SC stays criminal proceedings, notices to freeze voting rights in Yes Bank-Dish TV dispute

Asia's Tech News Daily

supreme court, yes bank, national securities depository limited, videocon, nsdl, kapil sibal

The Supreme Court on Tuesday stayed the criminal proceedings in the FIR lodged by Essel Group against the

Yes Bank

saying it cannot allow the police sitting in Gautam Buddha Nagar in Uttar Pradesh to freeze voting rights of shareholders of a company. The bench also stayed the operation of two notices issued by Gautam Buddha Nagar police to the stock exchange and the National Securities Depository Limited (NSDL) asking it to not allow any transfer of shares of Essel group held by the bank.

A bench of Justices DY Chandrachud, AS Bopanna, and Vikram Nath said, “Using criminal procedure to achieve results of civil proceedings will have a dangerous consequence. Tomorrow, anybody will catch a police officer and stall the voting of a shareholder. This will be the easiest thing to do”.

The bench said, “it cannot allow the police sitting in Gautam Buddha Nagar to freeze voting rights of shareholders of a public listed company. Here, the police have done something which the Company Law Tribunal won’t do”.

The bench said that it cannot allow this kind of act of police to happen in the country and that is why Article 226 of the constitution is a very valuable right under which the High Court can interfere in these kinds of cases.

The top court said, “We don’t want this kind of power to be given to the police or they will start interfering in corporate matters. This is short-circuiting the judicial process by getting orders from police officers. This we will not allow.”

It ordered, “Prima facie, at this stage we are of the view that it would be necessary to protect the interest of the petitioner in respect of the pledged shares and the pledge having been invoked. Hence, we issue notice and direct that pending further orders, there shall be the stay of the operation of the impugned notices. Also, there shall be a stay of further proceedings in respect of the impugned FIR”.

It asked the parties to file their counter affidavit within three weeks.

The top court was hearing an appeal filed by the bank against the November 25 order of Allahabad High Court refusing to quash the notices under section 102 CrpC and FIR lodged by the police.

During the hearing, senior advocate AM Singhvi, appearing for Yes Bank said, this is one of the most extraordinary cases where “malafide” criminal proceedings are initiated to scuttle the voting rights of the largest shareholder of the Essel Group.

He said that the earlier Yes Bank had disbursed a loan of amount Rs 5270 crore to the Essel Group and its sister concerns between 2016 and 2018 and for it, 44.5 crore shares were pledged against it.

Singhvi said that the pledge was invoked by the bank and it became the largest shareholder of the company and to prevent the bank from voting in the Annual General Meeting (AGM), which was earlier scheduled to be held on November 30, to change or refuse to reappoint the directors, these notices were issued.

Referring to the notices, Singhvi said,

“This is nepotism at worst. It reeks of it and stinks of it. Just see the language of it. If the High Court will not interfere in these matters, where will I go?”

He said that even in normal situations, the courts hardly interfere with the voting rights of shareholders and the transfer of shares; voting rights are axioms of company law and corporate law.

“It is a fundamental right to do business. I am a lender of over Rs 5000 crore and the shares I have under pledge are being rendered worthless by using the criminal procedure. This is an abuse of criminal procedure and the high court should have intervened and passed strictures”, Singhvi said.

He said that against invoking the pledge, the Essel Group filed a civil suit in Saket court here but it was withdrawn earlier this year and the FIR which was also lodged last year, is suddenly acted upon this year.

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for Essel Group’s Subhash Chandra, the original complainant, said that this case is not what is presented and he can show that the shares which are with the banks are tainted.

“The scheme was that I take a loan from Yes Bank and Videocon immediately returns that money to the bank to square off the books. There was complete round-tripping but the court knows in what state Videocon is today. The whole purpose was that you take my money and clean my books”, he said.

He urged the court to allow him to file a reply in the matter and added that Yes Bank can move the magistrate court to avail its remedies as said by the High Court.

Sibal said, “For 18 months they have not sold the shares and are sitting over it. The bank wants to take over the company. What business does the bank have to take over the company? They give loans and not take companies unless it is for somebody else”.

Sibal asked the court to record his statement that he will not hold the AGM and if he is able to prove that the shares are tainted, then the police have every right to go after them.

Singhvi intervened and said that the AGM which was scheduled for today was deferred because Yes Bank had mentioned before the CJI bench on Monday.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

'He's a warrior for us, he's a warrior for the Barrs. You take your hat off to him'

WHEN MICHAEL SHIELDS was pressed into action yesterday in Thurles, it was at a time of growing anxiety about the prospects of St Finbarr’s. Shields entry to the field on ... Read more »

Australian native and French giant among stars deserving of Six Nations debuts

Test-level rugby is an honour reserved for only a small percentage of elite rugby players, and the Six Nations represents one of the most prestigious platforms in the sport. It’s ... Read more »

Glaxo courts Qatar and Singapore to head off £50bn Unilever swoop

GlaxoSmithKline is courting the sovereign wealth funds of Qatar and Singapore as cornerstone investors in a listing of its £50bn consumer business as it seeks to head off a risky takeover ... Read more »

London drama student tipped for stardom by studio lands major role

© Bloomfields Welch Management ahmed.elhaj.jpg A 22-year-old London actor has landed a dream role in a major US drama after being chosen for a special scheme to help students affected ... Read more »

Dia Mirza shares gorgeous sunkissed PIC from a forest, says she misses taking her kids into the wild

© Provided by Pinkvilla Dia Mirza is missing spending time in the forest. Dia has been ruling our hearts for over two decades now. Apart from being a gorgeous actress ... Read more »

Virginia's 1st female lt. gov. takes her seat in the Senate

© Provided by Associated Press Virginia Lt. Gov. Winsome Earle-Sears pledges allegiance as she presides at the Capitol Monday Jan. 17, 2022, in Richmond, Va. (AP Photo/Steve Helber) RICHMOND, Va. ... Read more »

Bumrah: Captaincy, coaching changes 'don't make a lot of difference'

The Indian team is going through a transition. Rahul Dravid replaced Ravi Shastri as coach recently. A new support staff came in. Virat Kohli is no longer the captain in ... Read more »

IPL: Having picked Hardik and Rashid, Ahmedabad prefer Shubman Gill over Ishan Kishan

© Provided by The Financial Express Pandya is all set to captain the Ahmedabad franchise for the season and they have also finalised Rashid Khan. (File) The Ahmedabad IPL franchise ... Read more »

NDA crossfire in Bihar flares up with state BJP chief's FB post

© Provided by Hindustan Times BJP Bihar state president Sanjay Jaiswal . (HT Photo) PATNA The ongoing crossfire between the two key constituents of the ruling National Democratic Alliance (NDA) in ... Read more »

Ex-Brazil star Mario Jardel admits to week-long cocaine overdose before Bolton transfer

Former European Golden Boot winner Mario Jardel has admitted to overdosing on cocaine during a binge that kept him awake for seven days prior to joining Bolton Wanderers. The former ... Read more »

China's claim that Omicron came from Canadian mail dismissed as 'ludicrous'

OTTAWA — A claim by Chinese health authorities that the Omicron variant was introduced to a resident of Beijing through a piece of regular mail from Canada is being dismissed ... Read more »

84-year-old man's body found rotting in Brooklyn apartment, cops say

An elderly man’s decomposed body was found in his Midwood, Brooklyn home by NYPD officials during a wellness check. Christopher Sadowski An elderly man’s body was found rotting inside his ... Read more »

Exports target of $650 bn within this fiscal achievable: Piyush Goyal

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Assuring all support to the exporting community, Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal on Monday said the exports target of USD 650 billion ... Read more »

Rupee slips 9 paise to close at 74.24 against US dollar

© Provided by Zee Business Declining for the second straight session, the rupee on Monday fell 9 paise to close at 74.24 (provisional) against the US dollar as muted domestic ... Read more »

"Made contact with his representatives" - Journalist reveals THFC enquiry over "unique" 29 y/o

Tottenham have made contact over signing Manchester United attacker Jesse Lingard, says journalist Pete O’Rourke. The 29-year-old has barely kicked a ball this season, and it now looks like his ... Read more »

Karnataka reports 27,156 new Covid cases, including 287 Omicron

© Provided by Hindustan Times Bengaluru Urban district led the spike in Covid-19 cases with 15,947 new infections. (ANI) Omicron tally in Karnataka saw a steep spike as 287 new ... Read more »

UFC 270 Francis Ngannou vs Ciryl Gane UK start time: TV channel and live stream

Francis Ngannou will defend his heavyweight title against undefeated Frenchman Ciryl Gane this weekend. It’ll be the first pay-per-view event of the year in the UFC, kicking off with one ... Read more »

iPhone 12 gets a massive price cut on Flipkart, Amazon: Here's how you can get a better discount

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Even though the iPhone 12 is a year old, it is still one of the fastest and best camera phones available. The nicest ... Read more »

Robert Lewandowski crowned FIFA Best Men's Player pipping Lionel Messi to award

Robert Lewandowski has been crowned the 2021 FIFA Best Men’s Player. The Bayern Munich striker scored 69 goals in all competitions last year, winning the Bundesliga title and DFL Supercup. ... Read more »

BBC funding ‘up for discussion', says Nadine Dorries, as licence fee frozen

The culture secretary, Nadine Dorries, has confirmed that the BBC’s funding will be frozen for the next two years – but has softened her stance on the permanent abolition of ... Read more »

It Hasn't Completely Sunk in Yet: Keegan Petersen Still in Awe of His Peformance in Tests Against India

© Provided by News18 It Hasn’t Completely Sunk in Yet: Keegan Petersen Still in Awe of His Peformance in Tests Against India South Africa batter Keegan Petersen is still in ... Read more »

Budget 2022: Will there be more farm loan waivers or enhance in 80C limit in taxation? Here are expectations from 12 sectors

© Provided by Zee Business Prabhudas Lilladher expects a populist budget given state elections with five state elections lined up in the coming months, UP and Punjab being the major ... Read more »

Tottenham boss Rehanne Skinner reveals key reasons side conceded last-gasp equaliser to West Ham

Tottenham manager Rehanne Skinner blamed her side’s inability to manage momentum for passing up the chance to go second after conceding a late equaliser against West Ham. Spurs looked set ... Read more »

Virals: Liverpool 'preparing' bid for Leeds United ace Kalvin Phillips

© Pool/Getty Images Sport Leeds United v Liverpool – Premier League Liverpool are reportedly ‘preparing’ a bid for Leeds United midfielder Kalvin Phillips. The 26-year-old is highly rated and has ... Read more »

Canada's Combaluzier captures silver at World Para Snow Sports Championships

© Twitter/@Alpine_Canada Katie Combaluzier, who turns 28 on Tuesday, has earned two medals at the World Para Snow Sports Championship in Lillehammer, Norway. Toronto alpine skier Katie Combaluzier continued her ... Read more »

Honesty and humility will help combat COVID pseudo-science | View

Lockdowns, restrictions and public health measures have divided western societies. Even in European countries where vaccination rates are remarkably high, such as Spain (80 per cent fully vaccinated), Italy (75 ... Read more »

Serving Met Police officer pleads guilty to sexual communication with child

© PA The 33-year-old officer, attached to the Met’s Intelligence Command, was suspended in February last year – PA A serving Metropolitan Police officer has pleaded guilty to one count ... Read more »

This is how to master Valorant's newest agent Neon

Agent 19 Neon is speedy, stylish, and aggressive. Here’s how to play Neon in your ranked games to counter fast-paced agents like Jett. Jett’s mobility tactics ruled Valorant’s duelist roster ... Read more »

Millions face second record energy price hike this year, analysts warn

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Gareth Fuller/PA Millions of households could face a second record energy price hike this year which would lift the average gas and electricity bill ... Read more »

Climate crisis may wipe 1% a year off UK economy by 2045, say ministers

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Paul Marriott/REX/Shutterstock The climate crisis will wipe at least 1% a year off the UK’s economy by 2045 if global temperatures are allowed to ... Read more »

Here are all the Pokemon Center store locations

For Pokemon fans that make the pilgrimage to Japan, the Pokemon Center stores are a must-see attraction.  The brick-and-mortar retail locations offer some of the most memorable limited-edition items around. ... Read more »

Questions over plan for Royal Navy to take charge of tackling migrant crossings

© PA Wire A group of people thought to be migrants are brought in to Dover, Kent, by Border Force officers (Gareth Fuller/PA) – PA Wire Plans to put the ... Read more »

Nicolas Sarkozy Fast Facts

© VALERY HACHE/AFP/Getty Images Former French president Nicolas Sarkozy on March 10, 2014, in Nice, southeastern France. Here’s a look at the life of Nicolas Sarkozy, former president of France. ... Read more »

Barack Obama kisses wife Michelle Obama as he celebrates her 58th birthday; Read his sweet note

© Provided by Pinkvilla   Happy birthday, Michelle Obama! Former President Barack Obama marked his wife’s 57th birthday by posting a romantic  photo of the duo with a sweet caption ... Read more »

Nadine Dorries announces two year BBC licence fee freeze

Culture Secretary Nadine Dorries today confirmed the BBC licence fee will be frozen at £159 for the next two years as she also announced a review into the long-term future ... Read more »

Sadar Bazar pedestrian trial helps Gurugram bag award

© Provided by Hindustan Times On March 20 last year, the Municipal Corporation of Gurugram had attempted to turn a 600-metre stretch of the main Sadar Bazar market, between Jama ... Read more »

Ludhiana: Two women posing as maids steal cash, jewellery after sedating woman, daughter

© Provided by Hindustan Times The victim, a 40-year-old woman from Ludhiana, suspects that the accused sprayed the room with a sedative and stole cash and valuables. (Getty Images) Two ... Read more »

Sushmita Sen says 'I'm not lost sweetheart, you just haven't found me yet' with THIS sassy picture

© Provided by Pinkvilla Former Miss Universe Sushmita Sen enjoys a massive fan following and credit goes to her wittiness, beauty, and the niche she has created for herself in ... Read more »

Norway registered a 30-fold increase in the number of reinfections with corona after the omicron variant appeared in the country

Norway has registered a notable increase in the number of people who become corona infected for the second time since the omicron variant appeared in the country. In the first ... Read more »

Christina Haack shuts down criticism over her engagement to Josh Hall

© Bang Showbiz Christina Haack doesn’t care what the haters say about her relationship with Josh Hall Christina Haack has fired back at criticism that she has moved on with ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic