SC to hear on November 16 batch of pleas challenging OBC, EWS quota in NEET

Asia's Tech News Daily

NEET, EWS quota, OBC, Supreme Court, MCC

The Supreme Court on Thursday fixed November 16 for hearing a batch of pleas challenging the Centre and Medical Counselling Committee (MCC) July 29 notice providing 27 per cent reservation for Other Backward Class (OBC) and 10 per cent for EWS category in the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) admissions for medical courses. A bench of Justices DY Chandrachud, Vikram Nath, and BV Nagarathna was told by Solicitor General Tushar Mehta that the government has detailed discussion with senior officials of the department and those who have framed the notification.

“I request the matter to be taken up on reopening of the counselling after Diwali vacation. We also give our assurance with regard to not starting the counselling until the validity of the notification is decided”, Mehta said.

The bench said, “We can take Solicitor General’s assurance on record. Let us keep the matter on November 16”.

At the outset, Mehta said that the union government has filed a counter-affidavit responding to the queries and questions formulated by the court on fixing of Rs 8 lakh limit for determining the Economically Weaker Section (EWS).

Senior advocate Arvind Dattar, appearing for NEET aspirants, said that the Centre in its affidavit has majorly relied on Major General (retd) SR Sinho report which is a little complicated and detailed report.

The apex court was hearing a batch of pleas challenging the Centre and MCC July 29 notice providing 27 per cent reservation for OBC and 10 per cent for EWS category in the NEET admissions for medical courses

In its affidavit, the Centre has justified its decision to set the limit of Rs 8 lakh annual income fixed for determining the EWS category for reservation in NEET admissions for medical courses.

The affidavit filed by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment said that the principle of fixing the amount is rational and in keeping with Articles 14, 15, and 16 of the Constitution.

It had said that the exercise conducted to determine the creamy layer for OBC reservation would be equally applicable for the determination of EWS category since the fundamental premise is that if a person/his family have a substantial economic standing, he/she may not require the benefits of reservation at the cost of others.

“It is reiterated that even the Major General Sinho Commission had suggested that, “extending the existing criteria to identify ‘creamy layer’ among OBCs could well serve as to decide the upper limit or as a criterion for identifying EBC families among General Category too,” the affidavit said.

Major Gen (retd) SR Sinho commission was constituted by the UPA government in 2010 and it recommended welfare measures for the EWS category.

The ministry further said that the criteria for the determination of the EWS category were derived after due deliberation with all the concerned stakeholders.

The Centre said that even before the Office Memorandum dated January 17, 2019, was in existence in the context of identification of Economically Backward Classes (EBC), the Government had set up the Major General Sinho Commission in the year 2005.

It said that this Commission had by its report of July 2010, arrived at various conclusions including the criteria to identify ‘creamy layer’ amongst OBC’s could well serve as a basis to decide the upper limit or as a criterion for identifying EBC families amongst the General Category as well.

“Once such an exercise had already been done, the Government of India has adopted the same financial criteria. It is reiterated that although the Sinho Commission Report is one of the aspects taken into consideration while arriving at a policy decision to provide reservation to EWS of the society, the income criteria now fixed are not on the sole basis of the Major General Sinho Commission Report,” the affidavit stated.

The ministry submitted that the determination of the EWS category in terms of the Office Memorandum dated January 17, 2019, is not overinclusive and need not be interfered with.

“The fixation of eight lakh as income criteria is on the basis of the criteria detailed in the affidavit after taking into consideration the criteria for determining the creamy layer of OBCs. Further even the Major General Sinho Commission had recognised that the very same test can also be applied for EWS. To provide further checks so as to ensure that only the needy get the benefit of Article 15(6) and Article 16(6) reservations, the office memorandum dated January 17, 2019, provides further exclusions,” the affidavit said.

The Centre on Monday assured the top court that the counselling process of NEET-PG will not commence till the top court decides the challenge to 27 per cent reservation for OBC and 10 per cent for EWS category in PG all India quota seats (MBBS/BDS and MD/MS/MDS) from the current academic session.

On October 21, the top court had asked the Centre whether it would like to revisit the limit of rupees eight lakh annual income, fixed for determining the EWS category for reservation in NEET admissions for medical courses.

The top court had clarified that it is not embarking into the policy domain but is only trying to ascertain whether constitutional principles have adhered or not.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Moderna may have Omicron booster by March

© Copyright 2021, dpa ( Alle Rechte vorbehalten 01 December 2021, Brandenburg, Schönefeld: In the supra-regional vaccination centre in Schoenefeld, which has been open again since the early hours of ... Read more »

Aries: Your well being horoscope - December 03

© Astrofame Aries Today, you might experience a strong urge to seek adventure. You might want to take a spur-of-the-moment trip to an exotic place, meet new people in exciting ... Read more »

8 highest-paid Korean CF stars, from K-pop icons BTS and Blackpink's Jennie, to Jirisan's Jun Ji-hyun and football player Son Heung-min – who made the most millions in 2021?

Chanel muse Jennie raked in a whopping US$4.1 million and signed three endorsement deals that were held by CF Queen Bae Suzy of Netflix’s Start-Up fame Park Seo-joon made US$8.2 ... Read more »

Zoey's Extraordinary Christmas Almost Brought Back [Spoiler] in Marvel-Like End Credits Scene, EP Reveals

© Roku Channel screenshot Zoey’s Extraordinary Christmas hosted all of the NBC dramedy’s series regulars, plus a few special guests, for the holidays on The Roku Channel. But one fan ... Read more »

Sembcorp acquires 35% of China-owned wind and solar assets

© Provided by Singapore Business Review Sembcorp Industries has signed an equity transfer agreement with China state-owned State Development Investment Corporate Group (SDIC)’s Shanghai SDIC Xieli Development Equity Fund Partnership ... Read more »

'Gossip Girl' showrunner Joshua Safran says that there was 'no convincing necessary' to bring back several original stars for season 1

© HBO Max From left: Emily Alyn Lind, Jordan Alexander, Savannah Lee Smith, and Zion Moreno on season one, episode 10 of “Gossip Girl.” HBO Max Warning: There are spoilers ... Read more »

‘I Was Really Impressed With Her Metaphor of Freedom as a Burden': ‘THR Presents' Q&A With ‘Unclenching the Fists' Director Kira Kovalenko and Producer Alexander Rodnyansky

THR Presents Unclenching the Fists A small movement of young filmmakers in Russia’s remote, politically fraught North Caucasus Mountains is starting to make a big noise, first at the Cannes ... Read more »

China, US tussle over Biden's 'Summit for Democracy'

© Provided by Associated Press Chinese Vice Foreign Minister Le Yucheng speaks at a forum with experts arranged for foreign journalists in Beijing, Thursday, Dec. 2, 2021. China and the ... Read more »

Gov't warns public against giving money, material support to CPP-NPA-NDF

© Manman Dejeto/AFP New People’s Army guerillas stand in formation during the turn-over ceremony of captured government soldiers to officials and peace advocates in the hinterlands of Matanao town, Davao ... Read more »

Jung Hae In And Jisoo's New 'Snowdrop' Photos Are Legit Making Our Hearts *Flutter*

© Provided by Cosmopolitan Philippines Snowdrop, Jisoo and Jung Hae In‘s much-awaited K-drama, is almost here! The series will tell the story of Su Ho (Hae In), a student from a ~prestigious ... Read more »

Here's Proof That Maja Salvador Still Looks Gorgeous without Makeup

© Provided by When we asked our December cover girl Maja Salvador to take her makeup off on camera, she sat on a chair, grabbed a wet tissue, and ... Read more »

School chief: Discipline not needed for boy before shooting

OXFORD TOWNSHIP, Mich. (AP) — The superintendent of a Michigan school district says no discipline was necessary for a teen who was summoned to the office a few hours before ... Read more »

US out of step with much of the world on abortion

© Leigh Vogel Abortion remains a fiercely divisive issue in the United States nearly 50 years after the Supreme Court guaranteed a woman’s right to an abortion While many countries ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin Makes Disturbing Statement After Denying Shooting Responsibility

Sam Aronov/Shutterstock On October 21, what was supposed to be a regular day of filming for a Western movie turned into a horrific tragedy that led to the death of ... Read more »

Annie Live!: How the NBC Production Starring Harry Connick Jr., Taraji P. Henson Was Pulled Off

© Provided by People Paul Gilmore/NBC Annie has been a beloved Broadway musical since the curtain first when up in 1977 — and the 1982 film adaptation, featuring Aileen Quinn ... Read more »

Fauci calls out Fox for its silence after host compares him to Nazi doctor

Dr. Anthony Fauci on Thursday night called out Fox News for staying silent after one of its personalities and streaming hosts, Lara Logan, compared him to an infamous Nazi doctor. ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin insists he's not to blame for fatal shooting of Halyna Hutchins on ‘Rust' set

Actor Alec Baldwin breaks down in an emotional interview with ABC News‘ George Stephanopoulos which aired on Dec. 2, 2021. ABC News Alec Baldwin said he’s not to blame for ... Read more »

Cyclone Jawad Updates: Odisha, Bengal Brace for Rains as Storm to Hit Tomorrow; Trains Cancelled

© Provided by News18 Cyclone Jawad Updates: Odisha, Bengal Brace for Rains as Storm to Hit Tomorrow; Trains Cancelled The India Meteorological Department (IMD) has issued an alert for the ... Read more »

AP: Hundreds of US military explosives stolen, lost

A photo illustration of stolen military fragmentation grenades found in a home in Quantico, Virginia, on Jan. 19, 2010 At least hundreds and possibly thousands of U.S military explosives have ... Read more »

Next-Gen Morgan 3 Wheeler Teased With Never-Before-Seen Sketches

New Morgan 3 Wheeler Nose New Morgan 3 Wheeler On Road New Morgan 3 Wheeler Front Angle © Morgan 3 Wheeler Teaser Sketches No single sketch fully reveals the ... Read more »

Kes pertama varian Omicron dikesan di Malaysia

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Pengembara dari Afrika Selatan itu telah menjalani Perintah Pengawasan dan Pemerhatian serta menjalani kuarantin wajib, menurut Khairy Jamaluddin. PUTRAJAYA: Menteri Kesihatan, Khairy Jamaluddin mengesahkan ... Read more »

Delhi's air quality in severe category

© Provided by Hindustan Times (File photo) Delhi’s air quality was in the “severe” category on Friday morning even as the mercury was likely to dip to 12 degrees Celsius. ... Read more »

Omicron could cause more reinfections, say South African experts

Omicron could cause more reinfections, say South African experts A preliminary study by South African researchers has indicated that the newly detected Omicron variant could be associated with a higher ... Read more »

5 more passengers from 'at risk' countries test COVID-19 positive in Mumbai, tally reaches 9

© Provided by DNA Concerns have increased in the state of Maharashtra as five more people who have arrived in Mumbai from ‘at risk countries’ have been tested positive for ... Read more »

US is Currently Fighting a Dire Delta Wave. Now, It Has to Gear Up for Omicron

© Provided by News18 US is Currently Fighting a Dire Delta Wave. Now, It Has to Gear Up for Omicron While all eyes are on the new and little-understood omicron ... Read more »

Delhi Air Pollution Updates: Centre Forms 5-Member Task Force Day After SC's 24-hour Deadline

© Provided by News18 Delhi Air Pollution Updates: Centre Forms 5-Member Task Force Day After SC’s 24-hour Deadline The Centre has formed a five-member task force to crack down on ... Read more »

5 cases of Omicron variant of Covid-19 confirmed in New York state in US

There are five confirmed cases of the Omicron variant of coronavirus in New York state. (Photo: File) The state of New York has confirmed five cases of the coronavirus Omicron ... Read more »

Paddy procurement progressing smoothly: Centre

© Provided by Hindustan Times Image for representation. (ANI) The Centre has said the paddy procurement for Kharif season has progressed smoothly like in the previous years and about 1.81 ... Read more »

Forget meat, there's now lab-grown coffee that tastes like the real thing

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) In recent years, lab-grown meat has become a popular alternative to meat that comes from livestock or poultry. You can get a ribeye steak, ... Read more »

Watchdog to monitor pork industry after Australian producer gobbled up by Brazilian behemoth

The competition watchdog says it will closely monitor the pork industry after approving the takeover of Australia’s biggest producer, Rivalea, by Brazilian beef behemoth JBS. JBS, which is controlled by ... Read more »

Police searching for Oregon State Hospital patient who went missing in Eugene

Officials are searching for a Junction City state hospital patient after he went missing Thursday from an approved outing in downtown Eugene. The escapee, identified as Jordan James Sava, a ... Read more »

Omicron marches on as Biden prepares U.S. for grim winter

A pre-departure COVID-19 testing facility outside the international terminal at Sydney Airport in Sydney By Byron Kaye and Jeff Mason SYDNEY/WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Australia, despite restrictions on international visitors, became ... Read more »

Gun found in traffic stop

Dec. 2—A traffic stop and a vehicular search yielded a firearm earlier this week, according to a report from the Kings County Sheriff's Office. On Tuesday at around 10:15 p.m., ... Read more »

Kansas City man gets 28-year sentence for bank robberies in Leawood, Roeland Park

A 23-year-old man will spend almost 30 years in federal prison after being convicted of robbing two banks in the Kansas City suburbs by holding tellers at gunpoint while hiding ... Read more »

Michael Carrick opens up on decision to leave Manchester United

Michael Carrick intends to watch a Manchester United match from the away end again now he has left the club. Carrick’s 15-and-a-half year United career ended with him guiding them ... Read more »

Canada region drops Covid booster eligibility age

© Provided by MalaysiaNow Canada’s Ontario province, its most populous and with its most Covid infections, announced Thursday it is lowering the eligibility age for Covid boosters from 70 to ... Read more »

Microsoft now sends unwanted prompts to stop you from downloading Google Chrome on Windows 11

If you have been using Windows 10, you may be familiar with Microsoft’s ways of stopping you from changing the default browser to Google Chrome. That is because Microsoft just ... Read more »

'Put this outside Wankhede': Jaffer shares hilarious suggestion for India on how 'to negate the Jamieson threat'

Former Indian cricketer Wasim Jaffer is back, with yet another meme, of course a hilarious one, this time on the second Test between India and New Zealand which will be ... Read more »

Sai Pallavi is a proud sister as Pooja makes debut in Mollywood; Pens a heartwarming note

© Provided by Pinkvilla Sai Pallavi’s younger sister Pooja Kannan is all set to mark her debut in the Mollywood industry. She is playing the female lead in Fight choreographer-turned-director ... Read more »

Christine Lampard took mom, sister on first date with Frank

Former England and Chelsea star Frank Lampard’s wife Christine has revealed that she took her mother and sister along on her first date with the footballer. Speaking on British talk ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic