Rugby faces grassroots refereeing crisis over 'alarming' rise in abuse of officials

Rugby faces grassroots refereeing crisis over 'alarming' rise in abuse of officials
© TELEGRAPH Rugby faces grassroots refereeing crisis over ‘alarming’ rise in abuse of officials – TELEGRAPH

The behaviour of professional players and coaches is having a direct effect on the “alarming” rise of abuse of officials at grassroots level, according to English rugby’s top referee officials.

Last week, the Rugby Football Union’s disciplinary hearings handed out two lengthy bans for separate incidents of referees being shoulder barged on the pitch by players. Another recent case includes a 17-year-old referee claiming the adult coach of a youth team threatened to “smash [his] head in” after sending him off. 

This concerning treatment of grassroots referees is what prompted Mike Priestley, the chair of the Rugby Football Referees’ Union, to submit a letter to Anthony Watson’s disciplinary hearing last week. 

While cases of physical confrontation are mercifully rare, Priestley’s growing fear is that the recent high-profile examples of elite referees being abused, whether on social media or on the pitch, are now permeating through a sport that is already struggling with referee numbers. 

“Since the restart of rugby when the pandemic restrictions eased there has been a growth in the reporting of incidents (of abuse of officials),” Priestley told Telegraph Sport. “It’s alarming. That’s the reason we wanted to make a stance early so we can get on top of the issue before it becomes a substantial problem.

“If you see Premier League footballers surrounding a referee in a high-profile game then undoubtedly you would see that on the back pitches in your local park. What we wanted to say to RFU discipline from a referee union perspective and on behalf of our members in the county societies is an acknowledgment is that those behaviours, which are not aligned to the sport’s core values, when seen at the higher levels of the sport will have an impact at the lower levels of the sport.”

“The majority of people involved in officiating are volunteers. We are trying to recruit and retain enough match officials to service the game at a local level. Their enjoyment of the game is just as important as the players and coaches. 

“We want to avoid things that will have an impact on our ability to recruit and retain those referees. I personally think just by having it acknowledged, having it recognised and dealt with at all levels and making sure those people who are impacted by it are made aware of the consequences of people’s actions is really key.”

Priestley’s opinion is echoed by Michael Patz, the RFU’s match official development manager, who says high-profile players must be aware of the example their actions set. 

“I would say they are in the public eye and their behaviours are seen by everyone in the game and are replicated so really holding the core values of the game and understanding their responsibilities are really important,” Patz said.

“As someone involved in match official development, I don’t want to miss the next Wayne Barnes or the next Nigel Owens because he or she chooses not to take up the whistle for fear of the culture.”

Steep decline in refereeing numbers

His concerns have been heard by the Rugby Football Union who recently appealed against the leniency of a ban for referee abuse resulting in the suspension increasing from eight to 32 weeks. 

An RFU spokesperson said: “The RFU takes any allegation of abuse extremely seriously, which is why we directed for these cases to be heard by RFU disciplinary panels and they have taken swift action to impose significant sanctions.  

“The RFU publishes all judgments to increase awareness of the serious consequences of any behaviour that contradicts the core values of the game. Alongside regular work in the community game with clubs and Constituent Bodies, the RFU is working closely with PRL and its independent analysts to review player behaviours that could be considered against the values of the game.”

The ongoing issue of referee retention was brought into sharp focus by the pandemic. While the RFU were anticipating a drop in numbers when rugby resumed after an 18-month hiatus, they were shocked by the anecdotal evidence suggesting a much steeper decline. 

This was reinforced by a survey which showed a third of referees had not picked up a whistle in the first month after rugby resumed in September, which led to a number of grassroots games being postponed. 

“We had to go to plan D with the shortfall,” Patz said. “We had anticipated the extent of the drop off. We looked a various options to keep people engaged during the pandemic and the interactions were reasonable. We were caught on the back foot but you never know until you get there what people’s attentions are.”

Initiatives such as Keep Your Boots On, which encourages former players to stay involved in the game whether as a referee or a coach, have stemmed the losses. In the last five years, 4,711 referees have qualified through RFU courses. A follow-up survey of the referee society conducted last week showed 85 per cent of referees have now taken charge of a game. 

Recruitment and retention remain critical priorities for the RFU’s community department. After all if there is no referee, there is no game. “Now we need to work out how to engage them more and bring in the 15 per cent who have not refereed,” Patz said. 

“Referees want to enjoy their pastime and their voluntary engagement with rugby. Anything that undermines their ability to do that will be a concern.”

Being shouted at can send your self-worth through the floor but refereeing is a labour of love

By Neil Sweeney

For many that take up the whistle, it is a labour of love. I’m currently a level four referee, which means I oversee matches in the National Leagues. I was promoted to this level around Christmas in 2019 having formally retired from playing at Esher two years previously. I had refereed through work, as an RFU community coach and development officer, and just wanted to throw myself into it. I didn’t realise how much I would enjoy it.

For the first couple of years, I was doing 50 or 60 games per season. If you consider that the season is about 30 weeks long, that is two matches per week. Nothing will replace playing, which I really miss – especially the camaraderie and the away trips. But there is an element of control with refereeing and there is more to it than individual decisions. Going into it, I was pretty naïve to the concept of game management. I’m still learning about that and always will be.

Another strange side to it is the expectations of a referee, which links to the Rassie Erasmus episode. The expectation is that you are perfect and get everything right. Rugby union is pretty subjective and there is a lot going on. You can only see so much.

I have had three-hour journeys back home from games with one decision nagging at me until I saw it again on video. And I appreciate that I am lucky to get a video of my games. Lower down the levels, referees have to live with it and put it to bed. That is just one way in which you have to be resilient.

I feel like I got my mojo back last month but the previous two games I had not enjoyed for one reason or another – a busy week, preparation that wasn’t brilliant, travel. I did not have my best games and I knew it. When that happens, players can bicker among themselves and at you. 

I see it as an official’s job to uphold the game’s values, but it’s also up to coaches to coach them and players to know what behaviours are expected. I would say that it is easy to look at mistakes that referees make because they are easy targets.

With any decision, you have to place it in context with what has happened over the rest of the game. I don’t think the Rassie thing has helped any appetite to get into officiating, although there is the other side of the coin to think about. The persona of referees is changing. Some are mini-celebrities. Others have done punditry. Most of them will explain their decisions.

As a player, I preferred a referee I could work with but didn’t really notice. Being overly officious can negatively impact on the enjoyment of the game for everyone – coaches, players and referee. All in all, it’s a weird balancing act. And we cannot forget spectators. The reason that World Rugby is simplifying the law book is to make the sport more commercially attractive.

I can remember doing a game in and I just blew the arse off it. There were so many whistles, and I was fortunate enough to be able to have a chat with a fellow Hampshire referee afterwards. He said: ‘What’s changed?’ I think I’d lost my way a bit because I was thinking too much. When we reviewed it, we agreed that I should have given far fewer penalties, even though the ones I did award were technically accurate. That is what I mean about game management.

My first-ever fully-fledged league game took place on a lovely, sunny day. It went well. For 75 minutes. Then I switched off, and it descended into meltdown because I thought my job was done. That was an important lesson.

Some matches are great, and you can feel players are in tune with how you’re working. Others are characterised by players and coaches shouting at you for 80 minutes, and your self-worth goes through the floor. Then you figure out whether or not you can shake that off.

A number of colleagues have had high-impact decisions go the wrong way. They have fallen out of refereeing or had their progression halted because of brief moments in time. As a referee, you are clamouring for an opportunity at the next level. 

When you get there, you do not want to mess it up and that brings a different kind of pressure. At lower levels, players would ask ‘are you being assessed today?’ If the answer was ‘yes’, their faces would drop because they would know the referee would probably be nervous. All of those are challenges facing prospective officials, too.

I would like to take refereeing as far as I can but there is only so much space at the top. Most of the best in the country are very young, very driven and dedicate a lot of time to their fitness, physique, match preparation and reviews. It might turn out that I’m not good enough for that level anyway. Whatever happens, I am determined to keep enjoying it and I would recommend anybody thinking of trying it out to do so.

Sign up to the Front Page newsletter for free: Your essential guide to the day’s agenda from The Telegraph – direct to your inbox seven days a week.

News Related


Euro 2022 de handball : ce qu'il faut savoir sur la demi-finale France-Suède

L’équipe de France de handball affronte la Suède en demi-finales de l’Euro 2022, vendredi. © Fournis par franceinfo La France s’est sortie d’un sacré traquenard dans son dernier match décisif ... Read more »

Euro-2022 de hand : Après l'émotion, le défi suédois pour une finale

© Attila KISBENEDEK La joie des Français, après leur victoire, 30-29 face au Danemark, synonyme de qualification pour les demi-finales de l’Euro, le 26 janvier 2022 à Budapest L’équipe de ... Read more »

Konstmål av Zegras: "Jag hade tur"

© Graham Hughes/AP/TT Anaheims Trevor Zegras, mitten, firar sitt spektakulära mål. Anaheims unge trollgubbe, Trevor Zegras, svarade för ett konstmål i bortamatchen mot Montreal i NHL-ishockeyn. 20-åringen gjorde ett så ... Read more »

Lions are expecting nothing less than a tough, physical game, says Wandisile Simelane ahead of crunch Bulls URC clash

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Johannesburg – Despite any bluster that might be emanating from the two camps, you’d expect that both the Emirates Lions and the Bulls are ... Read more »

Super Rugby: Chiefs preparations on course for 2022

© PA Images Alex-Nankivell-celebrates-try-Chiefs-Super-Rugby-TT-2021-PA For a team that has suffered more on the injury front than most, the Chiefs look set to start the 2022 Super Rugby Pacific competition in ... Read more »

Willem II haalt drievoudig landskampioen transfervrij naar Nederland

© Aangeboden door Voetbalzone Willem II gaat zich versterken met Alexander Fransson, zo meldt De Telegraaf. De middenvelder gaat zich volgens het dagblad spoedig verbinden aan de Tilburgse club en ... Read more »

Voetbalminnend Amerika kijkt uit naar heuse titanenstrijd

© ProShots Voetbalminnend Amerika kijkt uit naar heuse titanenstrijd In de Noord-Amerikaanse WK-kwalificatiecyclus hebben topfavorieten Canada, de Verenigde Staten en Mexico vannacht geen fout gemaakt. Er wordt nu vooral uitgekeken ... Read more »

Tagliafico en Martínez genieten van prachtige treffer Di María

© ProShots Tagliafico en Martínez genieten van prachtige treffer Di María Argentinië, dat al zeker is van deelname aan het WK in Qatar, heeft vannacht in de Zuid-Amerikaanse kwalificatiecyclus Chili ... Read more »

Suárez beëindigt horrorreeks en houdt WK-hoop Uruguay levend

© ProShots Suárez beëindigt horrorreeks en houdt WK-hoop Uruguay levend Uruguay heeft vannacht een einde gemaakt aan een dramatische reeks in de WK-kwalificatiecyclus. Tegen Paraguay bewees Luis Suárez zich als ... Read more »

Le Mondial 2022 s'éloigne pour le Chili, battu par l'Argentine

L’Argentine, déjà qualifiée pour le Mondial 2022, n’a pas pour autant laissé filer son match face au Chili. © Di María Ángel On ne pourra pas accuser l’Albiceleste d’avoir ... Read more »

Mercato Inter, altro regalo in arrivo per Simone Inzaghi

© Fornito da La società nerazzurra mette a segno il secondo colpo in 24 ore. Il mercato delle ‘occasioni’, come lo ha sempre definito l’ad dell’Inter Beppe Marotta, porta ... Read more »

Rapid-Abgänge: "Pink wüsste, wo die Hütte steht"

© GEPA rapid Ercan Kara und Taxi Fountas verlassen Rapid, heuern in der US-Liga an. Ein schwerer Schlag für die Wiener? “Heute” fragte Fachmann Alfred Tatar. 21 Punkte Rückstand auf ... Read more »

Heute hebt Olympia-Team ab: Wer reist Business Class?

© GEPA, Austrian Airlines Abflug für unsere Olympia-Athleten Abflug für unsere Olympia-Athleten! Der Flieger nach Peking hebt heute in Wien ab. “Heute” hat alle Zahlen, Daten und Fakten zum Sonderflug. ... Read more »

Hypnose & Hexentanz! "Austrobob" verrät Gold-Geheimnis

© zVg Bob Fast jedes österreichische Kind fährt Bob. Benjamin Maier will als Bobpilot Olympiagold holen. “Heute” gab er Einblicke – in Hypnose und Hexentanz. Der “Austrobob” war nicht zu ... Read more »

Veldrijdster Brand begint zonder stress aan WK veldrijden

© ANP Veldrijdster Brand begint zonder stress aan WK veldrijden FAYETTEVILLE (ANP) – Haar overmacht dit seizoen in het veldrijden doet vermoeden dat Lucinda Brand zaterdag in het Amerikaanse Fayetteville ... Read more »

Le Canada de Buchanan toujours plus proche du Qatar, faux pas pour Murillo et le Panama

Les favoris de la zone CONCACAF se sont tous imposés cette nuit, mais le Panama a raté une belle occasion de s’isoler à la place de barragiste. © amir ... Read more »

Nadal verslaat Berrettini en is één zege verwijderd van 21e Grand Slam-titel

Rafael Nadal heeft vrijdag voor de zesde keer in zijn loopbaan de finale van de Australian Open bereikt. De Spanjaard was in vier sets te sterk voor Matteo Berrettini en is nu nog maar één zege verwijderd van zijn 21e Grand Slam-titel. Read more »

Why Teboho Mokoena turned down European offer in favour of Mamelodi Sundowns REVEALED!

© Provided by The South African Bafana Bafana international Teboho Mokoena has finally completed his move from SuperSport United to Mamelodi Sundowns.  READ | KAIZER CHIEFS CONFIRM HOW CLOSE THEY ... Read more »

Ashleigh Barty news: How Ben Crowe played a huge role in Barty's mental strength

© PA Images Ashleigh Barty celebrations World No 1 Ashleigh Barty has revealed the source of her mental strength following her success at the 2022 Australian Open. On Thursday Barty ... Read more »

Colombiaanse vloek? Trainingsmaatje en ploeggenoot Bernal na crash in zelfde ziekenhuis opgenomen

© André van den Ende Colombiaanse vloek? Trainingsmaatje en ploeggenoot Bernal na crash in zelfde ziekenhuis opgenomen Het zit INEOS niet mee… We zijn net een beetje van de schrik ... Read more »

Daily Schmankerl: FC Barcelona closer to Bayern Munich raid; Manchester City ousts Bayern in transfer battle; Niko Kovac won't go to Everton; Bernd Leno to Newcastle United?; Manchester United's Donny van de Beek to Crystal Palace?; and MORE!

© Photo by Matthew Ashton – AMA/Getty Images Barca closing in on Bayern prospect (Sport1) FC Barcelona is reportedly closing in on acquiring Bayern Munich youth prospect Kenan Yildiz: The ... Read more »

Argentinië wint mét Tagliafico en Martínez: ‘We kregen niet eens water'

© Aangeboden door Voetbalzone Argentinië heeft donderdagavond lokale tijd een zwaarbevochten overwinning in en tegen Chili afgedwongen. Het WK-kwalificatieduel in Calama eindigde in 1-2 dankzij onder meer een schitterend doelpunt ... Read more »

LeBron James, Kevin Durant named captains for NBA All-Star showcase

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Los Angeles – Los Angeles Lakers superstar LeBron James was named an NBA All-Star Game captain for the fifth-straight season on Thursday as the ... Read more »

Euro 2022 de handball : Guillaume Gille, le sélectionneur de l'équipe de France, positif au Covid-19

Les Bleus doivent affronter l’Islande, samedi, pour le deuxième match du tour principal du championnat d’Europe. © Fournis par franceinfo La loterie continue. Alors que les cas de Covid se ... Read more »

Palestre comunali chiuse per covid a Vercelli: ora le società sportive si alleneranno in quelle delle scuole superiori. Pala Piacco e Bertinetti “rimodulati”

Il Comune di Vercelli in collaborazione con la Provincia ha trovato una soluzione ai problemi di centinaia di atleti e baby atleti delle società sportive vercellesi che nel giro di ... Read more »

Covid, tutte le nuove regole per il rientro a scuola punto per punto: ecco cosa cambierà

Se c’è un positivo e sei alle elementari fatti i tamponi rapidi o molecolari. Se c’è un positivo alle medie e superiori mascherina Ffp2 e tamponi. Se hai due positivi ... Read more »

Favourite son Eto'o is pride of Cup of Nations host city Douala

© CHARLY TRIBALLEAU A statue of Samuel Eto’o in the green, yellow and red of Cameroon stands in the New Bell neighbourhood of Douala where he grew up Samuel Eto’o ... Read more »

Rohit Sharma returns to lead India on white ball series against West Indies

© PA Images India v England – 5th T20 International India have named their squads for the ODI and T20I series against the West Indies at home in February 2022. ... Read more »

Epic Games will list several top titles for free in 2022

Epic Games has been doing the gaming community a solid the past few years by distributing games like NBA 2K21, Control, Rise of the Tomb Raider, Civilization VI and even ... Read more »

76ers beat Lakers 105-87 as LeBron sits; Warriors top Wolves

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — Joel Embiid had 26 points and nine rebounds, leading the Philadelphia 76ers to a 105-87 victory over a Los Angeles Lakers team playing without LeBron James on ... Read more »

Diretta Berrettini-Nadal 0-2 (3-6/2-6). Terzo set: 4-3, Matteo gioca il miglior game del match e resta avanti

Berrettini-Nadal è la prima delle due seminfinali degli Australian Open. Il tennista italiano, dopo aver superato Gael Monfils, è a un match dalla seconda finale di uno slam della sua ... Read more »

Mazzù regrette les occasions manquées: "Sans un excellent Mignolet..."

Felice Mazzù était un coach déçu du résultat mais heureux de la prestation des siens ce jeudi soir au Jan Breydel. © Mazzu Union On attendait beaucoup de ce ... Read more »

Les Diables restent n°1 mondiaux : l'Équateur et le Brésil partagent au terme d'un match tendu

Cette nuit, le Brésil se déplaçait en Équateur et passait n°1 mondial en cas de victoire. Il n’en sera rien. La Belgique conserve donc encore ce statut, qui commence à ... Read more »

FC Nantes : Brest diminué pour le derby en Coupe de France

Le Stade Brestois pourrait avoir à composer sans deux cadres ce vendredi à l’occasion du 8e de finale de Coupe de France à Nantes. © Icon Sport Romain Faivre KO ... Read more »

Coupe du monde 2022: grâce à Suarez, l'Uruguay se relance pour la qualification

© BFMTV BFMTV L’Uruguay s’est remis dans la course à la qualification à la Coupe du monde 2022 en battant le Paraguay (1-0) pour se poster à la 4e place ... Read more »

Beijing Olympics: Rights groups call for diplomatic boycott

© Provided by DW A diplomatic boycott involves politicians and officials staying home while athletes compete at the Olympics An alliance of 243 human rights organizations and nongovernment organizations have ... Read more »

Angst voor besmetting onder olympiërs: 'Ik laat mijn zoontje elke keer testen'

De meeste Nederlandse olympiërs vertrekken woensdag richting China en zijn blij dat ze daarmee het risico om in Nederland een coronabesmetting op te lopen achter zich laten. Veel schaatsers zaten thuis in quarantaine of verblijven al weken in een hotelkamer. Read more »

Brazil's Alisson sees red twice but cards overturned in World Cup draw with Ecuador

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Quito, Ecuador – Brazil goalkeeper Alisson Becker had two red cards overturned by VAR reviews as Brazil hung on for a controversial 1-1 World ... Read more »

SuperSport United CEO slams Sipho Mbule! Gives reason why he won't join Kaizer Chiefs&

© Provided by The South African Kaizer Chiefs seems to have been dealt another huge transfer blow by SuperSport United this time with Sipho Mbule.  READ | UNHAPPY ORLANDO PIRATES ... Read more »

'Earn it': Chiefs boss issues message to new recruit Josh Ioane

Josh Ioane may be the headline recruit for the Chiefs leading into the new Super Rugby season, but the one-test All Blacks pivot won’t be receiving any special treatment from ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic