daughter’s death was linked to the medication, which is also known as Roaccutane.

The inquest in Northallerton had heard conflicting evidence from two expert dermatologists, Professor Anthony Chu and Dr Sarah Wakelin, on whether the Isotretinoin had contributed to Annabel’s death.

Mr Leach, the assistant coroner for North Yorkshire, said Prof Chu’s assertion that Annabel’s death was linked to taking the Isotretinoin ‘was clearly outside his level of expertise’.

‘Overall, he lacked the objectivity I look for in an expert,’ he said.

‘In contrast, I find Dr Wakelin to be measured and be prepared to qualify her view and evidence and to say when a question was outside her area of expertise.

‘For these reasons where there is a conflict, I prefer the evidence of Dr Wakelin.’

Recording his findings, Mr Leach said: ‘There is no evidence the balance of Annabel’s mind was disturbed and the fact she took her own life does not in itself mean the balance of her mind was disturbed and, if it was, there is no evidence that this was caused or contributed to by Isotretinoin.

‘The only evidence was from Annabel’s parents, who could not concede of any other reason why she would take her own life, and that of Prof Chu, and that part of his evidence was outside of his area of expertise.’

The inquest heard that Annabel saw her GP about her acne at the age of 12 and was later referred to Harrogate District Hospital when she was 14.

Her mother, Helen Wright, told the inquest her daughter had shown no signs of depression and her death ‘just didn’t make any sense’.

The family had been hoping for a verdict that Annabel took her own life while the balance of her mind was disturbed by the medication
Annabel

The family had been hoping for a verdict that Annabel took her own life while the balance of her mind was disturbed by the medication

Mrs Wright added: ‘I wasn’t made aware that suicidal impulses could overcome a perfectly normal person.’

Annabel’s father, Simon Wright, told the inquest: ‘There was no precursor of depression, mood change, being morose or anything like that.

‘Annabel was Annabel and that’s why I believe it was linked.’

The inquest heard that Annabel was seen by two different dermatologists, Dr Ibtessam El-Mansori and Dr Alison Layton, before she was prescribed Isotretinoin.

Dr Layton said she explained ‘all adverse effects’ of the treatment to patients and their parents, including the small risk associated with depression and suicide.

In his findings, Mr Leach said the decision to prescribe Isotretinoin was reasonable and the formal consent process was followed.

‘I am satisfied on the question of suicide and a link with Isotretinoin was raised and Dr El-Mansori advised that no causal relationship had been established, and where a suicide occurs there would be other contributory factors.

‘I am satisfied the Dermatology Association leaflet was given and she wanted Annabel and Mrs Wright to consider her advice and in the interim period prescribed a different antibiotic.

‘I do not accept that Annabel and Mrs Wright were not properly advised about the risks of taking Isotretinoin at all and I find the treatment options discussed and recommended were correct and proportionate.’

Outside court in Northallerton, North Yorkshire, the couple stood together as Mrs Wright read a prepared statement, blasting the coroner and NHS bosses.

She said: ‘The evidence provided during this inquest has shown that our normal, happy well adjusted child took her own life, suddenly, without warning and without any mitigating circumstances other than she was taking a drug which can cause suicide.

‘Despite this, the coroner has not seen fit to implicate this drug in her death. We are disappointed but not surprised by the verdict delivered here today.

‘Annabel was let down by Harrogate Hospital when they prescribed her a drug she did not need even though it could cause suicide.

‘She was let down in life and has been let down in death by the authorities’ steadfast refusal to recognise the role isotretinoin played in her death.

‘But we – our family, friends, and people who knew her – know the real truth, and this will not be changed by the opinions of those, who never met her, yet had the power to stand in judgment over her.

‘We are where we are today because the authorities have not listened to parents who have lost their children to this drug in previous cases.

‘Whatever the conclusion of this inquest was, it was never going to change anything for us. 

‘Annabel, our lovely daughter, is dead. But in failing to make a PFD (prevention of future deaths) report implicating the role isotretinoin had in her death, the coroner has missed a valuable opportunity to try to prevent what happened to Annabel happening to another child, another family.

‘We know we will never get justice for our child but we tried our best to get recognition for the role isotretinoin played in Annabel’s death.

‘In the face of wilful ignorance by those who refuse to listen, we could do no more.

‘In view of this, we – as bereaved parents – would like to take the opportunity to warn others of the dangers of isotretinoin, because they will not hear about the true side side-effects, including sudden suicidal impulses, from those who glibly prescribe it.

‘We hope others will take heed from this tragedy and refuse to allow their children to take this toxic drug.’

Mr Wright had nothing to add to the statement, other than to say that he felt the whole way the case had been handled, including the inquest, had been ‘bizarre’.

If you have been affected by this story, you can call the Samaritans on 116 123 or visit www.samaritans.org. 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

UK Covid: The one unusual effect that can impact you for months

An unusual Covid effect can impact your memory, according to new research. Even a mild Covid infection can cause attention and memory problems for months after recovery, scientists found. Reported ... Read more »

‘Tactically inept', ‘Time to go' – These Birmingham City fans discuss key figure after heavy Fulham defeat

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Huddersfield Town v Birmingham City Birmingham City’s poor form continued as they were hammered 6-2 by Fulham last night. Lee Bowyer’s side ... Read more »

Leicester vs Tottenham prediction: How will Premier League fixture play out tonight?

© Getty Images GettyImages-1363466778.jpg Leicester City face Tottenham Hotspur tonight in the Premier League as both sides look to get back on track following a number of fixture postponements. Tonight’s ... Read more »

Liverpool fans overjoyed as 'starboy' Harvey Elliott returns to training

© Catherine Ivill/Getty Images Sport Liverpool v Burnley – Premier League Liverpool fans were treated to a glimpse of the potential in Harvey Elliott at the start of the season ... Read more »

Pundit urges West Ham to spend 'good money' on Patrik Schick

Former Sheffield Wednesday ace Carlton Palmer has urged West Ham to spend ‘good money’ on Bayer Leverkusen striker Patrik Schick.  © Christian Kaspar-Bartke/Getty Images Sport Sport-Club Freiburg v Bayer 04 ... Read more »

Boris Johnson party news live: to face MPs amid growing pressure – as 'up to 20 plan to submit letters of no confidence'

Partygate latest as Boris Johnson to face MPs in Prime Minister's Questions from 12pm; Reports say at least 20 Tory MPs plan to submit letters of no confidence on Wednesday; PM to update on Plan B. Read more »

Manchester United have missed opportunity to control Paul Pogba contract situation

The Manchester United fans who draped a banner over the top tier of the Villa Park away end on Saturday castigating every aspect of their football club might be looking ... Read more »

Brentford vs Manchester United predicted line-ups: Team news ahead of Premier League fixture

© PA Archive Marcus Rashford (right) and Mason Greenwood could start against Brentford – PA Archive Manchester United could be boosted by the availability of a host of key players ... Read more »

Liverpool set to recall Williams from Swansea loan with Phillips expected to leave in January

Liverpool are set to recall Rhys Williams from his loan spell at Swansea, with the Reds expecting Nat Phillips to leave the club before the end of the transfer window. ... Read more »

Inflation soars to its highest rate in THREE DECADES: Headline CPI hits 5.4 PER CENT as cost of living squeeze continues amid warnings worse is yet to come and interest rate rise will be 'inevitable'

Consumer Price Index inflation up by more than expected to 5.4% in December ONS says inflation rate is now at its highest since March 1992 when it was 7.1% Rise was above economists' forecast of 5.2% and up from the 5.1% in NovemberIt adds pressure on the Bank of England to raise interest rates again next month  Read more »

Sheffield United targeting immediate transfer

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Nottingham Forest v Sheffield United Sheffield United boss Paul Heckingbottom has admitted to Yorkshire Live that the club needs to sign a ... Read more »

Review launched into the treatment of LGBT veterans who were forced to live double lives or stripped of military jobs and medals because of their sexuality under ban lifted in 2000

Review launched into treatment of LGBT veterans expunged from Armed ForcesOfficial review will hear stories of personnel stripped of jobs and medalsLGBT veterans were forced to lead double lives under ban lifted in 2000 Campaigners called the 22-year delay to begin the review a ‘national disgrace’ Read more »

New York AG Letitia James seeks court order for a subpoena to force Trump, Don Jr and Ivanka to answer questions under oath: Claims they gave 'fraudulent' valuations of their assets to get loans

Letitia James, the New York attorney general, on Tuesday evening announced that she was seeking a court order to force the Trumps to testifyJames has, since March 2019, been investigating the Trump Organization for tax fraud and financial irregularities - an investigation Trump calls a witch hunt James said on Tuesday that her team had made significant progress, and needed to talk to the former president, Don Jr and Ivanka - having already spoken to Eric'We have uncovered significant evidence' that the firm 'used fraudulent and misleading asset valuations on multiple properties to obtain economic benefits'She gave a detailed account of their findings so far, stating that Trump claimed his Manhattan penthouse was 30,000 sq ft when it was only 11,000He claimed his Westchester property was worth $291 million, yet a valuer in 2016 said it was only worth $56 millionTrump is also accused of inflating the financial records of his golf clubs, such as claiming that members were paying $150,000  Read more »

Browns lineman Malik Brown, 25, is released on $27,000 bail after being arrested for naked attack on Florida cop near child daycare center while out on probation for 2019 DUI

Cleveland Browns defensive tackle Malik McDowell was released from Broward County Jail after setting his $27,000 bail on Tuesday nightHe was arrested and charged with aggravated battery on a law enforcement officer, resisting an officer with violence and exposing his sex organs in publicPolice were responding to a report that a naked man was walking near a preschool in Deerfield Beach, Florida on Monday    Video from the arrest shows the naked 6-foot-6, 295-pound McDowell surrounded by officers and carried away in a stretcher while smilingAn officer reported being punched and left with possible permanent injuriesThe NFL player appeared in front of a judge on Tuesday who upheld the charges McDowell's attorney claims someone may have drugged his client In 2017, he was arrested for DUI and disorderly conduct and in 2019, he had a drunken brawl with Michigan police and later received a two-game suspension McDowell pled guilty to assault, resisting arrest, and operating a vehicle while intoxicated for the 2019 incident; He reportedly is still on probation He was a highly-touted second-round pick in 2017, but after signing a four-year, $6.95 million contract with Seattle, McDowell got into an ATV accident in 2017   Read more »

Dubai is the No1 destination in the 2022 Tripadvisor Travellers' Choice Awards, with London top in Europe and second overall and Las Vegas the highest-ranked U.S spot

Cancun comes third in the Tripadvisor ranking, followed by Bali (fourth), and the Greek island of Crete (fifth)  The winners were selected based on travellers' reviews and ratings from November 2020 to October 2021 Other categories that feature in the awards include 'Sun Seekers', 'Trending Destinations' and 'Food Lovers' Read more »

Stepdad of schoolgirl Charlise Mutten, nine, drove around for FIVE HOURS with her body stuffed in the back of a boat he was towing before dumping corpse near a river, police allege

Missing schoolgirl Charlise Mutten's body was reportedly found inside a barrel A man has been charged after police noticed inconsistencies in his story Shocking new detail comes as man prepares to face court charged with murder Allegedly tried to get barrel to river, but couldn't drag it through dense bushlandDo you know more? Email Tita.smith@mailonline.com  Read more »

Tottenham predicted team vs Leicester City: Returning players come into Conte's line-up

Injuries will force Antonio Conte into making certain decisions with his Tottenham Hotspur side to face Leicester City on Wednesday in the Premier League. Spurs’ north London derby against Arsenal ... Read more »

Journalist says £58.4m Serie A ace could become "world-beater" at Spurs under "perfect" Conte

Lazio star Sergej Milinkovic-Savic could become a “world-beater” at Tottenham under Antonio Conte, says journalist Conor Clancy. The 26-year-old has been linked with the north London club in the past and ... Read more »

Man City have accepted Liverpool FC reality in Premier League title race

After coasting to the title last year under the exceptional circumstances caused by the pandemic, Manchester City knew they had to get better. Pep Guardiola and his staff worked on ... Read more »

Grant Gilchrist explains why this Edinburgh Rugby version could be best yet

When Grant Gilchrist made his Edinburgh debut 11 years ago the club were riding high in Europe but struggling domestically. © Grant Gilchrist, right, celebrates with Matt Scott after a ... Read more »

Graffiti, broken furniture dumped in hallways and fire-scorched doors: Inside the grimy housing commission block where Charlise Mutten's stepdad was arrested over her alleged murder

Man accused of murdering stepdaughter arrested in grimy public housing blockBuilding has a bad reputation and photos from inside show it rundown and dirty N ine-year-old Charlise Mutten's body was found inside a barrel 100km away Stepdad Justin Stein, 31, allegedly bought sandbags and tried to dump the body  Stein allegedly tried to get barrel to river, but couldn't drag it through bushland  Read more »

Report: Bills' Joe Schoen had second interview with Giants

© Provided by Bills Wire © Provided by Bills Wire Getty Images Buffalo Bills assistant general manager Joe Schoen had a second interview with the New York Giants regarding their ... Read more »

Stan Kroenke finally justified over £550m offer to Alisher Usmanov as Arsenal avoid Everton mess

Arsenal could have gone down the same path as Everton had it not been for Stan Kroenke. Following a 2-1 defeat against Norwich City at the weekend, it was announced ... Read more »

Boris Johnson could face no-confidence vote in days as Tory mood ‘turns dramatically'

Boris Johnson is set to face an increasingly angry chorus of his own MPs amid reports the 54 letters which would launch a no confidence vote in the PM could ... Read more »

Arsenal set to announce defender deal as Mikel Arteta makes first January signing

Arsenal are expected to announce the signing of Lino Da Cruz Sousa, football.london understands. The left back, who is of Brazilian heritage, played two years above his age group for ... Read more »

Woman seriously injured after collision with e-Scooter in Dalston

A pedestrian was left with possible life-changing injuries after being struck by an e-Scooter on a busy high street in east London. The woman was hit in Kingsland Road at ... Read more »

Scottish Football Transfer News: Celtic in transfer boost for international winger, Ex-Rangers boss has say on Parkhead interest, Aberdeen rubbish Lewis Ferguson rumour, Jamie McGrath absence explained

It was a brilliant night in the cinch Premiership on Tuesday with thirteen goals across five games and fans back in grounds. © All the latest transfer news from around ... Read more »

‘Special', ‘Astonishing' – Many Fulham fans react to events involving Birmingham City

Many Fulham fans have taken to Twitter to react to their side’s astonishing performance as they emerged as 6-2 winners over Birmingham City last night.  Marco Silva’s side were once ... Read more »

Ash Barty crushes qualifier Lucia Bronzetti without facing a break point after winning a dominant first set in just 25 MINUTES at the Australian Open as the home favourite sets up third-round clash with Camila Giorgi

Australian favourite Ash Barty cruised into third round against Lucia Bronzetti Barty won 6-1, 6-1 and did not face a break point as she dictated the playShe next faces Camila Giorgi as she looks to win Australian Open on home soil  Read more »

Tennis Australia issue statement after Novak Djokovic controversy and make feelings clear

Tennis Australia have opened up on the decision not to allow Novak Djokovic to play in this year’s Australian Open. The world No 1 had been hoping to win a ... Read more »

Arsenal receive AFCON boost but Liverpool not so lucky thanks to Ghana and Senegal results

Thomas Partey is set to return to Arsenal in double quick time after Ghana were knocked out of AFCON in the group stages. The Gunners’ midfielder, who has become an ... Read more »

Rangers 1-1 Aberdeen extras: Ryan Kent and Lewis Ferguson centre of attention but eyes drawn to player with the 'Gazza' makeover

The key points as Rangers’ lead over Celtic in the title race is restricted to four points. © Rangers winger Ryan Kent is sent off by referee Kevin Clancy in ... Read more »

Incredible moment enormous super-yacht scrapes under bridge with inches to spare

A super-yacht has been pictured scraping under a low bridge with just 12cm to spare as it made its way to the sea. Dutch shipbuilders Heesen had to transport the ... Read more »

Livingston 2 Dundee 0 extras: James McPake “senior players” blast; Leigh Griffiths Scottish Cup dilemma; Livi striker mystery absence explained

Key issues and observations from Livingston’s crucial 2-0 win over Dundee at the Tony Macaroni Arena © Skipper Charlie Adam looks unhappy as he is substituted before the hour mark ... Read more »

NZ cancels Australia cricket tour over Ardern's extreme border closure

New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern‘s desperate attempt to keep the country Covid-free has scuppered the Black Caps one day international tour of Australia. The postponement means Australia will have ... Read more »

Emma Raducanu and Andy Murray defy age and expectation at Australian Open

Just a few minutes before midnight in Australia, Emma Raducanu cast her racquet aside and let out a cathartic roar. The magnitude of this battling 6-0 2-6 6-1 victory over ... Read more »

Thomas Tuchel shuts down Romelu Lukaku question after Chelsea's draw with Brighton

© Provided by Metro Romelu Lukaku had a frustrating night at Brighton on Tuesday (Picture: Getty Images) Thomas Tuchel says Romelu Lukaku is ‘by far not the problem’ at Chelsea, ... Read more »

Video: Korean high school zombie drama All Of Us Are Dead starring Squid Games actress Lee Yoo-mi is tipped to be Netflix's next blockbuster hit

Read more »

Manchester United should hijack Jurgen Klopp's transfer plan to sign elite midfielder

Premier League big-hitters Liverpool and Chelsea have both been recently been linked with Monaco midfielder Aurelien Tchouameni. The is poignant because Manchester United are also reportedly keen on the 21-year-old, ... Read more »

Why Jorginho made Thomas Tuchel livid as tepid Chelsea stumble with questions needing answers

Turgid first 26 minutes, an equaliser, then another turgid 64 minutes Make no bones about it, Chelsea barely deserved their lead given to them by Hakim Ziyech in the 28th ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic