Richard Bacon: ‘Cancel culture is public shaming under a new guise'

Asia's Tech News Daily

Richard Bacon: ‘If someone loses their job when they are 25 because of what they tweeted when they were 15, that isn’t reasonable’ – Tom Jenner

Richard Bacon is, he suggests with a merry laugh, someone who was ‘cancelled’ before the world had ever dreamt up the now ubiquitous phrase ‘cancel culture’. It was back in October 1998 and the then 22-year-old Blue Peter presenter was caught in a tabloid sting taking cocaine. Public outrage was huge, and required that he be sacked.

“No one had heard the words cancel culture back then,” reflects Bacon, now 45, his boyish smile as broad as ever, but his hair a little greyer round the edges. “But if it had all happened today, I probably would have been described as having been cancelled.”

His ignominy was complete when the BBC bosses demanded that he return his Blue Peter badge. Though he subsequently worked hard to “uncancel” himself, returning to the small screen having done suitable penance to present The Big Breakfast, Top of the Pops and numerous radio shows, and more recently relocating to Los Angeles to work more behind the camera devising and producing new game shows, Bacon will for some always be the man who shamed Blue Peter and compromised the innocence of Britain’s children.

If there can be an upside to such a life-defining experience, it is that it has made him the natural candidate to front Cancelled, a Channel 4 documentary that airs today on the rise and rise of cancel culture. Revisiting a series of recent high profile incidents, Bacon questions if this is a new phenomenon, the equivalent of book burning, or – as its defenders claim – the public finally finding an effective way to make the powerful listen to them.

“The words cancel culture can feel as if they have been around for 10 years, but in reality I’d say it is less than three,” muses Bacon, speaking from the California home he shares with his wife Rebecca and their children, aged seven and 10. “And I am interested in how we use that word, cancelled. At times it describes things that really would have happened anyway even if there was no cancel culture.”

Among high-profile examples he addresses in the documentary as he tries to find a definition for what cancel culture is and isn’t are the stand-off between Harry Potter creator JK Rowling and trans activists; the defacing of a statue of Winston Churchill in Parliament Square with claims that he is a racist; the no-platforming of well-known names at universities on the grounds that their views may offend woke student audiences; and local campaigns to rename or remove statues and monuments to Britain’s past on the grounds that they are tainted with the mark of slavery.

To view this content, you’ll need to update your privacy settings.Please click here to do so.

Some of the examples Bacon mentions in our conversation, however, are much more everyday and closer to home. “A younger female friend came round to see us recently. She was talking about a friend of hers called Sam. ‘When are you seeing him again?’ I asked. ‘Why do you assume Sam is a man,’ she replied. ‘You’ve just misgendered my friend.’ It is those sorts of exchanges that just make me feel exhausted.”

So what is his definition of cancel culture? “Sometimes,” he suggests, “it is easier to say what it isn’t.” He cites the example of a notional chief executive of a large company who, in a radio interview, makes a racist remark.

“It causes such an outcry that the individual” – note he has learnt his lesson and is using gender neutral language – “is fired. It goes down as one more victory for the cancel culture, but is it really? Or would that chief executive have been fired just the same if it had happened 10 years ago?”

Then there are the occasions when wily politicians use cancel culture to present themselves as victims. “Here in the States, I have seen plenty of examples where those who have said something stupid or offensive in public then turn up on Fox News, claiming to have been cancelled. But they are talking on a national television channel. How does that count as being cancelled?”

It may be as simple as playing up to the idea, popular in some quarters, that we are all caught up in culture wars. “By constantly describing things as part of cancel culture when they aren’t,” Bacon argues, “we are making it seem bigger than it is”.

He may be coming at this issue with his own baggage, but he believes that what we now call cancel culture is old-fashioned public shaming under a new guise. “It would almost be a better phrase for it. In the old days it was the newspaper editor who would decide, ‘we are going to turn someone over’. Now with social media, it is up to any individual. All the world is a stage and everyone has access to it. They can decide to turn on an individual and shame them.”

But it is, he adds, about more than pursuing individual misdemeanours. There are occasions when there is a real and substantial issue at the heart of the clash that is generating so much heat.

He discovers this when, as part of the documentary, he travels to Cambridge. Last month, the broadcaster and art critic Andrew Graham-Dixon was banned from ever again speaking at the Cambridge Union after giving a speech there in which he read out loud in a cod German accent parts of Hitler’s writings that included anti-Semitic and racial slurs.

When voices were raised in protest, Graham-Dixon backtracked and apologised, saying that he had only been trying to expose the evil of the Nazi ideology. But the union refused to back down, and when the president of the debating society issued his own apology, the whole episode quickly became the latest cause celebre in the controversy about cancel culture.

For his part, Bacon interviews a young woman of colour who was in the audience that night and was deeply hurt to hear the N-word read aloud. “You could react and say, ‘oh, she’s being oversensitive’,” he says, “but listening to her I realised she was teaching me something important about how it feels for her. Perhaps this example of cancel culture was a chance for me, as a white, middle-aged man, to think more carefully. And is that so awful?”

That pragmatic see-both-sides approach is how he pitches the whole documentary, moving between the serious examples and the more frivolous. He very deliberately steers the whole thing away from courting controversy. “I know that John Cleese is doing a series on a similar subject later this month, so I will leave the polemics to him.”

But controversy may well be generated anyway, Bacon concedes, because he also looks at the trans rights activists who have done their best to cancel both well-known feminists (Germaine Greer, Jenni Murray and Fay Weldon among them) and academics, including most recently Kathleen Stock, who was forced out of her post at Sussex University for speaking up about the tension between gender self-definition and the biological facts of sex.

“I expect that there will be some people who will object to those sections if only because we interview two academics from Reading University who also disagree with the trans activists,” says Bacon. “It illustrates the negative places we have got to with cancel culture. Even hearing their viewpoint will be controversial for some people.”

Bacon is reluctant to go much further down this line. “If you are running an institution,” he says when I press him, “and you’ve got to work out rules around who can use which bathrooms, then you may have no choice other than to enter the debate, but I’m not in that position. What I will say is that people deciding that they do not want to enter the debate is worrying.”

Ollie Robinson was given an eight-match suspension by the Cricket Disciplinary Commission after inappropriate historical tweets – AP

On other issues, though, Bacon is more willing to take a stance – for example, over the conjuring up of often very old posts on social media to cancel people in the public eye. That was the case with cricketer Ollie Robinson this summer, when he was dropped from the England team because some 10-year-old sexist and racist texts of his surfaced.

“If someone loses their job when they are 25 because of what they tweeted when they were 15,” says Bacon, “that isn’t reasonable. It doesn’t allow for that person growing up, seeing the world in a different way, and changing. We have to hold them to account for how they are now, not for the version of themselves 10 years ago.”

His eloquence, I can’t help thinking, is heart-felt. How much longer, runs the sub-text, will I continue to be remembered for what I did as a 22-year-old on Blue Peter?

Does he feel that in this new cancel culture that he chronicles, he would still be treated the same way now for his sins? “Well, Michael Gove talked recently about taking cocaine when he was younger,” Bacon replies, “and he didn’t lose his job over it.”

Cancelled is on Channel 4 on Thursday December 2 at 10pm

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Tata Motors launches latest range of passenger vehicles in Bhutan

Tata Motors | Representative image Tata Motors on Friday said it has launched its latest range of passenger vehicles in Bhutan. The company said it has launched the product range ... Read more »

Google is working on an AR headset codenamed Project Iris

(Image: Google’s Daydream VR headset, Courtesy: Google) Google is developing an Augmented Reality (AR) headset codenamed Project Iris. The company is eyeing a release window of 2024, according to The ... Read more »

Microsoft's Surface Pro 8 launched in India, to go on sale from February 15

The Surface Pro 7+ will also be available on the same date Microsoft has launched the Surface Pro 8 and Surface Pro 7+ in India. The devices will go on ... Read more »

Twitter finally rolls out Communities on Android

Representative image Twitter has announced the availability of the Communities for Android. Previously, the feature had been restricted to the iOS app and web, and Android users had to use ... Read more »

Are hard-up households going to get a £500 payout?

Rishi Sunak. (Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images) The government is believed to be considering new plans to help those facing significant financial hardship in the coming weeks. Experts warn that ... Read more »

IIT Madras offers course on Next Generation Mobile Wireless Networks

The ‘Next Generation Mobile Wireless Networks’ course is open to students of Engineering (UG & PG) & MSc (Electronics), PhD scholars, faculty members and professionals from Industry/Start-ups. IIT Madras Pravartak ... Read more »

PDFpenPro review

We classify PDFpenPro under word processing software as opposed to just being a PDF editor. The original company behind the PDF editing software is Smile Software. However, Smile Software sold ... Read more »

In the Big Tech Metaverse, is privacy an option?

The world’s largest companies go all-in on Metaverse, an alternative virtual reality world combining work, leisure, services and more. While they look for the best way to make everyone join ... Read more »

Why Is The Airline Industry So Concerned With The 5G Network?

While AT&T Inc (NYSE:T) and Verizon Communications Inc (NYSE:VZ) announced ambitious plans to deploy 5G services in the U.S., the airline industry has raised concerns about how this technology could ... Read more »

World faces shortage of lithium for electric vehicle batteries

Source: Reuters Lithium is in hot demand due to rapidly growing production of electric vehicles that use lithium-ion batteries, but there is a global supply shortage of the metal, with ... Read more »

Intel to build a $20-billion chip factory in Ohio

(Image Courtesy: Intel/TIME) Intel Corp is planning to massive a $20-billion chip manufacturing site in New Albany, Ohio in the US on a 1,000-acre site, as the world grapples with a ... Read more »

Everything you need to know about Wi-Fi 7

As networking devices with Wi-Fi 6 are becoming widely available and relatively affordable, tech companies are already looking ahead to implement Wi-Fi 7 in their products and services. This new ... Read more »

Did Elon Musk forget about OpenAI or is he just trolling his dumbest fans?

It’s impossible to tell if Elon Musk is serious about anything anymore. His image exists in a dichotomy between cartoonesque and genius. He’s simultaneously the richest man in the world ... Read more »

CESL launches tender for 5,500 electric buses in 5 cities

Representative Image Convergence Energy Services (CESL), a wholly-owned subsidiary of Energy Efficiency Services (EESL), on January 20 announced a tender for 5,500 electric buses in five cities — Delhi, Kolkata, ... Read more »

Families forced to cancel half term holidays because of ‘restrictive' Covid pass rules

Children between the age of 12-15 are unable to prove their vaccine status on the NHS Covid app – JUSTIN TALLIS Families have been forced to cancel half term holidays ... Read more »

Redmi Note 11 Pro 5G design renders leaked ahead of January 26 global launch

Redmi Note 11 Pro 5G will feature a Snapdragon processor. Redmi Note 11 Pro design renders have leaked online ahead of the global launch on January 26 even as the ... Read more »

Garmin Fenix 7 too expensive? Check out the super light Suunto 5 Peak instead

If your pockets aren’t deep enough for the newly launched Garmin Fenix 7 multi-sports watch the Suunto 5 Peak is an alternative that’s well worth considering. The new watch is ... Read more »

Godzilla is getting an Apple TV show set in the Monsterverse

Spoilers follow for Godzilla vs Kong. Godzilla fans, rejoice: a live-action TV series, set in Legendary Pictures’ Monsterverse, is in development for Apple TV Plus. Announced in a press release, ... Read more »

Exclusive | No Siri, Alexa, Smart Devices in Secret Meetings: Intel Note to Govt Officials on Tech Threats

(Image Courtesy: Reuters) Witnessing massive violation of national communication security policy guidelines and instructions of the government by officials and to control leaks of classified information, a new communication security ... Read more »

AT&T, Verizon begin turning on C-band 5G

Representative image After a six-week delay, and a whole lot of headaches, AT&T and Verizon have finally started to activate their C-Band 5G networks. People in some areas of the ... Read more »

Snapchat implements new safety features for teens

Snapchat has been busy trying to tackle a drug problem on its platform Snapchat is introducing new safety features for teens that limits the friend suggestions they get to people ... Read more »

Oppo Reno 7, Reno 7 Pro India launch confirmed via Flipkart; to feature World's first Sony IMX709 sensor

OPPO Reno 7 Pro will compete against the likes of the Xiaomi 11T Pro, OnePlus 9RT, etc. Oppo Reno 7 India launch has been confirmed. The company has said that its ... Read more »

FedEx Express commences electric vehicle trials in India

Source: Shutterstock FedEx Express, a subsidiary of leading global express transportation company FedEx Corp, on Friday announced the commencement of electric vehicle (EV) trials in India with Bengaluru to begin ... Read more »

Explainer | Artificial Intelligence, and its impact on advertising

Representational image. Srivibhu Timmaraju and K Rajeshwari “Artificial Intelligence is a tool, not a threat”: Rodney Brooks, Professor of Robotics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Ever been in a situation where ... Read more »

China 3-4 generations away from ‘cutting-edge' chip capabilities: Report

File photo of a semiconductor chip (Image Source: Shutterstock) Mario Morales, group vice president for enabling technologies and semiconductors at the International Data Corporation (IMC) feels China is “generations” away ... Read more »

5G Ultra Wideband just appeared on my iPhone and it's the speed I've always wanted

474.51 Mbps. I had never seen a mobile download speed like it before. 5G Ultra Wideband – yes, the controversial 5G C-Band you’ve been reading about for months – is ... Read more »

Pre-order Samsung's The Freestyle projector and get a free gift - ending soon!

Upgrade your home cinema experience to a whole new level with this pre-order deal on Samsung’s The Freestyle projector. For a limited time, Samsung is offering a free carrying case ... Read more »

Vergecast: Microsoft to acquire Activision, Google building a headset, and the 5G battle with airlines

© Image: Blizzard Every Friday, The Verge publishes our flagship podcast, The Vergecast, where we discuss the week in tech news with the reporters and editors covering the biggest stories. ... Read more »

Los Angeles weighs phasing out oil and gas drilling

The University Park neighborhood of Los Angeles has a lot in common with urban areas across the U.S.: A dense population with lots of businesses and housing. A cluster of ... Read more »

Sony seeking new partners for transformative EV project: Report

Sony Group will likely add new technology partners to its electric vehicle (EV) project to help it forge a mobility business to transform cars from transportation machines to entertainment spaces, ... Read more »

New York Mayor Adams to receive first paycheck in cryptocurrency

New York City Mayor Eric Adams on Thursday said his first paycheck, to arrive on Friday, will be automatically converted into cryptocurrency via Coinbase Global Inc. The salary will be ... Read more »

Epic Galaxy Fold 3 and Flip 3 deal: free Buds and $150 off Galaxy Watch 4 at Samsung

Samsung’s upping the ante this week with an array of awesome deals on its foldable devices – the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 3 and Flip 3. Right now, not only ... Read more »

Apple implements new verification process for educational discounts in US

Tech giant Apple has introduced a new verification process in the US to ensure that customers who want to benefit from its discounted education pricing are involved in education.According to ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S22 reservation teaser confirms Note-like design for S22 Ultra

The Samsung Galaxy S22 launch is expected very soon, and ahead of the February Unpacked event, Samsung has launched a reservation page so you can get the company to set ... Read more »

Apple fires back in Ericsson 5G legal battle

Apple has countersued Ericsson and is seeking an important ban on the import of the Swedish telecoms equipment manufacturer’s base stations into the US as part of a long-running legal ... Read more »

Casio's CT-S1000V keyboard makes it easy to sound like Daft Punk

Casio made a name for itself providing lots of bang-for-your-buck with its musical instruments, as evidenced by my review of the excellent $200 CT-S1 last year. Now the company is ... Read more »

The best macOS apps for your brand new MacBook in 2022

Of all the great feelings in the world, one towers above all. That’s right, I’m talking about getting a new Apple computer. Besides it obviously being a shiny new thing, ... Read more »

Ethereum inventor wants to replace pregnant women with synthetic wombs

Crypto bros never tire of sharing their utopian visions, but their big brain ideas aren’t always embraced by the proles. Vitalik Buterin, the co-founder and inventor of Ethereum, has become ... Read more »

Rimac's selling its hypercar EV tech to other automakers

We’ve already been blown away by Rimac’s breathtaking Nevera, the all-electric hypercar that goes 0-60mph in just 1.85 seconds. And we were stunned when Rimac swallowed Bugatti to become, well, Bugatti ... Read more »

This dystopic-looking bot could scrub greenhouse gases from the air

Two centuries of burning fossil fuels has put more carbon dioxide, a powerful greenhouse gas, into the atmosphere than nature can remove. As that CO2 builds up, it near Earth’s ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic