SA's climate policy is amplifying, not solving the crisis

Asia's Tech News Daily

SA’s climate policy is amplifying, not solving the crisis
© Provided by Independent Online (IOL)

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

OPINION: Our leaders have failed us dismally, again, lowering the target for our greenhouse gas emissions from 440 megatons in 2030 to just 420, as if this promised 5% reduction – voluntary with no binding provisions – is somehow laudable, writes Desmond D’Sa.

Climate Change is one of the biggest threats to humanity, and government intervention is needed urgently.

In 1992 at the original Rio de Janeiro sustainability conference, world leaders gathered to recognise the climate catastrophe that faces us. The most irresponsible was former US President George Bush, when he declared: “The American way of life is not up for negotiations.” When his son George W. Bush – an oil man – took over from 2001-09, there was even worse US arrogance.

But back in Rio, nearly all the leaders gathered then acted like the Yankees, ignoring the fact that, unless they addressed greenhouse gas emissions causing rising temperatures, droughts, wildfires, worse floods and other extreme weather events – like the Durban Rain Bomb of 2019 that killed 71 mainly black women, children and poor people – then the planet’s climate will start to degenerate.

The impact of that inaction is now clear for humans, animals and biodiversity, water and energy resources, agriculture, urbanisation and healthcare systems. At Rio, the world leaders failed, succumbing to:

– big fossil fuel corporations adamant they had no alternative but to continue producing fuel from coal, oil and gas,

– petrochemical firms addicted to plastics and toxic products,

– automakers reliant on petrol and diesel engines,

– agri-corporations intent on high-carbon fertilisers, meat and dairy,

– high-energy manufacturers especially in the extractive industries dependent on power for smelting and processing,

– high-methane waste disposal, and

– financiers using cyber-currency data-mining techniques which today chew up as much electricity as a country the size of the Philippines.

This pattern continued, even at the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change annual gatherings. Policy changes were made only at the margins, for example, in Kyoto in 1997, to introduce speculative fraud-filled gambling called emissions trading.

In Copenhagen in 2009, the idea of binding commitments was removed by Barack Obama, working with South Africa’s leader Jacob Zuma and the leaders of Brazil, China and India.

These annual gatherings did not serve the interests of the planet and people, but rather, of ripping more profits from the earth and society.

South Africa hosted the UNFCCC conference – the Cop 17 Conference of Polluters – in 2011, in Durban, my home city. We claimed to have the most progressive Constitution and environmental laws in the world, yet, when it was time to put these into action, we failed dismally.

Instead, throughout, our leaders cowered to our own – and the North’s and BRICS countries’ – major polluting corporations and big government bullies. They signed off on the execution of small island countries, as well as of our African sisters and brothers on the continent, who did least to cause the climate catastrophe, but will face the harshest consequences.

Worse, the South African delegation was often a big part of the problem in the UNFCCC, for example, by obstructing the call by the African and G77 bloc of countries to address the climate crisis seriously.

Since then, South Africa has recently submitted a ‘nationally determined contribution’ (NDC) to the UNFCCC. Our leaders have failed us dismally, again, lowering the target for our greenhouse gas emissions from 440 megatons in 2030 to just 420, as if this promised 5% reduction – voluntary with no binding provisions – is somehow laudable.

While UN climate negotiators are failing us, the UN’s scientific body – the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change – just warned of new climate feedback loops such as the loss of reflective white albedo from melting ice, large-scale venting of carbon dioxide and methane from melting permafrost peat bogs in the Arctic and Siberia, and the proliferation of wildfires.

The scientists conclude that “rapid and far-reaching” changes are needed in the economic system to keep temperature increases below 1.5°C.

We also believe that in the process, creating a more equal society is an imperative: “climate justice.” We remain the world’s most unequal society, with the poverty rate of roughly R50/person/day well over 60%, so whatever we do to address climate crisis must simultaneously address social injustice.

From politicians and big business, we have been hearing chatter about a Just Transition for low-income communities and workers that will be affected by de-carbonisation, like those in South Durban, but after all these years of such rhetoric, there has been zero progress.

Instead, the elites have introduced carbon trading, which allows those firms which reduce emissions to sell credits to ‘offset’ the emissions of others which want to keep polluting. Our Treasury has introduced a carbon tax law, with provision for offsets, which is at heart a market strategy. The real cost of CO2 emissions is now estimated at $3000 (R43496)/ton, new research suggests, but Treasury charges firms as low as $0.42/ton, and even that trivial tax will in future be offset.

Offsetting now underpins the phrase ‘net zero’. It relies on what Greta Thunberg terms ‘accounting gimmicks.’ They include supposed ‘natural climate solutions’ that assume carbon absorbed by restored sinks (wetlands, forests and grasslands) will permit more emissions from fossil fuels. While eco-system restoration is essential, it can only restore what was previously lost by eco-system destruction.

Offsets also rely upon ’carbon capture and storage,’ which is a hypothetical engineering solution to strip carbon from the exhaust gas and bury it under the earth. It is very expensive, very energy-intensive, and would require massive construction of new infrastructure. The few pilot schemes at power plants are technical and economic failures. In some cases, the CO2 is then sold for ‘enhanced oil recovery’ to restore pressure in ageing oil wells and so to extract more fossil fuel.

A genuine Just Transition must be based on the needs of the planet and must be generated bottom-up, by workers in high-carbon industries, by communities who will suffer, and by everyone whom the current system makes poor. The specific care-giving roles of women, the result of their subordination within patriarchal relations, means they and the youth should be central to the deep transformation needed for a Just Transition worthy of the name.

The youth and people of the world have spoken ‘’no to any more delays and compromising of tour future’ Act now and do the right thing for the planet and its people!

* Desmond D’Sa is chairperson of the South Durban Community Environmental Alliance.

** The views expressed here are not necessarily those of IOL and Independent Media.


Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Justin Verlander has yet to sign with Astros in ‘free agency mystery'

Justin Verlander is returning to the Astros … or is he? In November, everybody – including Verlander’s own brother, Fox Sports personality Ben Verlander – said the legendary pitcher was ... Read more »

BBC star Amol Rajan slammed for joking about ‘throwing a BRICK' at Kate Middleton & Prince William in unearthed tweets

A BBC journalist was today slammed for joking about throwing a brick at Kate Middleton and Prince William in unearthed tweets. Amol Rajan, who presented the controversial Beeb documentary The ... Read more »

We want to turbocharge every adult's Covid immunity with boosters – but we need you to join Sun's Jabs Army

TODAY I joined the nearly 19 million Brits who have had their immunity against Covid turbocharged with a booster.  It was just the latest of more than 116 million jabs ... Read more »

Bride passes out, vomits and gets pooped on during disaster wedding

Hollee Darnell went viral on TikTok after passing out, vomiting and getting popped on during her wedding. NYPost Composite This bride went from blushing to barfing in a matter of ... Read more »

NYPD's top cop Dermot Shea and second in command file for retirement

Dermot Shea announced on December 2, 2021 that he will be stepping down as Police Commissioner ahead of Mayor-elect Eric Adams taking over from Bill De Blasio. JASON SZENES/EPA-EFE/Shutterstoc NYPD ... Read more »

Aaron Maybin had a job with the Jets. He has a purpose in Baltimore.

Corey Sipkin The former first-round NFL draft pick, known for a brief but ultimately unfulfilling run with Rex Ryan’s Jets, reflects on those Sundays and his everyday mission of creating ... Read more »

Little Mix announce they're breaking up to pursue solo projects as they thank fans for ‘wonderful' 10 years

LITTLE Mix have announced they're taking a break next year to focus on solo projects. The girl group will go their separate ways after their Confetti tour but insisted they ... Read more »

Mitch Trubisky and wife Hillary celebrate baby-to-be with Bills family

Buffalo is ready to welcome baby boy Trubisky to #BillsMafia. On Wednesday, quarterback Mitch Trubisky and wife Hillary were joined by Bills players and their significant others for a lavish ... Read more »

Keanu Reeves says studio wasn't ‘ready' for trans character in ‘Matrix'

Keanu Reeves played the role of Neo in all four installments of “The Matrix,” beginning in 1999. Keanu Reeves admitted that a trans character was cut from a script draft ... Read more »

Fully-vaccinated Israeli doctor with Omicron appears to pass bug on — to one person

A fully-vaccinated Israeli doctor who became infected with the Omicron COVID-19 variant appears to have only passed the bug on to one other person — despite coming into close contact ... Read more »

Wall Street balks as Fed signals party's ending, but is it?

NEW YORK — The Federal Reserve’s job, its longest-serving chairman once said, is to “take away the punch bowl just as the party gets going,” and that’s exactly the message ... Read more »

Discovery Channel Just Dropped Amazing News For BattleBots Fans

Discovery Channel/YouTube The merest mention of “BattleBots” brings a tear in the eyes of the faithful who have spent many an hour being greatly entertained by the awesome, armor-wrecking battles ... Read more »

Robert Griffin III will detail being sexually harassed in upcoming WFT book

Robert Griffin III will document being sexually harassed in his upcoming book exposing the Washington Football Team, according to his wife, Grete. Earlier this week, the former quarterback released a ... Read more »

This evening I saved a man's life on M25 flyover, says EastEnders' Danny Hatchard

EASTENDERS star Danny Hatchard helped save a man who was contemplating taking his own life on the M25 flyover yesterday evening. The actor, who is best known for playing Lee ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity star Danny Miller's Love Island pal behind plane flying over the camp with banned message

I'M A Celebrity star Danny Miller's pal was behind the plane prank that saw a supportive message flown high above Gwrych Castle. The Sun can exclusively reveal that the banner ... Read more »

Hunter Biden plotted 2010 investment meeting with Serbian prez, emails show

According to the emails, it is unclear if Hunter Biden went to Serbia to meet with President Boris Tadic. Handout/DNCC via Getty Images Hunter Biden plotted an investment meeting with ... Read more »

On The Vine: Spark change, blaze a path

We back! Hope you turned off the news, silenced the phones and manged to have a restful holiday. Ready to dive back in? Around the block Eric DeValkenaere, center, is ... Read more »

S.Africa's health body sees threefold higher risk of reinfection from Omicron

A nurse prepares a dose of the of coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in Dutywa JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) – The new Omicron variant of the coronavirus poses a threefold higher risk of reinfection ... Read more »

Starbucks fights expanding unionization effort at its stores

FILE – Richard Bensinger, left, who is advising unionization efforts, along with baristas Casey Moore, right, Brian Murray, second from left, and Jaz Brisack, second from right, discuss their efforts ... Read more »

NSE-BSE bulk deals: Nalanda India Fund sells stake in Kirloskar Oil Engines

MUMBAI: Nalanda India Fund today sold 5.2 million shares of Kirloskar Oil Engines at Rs. 180.9 apiece through two bulk deals on the National Stock Exchange. In another transaction, Franklin ... Read more »

Haley to receive GOP group's highest award at The Citadel

1 / 2Las Vegas Republican Jewish CoalitionFormer Ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley gives a speech during the Republican Jewish Coalition’s annual leadership meeting at The Venetian hotel-casino Saturday, ... Read more »

Bergen temporarily stops drop-in vaccination

Bergen Municipality will temporarily stop drop-in vaccinations from December 6. Therefore, people who want to get the corona vaccine will have to book an appointment once again.  “Appointments are more ... Read more »

Portland women face meth-dealing charges

PORTLAND, Ind. — Two Portland women face meth-dealing charges after a traffic stop led to their arrests. The dealing charge filed in Jay Circuit Court against 30-year-old Ariel Louise Gallo ... Read more »

Malcolm Molyneux obituary

Tropical medicine researcher who advanced understanding of malaria and helped improve healthcare in Malawi When Malcolm Molyneux, who has died aged 77, went to the Queen Elizabeth Central hospital in ... Read more »

Can be punished for 5 yrs if guilty, have spent 3yrs in jail already: Agusta Westland accused to HC

Christian Michel James, the alleged middleman in the AgustaWestland chopper deal case, on Thursday urged the Delhi High Court to release him on bail, saying he has already spent three ... Read more »

Lok Sabha: Oppossition members seek to know government's stand on Covid booster dose

Members of opposition TMC and NCP on Thursday sought to know from the government its stand on booster doses for COVID-19, besides usage of money from the PM-CARES funds. Participating ... Read more »

‘Wicked' stepmother and ‘pitiless' father guilty over death of six-year-old

A “wicked” stepmother and a “pitiless” father have been convicted of killing his six-year-old son after subjecting the defenceless boy to a campaign of “evil” abuse. Emma Tustin, 32, was ... Read more »

Murfreesboro Police Department arrests man in shooting death of ex-girlfriend

Detectives with the Murfreesboro Police Department's Criminal Investigations Division on Wednesday arrested a man on charges of shooting his former girlfriend to death. Myron Jenkins, 26, is charged with first-degree ... Read more »

Charles's former closest aide co-ordinated with ‘fixers' over honours

The Prince of Wales’s former most trusted aide co-ordinated with “fixers” over honours nominations for a Saudi billionaire donor to the Prince’s Foundation, an investigation into cash for honours claims ... Read more »

MTA ‘needs to reassess' after falling behind on vital infrastructure: comptroller

State Comptroller Tom DiNapoli found the MTA is behind on needed maintenance and upgrades. Getty Images MTA officials have fallen seriously behind on shoring up New York’s aging transit infrastructure ... Read more »

Letter: Ian Wallace the bird artist

Stephen Moss’s obituary of the ornithologist Ian Wallace rightly highlighted Ian’s written contributions to the Handbook of the Birds of Europe, the Middle East and North Africa: The Birds of ... Read more »

Labour must seek a broad alliance to oust the Tories

Readers respond to an article which argued that Labour’s best route to power is through a coalition of leftwing parties, and to an editorial on the party’s shadow ministerial reshuffle ... Read more »

FBI searching in Columbia for man wanted on drug and gun charges

The FBI is asking for help in its search for a wanted man who could be in the Columbia area. A federal warrant has been issued for Levester Tyyon Woods. ... Read more »

The Guardian view on human rights and the borders bill: the wrong path

The government belief that national sovereignty trumps humanitarian principle leads to bad policy and moral aberration When government policy collides with human rights legislation, the Conservative party instinctively finds fault ... Read more »

Student arrested after joyride in stolen school bus, Oklahoma cops say

A student accused of hopping behind the wheel of a school bus and taking it on a joyride has been arrested, according to Oklahoma authorities. Stillwater police got a call ... Read more »

Complaint: UF wants to ax 'critical race' from study title

ORLANDO, Fla. (AP) — University of Florida administrators told faculty members they couldn’t used the words “critical” and “race” together in describing a new study, out of fear that it ... Read more »

As omicron looms, US is still battling the delta wave

1 / 5Virus Outbreak USFILE – Licensed practical nurse Yokasta Castro, of Warwick, R.I., draws a Moderna COVID-19 vaccine into a syringe at a mass vaccination clinic, May 19, 2021, ... Read more »

Sir Frederick Barclay's ex-wife asks judge to commit him to jail in money fight

Businessman Sir Frederick Barclay’s ex-wife has asked a judge to commit him to prison after alleging that he breached orders made in a High Court fight over money. Lady Hiroko ... Read more »

Philanthropist Jacqueline Avant helped unite the worlds of Black politics and entertainment

Jacqueline Avant, shown with husband Clarence Avant in 2020, was known as a quiet force who helped unite powerful figures from the worlds of sports, entertainment and politics, usually to ... Read more »

Households should pay higher tax on gas to reflect cost of climate change, say government advisers

The Climate Change Committee said the Government is effectively subsidising the cost of fossil fuel heating and should make it more expensive to reflect the costs of climate change Gas ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic