San Francisco green lights SFPD rule allowing robotic lethal-force

San Francisco green lights SFPD rule allowing robotic lethal-force

A hot potato: The San Francisco Police Department now has the authority to use lethal robotic force against violent criminals under new city rules. Only three of the 11 Board of Supervisors members opposed the controversial decision. Opponents, including the ALCU and the EFF, fear using robots against human suspects removes the humanity in law enforcement and violates a suspect’s due process. The SFPD insists it will not misuse the tactic.

Last week, the San Francisco Police Department (SFPD) submitted a controversial regulation change allowing officers to use robots to kill suspects. The rule faced pushback from the Board of Supervisors and civil rights advocates, including the ACLU. After at least one set of revisions, the SFPD finally submitted the proposal to city officials for approval.

On Tuesday, the Board of Supervisors approved the new rules in an 8-3 vote with revisions. Fox affiliate KTVU notes, the regulation regarding using lethal robotic force stipulates that “trained” officers can use “military-grade machines” to kill suspects in “critical incidents.” An added requirement not in the original draft was that the SFPD must evaluate the situation and apply alternative non-lethal tactics first.

Beyond disappointed that the Board seems poised to allow SFPD to use weaponized robots to use force against human beings. Only 4 of us clearly against. Shortsighted, dangerous, sad. The spirit of the SF I have always admired is weeping today.

— Hillary Ronen (@HillaryRonen) November 30, 2022

Additionally, the rule was altered so that the 17 robots in the SFPD arsenal, which are all unarmed, cannot be fitted with firearms. Instead, they will use explosives, including concussive devices intended to disorient the suspect. However, the Board will consider lethality acceptable collateral damage. It is worth mentioning that the first time police used a robot to kill a suspect in the US, explosives were the weapon of choice.

“A lot of talk of ‘Robocop,’ which I think sets a lot of minds going to a whole lot of places, but this is not that [sic],” said proponent Supervisor Rafael Mandelman. “I think it’s totally appropriate. In fact, I think it would be irresponsible not to make plans to use that technology in that horrific eventuality.”

Civil rights groups still don’t share the same optimistic outcome of the rule. Policy Analyst Matthew Guariglia with the Electronic Frontier Foundation says it is a very slippery slope.

Today’s vote approving the SFPD’s dystopian military equipment policy—which will allow SFPD to use robots to kill people—is deeply disturbing. This is a sad moment for our City, and it shows how far we have strayed from the 2020 reckoning on police violence. Here’s my statement.

— Dean Preston (@DeanPreston) November 30, 2022

“It’s really just opening a window that eventually somebody’s gonna wanna crawl through,” Guariglia told KTVU. “We are going to lessen the burden of using deadly force from having to pull a gun and pull the trigger to a button on a remote control.”

The SFPD assures the public that it will primarily use the explosive-equipped robots to breach buildings that violent and dangerous suspects have barricaded themselves in and that the force of the blast could potentially cause unintended death. Ideally, officers will still have to confront and attempt to arrest the suspects.

“While an explosive charge may be considered an intermediate force option, it could potentially cause injury or be lethal. Robots equipped in this manner would only be used in extreme circumstances to save or prevent further loss of innocent lives,” a spokesperson said.

None of the robots have firearms attached, and SFPD has no plans to attach firearms. However, in extreme circumstances it is conceivable that use of a robot might be the best and only way of dealing with a terrorist or mass shooter. 3/5

— Rafael Mandelman (@RafaelMandelman) November 30, 2022

Supervisor Hillary Ronen was among the three board persons to vote no on the proposed rules calling the mechanical force rule “shortsighted, dangerous, [and] sad.”

“Beyond disappointed that the Board seems poised to allow SFPD to use weaponized robots to use force against human beings. Only 4 of us clearly against. Shortsighted, dangerous, sad. The spirit of the SF I have always admired is weeping today,” Ronen tweeted just before it was taken to a vote. “Even worse than I thought! Only three of us – myself, Shamann Walton and Dean Preston voted against arming robots with weapons to kill. A damn shame,” she corrected later.

Board President Shamann Walton said it was just another thing that would increase the odds of negative police interactions with “people of color.” District 5 Supervisor Dean Preston called it “deeply disturbing” and “dystopian.”

Proponents defended their votes with Supervisor Rafael Mandelman pointing out that the SFPD has used the robots for 10 years without attached firearms, and the department has no intentions of equipping them. It will continue to use them for remote surveilance of a situation and the disposal of bombs, but using them as a weapon of lethal force will be a last-resort option.

“I’d buy that for a dollar.”

News Related


Bournemouth vs Nottingham Forest live stream: how to watch any Premier League game

(Image: © Getty Images / Andrew Kearns – CameraSport) Winless since the Premier League restart, Bournemouth have rapidly tumbled back towards the relegation zone, and if they lose to Nottingham ... Read more »

Scuf Reflex Pro review

Pimp my pad Read more »

Best PS5 games: top PlayStation 5 titles to play right now

Start adding the best PS5 games to your library Read more »

Zoom is going to work a lot closer with one of its biggest rivals, and I couldn't be happier

null The wait is over, because Google Meet users will now be able to join Zoom calls straight from their own devices without needing to install the Zoom client. Initially ... Read more »

Southampton vs Aston Villa live stream: how to watch Premier League online from anywhere

(Image: © Getty Images / Visionhaus / Catherine Ivill) Southampton may be rooted to the bottom of the table, but they’re one of the Premier League’s in-form teams. Three consecutive ... Read more »

West Ham vs Everton live stream: how to watch Premier League online from anywhere

(Image: © Getty Images / Simon Stacpoole / Offside) David Moyes and Frank Lampard may be thinking back to happier times when West Ham vs Everton gets underway this Saturday. ... Read more »

Apple Just Released Code for Its 40-Year-Old “Lisa” Computer

John Couch / Computer History Museum The Lisa was Apple’s first computer with a graphical desktop interface, predating the Macintosh by a year. Now, 40 years later, you can see ... Read more »

Sharing a Netflix Account? Get Ready to Pay For It

DANIEL CONSTANTE/ Netflix is about to get serious in its efforts to eliminate freeloaders. If you share a Netflix account with family or friends outside your household, get ready to pay ... Read more »

‘7 Wonders’ Board Game Gets a New ‘Edifice’ Expansion

Asmodee and Repos Production Board game lovers have a wonderful reason to celebrate today. Board game makers Asmodee and Repos Production announced their latest collaboration: 7 Wonders Edifice, an expansion ... Read more »

Best Nintendo DS games: everything for the handheld you need to play

The best Nintendo DS games prove the console's strengths. Read more »

Man vs Paper Bag: BBC Shows Us How Far Entertainment Has Evolved in 50 Years

The entertainment industry has come a long way in the past 50 years, with movies and tv shows creating ever more impressive spectacles. Oftentimes, it’s easy to forget the humble ... Read more »

These Four Actors Make Up the Rushmore of Comedy

Comedy has been one of the genres most used in cinema since its embryonic beginnings in the silent era. It has been used to denounce bad things in our society ... Read more »

Save Time in Microsoft PowerPoint by Making Your Own Theme

Using the Variants on the Design tab, you can create a PowerPoint theme with your own style. Save the theme and reuse it for future presentations to build your brand ... Read more »

T-Mobile Kicks Off 2023 With Another Data Breach

r.classen / In a press release, T-Mobile confirms that it detected a data breach in its systems on January 5th. A “bad actor” managed to steal personal information (but ... Read more »

Sundance Is Raving About Daisy Ridley’s Upcoming Deadpan Yet Sincere Comedy About Mental Health

Have you been wondering what’s Star Wars alum Daisy Ridley has been up to since she ended her fighting in a galaxy far, far away? The actress has been doing ... Read more »

Millions of T-Mobile customers have data stolen in breach

null T-Mobile has warned millions of its customers that a threat actor used an Application Programming Interface (API) to gain access to some of their sensitive data. In a warning ... Read more »

What is DataOps and why does it matter?

null The challenge of not yet knowing how to integrate their enterprise-scale data platforms is one that many organisations are now dealing with. Their failure to make their operations data-driven ... Read more »

Windows 11 Is Improving HDR and GPU Switching

Windows 11 introduced an updated Settings application, with better organization and more options. Even more changes are on the way, as Microsoft is testing changes to the graphics section. Windows ... Read more »

7 new movies and TV shows on Netflix, Prime Video, HBO Max and more this weekend (January 20)

Catch That '90s Show, Violent Night, Accused and more Read more »

Valve Index 2: rumors, predictions and what we want from the VR headset

What could the Valve Index 2 bring to VR? Read more »

MacBook Air 2023 could be faster and sleeker with new M3 chip

null A MacBook Air with M3 chip will be unleashed on the world by Apple in the second half of 2023, if a new rumor is to be believed. As ... Read more »

2023 Alfa Romeo Tonale PHEV: full pricing and specs revealed

Italian brand’s striking compact SUV is now on sale with a petrol-powered mild- or plug-in hybrid powertrain Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra: latest rumors and everything we know so far

null The Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra has the potential be one of the best phones of 2023, and there’s not long to wait for it, as Samsung is set to ... Read more »

Octopath Traveler 2’s Latest Trailer Teases Branching Stories, Side Quests, & 2 New Playable Characters

Square Enix pulled back the curtain on its fast-approaching and much-anticipated retro-styled RPG, Octopath Traveler 2, in a brand new trailer today. The freshly-revealed footage introduces players to two new ... Read more »

You People Review — Mind the Generational Gap

Despite having heavy subject matter such as generational trauma and biases, You People pleasantly paints itself with a comedy lens, making for a witty yet topical film full of laughs. ... Read more »

You can now get ChatGPT on a Linux desktop

null ChatGPT is now available as an extension for your Linux laptop or desktop, but it’s early days and some things may not work as you might expect. The AI ... Read more »

JBL Quantum Stream Dual Pattern USB mic review: best for novice streamers

Beginner streamers will love the JBL Quantum Stream Read more »

11 Horror Game Moments That Are So Ridiculous It’s Funny

The feelings of tension and dread that horror games can produce in players are perhaps more visceral than anything else in the industry. When a spooky game is firing on ... Read more »

Shape Island squares the circle: It’s stop-motion perfection for kids and parents [Apple TV+ review]

★★★★★ Minor problems deliver major entertainment in excellent new stop-motion animation series Shape Island. on Apple TV+. Image: Apple TV+ Shape Island arrives on Apple TV+ today to teach kids ... Read more » review

On a budget? This host is seriously cheap, but beware - it has some unexpected costs Read more »

PayPal confirms data breach, sends warning emails to users

null PayPal has issued a warning to some of its customers that their accounts have been breached, and some sensitive data compromised. In its report, the company confirmed that on ... Read more »

Will 5G Make Me Use More Cellular Data?

Joe Fedewa / How-To Geek 5G is the latest and (supposedly) greatest wireless standard. With speeds that can sometimes rival home internet, you may be wondering if using 5G means ... Read more »

Sony adds 13 more games that will come to PS VR2 on February 22: Read on to know more

Sony unveiled the PS VR2 gaming console including the PS VR2 sense controllers, PS VR2 headset, and charging station in November 2022. The company had confirmed that the PS VR2 ... Read more »

5 Ways to Download a Browser on Windows Without a Browser

Downloading another web browser is one of the first tasks many people do on a new Windows PC, usually with the built-in copy of Microsoft Edge or Internet Explorer. However, ... Read more »

PS5 Slim: when will we see a smaller, lighter PlayStation 5?

A PS5 Slim is coming, it's just a matter of when Read more »

End of an era: Microsoft will soon stop selling Windows 10 licences

null Microsoft has announced that it will officially cease sales of Windows 10 licenses through its website on January 31, marking an end of sorts to the reign of the ... Read more »

Spotify could soon match Amazon Music Unlimited's untimely price hike

null Just when you thought your subscription bills couldn’t get any bigger, Amazon has announced a price increase for its Music Unlimited streaming service – and it could sadly point to ... Read more »

Simple One Electric Scooter New Factory – First Photos From Production Line

With figures like 72 Nm torque, 300+ km range from a single charge and up to 6.4 kWh battery, Simple Energy EV has a lot of potential Simple One Electric ... Read more »

Ransomware is getting less lucrative as victims stop paying

null The amount of money cybercriminal groups extorted through ransomware attacks is down 40% year-on-year, suggesting that businesses are increasingly refusing to pay to get their sensitive data back. A ... Read more »

I really hope this Nvidia RTX 4060 Ti GPU performance rumor is fake

Frame rate shifting powers to only be equivalent to the RTX 3070? Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự