SC suggests mediation to Lalit Modi and his mother for resolving property dispute in family

Asia's Tech News Daily

Lalit Modi, Supreme Court, k k modi, n v ramana, Kapil Sibal

The Supreme Court Monday suggested mediation to Lalit Modi and his mother Bina Modi, wife of late industrialist K K Modi, to resolve the long pending property dispute in the family and asked both the parties to give names of mediators of their choice.

The top court was hearing the appeal of Lalit Modi against the judgement of a division bench of the Delhi High Court which had held that the anti-arbitration injunction lawsuit filed by Bina Modi against her son Lalit Modi is maintainable.

The lawsuit was earlier filed by Bina Modi seeking to restrain the arbitration proceedings initiated by Lalit Modi in Singapore over the dispute.

A bench headed by Chief Justice N V Ramana, after hearing brief arguments from a battery of senior lawyers appearing on both sides, said that ultimately, it was a family dispute over property and money and suggested mediation or arbitration in India to resolve the case.

“Harish Salve group (Lalit Modi) is willing to have arbitration. What we feel is that this is a dispute of family members apart from trust etc. There is a provision in the deed also that this can be mediated…this is only a suggestion. We do not compel anybody to agree. Why don’t you agree for mediation or arbitration in India,” suggested the bench which also comprised justices Surya Kant and Hima Kohli.

“We have no problem”, said senior advocates Kapil Sibal and Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for Bina Modi.

“I am pleasantly surprised. We are very happy,” responded Salve who along with senior advocate A M Singhvi represented Lalit Modi.

“All right, both sides suggest some names. We choose one name. You can send the name/names in sealed cover… We will send it for mediation,” the bench said and listed the plea for hearing on December 13.

In December last year, the division bench of the high court had held that it has the jurisdiction to decide Bina Modi’s plea challenging Lalit Modi’s move to initiate arbitration proceedings in Singapore.

The division bench had set aside the judgement of a single judge of the high court which had said that it does not have the jurisdiction to adjudicate the anti-arbitration injunction suits filed by Lalit Modi’s mother Bina, his sister Charu and brother Samir and they are open to take such pleas before the arbitral tribunal in Singapore.

The single judge had said that an anti-arbitration injunction suit does not lie, so the pleas are not maintainable, and dismissed.

Bina, Charu and Samir, in two separate suits, contended that there was a trust deed between the family members and the KK Modi family trust matters cannot be settled through arbitration in a foreign country as per Indian laws.

They have sought permanent injunction restraining Lalit Modi from prosecuting or continuing with the application for emergency measures and any arbitration proceedings against them in Singapore.

The division bench, in its 103-page judgement passed on December 24, 2020, had said the subject dispute ought to have been prime facie adjudicated by the single judge, who had to exercise the jurisdiction vested in the court as all the parties are Indian citizens and situs of immovable assets of the trust is in India.

“In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the considered view that the single judge gravely erred by failing to exercise the jurisdiction vested in the court, which statutorily required him to adjudicate, whether the disputes between the parties, in relation to the trust deed, were per se referable to arbitration.

“This, in our respectful view, is tantamount to wrong exercise of jurisdiction by the single judge. The impugned judgment cannot resultantly be sustained..,” the bench had said.

The division bench had remanded their two civil suits to the single judge for further proceedings, in accordance with law, from the stage of issuance of summons and directed the registry to list them for hearing.

As per the case, the trust deed was executed at London by KK Modi as settlor/ managing trustee and Bina, Lalit, Charu and Samir as trustees, and in pursuance to oral family settlement recorded between them on February 10, 2006.

KK Modi died on November 2, 2019 after which the dispute emerged amongst the trustees.

Lalit Modi contended that after the demise of his father, in view of lack of unanimity amongst the trustees regarding sale of trust assets, a sale of all assets of the trust has been triggered and distribution to beneficiaries has to occur within one year thereof, the single judge had noted.

His mother and the two siblings contended that on a true construction of the trust deed, no such sale has been triggered.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

INSIDE PICS of Javed Akhtar's birthday celebration with Farhan Akhtar, Boney Kapoor, Shibani Dandekar & more

Famous lyricist and Screenwriter Javed Akhtar, who is also quite famous for voicing his political opinion, turned 77 on Monday. His loved ones surely did their best to make his ... Read more »

I never say no to my kids, my 4-year-old stays up til 10pm & has mac ‘n' cheese for breakfast – people call me negligent

DAY-LONG sessions of watching YouTube, mac ’n’ cheese for breakfast and 11pm bedtimes may sound like any child’s dream routine. But this is reality — if they choose it — ... Read more »

I threw a chair to escape Texas synagogue hostage-taker Malik Faisal Akram after I invited him in for tea

A TEXAS Rabbi made a desperate bid to escape the synagogue hostage-taker, Malik Faisal Akram, after inviting him in for some tea. The FBI named Akram, a British citizen, as ... Read more »

North Nigeria state reopens schools shut after abductions

© Aminu ABUBAKAR A group of girls who were kidnapped from their boarding school in northern Nigeria are seen in March 2021 at the Government House in Gusau, Zamfara State ... Read more »

Samsung Freestyle: Everything We Know About This Smart Laser Projector

CES, the annual tech conference in Las Vegas, has always been about showcasing brands’ newest and coolest gadgets, the products they hope to become popular in the years ahead. Some ... Read more »

Burkina Faso draw with Ethiopia to get into second round

© Pius Utomi Ekpei, AFP Burkina Faso secured a place in the knockout stage at the Africa Cup of Nations after Cyrille Bayala’s first half goal helped them to an ... Read more »

Sean Dyche not angry with Chris Wood as Burnley look to replace striker

© PA Wire Chris Wood left Burnley to join Newcastle last week (Owen Humphreys/PA) – PA Wire Burnley boss Sean Dyche will look to the transfer market to replace Chris ... Read more »

What is Woodoku? How to download and play the brilliant puzzle app you've seen on TV

© WOODOKU Woodoku Quiz app on iPhone and Android Ever feel like there are too many apps on iPhone and Android? The respective app stores are bombarded with new apps ... Read more »

Only seven per cent general public visit the secretariat: Himanta Biswa Sarma

Citing a recent study, Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma said that out of the people visiting the state secretariat in Guwahati only 7 percent are general public and 6 ... Read more »

Kendall at Everton, Shearer at Newcastle: 16 ex-players who went on to manager their old clubs

Wayne Rooney is being backed as a favourite to become the next Everton manager. Former Blues boss was sacked on Sunday afternoon after overseeing Everton drop to a lowly 16th ... Read more »

Andy Murray told what he needs to do for 'really good success' in Australian Open

Andy Murray is preparing for his first Australian Open appearance in three years. Back in 2019, the former world No 1 gave a tearful press conference in Melbourne Park, admitting ... Read more »

UK govt freezes BBC funding for two years

© – Britain’s Culture Secretary Nadine Dorries gives a media update statement on January 17, 2022 in this video grab from the UK Parliamentary Recording Unit The UK government on ... Read more »

‘That temptation is still there': Berbatov issues Spurs transfer warning ahead of summer window

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Harry Kane clapping Tottenham Hotspur supporters According to reports by The Mirror (as relayed by football.london), former Tottenham striker Dimitar Berbatov fears that Harry Kane ... Read more »

Pfizer extends shelf life after revelation NHS could waste jabs

Health chiefs have extended the shelf life of Pfizer’s Covid jabs over fears millions of injections would have to be binned. A slowdown in the booster drive prompted concerns that ... Read more »

UK government announces freeze on BBC's license fee

© Provided by WION UK government on Monday announced freeze on British Broadcasting Corporation’s (BBC) license fee. The government claimed that freeze on the license fee was aimed at providing ... Read more »

Spain Covid restrictions: What are the travel rules and are there still flights available?

BRITS have started returning to Spain as travel restrictions are eased in the UK, although there are still some rules in place abroad. Here is everything you need to know ... Read more »

Balika Vadhu 2, 17th January 2022, Written Update: Anandi reaches the court

© Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, Kiara wishes Anandi all the best. Anandi gives her project to Kiara for submissions and Kiara thanks her and tells her designs her ... Read more »

Carlos Slim Fast Facts

© AFP/Getty Images qmb parker mexico carlos slim intv_00042617.jpg Here’s a look at the life of Mexico’s richest man, businessman and investor Carlos Slim. Personal Birth date: January 28, 1940 ... Read more »

Now Indy SAGE wants us to 'do more' to prevent flu!

A pro-lockdown scientist today called on the UK to ‘do more’ to prevent flu as a consensus begins to emerge that the worst of Covid is over.   Parallels between coronavirus ... Read more »

Charles Taylor Fast Facts

© Koen van Weel/AFP/Getty Images Former Liberian President Charles Taylor waits in the courtroom of the Special Court for Sierra Leone in The Hague prior to the appeal judgement on ... Read more »

Full dress rehearsal for Republic Day celebrations to be held at Ludhiana's Guru Nanak Stadium

© Provided by Hindustan Times Ludhiana’s Guru Nanak Stadium will be hosting the full-dress rehearsal for district-level Republic Day celebrations on January 24. (REUTERS) Additional deputy commissioner (ADC) (general) Rahul ... Read more »

Rochelle 'wouldn't know what to do' if daughter has asthma attack

Rochelle Humes has revealed her youngest daughter Valentina, four, has asthma.  The presenter, 32, said she wouldn’t know what to do if her daughter started having an attack as she ... Read more »

Jalen Reagor gives Eagles fans more reasons to boo him in playoff loss

Giants fans could nod knowingly. They had seen this Jalen Reagor before. The same hyped wide receiver, who dropped a pass at the goal line in late November that would ... Read more »

BBC licence fee advert from 1980s resurfaces, showing how bold broadcaster could be when fighting for funding

A punchy BBC advert from the 1980s showing the broadcaster’s strong defence of the cost of the licence fee has resurfaced following the latest row over the payment. The clip ... Read more »

Skipper Kohli had the aura of Pataudi, Imran

© Provided by Hindustan Times File photo of Virat Kohli. (AP) Those wanting to know whether Virat Kohli gave up the Test captaincy because he was tired, retired, or retired ... Read more »

This pink Marks & Spencer coat looks incredibly like Kate Middleton's

Cast your mind back to the time the Duchess of Cambridge opted for a full pink ensemble, which we couldn’t get enough of then, and still aren’t over now.  On 11 ... Read more »

Delhi HC restrains websites from using HT Media's ‘Shine' trademark

© Provided by Hindustan Times The company’s petition said that rogue websites have been advertising themselves as HT Media’s Shine, specifically by mirroring the website of HT Media’s www.shine.com. (HT) ... Read more »

Body found in search for missing Irish man in Denmark

THE BODY OF an Irish man missing in Denmark since 5 December has been found, Danish police have confirmed. Peter Burns (29), from Dunboyne in Co Meath, was working as ... Read more »

A Guide to Manifestation for Skeptics, According to a Healer

© Unsplash Woman on a mountain top overlooking the vistas below When it comes to creating the life you desire, the concept of simply *manifesting* your dreams can seem like ... Read more »

When does Phase 3 release in World of Warcraft Classic Burning Crusade?

© Provided by Dot Esports The next raid tier of World of Warcraft Classic TBC is on the horizon with a pair of instances becoming available before the end of ... Read more »

Russian invasion fears prompt UK to give Ukraine extra weapons and training aid

Britain is providing further “self-defence” weapons and training to Ukraine amid concerns over a possible Russian invasion. Defence Secretary Ben Wallace said light anti-armour defensive weapons systems would be supplied ... Read more »

Texas hostage taker had criminal and mental health history in UK

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Ralph Lauer/EPA A British man who flew to the US, acquired a gun and took hostages at a Texas synagogue had a criminal record ... Read more »

Tonga volcanic eruption captured in dramatic satellite footage

Dramatic satellite footage has captured the sheer power of the underwater volcanic eruption near Tonga, showing a monstrous plume of ash and smoke bursting from the ocean’s surface. The eruption ... Read more »

Tonga: First reconnaissance flights survey aftermath of volcanic eruption

© Provided by DW The eruption of the Hunga Tonga-Hunga Ha’apai was heard thousands of miles away in Alaska New Zealand said Monday it was able to send a surveillance ... Read more »

‘AFV' honors former host Bob Saget with touching tribute: ‘Bob being Bob'

Bob Saget, who hosted “America’s Funniest Home Videos” throughout the 1990s was remembered fondly by the show. Courtesy of America’s Funniest H “America’s Funniest Home Videos” is helping the world ... Read more »

Grenade attack on Srinagar PCR, none hurt

© Provided by The Times of India SRINAGAR: Terrorists hurled a grenade at the Police Control Room in Srinagar’s Batamaloo area late Monday. None was injured, confirmed a senior police ... Read more »

Report: Brentford interested in signing Christian Eriksen

Tottenham Hotspur boss Antonio Conte recently said he’s open to midfielder Christian Eriksen training with the Premier League club where he previously spent seven years after the 29-year-old had his ... Read more »

Has the younger generation already killed off the BBC?

© Provided by The Telegraph bbc Reaching a centenary is usually an event to be celebrated, but when the BBC licence fee turns 100 next year, the landmark will pass ... Read more »

Erik Lamela wins Puskas Award for stunning rabona goal against Arsenal

© POOL/AFP via Getty Images GettyImages-1231713325.jpg Erik Lamela’s stunning rabona goal in the north London derby against Arsenal was named the winner of the Puskas Award at the Fifa Best ... Read more »

Uttar Pradesh Assembly Elections: AIMIM announces second list of candidates

© Provided by DNA AIMIM released the second list of candidates for the upcoming Uttar Pradesh Assembly polls on Monday. The second list includes the names of eight candidates. Earlier ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic