Roy Keane and Jamie Carragher debate shows Man City were right about Cristiano Ronaldo

Asia's Tech News Daily

Cristiano Ronaldo is only 15 games into his return to Manchester and is already showing why both City and United wanted to sign him in the summer.

When it looked like City were about to pull off a sensational late transfer window swoop for Ronaldo, United got wind and made sure he would return to Old Trafford, with Sir Alex Ferguson and Rio Ferdinand among the Old Trafford legends personally intervening to make the transfer happen.

Fast forward three months and Ronaldo has shown exactly why City were ready to break with their usual long-term transfer plans to sign a 36-year-old at the last minute.

Ronaldo has 10 goals in 15 appearances, winning seven points for United as a direct result of his goals. Without Ronaldo, United would have five fewer points in the Champions League and be staring at the Europa League. With him, they won the group with a game to spare.

In the Premier League, they’d be two places lower without Ronaldo’s goals, and he surely kept Ole Gunnar Solskjaer in his job for longer than he eventually got.

So why is there still an argument over Ronaldo’s suitability in United’s side? And why will City be watching on with their feet up relieved to have missed out on his signing?

If we ask Roy Keane and Jamie Carragher it’s still to do with Ronaldo’s infamous ‘lack’ of pressing, as well as United’s targets this season. Despite his ridiculous goals record and super-human ability to win games on his own in the last minute, Ronaldo is still coming in for criticism due to his supposed disruption to United’s balance.

So when caretaker manager Michael Carrick dropped Ronaldo to the bench for their 1-1 draw at Chelsea this weekend, it was inevitable that the Sky Sports studio would descend into a viral shouting match at full time.

This week, it was Keane and Carragher taking turns to shout louder than the other asking the same questions over and over to each other. The main gist of the ‘debate’ was that Keane felt Ronaldo’s goal record was justification for his lack of pressing in a game, while Carragher believed Ronaldo’s place on the bench was justified, and that if he wasn’t signed to win United the title this season then perhaps he wasn’t the best signing they could have made.

Both valid points, and it would be an interesting debate if conducted at a few decibels lower, and one exchange stood out in the clip that has been shared and shared in the last 24 hours.

Carragher asked: “Why did Man United sign Ronaldo in the first place? They signed him because he was about to sign for Man City. There was no plan to sign him. They signed him at the last minute.”

Keane replied: “Not to go to City but to come and sit on the bench?”

Carragher: “The United manager is allowed to put Cristiano Ronaldo on the bench,” to which Keane disagreed and the shouting continued.

It was the mention of City that has gone under the radar in the analysis of the ‘analysis’. Yes, City would have benefitted from Ronaldo’s presence and goals, just as United have, but imagine if Pep Guardiola had dared to put Ronaldo on the bench for a big game like a trip to Stamford Bridge.

At United, Ronaldo getting benched is a big story. At City, he would have to get used to it as a matter of course. He would also have to get used to pressing and playing for the team.

In fairness, Guardiola recently said Ronaldo and Lionel Messi are the only players in the world who can’t be managed, but there would still be a level of expectation for what Ronaldo would have had to do off the ball at City.

If Ronaldo stormed down the tunnel after every game as he is doing this season, that wouldn’t exactly go down well with a City support who adore their team collective that Guardiola has built.

And for all the talk of City’s lack of striker, every passing game this season is proof that maybe the decision to go without a ‘number nine’ this season was justified, as every player in the squad knows the system in their sleep — and that is enough to score goals whoever plays centrally.

There’s a fair argument that Ronaldo could have unbalanced that approach, as he’s showing at United. And the furore over every decision made surrounding Ronaldo at Old Trafford is another reminder to the bosses at City that they don’t need the drama that comes with someone like ‘CR7’. City are showing once again, that a cohesive unit is much more likely to return trophies than a team of individuals.

They’d of course take his goals, but the league table shows that maybe City have had a lucky escape with Ronaldo.

Sign up to our City newsletter so you never miss an update from the Etihad Stadium this s eason.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Irish Cabinet to consider recommendations to ease Covid-19 restrictions

The Irish Cabinet will meet later to consider recommendations from health chiefs to end most of the state’s Covid restrictions. It is understood that the National Public Health Emergency Team ... Read more »

Video: Traveller shares her sneaky 'disguised pillow' hack to avoid excess baggage charges on a plane - and ANYONE can do it  

Read more »

Banks lead the charge back to the office after work from home axed

Business giants began calling staff back to offices yesterday after Boris Johnson scrapped work-from-home guidance. Large banks, advertising firms and insurers announced plans to return to the office – although ... Read more »

Pioneering electric car battery plant gets £100m cash injection

Ministers have invested £100million in a pioneering electric car battery factory that will turbocharge Britain’s push to go green. Britishvolt’s £3.8billion plant in Blyth, Northumberland, will create 8,000 jobs in ... Read more »

Largely unvaccinated patients infected with Omicron continue to swamp WA hospitals

Omicron has not yet loosened its grip on hospitals in Washington, with Pierce and King counties taking the brunt of the case surge so far. That’s according to hospital officials ... Read more »

NFL Divisional Round prop bets: 49ers vs. Packers

© Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports Green Bay Packers wide receiver Davante Adams. The first NFC game in the Divisional Round will be Saturday night between San Francisco and Green Bay, ... Read more »

Bears complete interviews with Byron Leftwich, Reggie McKenzie on Thursday

The Chicago Bears are in the middle of their searches for a new general manager and head coach following the firings of Ryan Pace and Matt Nagy last week. © ... Read more »

Steve Kerr: I hope Andrew Wiggins makes the All-Star

Connor Letourneau: Steve Kerr on Andrew Wiggins’ All-Star candidacy: “I really, really hope he makes it. I think he deserves it.” © Provided by HoopsHype Source: Twitter @Con_Chron What’s the ... Read more »

Domantas Sabonis out for several games with ankle injury

Scott Agness: Sabonis will miss at least a few games with a left ankle sprain, Rick Carlisle says. Before tonight, he has only missed one game this season. © Provided ... Read more »

Lakers guard Kendrick Nunn urges patience from fans

One Los Angeles Lakers guard is asking fans for a virtue that they might not have right now. © Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports First-year Laker Kendrick Nunn, who has ... Read more »

Premier League top-four race hots up as Chelsea stumble

© Geoff Caddick Steven Bergwijn scored two last-gasp goals in Tottenham’s 3-2 win against Leicester Manchester City could move 14 points clear at the top of the Premier League on ... Read more »

Sharks at Kraken: Lines, how to watch & open thread

© Photo by Amanda Cain/NHLI The San Jose Sharks are taking a quick trip up to the Pacific Northwest tonight to take on the Seattle Kraken at the shiny new ... Read more »

Sage experts admit they got doom-laden forecast on Omicron wrong

Sage scientists have admitted their dire predictions of soaring Covid hospitalisations have ‘not been seen’ – as it was revealed that almost two-thirds of London patients with the virus were ... Read more »

Best fit for four intriguing NFL head coaching openings

© Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports Kansas City Chiefs offensive coordinator Eric Bieniemy. There are a lot of intriguing NFL head coaching vacancies out there right now. Let’s take a closer ... Read more »

Keir Starmer failing to convert Red Wall Tories, focus group suggests

Sir Keir Starmer appears to be failing to convince Tory voters in Red Wall seats to switch to Labour despite anger over the No10 party scandal. More In Common conducted ... Read more »

UK aid heading to Tonga to ease devastation caused by volcano and tsunami

UK-funded aid is heading to Tonga to help the relief effort following the devastating volcanic eruption and tsunami. The supplies, being sent on board HMAS Adelaide, of the Australian navy, ... Read more »

Annastacia Palaszczuk in brutal smackdown of reporter who asked her if she regrets opening the border to the rest of Australia

Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk gave snippy reply to a questionA reporter asked if she regretted re-opening the state's border after Omicron Drop in new Covid cases to 16,031 in Queensland but deaths rise to 13 peopleEligibility for booster jabs reduced to three months from second dose of vaccineQR code check-in will not be dropped, Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk said Ms Palaszczuk said millions of rapid antigen tests will shortly arrive in the state  Read more »

Lonzo Ball set for knee surgery, out for up to eight weeks

© Provided by SPIN.ph CHICAGO — Chicago Bulls guard Lonzo Ball will have arthroscopic surgery on his left knee and is expected to be out six to eight weeks, the ... Read more »

Sea of Thieves Pirate Emporium Update: Release Date, Patch Notes and More

The Sea of Thieves Pirate Emporium Event is now live in the game and we have all the information around the patch notes for this big update. The great pirate ... Read more »

Former All-Star Paul Millsap, Nets agree to part ways

© Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports Brooklyn Nets forward Paul Millsap. Four-time All-Star forward Paul Millsap is on the trade market, according to Shams Charania of The Athletic, after he and ... Read more »

So are YOU entitled to a payout? As a damning report says more than 100,000 pensioners were let down by the Government, how to find out if you have been short-changed

MPs warned retirees are still at risk of being denied the money they deserve Scandal affected women whose pensions should've been upgraded by the DWPWives entitled to 60% rate from day their husband reached state pension age  Read more »

E-scooters 'turn pavements into a jungle': Tory Baroness calls for urgent action over motorised devices and says they should be banned or face tough rules over use

The Government is considering whether to legalise e-scooters  Privately owned e-scooters are banned from roads, pavements and cycle pathsRental trials of e-scooters have taken place in cities across the country Read more »

Mikel Arteta resumes Pep Guardiola blueprint at Arsenal as Edu makes surprise bid for USMNT star

Arsenal’s potential sale of Bernd Leno has opened the door for the Gunners to repeat Manchester City’s Zack Steffen deal with the signing of New England Revolution goalkeeper, Matt Turner. ... Read more »

Erling Haaland pursuit could help Man City develop a superstar striker of their own

There is an element of ‘two passing ships’ about Manchester City’s failure to sign a striker last summer and the injury woes of young goalscoring prodigy Liam Delap. When Sergio ... Read more »

Non-Jewish US House reps form ‘Caucus for Advancement of Torah Values’

© (photo credit: Sruly Saftlas/CNW Group/Dirshu) The inauguration of the Congressional Caucus for the Advancement of Torah Values was attended by, from left to right, Rep. Kat Cammack; Rep. Don ... Read more »

''What a disgrace': Adele's fans furious as singer cancels concert

Adele on Thursday shocked and angered her fans by canceling her Caesar’s Palace Las Vegas residency at the last minute, leaving many stranded in the city out of pocket, and unsure ... Read more »

Emma Raducanu verdict: Rankings rise and what comes next for US Open champion

© PA Images Emma Raducanu applauding In the end, Emma Raducanu suffered a fate many predicted at the Australian Open, but this was not a failure on the grand scale. ... Read more »

Tom Brady Has Honest Admission On Rematch Vs. Rams

© Provided by The Spun Tom Brady and the Buccaneers on the field in Los Angeles. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers already faced the Log Angeles Rams, their opponent in Sunday’s ... Read more »

Podcast: Exploring the Patriots' paths to acquiring a WR1 for 2022

© Provided by Patriots Wire Mac Jones may not need an elite receiver. But it wouldn’t hurt. The New England Patriots rookie quarterback would benefit from that No. 1 wideout that ... Read more »

England to face Afghanistan in first round of T20 World Cup

© PA Archive England will begin their T20 World Cup against Afghanistan and Scotland have drawn a first-round match against the West Indies (Owen Humphreys/PA) – PA Archive England will ... Read more »

UFC 270 faceoff: Francis Ngannou, Ciryl Gane have first staredown at press conference

© File photo Ciryl gane vs Francis ngannou faceoff ufc 270 ANAHEIM, Calif. – Francis Ngannou and Ciryl Gane came face-to-face as opponents for the first time following Thursday’s UFC 270 ... Read more »

Soccer-Conte's Tottenham on a high ahead of trip to Chelsea

© Reuters/CRAIG BROUGH Premier League – Leicester City v Tottenham Hotspur By Martyn Herman LONDON (Reuters) – When Tottenham Hotspur manager Antonio Conte was asked what he was hoping for ... Read more »

Video: Radio host breaks down talking about Charlise Mutten's death after nine-year-old girl's body was found in a barrel 

Read more »

Video: France will introduce new vaccine passport rules for visitors to cafes and restaurants from next week while Austria moves one step closer to making vaccines compulsory as Omicron cases surge on the continent 

Read more »

Radio host breaks down talking about Charlise Mutten's death after nine-year-old girl's body was found in a barrel

Mark Geyer choked back tears on radio show while discussing Charlise MuttenTriple M host described schoolgirl's death as 'absolutely devastating' and unfair  Charlise's remains found in a barrel near the Colo River north-west of Sydney Read more »

49ers get great injury news heading into playoff matchup vs. Packers

The San Francisco 49ers got a great bit of injury news prior to their playoff matchup against the Green Bay Packers.  © Provided by Fansided After the San Francisco 49ers ... Read more »

Bills' Josh Allen reveals what Bill Belichick told him after playoff blowout

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen admitted he got some high praise from Bill Belichick after dismantling the New England Patriots. © Jamie Germano / USA TODAY NETWORK Bills quarterback Josh ... Read more »

Another Raiders star gives his vote for Rich Bisaccia to be head coach

Las Vegas Raiders defensive end Maxx Crosby said he would vote for Rich Bisaccia to be the team’s permanent head coach. © Provided by Fansided The Las Vegas Raiders are ... Read more »

Hundreds of combat ready British troops could be sent to Ukraine's Nato neighbours to bolster security forces amid threat of Russian invasion

NATO talks held on bolstering presence in Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and PolandBritain already has 830 troops in Estonia where it is leading 1,200-strong groupThere are also 140 troops in Poland and a further 100 stationed in UkraineBut the MoD is in discussions to increase British presence further amid escalating tension in the region, with 127,000 Russia troops station near Ukraine  Read more »

Cotswolds Tory chief is forced out by 'bullies' as she pushes for probe into 'venal behaviour'

Diana MacKenzie-Charrington forced to quit role due to 'outfight bullying'She was chairman of the Cotswolds Conservative Association in WiltshireLeaked letter sent to more than 1,200 members says she will report behaviourShe claimed the ‘senior long-standing minority’ were guilty of ‘venal behaviours' Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic