RIP, Angelo Codevilla, the conservative thinker who took on the ruling class

 									conservatives								,  									donald trump								,  									ideas								,  									republicans

Angelo Codevilla was a senior fellow at the Claremont Institute. Gage Skidmore

Donald Trump’s election in 2016 caught most intellectuals by surprise — and not least conservative intellectuals.

The right-of-center editors, columnists and think-tankers who had sung hymns to democracy promotion overseas had overlooked what was going on at home: how Big Tech and the HR department had worked around the Bill of Rights; how democracy had been usurped by judges and bureaucrats who, regardless of party affiliation, failed to reverse the assault against family, country and faith; and how nation-building abroad had consumed treasure and blood while whole swaths of America fell into what Trump memorably called “American carnage.”

One rare exception to the general cluelessness of the right-wing intelligentsia was Angelo Codevilla, a senior fellow at the Claremont Institute and former professor of international relations at Boston University who died this week in a car accident, aged 78.

Far from being surprised by the Trump phenomenon, he predicted its broad outlines in a 2010 essay for The American Spectator, read on air by the late Rush Limbaugh. In it, Codevilla observed that Americans could no longer maintain the pretense of being equal citizens. They were now aware of being divided into two classes, rulers and ruled — a court party clustered around universities, urban hubs and the government bureaucracy lording over an unorganized country party attached to habits and regions that history seemed to have passed by.

 									conservatives								,  									donald trump								,  									ideas								,  									republicans

Protesters dance together outside of the White House on a section of Black Lives Matter Plaza on July 4, 2020.

Maya Alleruzzo/AP

Codevilla’s language was startling. He insisted that understanding America required speaking of class, a challenge to the long-standing idea that America, unlike the Old World, wasn’t a class-based society. He informed voters who thought of themselves as “conservatives” that they stood on the outside of the established order. Insofar as they opposed the assembly of billionaires, mega-firms, NGOs, universities and government agencies that run the country, they were revolutionaries.

When the essay first appeared, some deemed Codevilla’s analysis too extreme. A radical by nature, he often seemed to go two steps too far. But events usually caught up with him.

Anyone who doubted that America was unfree had only to observe the extraordinary censorship of this newspaper’s reporting on the Hunter Biden Files. Those who disliked the claim that America was divided between the rulers and the ruled had only to observe the way doctors and elected leaders cheered on Black Lives Matter protests as essential to public health while denouncing Orthodox Jewish funerals for spreading COVID.

What explained Codevilla’s farsightedness? Part of it was biography. Born in Italy, Codevilla served in the US Navy and as a foreign-service officer before becoming a staffer for the Senate’s Select Committee on Intelligence. On that committee, he observed up-close the workings of what would one day be called the Deep State. This experience, along with his study of Machiavelli, made it difficult to harbor illusions about those who wield power in America.

 									conservatives								,  									donald trump								,  									ideas								,  									republicans

Angelo Codevilla was not surprised but former President Trump’s rise.

Evan Vucci/AP

A Catholic, he was disinclined to sympathize with the internationalist, post-WASP ethos of the Central Intelligence Agency. He saw how its biases made it hostile to certain forces at home and abroad, notably conservatives and Israel. He protested the treatment of Jonathan Pollard, a US intelligence analyst who passed secrets to the Israelis. Codevilla acknowledged that Pollard had done wrong, but argued that the sentence — life in prison — was far in excess of what the crime merited. Later, he showed similar independence of mind in questioning the police killing of Ashli Babbitt on Jan. 6.

Codevilla was notable above all for his intellectual courage. Unlike most thinkers on the left and the right, he was willing to go where his logic led him. He was far from the only writer to offer a radical critique of contemporary society, but he was one of the few who were willing to discuss solutions equal to the problems he claimed to see. As he pointed out, leaders of a movement opposed to the power elite must be prepared to do un-conservative things, including “fostering and leading campaigns of civil disobedience.”

Most public intellectuals outlive their influence. They die long after their insights have faded. That wasn’t Angelo Codevilla’s fate. His work, embodied not just in his famous essays, but in many learned books, has never been more relevant. Intellectually, he died in the strength of his years.

Matthew Schmitz is senior editor of First Things.

Twitter: @MatthewSchmitz

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


French fishermen deem UK ‘too timid' to resolve post-Brexit licence row

France is disappointed by the pace of negotiations with Britain on settling a row about post-Brexit fishing rights but talks are set to continue on Monday, the head of a ... Read more »

Andrew Lloyd Webber almost wrote a James Bond-themed musical, his longtime collaborator says

Musical theatre composer Andrew Lloyd Webber pictured earlier this year – Rii Schroer Andrew Lloyd Webber nearly wrote a James Bond-themed musical instead of Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, ... Read more »

Armorer, assistant director in focus of Baldwin movie set shooting probe

Alec Baldwin fires prop gun on movie set, killing cinematographer By Barbara Goldberg (Reuters) -As law enforcement investigates the fatal shooting of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins by actor Alec Baldwin ... Read more »

Crew member who gave Baldwin gun subject of prior complaint

1 / 8Prop Firearm Movie SetThe Bonanza Creek Film Ranch is seen in Santa Fe, N.M., Saturday, Oct. 23, 2021. An assistant director unwittingly handed actor Alec Baldwin a loaded ... Read more »

Tua Tagovailoa's touchdown throw puts Dolphins up early

© Provided by NBC Sports Tua Tagovailoa surely has heard the Deshaun Watson-to-Miami talk. Whether a deal is close or not, the Dolphins starting job belongs to Tagovailoa for now. ... Read more »

Calls to ban guns on movie sets grow after Baldwin shooting

Calls were multiplying in Hollywood Sunday to ban the use of firearms on movie sets, three days after actor Alec Baldwin fatally shot cinematographer Halyna Hutchins in a shocking on-set ... Read more »

Barcelona vs. Real Madrid result: El Clasico goes to Real on goals by Alaba and Vasquez

Real Madrid is simply a cut above FC Barcelona this year. The Merengues went into the Camp Nou and showed their class in a 2-1 El Clasico win, scoring first ... Read more »

Angelina Jolie Embodies Classic Elegance in a One-Shoulder Dress & Platforms for ‘Eternals' Rome Premiere

© Stefano Costantino / MEGA AJolie Angelina Jolie was the epitome of elegance while hitting the red carpet for the premiere of her new film, “Eternals,” at the Rome Film ... Read more »

Is This $30 L'Oreal Paris Eye Serum the Next Viral TikTok Eye Cream?

© L’Oreal Paris. One of the most sensitive areas on the face is the skin around the eyes and we always want to give this spot a little extra TLC, ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin seen consoling family of slain cinematographer as set problems mount

Vigil for cinematographer Halyna Hutchins in Albuquerque By Lisa Richwine SANTA FE, N.M. (Reuters) – Alec Baldwin has been seen consoling the family of the cinematographer he accidentally killed on ... Read more »

Striking bourbon workers scheduled to vote on new contract

Kentucky Bourbon Producer-Strike (Lexington Herald-Leader/Silas Walker) Striking workers at one of the world's largest bourbon producers are scheduled to vote on a new contract on Saturday, a day after announcing ... Read more »

Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe's husband goes on hunger strike

Richard Ratcliffe, the husband of Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe, in Westminster last year – PA The husband of Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe has gone on hunger strike for the second time in two years ... Read more »

Liverpool fans went into savage mode with 'Ole's at the wheel' chant during 5-0 win v Man Utd

Manchester United were humiliated by Liverpool on Sunday afternoon. © GiveMeSport Oh dear, Ole… Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s side went into the game on the back of an epic 3-2 comeback ... Read more »

T20 World Cup 2021: All-round Pakistan Thrash India by 10 Wickets in Dubai

© Provided by News18 T20 World Cup 2021: All-round Pakistan Thrash India by 10 Wickets in Dubai India vs Pakistan, Highlights, T20 World Cup 2021 Match Latest Updates: Pakistan openers ... Read more »

"I expect Villa to be in the market for..." – Ashley Preece drops huge AVFC transfer admission

Journalist Ashley Preece expects Aston Villa to try and strengthen their goalkeeping department next summer. © GiveMeSport p1fibulq8fda51mualch5ma1hagf.jpg Jed Steer has been with the club for more than eight years ... Read more »

Charith Asalanka: ‘I backed myself to play my natural game'

The hero of Sri Lanka’s incredible run chase in the T20 World Cup Super 12s match against Bangladesh, Charith Asalanka, says that the freedom to play his natural game was ... Read more »

New York life-saving drug saved boy, 5, with rare cancer

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A boy aged five who went to New York for a potentially life-saving vaccine after his family raised more than £232,000 is now ... Read more »

Manchester United vs Liverpool result: Mohamed Salah scores hat-trick in humiliating rout

Imagine if Liverpool had actually played well. As such, it would be hard to imagine any other outcome than Ole Gunnar Solskjaer losing his job – except this is Manchester ... Read more »

Scottish Cup: Falkirk and Raith Rovers grudge match plus two all-Championship ties in third round draw

Falkirk and Raith Rovers will play out a Scottish Cup grudge match after being drawn amongst the 20 ties in the competition’s third round. © The Scottish Cup trophy is ... Read more »

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's Manchester United future under the spotlight - have your say

Manchester United suffered humiliation at the hands of Liverpool, in their worst defeat at Old Trafford for many years. After steady progress in previous seasons, manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has ... Read more »

Watch: Paddleboarders rescued near Portobello Beach amid 'changing weather conditions'

© Two paddleboarders were caught out by a change in the weather conditions near Portobello Beach. Pict… The Royal National Lifeboat Institution (RNLI) was called into action when one of ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin shooting – latest: Halyna Hutchins's father says actor ‘not responsible' for death

© AP PRI206526027.jpg LIVE – Updated at 18:24 Hundreds have attended a vigil for cinematographer Halyna Hutchins in Albuquerque, New Mexico — not far from the Rust film set in ... Read more »

Katastrophe in Zeitlupe: Schon fünf Wochen Vulkanausbruch auf La Palma

Der Vulkanausbruch auf der Kanareninsel La Palma ist auch am Sonntag mit unverminderter Heftigkeit weitergegangen. Seit dem 19. September spuckt der bisher namenlose Feuerberg in der Cumbre Vieja im Süden ... Read more »

Zur Weltklimakonferenz COP26: Queen will noch immer nach Glasgow reisen

Trotz gesundheitsbedingter Ruhepause und einem kurzen Aufenthalt im Krankenhaus will Königin Elizabeth II. (95) einem Bericht zufolge noch immer Anfang November zur Klimakonferenz nach Glasgow reisen. © Bereitgestellt von Blick ... Read more »

NHS maternity services near breaking point, warns top doctor

Photograph: UK Stock Images Ltd/Alamy The NHS could soon be unable to deliver “the care it needs to” for women giving birth if the surge in Covid cases continues, the ... Read more »

Labour accuses Sunak of ‘smoke and mirrors' budget due to lack of new money

Labour has accused Rishi Sunak of presiding over a “smoke and mirrors” budget after he conceded that just 20% of his biggest single spending commitment unveiled before the speech is ... Read more »

Democrats weigh changes in filibuster to pass voting rights legislation after GOP opposition

WASHINGTON – After another failed vote to advance voting rights legislation last week, Democratic lawmakers are debating the merits changes in the filibuster rule that many in the party see as ... Read more »

Liverpool's Salah sends social media into meltdown after breaking Drogba's record

Mohamed Salah sent Twitter into a frenzy after breaking Didier Drogba’s record against Manchester United to become the highest-scoring African in Premier League history. Following his effort in Liverpool’s 5-0 ... Read more »

‘I don't agree' – Santo rejects suggestions that Spurs lack creativity

Tottenham Hotspur boss Nuno Espirito Santo rejected suggestions that his team lack creativity in midfield after their defeat to West Ham United. © PA Images Tottenham-boss-Nuno-Espirito-Santo-2 Spurs faced their London ... Read more »

Andy Robertson in 'ruthless' Liverpool message as he takes no prisoners in Manchester United thrashing

It might have been Mo Salah who grabbed the headlined for Liverpool with his stunning hat-trick against Manchester United. But Scotland skipper Andy Robertson also showed just what makes him ... Read more »

Aston Villa fans pile in on Man Utd misery as Liverpool run riot

Aston Villa fans watched Manchester United ship four goals in the first half of their Premier League clash against Liverpool, as Jurgen Klopp’s side ran riot at Old Trafford this ... Read more »

Manchester United player ratings: Harry Maguire and Luke Shaw awful vs Liverpool

David de Gea Exposed time and again by dire defending and could do little about the goals. Saved well from Trent Alexander-Arnold – at 5-0. 5 Aaron Wan-Bissaka A defensive ... Read more »

Watch: Man Utd's Cristiano Ronaldo avoids red after kicking out at Jones

Manchester United endured a shocking first half against Liverpool, conceding four goals and being run ragged by incessant counter-attacks – this wasn’t what Cristiano Ronaldo returned to the club for. ... Read more »

Ivy League admits officiating error cost Harvard a game-winning score in Princeton's 5OT win

Harvard should have beaten Princeton on Saturday. Princeton is officially recognized as the 2021 winner of the annual rivalry game after Jacob Birmelin caught a two-point conversion pass in the ... Read more »

Titans' Derrick Henry Tosses TD Pass vs. Chiefs

© Provided by Sports Illustrated What doesn’t Derrick Henry do for the Titans? View the original article to see embedded media. Titans running back Derrick Henry entered Week 7 on ... Read more »

Emily Ratajkowski, Oscar Isaac and Succession's Nicholas Braun Make Cameos on SNL

Emily Ratajkowski and Oscar Isaac dropped by Saturday Night Live, but they couldn’t seem to get a word in edgewise. Jason Sudeikis hosted the venerable NBC comedy show on Saturday, ... Read more »

Liverpool vs Manchester United: Three things we learned as Klopp's Reds humiliate rudderless rivals

© Provided by NBC Sports Mohamed Salah and Liverpool absolutely clobbered Manchester United with a lethal, four-goal first half en route to a 5-0 win at Old Trafford on Sunday. ... Read more »

Cleo Smith's voice was heard on CCTV at the campsite where the four-year-old was staying when she disappeared

CLEO Smith's voice has been heard on CCTV at the campsite where the four-year-old vanished, say cops. The audio was revealed as police in Western Australia seek the driver of ... Read more »

Emergency zone expanded around burning container ship

Sixteen people have been evacuated from a container ship that caught fire off the coast of Canada, according to officials. A fire broke out in 10 containers on the MV ... Read more »

Chandrababu Naidu to meet President Kovind, demand Article 356 in Andhra Pradesh

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Telegu Desam Party (TDP) chief and former Andhra Pradesh chief minister N Chandrababu Naidu, scheduled to arrive in Delhi on Monday ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic