School choice advocates promised students a better education. They haven't delivered.

It’s an old idea: Give families a choice in where their children attend school and students will receive a better education. Not all schools are a good fit for all kids and some schools aren’t good for anyone. Free market logic says competition and choice will fix things.

In practice, however, school choice hasn’t been the fix that proponents promised, although its application is varied.

Many school districts offer magnet schools and other alternatives to neighborhood schools that link enrollment to students’ home addresses. Open enrollment policies allow students to attend any school in their home district, and interdistrict permits allow students from outside the district to enroll in the school of their choice. These policies help reduce, although don’t eliminate, the economic segregation that plagues many cities.

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

Charter schools have mixed success

Charter schools, another form of educational choice, use tax dollars to create even more alternatives. The concept originated as a way for experienced teachers to extricate from the often ill-conceived and capricious mandates of school boards and superintendents, but the majority of charter schools are run by organizations with the same kinds of hierarchical leadership as traditional public schools. Some have succeeded at providing high-quality alternatives, but many have not.

Opinions in your inbox: Get exclusive access to our columnists and the best of our columns every day

In perhaps its most extreme form, school choice means allowing families to use their tax dollars to pay tuition for a private school. Voucher programs are available, to varying degrees, in most states.

Although there is much political enthusiasm for them, less than 1% of America’s 50 million K-12 students use vouchers, and there is little more than anecdotal evidence supporting their effectiveness in improving student achievement.

Underlying the school choice debate are two conflicting ideals: Equal opportunity for all children to a good-quality education versus the desire of some people for their children to not attend school with certain other children.

The ideas of school choice are rooted in the long and still lingering history of educational segregation, and that ought to keep us suspicious of choice-centered policies. Even so, parents who seek out better educational opportunities for their children are not necessarily trying to keep their kids away from students of color. In fact, charter schools serve a higher percentage of children of color than traditional public schools do.

US Education secretary: COVID-19 hurt student academic achievements, but we can recover

The high school at which I teach has become a school of choice, an alternative to inferior and sometimes perilous inner-city neighborhood high schools. And as with most such schools – alternative schools, magnet schools and many charters – there are not nearly enough seats to meet the demand.

In the community where I teach, neighborhood schools are shrinking – some with enrollments barely 20% of what they once were. In capitalist language, the marketplace has spoken, but what remains on those campuses are a lot of kids without parents or without parents who have the wherewithal to find their children an alternative, or they lack the means to transport them to a school more than a few blocks away.

Disadvantaged students are left behind

Also left behind are students whom the desired schools don’t much want on their campuses (because schools are generally not interested in reluctant learners or kids with serious challenges). Teaching positions at those shrinking neighborhood schools go unfilled longer than elsewhere, and a high turnover of administrators and an often-corrosive environment prevent the strongest teachers from wanting to work at them.

Thus, the quality of education almost inevitably erodes for students who ought to have access to the best teachers and support systems.

Chrissy Teigen’s Q&A with Feeding America: How can we help children who are going hungry?

An education system that doesn’t prioritize its most disadvantaged and challenged students cannot meaningfully claim success. Allowing middle-class and even wealthy families to use tax dollars to pay private school tuition exacerbates that failure.

What if school choice meant that the most disadvantaged children could attend school anywhere, even outside the city or district limits? Imagine if instead of arresting an impoverished mother for fudging her address to give her kid a chance, she could legally access the best public schools regardless of her residence?

Some states allow such transfers, but many school districts have been slow to allow students who live outside their boundaries to enroll.

Give students themselves more choice

I am glad for the choices that students and their parents have, and I am for more choice, but let’s start with choices inside each school. I mean giving students more agency over their own education.

The K-12 system seems – with not nearly enough exceptions – to do everything in its power to crush the natural curiosity of children along with their urgent impulse to learn.

Opinion alerts: Get columns from your favorite columnists + expert analysis on top issues, delivered straight to your device through the USA TODAY app. Don’t have the app? Download it for free from your app store.

Journalist and author Ta-Nehisi Coates expressed this perfectly in the opening of “Between the World & Me”: “I was made for the library, not the classroom. The classroom was a jail of other people’s interests; the library was open, unending, free.”

It was tragic for him and for those who can relate, considering we all are or have been consigned to 13 years of narrowly defined and all-too-often uninspired education.

