School bans on mobile phones violate students' human rights

Asia's Tech News Daily

School bans on mobile phones violate students' human rights


By Lee Hyo-jin

A complete ban on the use of mobile phones in schools infringes on the basic rights of students including freedom of communication, the nation’s human rights watchdog said, Wednesday.

The National Human Rights Commission of Korea (NHRCK) expressed the opinion in response to a complaint filed by a student at a high school in the southeastern city of Daegu.

Under the school policy, students must have their mobile phones turned off during school hours, with no exceptions even for recess and lunch time ― a common regulation at schools here.

If a student is caught using their phone, teachers take it away for one week, and for two weeks if the student is caught a second time. The student may face other penalties such as cleaning duties.

If the student is caught a third time, their parents are notified. When caught a fourth time, the student may face additional actions based on the decision of the school’s disciplinary committee.

The school explained that the outright ban on mobile phone use aims to minimize unnecessary use of electronic gadgets at schools and create a better educational environment.

It added that students can use the school computer lab to access the internet and they are also allowed to use phone booths installed on each floor. In case of emergency, they may contact their parents through their homeroom teachers.

The NHRCK, however, said such rules violate basic human rights including freedom of communication guaranteed by the Constitution.

The commission also viewed that banning phones not only during class but also breaks is an excessive restriction.

“In modern society, a mobile phone is not only a tool for telecommunications, but also the means for social interaction and connection, as well as a source of obtaining necessary information,” it said in a statement.

“Aside from the complete ban, the school should seek different ways to create a better educational environment while minimizing the violation of students’ basic rights,” it added, recommending the school principal revise the rules.

The NHRCK also said, “The school makes students contact their parents through homeroom teachers in case of emergency instead of using their own phones, but this may result in breach of privacy in certain situations.”

While debates over the bans on phone use in schools is not new in Korea, the human rights watchdog has been recommending against excessive bans in its responses to previous similar complaints.

Earlier in October, it made a recommendation to a high school to revise its rules under which teachers collect the students’ phones in the morning and return them when classes are over.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Tighter lending rules leads to increase of corporate lending

A branch of Hana Bank in Seoul. Korea Times file By Lee Kyung-min The growth of household borrowing fell sharply in November, due to a combination of tightening lending rules ... Read more »

Home treatment feared to increase virus spread

A monitor at the disaster control center in Songpa District Office, Seoul, shows an all-time high of 7,175 new daily COVID-19 infections for Tuesday. Yonhap Experts say daily infections could ... Read more »

HanmiGlobal partners with Chartered Institute of Building for PM education content

Lee Sang-ho, left, the president of HanmiGlobal, and CIOB CEO Caroline Gumble pose after signing a partnership agreement online, Dec. 7. Courtesy of HanmiGlobal By Baek Byung-yeul HanmiGlobal has said ... Read more »

S. Korea's top diplomat to attend G-7 ministerial talks in Britain this weekend

Foreign Minister Chung Eui-yong (Yonhap)South Korean Foreign Minister Chung Eui-yong will visit Britain this weekend to attend a meeting of foreign and development ministers from the Group of Seven (G-7) ... Read more »

Top POSCO shareholder set to disapprove business overhaul plan

POSCO’s headquarters in Seoul / Courtesy of POSCO POSCO board expected to push ahead with spin-off to establish holding company structure By Kim Hyun-bin The National Pension Service (NPS) is ... Read more »

Chanel Korea employees to begin strike next week

Chanel Korea’s employees protest at the French luxury brand’s cosmetics counter at a local department store in Seoul on Oct. 10. Korea Times file By Kim Jae-heun Chanel Korea’s employees ... Read more »

Book addresses Koreans' underused 'gene' for success

Three co-authors of the newly published book “Republic of Korea: From Periphery to the Center of the World” pose in this undated photo. From leaf are Choi Soo, Lee Ki-dong ... Read more »

Ruling party mulls changing timing, scope of teenage vaccine pass

An employee posts a notice informing visitors of a new requirement for vaccine passes at a cram school in Seoul on Tuesday. (Yonhap)The ruling Democratic Party has begun looking into ... Read more »

Advisers to rival presidential candidates clash over NK policy

Former South Korean Ambassador Wi Sung-lak(left), who advises Lee Jae-myung of the ruling Democratic Party of Korea, and Kim Sung-han, a professor at the Korea University Graduate School of International ... Read more »

Lee welcomes opposition's proposal to allocate W100tr to virus-hit small businesses

Lee Jae-myung, the presidential candidate of the ruling Democratic Party, visits a convenience store used for job training of disabled people in Seoul on Wednesday. (Yonhap)Lee Jae-myung, the presidential candidate ... Read more »

[Election 2022] AI spokesman, avatars enter election campaigns

AI Yoon Suk-yeol, a digitally-created character speaks in a 1-minute video revealed at People Power Party election committee’s inauguration ceremony on Monday. The AI character said, “Hello. I am AI ... Read more »

Seoul's average apartment price jumps twofold under Moon government: civic group

This Nov. 15 file photo shows a bird’s eye view of an array of apartment compounds in Seoul. Yonhap The average price of Seoul apartments has soared more than twofold ... Read more »

Samyang joins global consortium to promote Allulose in Europe

Samyang Corp.’s production facility in Daejeon / Courtesy of Samyang Corp. By Kim Jae-heun Samyang Corporation has joined hands with global food ingredient manufacturers to target the European food market. ... Read more »

4MEN teams up with Singaporean David Yong for new single, 'My Way'

Singaporean artist-entrepreneur David Yong, second from right, poses with the members of R&B group 4MEN. Courtesy of MAJOR9 By Dong Sun-hwa R&B group 4MEN has teamed up with Singaporean artist-entrepreneur ... Read more »

Trade ministry eases rules for export firms

gettyimagesbank By Lee Kyung-min The government will simplify the administrative procedures for exporters of Korea’s key goods, as part of an expanded compliance program (CP), whereby 156 businesses abide by ... Read more »

Moody's maintains negative outlook for E-mart, SK hynix, SK Innovation

gettyimagesbank LG Energy Solution’s IPO raises positive outlook for LG Chem By Park Jae-hyuk Moody’s Investors Service maintained its negative credit outlook for E-mart, SK hynix and SK Innovation, citing ... Read more »

Politics or misguided conviction? Is Moon obsessed with ending the Korean War?

President Moon Jae-in speaks in a congratulatory video speech at the 2021 Seoul UN Peacekeeping Ministerial in Seoul on Tuesday night. (Yonhap)With the clock ticking on his term in office, ... Read more »

S.Korea develops real-time, standoff chemical warfare agent detector

South Korea has developed a Hyperspectral Imaging Stand-off Chemical Agent Detection System. (Agency for Defense Development)South Korea has developed the first domestically developed technology for early detecting chemical weapons attacks ... Read more »

S. Korea establishes new national cemetery on Jeju

This photo, taken on Wednesday, shows the Jeju National Cemetery on the southern island of Jeju. (Yonhap)South Korea on Wednesday opened a new state cemetery for fallen national heroes, including ... Read more »

Korea H2 Alliance attracts $1 billion investment for hydrogen business

Kim Min, center, the chairman of Korea H2 Alliance and Kim Si-eun, fifth from left, the CEO of Korea H2 Alliance, pose during a virtual investment agreement ceremony with officials ... Read more »

Moon vows to support creation of mutually beneficial local jobs

President Moon Jae-in (Yonhap)President Moon Jae-in pledged Wednesday to provide a variety of support for an initiative to create jobs through joint cooperative projects between local governments, businesses and residents. ... Read more »

Lee pledges to increase budget for startups to W10tr

Lee Jae-myung (2nd from R), the presidential nominee of the Democratic Party, takes a look at products made by small and medium-sized businesses at an industrial complex in southwestern Seoul ... Read more »

Military reports 31 more COVID-19 cases

South Korean soldiers (Yonhap)South Korea’s military on Wednesday reported 31 additional COVID-19 cases, including 28 breakthrough infections, raising the total caseload among its personnel to 2,583. Of the new cases, ... Read more »

S. Korea develops technology for early, real-time chemical agent detection

This conceptual image, provided by South Korea’s state-run Agency for Defense Development, depicts how the Hyperspectral Imaging Stand-off Chemical Agent Detection System works. (South Korea’s state-run Agency for Defense Development)South ... Read more »

Yoon leads Lee by 8.2 percentage points in presidential race: survey

Lee Jae-myung (L), the presidential nominee of the ruling Democratic Party, and Yoon Suk-yeol, the nominee of the main opposition People Power Party, attend the Korea National Prayer Breakfast at ... Read more »

[Contribution] Is inflation really out of control?

Another Great Inflation unlikely today By Stephen Lee Stephen Lee is the chief economist at Meritz Securities, Seoul. Courtesy of Mertiz Securities Inflation has been drifting higher recently, with October’s ... Read more »

Korea's daily COVID-19 cases surpass 7,000 for 1st time: PM

Health workers clad in protective suits conduct virus tests on students at an elementary school in the southwestern city of Gwangju, Dec. 7. Yonhap South Korea’s daily COVID-19 cases have ... Read more »

US committed to dialogue with N. Korea despite no success so far: White House czar

Flags of North Korea and the US (123rf)WASHINGTON — The United States remains committed to engaging with North Korea diplomatically despite having no success so far, White House policy coordinator ... Read more »

Renowned accordionist Shim Sung-rak dies at 85

Accordionist Shim Sung-rak / Yonhap By Park Ji-wonShim Im-sub, an accordion virtuoso better known by his stage name Shim Sung-rak, died Saturday. He was 85.According to his acquaintances, Shim underwent ... Read more »

‘Eat breakfast like a king, lunch as prince, and dinner like a pauper'

Colombian chef Alvaro Clavijo speaks to The Korea Herald at Four Seasons Hotel on Dec. 1 (Sanjay Kumar/The Korea Herald)Korean and Colombian cuisines have a lot in common, according to ... Read more »

LG Energy Solution seeks to raise up to 12.75 trillion won in IPO

LG Energy Solution plant in Ochang, North Chungcheong Province / Courtesy of LG Energy Solution Battery maker LG Energy Solution is seeking to raise as much as 12.75 trillion won ... Read more »

Schools warned about impact of commercial tutors on equality

The Dutch schools council Onderwijsraad has sounded the alarm about the increasing impact of commercial tutors in secondary school education and say that using such services is increasing inequality of ... Read more »

WINNER's Mino returns as 'Digital Gunman'

By Dong Sun-hwa Mino of K-pop boy group WINNER poses during an online press event Tuesday. Courtesy of YG Entertainment “Digital Gunman,” a key phrase describing Mino of K-pop boy ... Read more »

Financial authorities vow to enhance ESG disclosure system

Financial Services Commission (FSC) Chairman Koh Seung-beom speaks during an ESG-themed seminar hosted jointly by the FSC and the Korea Exchange (KRX) at Fairmont Ambassador Seoul, located in Seoul’s financial ... Read more »

SK faces huge hurdles to building chip plant in US

SK Group Chairman Chey Tae-won, right, speaks with U.S. Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell at the U.S. Capitol in Washington D.C., Oct. 27. Courtesy of Senator Mitch McConnell’s office Costs, ... Read more »

Fed's earlier end to tapering prompts call for Korea to increase dollar reserves

Bank of Korea Governor Lee Ju-yeol speaks during a press conference at its headquarters in Seoul, Nov. 25. Yonhap By Lee Min-hyung Korea should increase its foreign exchange reserves amid ... Read more »

Gov't CPTPP push to drag on until after presidential election

The National Assembly is in a plenary session, during which a bill on Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) passed, Dec. 4. Korea Times file Gov’t refuses to broach politically charged ... Read more »

[ANALYSIS] Samsung's combined set-making business mimics Apple

By Baek Byung-yeul Samsung Electronics implemented a large-scale reshuffle of executives Tuesday and one notable aspect was the appointment of Han Jong-hee, president of its TV business, as vice chairman ... Read more »

Australia's conditional approval of COVID-19 treatment unlikely to help Celltrion rebound

Samples of Celltrion’s COVID-19 antibody treatment Regkirona / Courtesy of Celltrion By Kim Jae-heun Australia’s Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) said Tuesday it has conditionally approved Celltrion’s COVID-19 antibody treatment Regkirona ... Read more »

Omicron variant feared to be spreading nationwide

A notice attached at a library on Hankuk University of Foreign Studies campus in Seoul, Tuesday, reads that it will operate in a limit manner after it was confirmed a ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic