SA football must create it's own identity for success

sa football must create it's own identity for success
© Provided by Independent Online (IOL)

Durban – If South Africa wants to develop in a football sense, it needs to create its own identity rather than trying to emulate systems from Europe and South America.

Yes, Europe and South America have won all the men’s World Cups so far and generally are far more successful than SA when it comes to development. But trying to copy systems from those continents will not work as SA has its own set of nuances which are unique and require their own systems.

Trying to emulate other models in SA actually may harm our football and this could be happening at the moment. In

SA, the reality is that players of 26 and 27 are still considered relatively young and still developing while in Europe and South America, players at this stage of their careers should be at the peak of their powers without much room for improvement.

This is not the fault of SA footballers, as they are victims of a system which has negatively impacted upon their development as players. By watching the South African Premiership and comparing it to the top five leagues across Europe, one notices that players in SA typically still often execute basics of the game such as structured passing, transition play and shooting woefully wrong. Mamelodi Sundowns are the exempt team from these misdoings and hence have been dominating SA football for the best part of the last decade.

The harsh reality is that a team from England’s League One (third tier of English football) would probably perform relatively well in the South African Premiership if they were pitted against top-flight teams in SA.

One thing that SA can do to aid the development of players in the short term is to completely remove age restrictions surrounding the GladAfrica Championship and Diski Challenge.

While the purpose of having the age restrictions in place is an attempt to give younger players an opportunity, it is misguided according to the nuances of SA football. Many players who could continue to refine their games, but who still make basic errors and cannot be fielded in these games are being denied an opportunity to hone their craft.

Inequality also remains a major issue in SA and most professional footballers typically do not come from well-off homes. This is yet another reason why development systems used in Europe will not work in SA. It is only well-off individuals in

SA, who are a small percentage of the population as a whole, who would be able to afford sending their kids to elite football academies from the age of five and six.

Unlike SA, the US realised it would have to develop its own independent men’s football system and even created a league without relegation. Today they are ranked an impressive 15th in the Fifa rankings.

News Related


What next for Serena Williams as she loses in the first round of Wimbledon?

© PA Images Serena Williams waves farewell to Wimbledon Serena Williams is facing fresh questions over her future in tennis after her much-hyped comeback ended with a thrilling first round ... Read more »

Eight-year-old boy found in sewer after missing from home for eight days

© Oldenburg Police Police had searched for eight days for the boy who was eventually found in a sewer An eight-year-old boy missing from home in Germany for over a ... Read more »

King County voters to decide on moving local elections to even-numbered years on November ballot

© Karen Ducey RENTON, WA – NOVEMBER 03: Unopened ballots await processing at the King County Elections headquarters on November 3, 2020 in Renton, Washington. Washington state is on track ... Read more »

US ramps up monkeypox vaccination campaign, releasing 56,000 doses

© Cynthia S. Goldsmith This undated electron microscopic handout image provided by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention depicts a monkeypox virion US health authorities said Tuesday they were ... Read more »

Justice for Marikana community suffers a blow after activist gunned down at her front door

The unfinished business of justice for the community of Marikana after the massacre there 10 years ago has been dealt a devastating blow by the murder of a community activist. ... Read more »

PowerBall dividends: Check those tickets! We have a R33 million winner

A lucky player hit the PowerBall PLUS jackpot in Tuesday night’s draw. The prize for the PowerBall draw keeps growing and will be worth even more on Friday, 1 July ... Read more »

Fiery crash at Vancouver’s Pearson Field kills pilot of small plane

© Mark Graves/ Southwest Washington news from The Oregonian/OregonLive. A pilot died early Tuesday in a fiery crash on the runway at Pearson Field in Vancouver, the Federal Aviation Administration ... Read more »

'Stacks of bodies': Death toll rises to 51 after migrants found in tractor-trailer in San Antonio

At least 51 suspected migrants have died and several others are hospitalized with heat-related injuries after being found Monday evening in a sweltering, abandoned tractor-trailer on a rural San Antonio road, officials said ... Read more »

Dame Deborah James' incredible life and work as she dies aged 40

© Provided by Metro Dame Deborah James has died at the age of 40 (Picture: Bowel Cancer UK; Rex; @bowelbabe) Dame Deborah James has been hailed as an ‘inspiration’ following ... Read more »

Las automotrices fueron al Congreso y pidieron apoyo para la Ley Autopartista

© Argentina Adefa Congreso Comision Industria “Para radicar una nueva plataforma en Argentina se necesitan inversiones por más de 600 millones de dólares”, dijo el presidente de Adefa La ... Read more »

'That's So Raven's T'Keyah Crystal Keymáh on Returning as Tanya Baxter After More Than 16 Years (Exclusive)

Mama Baxter is home! That’s So Raven alum T’Keyah Crystal Keymáh makes her anticipated return as Tanya Baxter on the Disney Channel series, Raven’s Home, after more than 16 years — and the actress ... Read more »

Trump tried to grab steering wheel to join supporters at the Capitol on Jan. 6, witness

© Jose Luis Magana, AP Donald Trump tried to grab the steering wheel of his presidential limousine on Jan. 6, 2021, when his security detail declined to take him to the ... Read more »

From rock stars to obscurity – searching for lost Thoroughbreds

Thoroughbred horses are bred to be specialised athletes. They’re microchipped, have long pedigrees and the National Horse Racing Association says it tracks their life and retirement. But what happens when ... Read more »

Google's new California offices bank on in-person work

© NOAH BERGER Google has opened a new campus in Silicon Valley Roofs coated with canopy-like solar panels and indoor spaces awash in sunlight: Google has bet big on in-person ... Read more »

Zondo let the State Capture bankers off the hook

How did the State Capture network move billions of rand stolen from the South African people across the globe? The Zondo Commission report provides some of the details of the ... Read more »

Nigeria’s Consul-General steps in as Operation Dudula truce falls apart in Orange Grove

An uneasy truce struck between Operation Dudula and foreign shop owners in Orange Grove, Johannesburg, has fallen apart. The Consul-General of Nigeria has now acted to assist his country’s nationals. ... Read more »

Report finds some improvement at Mpumalanga clinics, but serious challenges remain

The community-led clinic monitoring project Ritshidze last week released its follow-up report on the state of (primary) healthcare in Mpumalanga. There were some improvements, but patients are still waiting for ... Read more »

Heroic Destroyer USS Samuel B. Roberts Is Now the Deepest Wreck Ever Discovered

An underwater expedition has discovered the final resting place of the destroyer escort USS Samuel B. Roberts. Samuel B. Roberts was sunk in the Battle off Samar, one of the ... Read more »

Jerry Pillay, SA academic labelled by some as ‘anti-Jewish’, elected to top World Council of Churches job

The University of Pretoria’s Dean of Theology and Religion, Jerry Pillay, will be leaving to take up the post of general secretary of the World Council of Churches in Geneva. ... Read more »

Premier David Makhura ‘will respond’ to Gauteng hospital crisis as more doctors speak out

Gauteng Premier David Makhura has told Maverick Citizen that the Gauteng Cabinet’s Provincial Executive Committee will on Tuesday discuss a report on the state of hospitals in the province. He ... Read more »

ConCourt rules Communications Minister Ntshavheni’s digital migration deadline was unlawful

Minister of Communications Khumbudzo Ntshavheni did not consult telecommunications, broadcasting and civil society players about South Africa’s decision to migrate from analogue to digital broadcasting on 30 June 2022. And ... Read more »

Motorists ‘pop pills’ into petrol tanks in a bid to save fuel: Is it safe? – WATCH

© Provided by The South African Crippling petrol price hikes in recent months have seen South African motorists take matters into their own hands in a desperate bid to save ... Read more »

Timo Werner to Liverpool talk resurrected as pundit reveals how Jurgen Klopp can save Chelsea man

© PA Images Timo Werner celebrates goal v Southampton Jurgen Klopp is being tipped to revisit Liverpool interest in Timo Werner as he looks to bring in a potential replacement ... Read more »

Hyundai Ioniq 6 pics show a concept car come to life

The transition from concept to production car so often is greeted with the sound of a sad trombone as the pesky realities of packaging, regulations and budget get in the ... Read more »

Amcu’s Mathunjwa has a strong message for Sibanye ahead of wage talks

Amcu president Joseph Mathunjwa has a message for Sibanye-Stillwater ahead of wage talks with the company’s platinum unit: after four meetings if there is no deal in sight, the union ... Read more »

Laura Prepon Recalls Deciding to Terminate Her Pregnancy: 'I Had the Choice'

© Arturo Holmes/Getty Images Laura Prepon is speaking out on the heels of the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, saying that though she once made the tough decision to ... Read more »

‘No problem is insurmountable’ — Dr Imtiaz Sooliman on Nelson Mandela Bay’s Day Zero

With his ‘can-do’ attitude and trademark energy, Gift of the Givers’ Dr Imtiaz Sooliman has brought some hope to Nelson Mandela Bay — a city torn apart by political bickering ... Read more »

Haas braced for ‘very tough month’ ahead in Formula 1

© PA Images Kevin Magnussen going round a corner. Mick Schumacher has said Haas are bracing themselves for a tough month of July as we hit one of the busiest ... Read more »

Bass on The Move

The old saw has it that striped bass arrive when the lilacs bloom. That was mostly directed at Cape Cod. However, since lilacs bloom progressively up the coast, it is ... Read more »

German man leaves severed human head at courthouse

© (photo credit: JPOST STAFF) Breaking news German police on Tuesday said they detained a man suspected of leaving a human head in front of the Bonn district court. A ... Read more »

Direct presidential elections won’t prevent another ‘Zuma’ presidency — there are better ways of doing it

If Chief Justice Raymond Zondo really wants to fix South Africa’s electoral and governance systems for the betterment of South African citizens, then the real culprit he should be targeting ... Read more »

There are more new jobs in SA, but fewer are full-time

© Provided by 702 @ ibreaker213/ More people are being employed in part-time jobs rather than full-time, according to the Quarterly Employment Statistics for the first quarter of 2022 (QES, ... Read more »

Eskom strike appears to be over after unions call on workers to ‘normalise the situation’

The Numsa and NUM unions have called on workers to ‘normalise the situation’ after they said Eskom had agreed to return to the bargaining table. That is a transparent code ... Read more »

Cuba says it was in shootouts with boats heading to pick up migrants

© U.S. Border Patrol/U.S. Border Patrol/TNS Federal agents stand near a boat in shallow water off a remote island about 20 miles west of Key West, Florida, where 12 migrants ... Read more »

Survivor of South Africa Nightclub Tragedy — in Which at Least 21 Died — Says She Fainted Over 'Strong Smell'

© Provided by People STR/AFP via Getty Police and investigators at nightclub in East London on June 26, 2022 A survivor of the deadly nightclub tragedy in South Africa says ... Read more »

Man's warning after unknown lake creature 'drags three geese to their death'

© Owen Humphreys/PA Wire The birds were spotted bing pulled under the water by an unknown creature at Ullswater lake. A man has warned Lake District visitors to out of ... Read more »

Did you know San Antonio has a community tool shed with free equipment checkouts?

© Provided by mySA San Antonio offers a community tool shed with free equipment checkouts. Have a yard in need of weekend TLC? San Antonio has a community shed with ... Read more »

Second monkeypox case identified in SA, now in Western Cape

A case of monkeypox has been identified in Cape Town. This is the second confirmed case in South Africa. Both infected persons have no travel history, suggesting a high probability ... Read more »

Loose Pass: No harm in Quade Cooper-Marcus Smith chats and farewell to a New Zealand legend in the USA

© PA Images Loose-Pass-on-June-28-PA This week we will mostly be concerning ourselves with information exchange, triumphant finales and the return of the real July Tests… Not everything needs to be ... Read more »

Zendaya Is Stunning in 'Vogue Italia' -- See Tom Holland's Reaction

© Elizaveta Porodina/Vogue Italia Zendaya’s friends, fans and boyfriend are in absolute awe of her recent photo shoot for Vogue Italia. On Tuesday, the 25-year-old actress shared a series of ... Read more »