As a teacher I have tried to make it different for my students – to let their interests, attitudes and sensibilities steer the class and to find their own way to enlightenment and their own voice in writing. I’ve encouraged them to disagree with me and push back against the tyranny of my curriculum. Let them constructively take over the class or, if necessary, make them take it over.

school choice advocates promised students a better education. they haven't delivered.

Los Angeles teacher Larry Strauss takes students to a play in the spring of 2020 before the COVID-19 pandemic.

Mostly the students I teach are more resistant to my offer of intellectual freedom than anything else. They’ve been conditioned to be compliant or to not care at all, determined to learn what will please me and get a good grade or what will sabotage what has alienated them. Few kids value their education beyond the grades that will get them into a good college – if they value it at all – but they can learn. They do. It’s a matter of trust. I in them; them in me; all of us in ourselves. Trust and patience and faith in that curiosity and hunger to learn with which all of us start out.

If we all did a better job of that – if we committed ourselves to mining for the gold of student curiosity and intellectual hunger – then there might, ultimately, no longer be any schools that parents and students would wish to avoid.

If we could get students to value learning and indulge their natural curiosities, then we might also discover that children want to attend school with other children who are not like them, learn about other people and discover how much of our humanity we share.

Larry Strauss has been a high school English teacher in South Los Angeles since 1992. He is a member of USA TODAY’s Board of Contributors and the author of more than a dozen books, including “Students First and Other Lies: Straight Talk From a Veteran Teacher” and his new novel, “Light Man.” Follow him on Twitter: @LarryStrauss

More from Larry Strauss: 

I’ve taught in South Los Angeles for 30 years. The forces that drive violence are complex.

Florida’s ‘don’t say gay’ law and other restrictions hurt kids and drive away teachers.

I’m not paid for all the time I spend teaching. It’s pathetic my generation is OK with this scam.

You can read diverse opinions from our Board of Contributors and other writers on the Opinion front page, on Twitter @usatodayopinion and in our daily Opinion newsletter. To respond to a column, submit a comment to

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: School choice advocates promised students a better education. They haven’t delivered.

News Related


Why Aren’t More People Talking About The Death Of Joyce Bryant?

The necklines of her gowns hung riskily low. Like, prudish audible gasp low. Too quick of an arm flourish would’ve placed Joyce Bryant at the center of a scandal. Maybe ... Read more »

Garland praises Oath Keepers verdict, won’t say where Jan. 6 probe goes

Garland praises Oath Keepers verdict, won’t say where Jan. 6 probe goes A day after a federal jury convicted two far-right extremists of leading a plot to unleash political violence ... Read more »

Cramer's Lightning Round: Crestwood Equity Is a Dynamite Stock

It’s that time again! “Mad Money” host Jim Cramer rings the lightning round bell, which means he’s giving his answers to callers’ stock questions at rapid speed. The Williams Companies ... Read more »

U.S. Virgin Islands reaches $105-million settlement with Jeffrey Epstein estate

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico —  The U.S. Virgin Islands announced Wednesday that it reached a settlement of more than $105 million in a sex trafficking case against the estate of financier ... Read more »

Lionel Messi destaca el accionar de los jóvenes ante Polonia; Argentina va contra Australia en Octavos

Ras Abu Abboud, Qatar —  Argentina corrigió el camino y se clasificó para los Octavos de Final de Qatar 2022 tras vencer el martes a Polonia por 2-0 en el Stadium ... Read more »

Why Rams removed Odell Beckham Jr. nameplate from locker room

The Rams presumably fell out of the running to re-sign free-agent wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr. by failing to contend for the playoffs. As perhaps an admission that that their ... Read more »

World Cup: U.S. men’s and women’s teams to split prize money

DOHA, Qatar —  U.S. Soccer’s recently ratified an equal-pay agreement, which requires the men’s and women’s national teams to split World Cup prize money evenly, and that means each team will ... Read more »

Elon Musk meets Apple CEO Tim Cook, says Twitter not at risk of getting pulled from App Store

Twitter CEO Elon Musk met with Apple's CEO Tim Cook on Wednesday at Apple's headquarters Read more »

Former Royal Chef Reveals Only 1 Royal Family Member ‘Actually Talked’ to Them

A former royal pastry chef revealed that Prince Philip was the only member of the royal family who “actually talked” to the kitchen staff. Here’s what the chef said and ... Read more »

Lazard Says Rodgers Needs to ‘Renew His Ownership' of the Bears

Lazard says Rodgers needs to ‘renew his ownership’ of the Bears originally appeared on NBC Sports Chicago Aaron Rodgers self-proclaimed himself healthy enough to play this week on Tuesday during ... Read more »

20,000 People Still Need Gifts From Salvation Army's Angel Tree Program

The deadline is quickly approaching for The Salvation Army’s Angel Tree program and thousands are still in need of a gift. The deadline to adopt an angel is Dec. 3, ... Read more »

Coach Leaves Team Immediately Following World Cup Elimination

LUSAIL CITY, QATAR – NOVEMBER 24: General view inside the stadium prior to the FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022 Group G match between Brazil and Serbia at Lusail Stadium on ... Read more »

Chicago Restaurant Victimized by Imposter Account on Delivery App

Link video: Business is back to normal at Smoque BBQ on Pulaski and Grace in the Old Irving Park neighborhood, but owners are still searching for answers after an ... Read more »

Quebec Sets Plan to Bar Most Immigrants Who Don’t Speak French

(Bloomberg) — Quebec Premier Francois Legault, concerned about the decline of the French language in the Canadian province, has set a new goal for immigrants: They should all speak French. ... Read more »

Kari Lake Claims America Will Be ‘Enslaved By a Globalist System’ If More People Don’t Pretend She Won

Kari Lake is continuing to deny the midterm election results in Arizona that saw her opponent, Katie Hobbs, securing the victory. On the Tuesday edition of Steve Bannon’s War Room, ... Read more »

EV Charging Startup Volta Falls Below 50 Cents

(Bloomberg) — Shares in electric car charging company Volta Inc. closed below 50 cents for the first time since the startup went public last year, as a cash crunch and ... Read more »

Al Roker Rushed Back To Hospital By Ambulance 24 Hours After Being Released

mega Al Roker was rushed back to the hospital by ambulance the day after Thanksgiving. “Al was taken from his home in a stretcher back to the hospital on Friday, ... Read more »

Amtrak, Metrolink Commuters Brace For Impact Of Potential Rail Strike

Metrolink and Amtrak rails could see a full stop of services starting December 9. RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CA — Residents of Riverside County and the Inland Empire who ride the Metrolink ... Read more »

DNC Chairman Accuses Lindsey Graham of ‘Ethics Violation’ For ‘Soliciting Campaign Contributions’ on Fox News While in the U.S. Capitol

Lindsey Graham Chairman of the Democratic National Committee, Jaime Harrison, accused Sen. Lindsey Graham of committing an ethics violation on Wednesday by soliciting campaign contributions during a Fox News interview ... Read more »

Breaking: Nebraska Coach Mickey Joseph Arrested Wednesday

Dublin , Ireland – 27 August 2022; Nebraska Cornhuskers associate head coach – wide receivers / passing game coordinator – Mickey Joseph during the Aer Lingus College Football Classic 2022 ... Read more »

Construction On 529 French Valley Residences Begins In January

A southwest view from within the project area, looking toward Washington Street in French Valley. FRENCH VALLEY, CA — Construction on more than 500 new residences in French Valley is ... Read more »

Doja Cat Responds to 'Unbelievably Crazy' Criticism of Her Blackness

Photo: Pascal Le Segretain (Getty Images) I’ve never understood why some Black people are obsessed with policing others’ Blackness. It’s an uncomfortable part of our community. The latest star defending ... Read more »

Louisiana retired priest one of two victims burned beyond recognition, authorities say

Generic and blurry police lights from a cruiser vehicle and car headlights behind yellow crime scene do not cross caution tape at night. A retired Catholic priest has been identified ... Read more »

Mauna Loa, Kilauea volcanos erupting at same time in Hawaii

Nov. 30 (UPI) — The Big Island of Hawaii was experiencing two volcano eruptions simultaneously Wednesday for the first time since 1984. Mauna Loa and neighboring volcano Kilauea were both ... Read more »

Macron State Dinner Menu: What Biden Is Serving French President

Above, US President Joe Biden and first lady Jill Biden depart the White House on November 21, 2022 in Washington, DC. President Biden is scheduled to travel to North Carolina ... Read more »

First Lady Casey DeSantis Announces Florida Is First in Nation to Reframe and Rethink the Way Mental Health Is Taught in Schools

The State Board of Education unanimously approved the First Lady’s trailblazing resiliency education initiative Press release from the Office of Governor Ron DeSantis ORLANDO, Fla. — Yesterday, First Lady Casey DeSantis ... Read more »

Retirements Drive US Labor-Participation Shortfall, Powell Says

(Bloomberg) — Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell said the shortfall in labor force participation in the US relative to its pre-pandemic trend is mostly due to excess retirements, which can’t ... Read more »

Manhattan doctor, 5 others arraigned in prescription pill distribution scheme

NEW YORK — A Manhattan doctor and several other men stand accused of conspiring to distribute tens of thousands of opioids and other controlled substances. On Wednesday, one by one, ... Read more »

Stevie Nicks Mourns ‘Best Friend in the Whole World’ Christine McVie With Haim Lyrics

Stevie Nicks Mourns ‘Best Friend in the Whole World’ Christine McVie With Haim Lyrics Following news that Fleetwood Mac member Christine McVie died on Wednesday (Nov. 30) at age 79, her bandmate ... Read more »

3 nabbed after tying up employees while robbing Verizon store at gunpoint, cops say

Three of the four men who allegedly robbed a Verizon store in Voorhees at gunpoint and tied up employees on Monday night were arrested hours later in Philadelphia, authorities said. ... Read more »

‘GMA’ Star Amy Robach & Husband Sold Off $5.2 Million NYC Home Weeks Before Her Romance With Co-Host T.J. Holmes Was Revealed

mega Good Morning America star Amy Robach and her husband Andrew Shue sold off their New York apartment only weeks before her romance with her co-host T.J. Holmes went public, ... Read more »

Another round of lowland snow possible for Puget Sound region by Thursday morning

Western Washington got its first taste of winter Tuesday as a weather system brought wind, rain and lowland snow to the Puget Sound region. Just under an inch of snow ... Read more »

Why the Drummer on The Beach Boys’ Final No. 1 Hit Said Critics Hated the Song

TL;DR: Mike Love felt The Beach Boys’ “Kokomo” was one of the great songs from his band’s catalog. The uncredited drummer who performed on the song said it had a ... Read more »

Dog Found Abandoned and Injured on Train Tracks in Montgomery County

Dog Found Abandoned and Injured on Train Tracks in Montgomery County A dog is fighting for his life after he was found abandoned and injured on the train tracks in ... Read more »

Maddow Blog | Stefanik echoes Trump on Justice Department, special counsel

After Attorney General Merrick Garland appointed Jack Smith to oversee the criminal investigations into Donald Trump, the former president wasted little time telling his Republican allies about his expectations. As ... Read more »

Pierce County begins preparations for expected Thursday snow

Pierce County begins preparations for expected Thursday snow Pierce County residents are gearing up for temperatures to drop Wednesday night, as road conditions are expected to freeze in certain areas, ... Read more »

Search Committee unanimously recommends United States Senator Dr. Ben Sasse as sole finalist for University of Florida's 13th President

The University of Florida Presidential Search Committee has unanimously recommended United States Senator Dr. Ben Sasse as the sole finalist for President of UF Press release from the University of ... Read more »

FDOT Announces I-75 Closure between Mile Markers 179 and 191 Due to Rising River

Due to the rising water, I-75 in both directions is now closed from mile marker 179 (North Port / Toledo Blade Blvd) to mile marker 191 (Englewood / Jacaranda Blvd). ... Read more »

Philadelphia Police to Reveal Identity of ‘Boy in the Box' Next Week, Sources Say

Philadelphia Police to Reveal Identity of ‘Boy in the Box' Next Week, Sources Say What to Know On February 25, 1957, a boy between the ages of 3 and 7, ... Read more »

Wendy Williams’ Salary From Former Daytime Talk Show Revealed

It’s been over a year since fans have seen Wendy Williams on the small-screen. The former queen of hot topics is reportedly prepping a comeback after losing her long-running daytime ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network